
PhD candidate at @TelAvivUni. Researcher of the spine and people experiencing pain. MSK Physiotherapist and đđ» philosopher wannabe blog
Omnipresent
Joined June 2017
- Tweets7.4K
- Following1.5K
- Followers3.2K
- Likes12.3K
Pinned Tweet
Officially publishedđ„ A reboot to the pain field! The aphorism that ânociception is neither necessary nor sufficient for painâ has caused a lot of damage to patients and set back the field.
This paper was not easy to publish and was rejected by all the major pain journals for obvious reasons of bias and suspected vested interests. Eventually, BRAIN which has more than double the impact of any pain journal identified the true potential and implications of the paper đȘđ»
The paper is a systematic and critical review. The systematic part identified that all those who cited the aphorism had no references to back this claim and they mostly just cited themselves circularly. The critical part covers EVERY piece of supposed empirical evidence that was ever presented as evidence for pain without nociception and shows that none stand critical scrutiny.
The main and most important implication of the paper is that if we accept that âNociception is necessary but not sufficient for painâ, then all pain states are fundamentally explainable and have somatic basis. The notion of âpsychological painâ or âbrain painâ should be shunned and binned.
Free link in the comments.
*The Supplementary Table of the systematic search results is not available in the free version
An incredibly prevalent and annoying aphorism. But is it true? Not exactly!
Link to the blog in the comments.
painlosophy.wordpress.com/20âŠ
Finally publishedđ„ The notion that âpain does not correlate with imaging and has no biomarkersâ is one of the most prevailing myths in the field of pain.
jpain.org/article/S1526-5900âŠ
I am looking for predictive-processing zealots and pain reprocessors to volunteer for my new blinded, randomised clinical trial. Surely I should expect an overwhelming amount of volunteers?
painlosophy.wordpress.com/20âŠ
If you think you get an answer to the question in the title donât bother reading. All these people gathered around to say nothing.
Super important conversation of mine with patient advocated from The Patient Doctor Forum about the harms of âMind-body Industryâ. And trust me, those advocates have heard so many horror stories and they have data of thousands which I have seen in my own eyes.
You won't want to miss this podcast with @AsafKlaf debunking the common pain narratives.
Pain Patients Were Right: The âItâs All in Your Headâ Narrative Is Falli... youtu.be/1HbbkoyfXWw?si=pnR5⊠via @YouTube
I must admit that âunlearn your depression fatigue and anxietyâ is a totally new kind of dumbf****y to me. How do people even take this sort of stuff seriously?
A new blog on our study, which was published last year in PeerJ, and why it KILLED all the psychologically-based interventions for pain, including "Pain Reprocessing Therapy."
YES, It KILLED those approaches!
painlosophy.wordpress.com/20âŠ
New blog on the nonsense tgat is âPain Reprocessing Therapyâ by Drs. Quintner and Cohen
painlosophy.wordpress.com/20âŠ
How do presumably smart academics fail to see the absurdity of such titles? Why does the pain field continue to ignore our 2018 and 2022 papers stating the absurdity of the concept of âpain insensitivityâ is beyond me. In the meanwhile we will continue to have an absurd conception of people who cant experience pain that experience pain. And have no doubt, people labelled with the misnomer âcongenital insensitivity to painâdo experience pain, as is evident in this new case study.
Drs. Quintner and Cohen update their arguments against âPain as a protectorâ
painlosophy.wordpress.com/20âŠ
Optical illusions or âclassical illusionsâ have NOTHING to do with predictive processing or prediction at all! If anything, they show that human optical perception is rather predictable and kind of universal.
Those effects are the result of the intrinsic properties of our nervous system and how it is built. Even âthe dressâ shows that the majority of perception was divided into roughly 50% blue and black and 50% gold and white. The main effects underlying those âillusionsâ are: Color constancy, gradient lightness perception, forced perspective, impoverished stimuli under artificial conditions and local vs global consistency.
If predictive processing had anything to do with those effects, we would expect everyone to perceive those differently because everyoneâs priors are completely different. However, those effects are rather universal and most people perceive them exactly the same and the effects cannot be influenced by demand characteristics.
The use of predictive processing to explain those phenomena/effects is pseudoscience, and especially the attempt to use those effects as examples of how pain âworksâ.
đ„đ„In a first of its kind study, Elly-Lilly present impressive effects of GLP-1s on Psoriasis outcomes and disease activty in patients also with obesity. I predicted a long time ago that we will see that.
Report: investor.lilly.com/news-releâŠ
Combination (Taltz + Zepbound):
ââââââââââââââââââââââââ 33.5%
Taltz alone:
ââââââââââââ 20.4%
7
957
Pain medicine is full of paradoxes. For starters, while pain is the number one reason for seeking medical care, it is the least taught subject in medical school and is considered a sub specialty. Presuming to apply objective scientific methodology to study a subjective experience is yet another paradox. Honestly, there are just too many.
đ„I havenât read the full text yet but this may shake the foundations of many biopsychosocialists out there. Itâs pretty wild and will probably be scrutinized under all kinds of methodolgical microscopes and likely produce some LTEs.
Here are several snippets from our recent papâThe pain education paradox and the validation gapâ that I think necessitate highlighting as they stand by themselves:
âMany PNE programs define and frame pain as âbrain perceptionâ or âresponse to perceived threatsâ diverging significantly from the IASP's consensus definition of pain as âan unpleasant sensory and emotional experience associated with, or resembling that associated with actual or potential tissue damageâ
âPatients still need to understand that peripheral nociceptive input can arise without visible tissue damage and that pathophysiology is not the same as pathoanatomyâ
âPNE validation methods exemplify faulty circular reasoning. Developers create their own assessment tools, such as the Neurophysiology of Pain Questionnaire (NPQ), which are then used to demonstrate the effectiveness of their educational approachâ
âSpecifically, practitioners must understand that nociception can be initiated through numerous mechanisms beyond tissue damage, including immune and cell-to-cell communication, that cannot be targeted through exercise or manual therapyâ
âOn one hand, âTreating painâ requires directly targeting pain-related mechanisms through validated means; primarily pharmacological or technological interventions that influence specific molecular or cellular processes. In contrast, treating someone experiencing pain acknowledges the person's experience while providing support within the realistic scope of practiceâ
âAnother essential aspect that warrants acknowledgment is that while stress responses can influence nociceptive activation through hormonal and neuroimmune pathways, this does not mean that stress âcausesâ pain in a simplistic manner or that treating stress necessarily resolves painâ
Open access link: kwnsfk27.r.eu-west-1.awstracâŠ
đ„New publication from our labđ„
Is pregnancy a major risk factor for musculoskeletal pain? According to Betteridges law of headlines, and our study, the answer is - NO!
To our surprise we couldnât find any previous studies that compared prevalence of musculoskeletal pain in pregnant females to non pregnant controls. So, naturally, we had to do this study on N=1651 women.
We examined many areas of musculoskeletal pain and just couldnât find any significant associations after robust adjustments and sensitivity analyses. The implications are discussed and there are more results from this huge dataset that will be published.
Open access link: mskscienceandpractice.com/arâŠ
1
456
âFibromyalgiaâ is a label assigned to a collection of symptoms that we currently have no way to know the underlying biological nociceptive mechanisms (widespread pain, fatigue and brain fog). This is important because the last 20 years revealed previously unknown nociceptive mechanisms in people who were granted the label like Small Fiber Neuropathies and previously unknown autoantibodies.
Optimally, once a nociceptive mechanism is identified it really shouldnât remain under the Fibromyalgia label anymore. Practically, this doesnât happen fast enough because medical science moves slow and this leads to ridiculous claims like fibro is âa brain disorderâ a âblood sugar problemâ, an âautoimmune problemâ etc. Theoretically, there could be thousands of mechanisms that lead to this collection of symptoms.
To conclude, Fibromyalgia is not one âthingâ or entity. It is a just a label = collection of symptoms which we donât understand its origin. Once we understand a new mechanism it is longer a Fibro.
The increased use of the term âNeuroplastic Painâ by psychologists is disturbing becuase they really do not mean âNociplastic Painâ whatsoever. It is a deliberate use of a term that denies the âNociâ part altogether to imply pain that is brain generated as conceived by Melzack.
Another disturbing aspect is that non of the references cited by the most prominent users of this term do not support any of their assertions and are grossly misinterpreted (see pain reprocessing therapy website). I also saw they refer to it as mind body syndrome which is an explicit admission they believe that pain is caused by the mind.
I have one unanswered question that I keep asking all those BELIEVERS: What is the diagnostic criteria for this âbrain generated painâ? How do they rule out actual somatic nociception or altered nociception? For example endometriosis has a delay of 6-10 years in diagnosis, sero-negative arthritides in people with psoriasis which are often not aware that psoriasis causes arthritis and donât bother to tell that to the therapist. How do they rule out compartmentalized inflammation of nerves that are often missed?
Until they answer with demonstrated sensitivity and specificity, this construct remains a belief and pseudoscience!




















