Ashish Dhar retweeted
Between the Hinduism represented by Neem Karoli Baba vs Swami Karpatri Ji, it is possible that overwhelming majority of Hindus would gravitate towards Neem Karoli Baba Ji. However, that Hinduism may not survive another generation.
Please note that I am not criticising Neem Karoli Babaji here. In fact, he plays a very important role in my own spiritual journey. Within months of visiting Kainchi Dham and spending three days there, I found Pujya Gurudev and Swami Karpatri Ji. I will always remain thankful to him. (Thanks also to @entropied2223)
Large numbers of ordinary Hindus (and many Western seekers) naturally gravitate toward NKB's Hinduism (immediate, miracle-tinged, bhakti-centred, low on formal barriers, high on personal grace and “love everyone, serve everyone”). This Hinduism is emotionally accessible. Can it however carry tradition and thus Hinduism forward? Maybe not.
A tradition does not survive merely because it feels warm and approachable to the median person in any given generation. It survives when its doctrinal spine, institutional memory, ritual integrity, and capacity to resist legislative/cultural erosion remain intact. That is the work Swami Karpatri Ji performed; often at the cost of popularity.
Karpatri Ji’s record is concrete: founding Dharma Sangh and later Ram Rajya Parishad to give dharma a political voice in the democratic era; sustained, uncompromising opposition to the Hindu Code Bills as an assault on shastric autonomy; leadership in the 1966 cow-protection agitation (including imprisonment); establishment of a new Vishwanath temple when traditional rights were being overridden; large-scale scholarly output in Sanskrit and Hindi that purified and defended the classical corpus against both Arya Samaj-style reductionism and modernist dilution; and the quiet, practical work of reintegrating forcibly converted people (the Bengal episode recounted by Pujya Gurudev).
It is the unglamorous, often adversarial labour that keeps the infrastructure standing. The "only" Bhakti oriented path flourishes within a larger civilisational frame that Swami Karpatri Ji defended. Strip away that frame (through progressive legislation, state control of temples, erosion of varnashrama norms, conversion pressure, or simple intellectual forgetfulness) and the accessible Hinduism becomes a set of private feelings and ashram experiences that the next generation can abandon without structural consequence.
Soft bhakti without hard dharma does not transmit across generations under adversarial conditions; it evaporates.
@infinitchy @Anviksiki
Replying to @shatrusamhara @Anviksiki
Between the Hinduism represented by Neem Karoli vs Karpatri, the overwhelming majority of Hindus would gravitate towards the former.
Ashish Dhar retweeted
🥀It was Swami Karpatri ji,who convinced Gita press not to omit raspanchadyayi, so don't know what you are implying
For Krishna lilas:
अनुष्ठितं तु यद्देवैर्मुनिभिर्यदनुष्ठितम्।
नानुष्ठेयं मनुष्यैस्तु तदुक्तं धर्ममाचरेत्॥
Their is also a Shuka-vachan similar to this in Bhagwatam
Unpopular opinion but if lord Krishna was to reincarnate today, all the trad wing boomer would have declared him anti Hindu by now because he broke every god damn rule and stereotypes that existed and mould it in a way to propagate the political dharmic era to start! Krishna was the first proper political Hindu who made sure that dharma prevails in the very society not the so called “knower” of scriptures parroting verses and not following an ounce of it whatsoever when the situation like it demands it 🙂
Ashish Dhar retweeted
"We cant take everyone with us with those ideas" is the main concern, the most immoral idea has made it into hindutva of late so it is not a moral problem. Another angle is the tradition comes in way of every tom dick harry claiming he is a legitimate representative of Hindus.
The growing animus against Swami Karpatri aming sections of Hindutvaites is a reflection of the schizophrenic trauma of modern Hindus that pulls them in two opposite directions:
1. The obligation to represent Hindus in modern politics informs their polemic against Islam.
2. The polemic against Islam compels them to turn against similar ideas in Hindu tradition and deny their validity.
Traditional institutions and paramparik acharyas like Karpatri ji simply stand in the way of this cancelling of shastras. The only options available to them are: make the effort to understand and rationalise the traditions in a respectful manner or discredit them. The latter is easy and rewarding, therefore prevalent.
Ashish Dhar retweeted
Absolutely.
The growing animus against Swami Karpatri aming sections of Hindutvaites is a reflection of the schizophrenic trauma of modern Hindus that pulls them in two opposite directions:
1. The obligation to represent Hindus in modern politics informs their polemic against Islam.
2. The polemic against Islam compels them to turn against similar ideas in Hindu tradition and deny their validity.
Traditional institutions and paramparik acharyas like Karpatri ji simply stand in the way of this cancelling of shastras. The only options available to them are: make the effort to understand and rationalise the traditions in a respectful manner or discredit them. The latter is easy and rewarding, therefore prevalent.
Ashish Dhar retweeted
How Caste Protected Hindus in the past from conversion to Christianity (Direct Missionary Accounts) 🧵
Ashish Dhar retweeted
UP BJP IT cell के उपाध्यक्ष बालियान जी को गुस्सा इसलिए है कि अब हम चुपचाप 73% आरक्षण क्यों नहीं सह रहे हैं?
इनके हिसाब से अगर आप 73% आरक्षण कबूल नहीं करते तो "आप एकतरफ़ा जातियों को भिडवाते हो"!
कमाल ये कि ये ज्ञान बालियान जी 73% आरक्षण मांगने वालों को नहीं देते! सिर्फ GC को देते हैं!
तो ऐसा है बालियान जी,
अब हमने guilt trip होना बंद कर दिया है!
हां, हैं हम जातिवादी!
खुल के हैं, जैसे आप हो!
धन्यवाद 🙏
Whenever BJP and RSS want to usurp an institution or break it they start demonizing. They do so in order to implement the evil policy of reservation
They deionized higher judiciary by fueling public anger and sentiment in order to implement reservation (the process is going on), now they are demonizing private sector in order to implement reservation there by bullying private companies.
#BREAKING
PM Modi questions corporate India: Tax cuts given, but where are the jobs and salary hikes?
Addressing FICCI, PM Modi reminded business leaders that corporate tax was cut from 30% to 22%, while individuals now pay no income tax on earnings up to ₹12 lakh under the new regime
“You always ask for more. But did you hire more employees? Did you increase their salaries?”
Tough question to India's biggest businesses!
Ashish Dhar retweeted
Yes. Just as it is Karpatriji in the north, it is Paramacharya in South. Other than that they were strictly shastraic, they also showed that it is possible to live per the shastras - that galls them even more because it disproves their position that shastras are invalid today.
The growing animus against Swami Karpatri aming sections of Hindutvaites is a reflection of the schizophrenic trauma of modern Hindus that pulls them in two opposite directions:
1. The obligation to represent Hindus in modern politics informs their polemic against Islam.
2. The polemic against Islam compels them to turn against similar ideas in Hindu tradition and deny their validity.
Traditional institutions and paramparik acharyas like Karpatri ji simply stand in the way of this cancelling of shastras. The only options available to them are: make the effort to understand and rationalise the traditions in a respectful manner or discredit them. The latter is easy and rewarding, therefore prevalent.
Ashish Dhar retweeted
Objection by radical juveniles on these matters should is a compliment.
Not only is there is a temperament problem but also a comprehension one for these 'Vedas is mining' folks.
The growing animus against Swami Karpatri aming sections of Hindutvaites is a reflection of the schizophrenic trauma of modern Hindus that pulls them in two opposite directions:
1. The obligation to represent Hindus in modern politics informs their polemic against Islam.
2. The polemic against Islam compels them to turn against similar ideas in Hindu tradition and deny their validity.
Traditional institutions and paramparik acharyas like Karpatri ji simply stand in the way of this cancelling of shastras. The only options available to them are: make the effort to understand and rationalise the traditions in a respectful manner or discredit them. The latter is easy and rewarding, therefore prevalent.
Amongst all shades of opinion and strategizing, the urge to show Swami Karpatri ji as a plagarist is the lowest in my view.
Agreeing or disagreeing with views is everyone's prerogative but to judge a guru-shishya relationship with modern academic blinkers is not useful let alone being Dharmic.
Traditional knowledge transmission mechanisms are distinct.
Learnt from Paturi sir recently about how Bhagavatpada Adi Shankara wrote bhaashya to his síshya Hastaamalakaachaarya's book.
Might be unfathomable for a modern brain seeped in Western academic discourse
Beyond everything, the purpose of studying our knowledge is to understand the subtleties of Dharma and Karma and bring it into behavior.
The inability to factor karmic consequences is the main concern and the real education we need to advance.
Ashish Dhar retweeted
Se exact logic seculars used to equate hindus and jihadis. Same power hunger same dishonesty same inversion of purposes.
Ashish Dhar retweeted
RaGa's top tier ragebait reg indians not being affectionate towards their wives has reasonated with a lot of young women.
But Indian aversion to PDA is not lack of affection but the proof of its heightend engagement with Shringara Rasa thus rejection of vulgar self-expression.
Saw one more clip of DevduttP being shared..
Just put some keywords in and you can literally simulate DevduttP talking points endlessly..
Buddhism.. Jainism.. Merchant class .. Marwaris .. Brahmins.. Vegetarianism..
He will keep doing permutations and combinations around these.
Ashish Dhar retweeted
See, How deeply BJP broke the society💔
.
chote chote baccho ko jaati dwand me uljha diya
Ashish Dhar retweeted
Pseudo & Inept Saṁnyāsins in Ādhunika Kalikāla
(Observation of Svāmi Hariharānanda Āraṇya)
I set out in search of a guru who would guide me in the quest (of mukti). But it was not easy to come across a guru who is wise, practices detachment, and communes with his inner-self. Most of the so-called religious men whom I meet, were engaged in mundane affairs. While I was hankering to meet someone who had renounced all earthly desires and comforts, I found these people wallowing in luxury. Hefty, obviously overfed religious mendicant, dressed in costly silk and shawl and bedecked with jewellery appeared preposterously comical. The very word Sannyasin or religious mendicant has a hallowed association. But nowadays many good for nothing fellows have desecrated its sanctity. They would manage to get a few sheepish fellows under their fold and fleece the latter in order that they themselves could lead a life of comfort. I got the insight on approaching some of them inadvertently. I also met ascetics who had apparently renounced outwardly things but remained greedy at heart. There were others, apparently good people, but lacking in common sense. Some again had imposed on themselves the duty to teach people and would be upset if they did not get devoted listeners even for a few hours..
Source: A Unique Travelogue by Svāmi Hariharānanda Āraṇya
Ashish Dhar retweeted
"Modern man, instead of attempting to raise himself to truth, seeks to drag truth down to his own level."~René Guénon
“Despite all our philosophy maxxing, our moksha maxxing, people in this country still don’t have food to eat.”
@indiainpixels argues we’re now in Vedic Age 2.0. The internet pulled us out of our well, the world doesn’t particularly like us, and we’re approaching an intelligence that no scripture has prepared us for.
Ashish Dhar retweeted
On one hand he says India should demand more respect globally but on the other hand he says "Russia is the true motherland" on some "epigenetic" level and that Hindus should do tirth yatras to Russia. See these 'gem' of his tweets from not long ago for yourself to get the idea.
“Despite all our philosophy maxxing, our moksha maxxing, people in this country still don’t have food to eat.”
@indiainpixels argues we’re now in Vedic Age 2.0. The internet pulled us out of our well, the world doesn’t particularly like us, and we’re approaching an intelligence that no scripture has prepared us for.
Ashish Dhar retweeted
The recent Indrajeeting is less about religion and more about the rootless individualist pathology that afflicts the young Indian today.
Being small souled he cannot exhibit his non-existent greatness when he's among a group of people hence he must become contrarian.
Ashish Dhar retweeted
They are openly admitting that they want to introduce "incompetence" into CA courses!!
And guess what gives them that arrongant confidence?
- Govt's own recommendation
So it's a proof that these social justice warriors actually work with govt to introduce anti-merit policies.
And govt fools you by saying
"Sarkar hamari hai but system unka hai".
Ashish Dhar retweeted
This podcast was cringe promax. I was curious about the case they put up, but as soon as they started talking it was just random sentences here and there, no correlation no point, no clarity.
It was like listening to 3 teenagers arguing why Batman is the coolest superhero.
“Despite all our philosophy maxxing, our moksha maxxing, people in this country still don’t have food to eat.”
@indiainpixels argues we’re now in Vedic Age 2.0. The internet pulled us out of our well, the world doesn’t particularly like us, and we’re approaching an intelligence that no scripture has prepared us for.

































