Ashley S Kinseth (@AshleyKinseth) header
Ashley S Kinseth (@AshleyKinseth) profile picture

Human rights lawyer and researcher on atrocity crimes and statelessness. Fieldwork in Myanmar, Bangladesh, India. Al Jazeera, WaPo, The Diplomat, Opinio Juris.

Joined November 2026
New in @newmandala: As the #ICJ rules, online hate is putting #Rohingya at risk, from Myanmar to Malaysia. I argue host governments and intervening states must act to keep it from feeding real-world violence, as it did in 2017, not leave it to Meta. newmandala.org/online-hate-e…
17
Ashley S Kinseth retweeted
A really illustrative table prepared by @Yusra_Suedi (SAIL) summarizing the differences in approach between the judges who supported and those who opposed the ICJ’s judgment in The Gambia v. Myanmar case:
8
75
9
261
14,107
The Court ordered Myanmar to allow the #Rohingya's safe, voluntary and dignified return (¶615). It will also depend on the Arakan Army, which holds much of Rakhine and is outside the case. In @Diplomat_APAC, I argue the ICC can already reach its conduct. thediplomat.com/2026/11/what…
6
219 Myanmar civil society groups, including Rohingya alongside Chin, Karen, Kachin and Karenni organizations: “it can never again be denied.” #ICJ #Rohingya
The world's highest court @CIJ_ICJ confirmed what #Rohingya survivors said for years: Myanmar’s military committed genocide.🚨 219 Rohingya & #Myanmar CSOs welcome today’s ICJ ruling. The international community must fully implement the judgment. 🖇️ bit.ly/4CdrSHf
7
On citizenship: the Court declined to order full citizenship, but called its denial "central to the overall pattern of discrimination and vulnerability" and ordered Myanmar to protect the #Rohingya from discrimination, including in access to citizenship (¶¶603, 616). #ICJ
Replying to @AshleyKinseth
Remedies. Beyond prosecutions, reparations, and safe return, The Gambia asks the Court to order “full and equal citizenship” for the Rohingya, most of whom were rendered stateless decades before 2017. But the Court has long been reluctant to order changes to domestic law. 5/5
8
On sexual violence: the Court held that mass rape was among the "measures intended to prevent births" under the Genocide Convention (¶¶366–371), and that sexual violence that degraded victims "to an extreme degree" supports the inference of genocidal intent (¶420). #ICJ #Rohingya
Replying to @AshleyKinseth
Sexual violence. Survivors’ accounts of widespread rape are central to the case. @P4HR notes the ruling could be the first time a permanent international court recognizes sexual violence as acts of genocide. 4/5
8
On speech: the Court attributed the military's Facebook campaign to Myanmar and found it contributed to "a climate conducive to targeting a group for destruction." It wasn't convinced the posts directly called for genocide, so no incitement of civilians (¶¶404, 505). #Rohingya
Replying to @AshleyKinseth
Speech. The Gambia’s claims include incitement, and the record documents years of anti-Rohingya hate speech on Facebook, including from a covert network Meta tied to the military. Does the Court treat it as evidence of intent, and what does it say about incitement? 3/5
7
On intent: the Court kept the "only reasonable inference" test, but held that genocidal intent can coexist with other aims, such as displacement or punishment, as long as only genocide explains all the evidence taken together (¶¶443, 456, 464). #ICJ #Rohingya
Replying to @AshleyKinseth
Intent. In the Bosnia and Croatia cases, the Court required genocidal intent to be the only reasonable inference from a pattern of conduct. The Gambia argues it meets that test. Six intervening states urged the Court to weigh the evidence holistically rather than act by act. 2/5
6
The #ICJ has found, by 9 votes to 6, that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya—the first time it has held a state responsible for committing genocide. It ordered Myanmar to investigate those suspected, allow the Rohingya's safe return and compensate them. #Rohingya
1/ The ICJ delivers its judgment in The Gambia v. Myanmar tomorrow at 10 a.m. in The Hague (4 a.m. ET, 3 p.m. Dhaka, 3:30 p.m. Yangon, 5 p.m. Kuala Lumpur). It will stream live on the Court’s website and UN Web TV. A few things I’ll be watching: 1/5 #ICJ #Rohingya
1
9
1/ The ICJ delivers its judgment in The Gambia v. Myanmar tomorrow at 10 a.m. in The Hague (4 a.m. ET, 3 p.m. Dhaka, 3:30 p.m. Yangon, 5 p.m. Kuala Lumpur). It will stream live on the Court’s website and UN Web TV. A few things I’ll be watching: 1/5 #ICJ #Rohingya
1
1
1
21
Sexual violence. Survivors’ accounts of widespread rape are central to the case. @P4HR notes the ruling could be the first time a permanent international court recognizes sexual violence as acts of genocide. 4/5
1
1
1
17
Remedies. Beyond prosecutions, reparations, and safe return, The Gambia asks the Court to order “full and equal citizenship” for the Rohingya, most of whom were rendered stateless decades before 2017. But the Court has long been reluctant to order changes to domestic law. 5/5
1
1
14
The Guardian reports #ICJ judges have sought advice on shielding their assets from possible US sanctions ahead of tomorrow’s #Rohingya genocide ruling. In 2022, the US itself determined that Myanmar’s military committed genocide against the Rohingya. theguardian.com/world/2026/n…
13
Ashley S Kinseth retweeted
I’ll be in the court Thurs for the ICJ’s judgment in The Gambia v. Myanmar, the historic Rohingya genocide case. Many have asked what happens if the ICJ finds Myanmar responsible for genocide & the junta defies the ruling. There are several possible paths forward. A thread:
11
131
17
449
39,974
Ahead of Thursday’s #ICJ ruling, BHRN reports nationalists preparing protests and rising dangerous speech online, much of it on TikTok and Facebook. Platforms treat elections as high-risk periods, and should do the same for this ruling. #Rohingya bhrn.org.uk/en/press-release…
12
I met Dil Mohammed at No Man's Land in 2018; he was generous with his time and his knowledge. More than a year ago, a UN Working Group found his detention arbitrary and called for his immediate release. He is still being held.
rohingyarefugee.news/p/the-n… Four years after the No Man’s Land raid, Rohingya spokesman Dil Mohammed remains detained. The UN Working Group found his detention arbitrary and called for his release. Barrister Haydee Dijkstal @dijkstal , his international counsel, has issued this:
14
The ICJ's Nov. 19 judgment will bind only Myanmar, but the Rohingya still in northern Rakhine live under the Arakan Army. In @Diplomat_APAC, I argue the ICC can already reach the AA's conduct—and states backing The Gambia should press for it in December. thediplomat.com/2026/11/what…
43