
Neurosurgery and Health Policy. Views my own. Co-Host: @DRsLoungePod Author: https://teapaw.org/t.co/yCG1hZyvF9
San Francisco, CA
Joined January 2013
- Tweets22.5K
- Following3.4K
- Followers16.6K
- Likes50.6K
Pinned Tweet
Replying to @DrDiGiorgio
Anthony DiGiorgio, DO, MHA retweeted
Yale's M4A "study" - which is not peer reviewed - simply plugged in lower spending levels without modeling how the health care system would function under the policies.
So they achieved $1 trillion in savings by... assuming $1 trillion in savings. Congratulations? 🧵
A new Yale analysis found Medicare for All would cover every American AND save more than $1 trillion a year, cutting national health care spending by 20%.
It would also mean better pay for doctors, nurses, and healthcare providers. The savings from cutting private insurance and Big Pharma profits as well as administrative waste would pay for increased Medicare reimbursement rates and $52 billion in unpaid hospital care.
Medicare for All saves money and lives.
Anthony DiGiorgio, DO, MHA retweeted
Replying to @DrDiGiorgio
@DrDiGiorgio @anish_koka asked me if there was too much politics in science… you should watch to find out in the @DRsLoungePod youtube.com/live/BzxUjmGME5g… but look at the below and tell me what you think.
I did a thing. Opened the American Journal of Public Health @AMJPublicHealth for the first time in years.
The current “First Look” lineup makes me wonder if public health research still exists…or if it’s just politics with a journal and @NIH funding.
Everything I see every day tells me the opposite: we need a strong, credible public health ecosystem now more than ever. Instead, we spit in the public’s face with this masquerade.
Anthony DiGiorgio, DO, MHA retweeted
When I was in medical school, a professor lectured the class and proudly displayed the famous "Life expectancy vs healthcare expenditure" graph as evidence that the US healthcare system spends so much and yet the healthcare system performs worse than other OECD countries.
Of course, back then I didn't know all the different ways in which this graph is nothing short of one of the most misleading pieces of slop propaganda that should be disqualifying to anyone who cites it...but I did think of at least one potential issue at the time.
After the lecture, I walked up to the professor and asked just one question: "Were these different life-expectancies adjusted for confounding factors (beyond mere age/sex standardization)?"
The lecturer froze for several seconds. Then said "Uhh...yes. They were...Yes."
I politely nodded and thanked him for his time. But I suspect he didn't know, and I suspect he knew I suspected that he didn't know too.
Of course, he was wrong. Zero of such confounders are adjusted for in this graph. So why did a professional of such respected standing tell me otherwise and mislead a trainee?
Believe it or not, I suspect he didn't even mean to lie. I think what happened is no one bothered to ask the question before, he never bothered to think of it before, and when it was finally first presented to him, he simply assumed that whoever was behind this graph must have done at least some sort of causally informed adjustment modeling for baseline risk factors or else such a graph would be ridiculous. So he just figured such a thing must have surely happened.
But of course, it never did. And across the numerous well-cited professional working papers smearing the US for its poor quality healthcare by comparing outcomes to other countries, it has basically never happened. Not back then, and not now.
Of course, that's just the tip of the iceberg of insane issues with this graph, but for me, this was the beginning. It was the point when I realized that so much of the anti-US healthcare propaganda work might just be slop motivated by policy driven ideology rather than any genuine interest in how the US healthcare system actually performs in reality.
And incidentally, it's my view now that when all the basic level 0 issues are corrected, the evidence indicates that the US actually delivers the highest quality of healthcare over and above the other countries listed here. But that's a post for another time.
The government says the hospital can't get paid for a surgery unless they force the doctor to document a 12-point review of systems in the note.
Now the doctor has to spend time doing a meaningless 12-point review of systems.
That's how the government runs the hospital.
Replying to @DrDiGiorgio
The government has a lot of power, yes, but it is not the same thing as government running the hospitals and employing the doctors.
If every private insurance patient switched to traditional Medicare, there would be no decrease in administrative burden for doctors.
If anything, it would get worse.
Anthony DiGiorgio, DO, MHA retweeted
Eric Potts: "My hospital CEO's favorite case is a lumbar fusion anterior-posterior with major comorbidities or complications." Follow the incentives.
Full episode with @anish_koka and @DrDiGiorgio: open.spotify.com/episode/4To…
This is such a persistent lie.
If all my private insurance patients suddently went to Medicare, my administrative burden would not drop one bit. If anything, it would increase. Doctors would not have one iota of time "freed up" if patients all went to Medicare.
Anthony DiGiorgio, DO, MHA retweeted
I love the way you lie.
Section 107 of the Medicare for All Act explicitly prohibits private insurance that duplicates government coverage. Private insurance can only cover benefits the government doesn’t cover.
Private schools can offer the same education as public schools. Under your bill, private insurers cannot offer the same coverage.
And public schools aren’t ‘free.’ They’re taxpayer funded.
Anthony DiGiorgio, DO, MHA retweeted
I just didn't see Spencer Pratt coming.
What fascinates me (and I'm not sure whether others see it the same way) is how his tweets so often manage to appeal simultaneously to populism, pragmatism, and capitalism, all while unapologetically acknowledging the threat posed by scumbag commie shitlibs.
Not everyone on the political right has that savvy or moral clarity.
One of the more profound challenges in America is an outsized number of permastudents, who just put themselves in debt because they believed the fake sales pitch of elite universities...they thought a degree was a magic piece of paper that unlocks some infinite money printer, only to find out it was a total lie.
Only a small minority of the economy (lawyers, doctors, engineers, biologists, and biz/finance) actually need and benefit from institutionalized certification at elite universities. The University lie was that this somehow trickles down to esoteric degrees like gender studies, which have precisely zero market value in the real world. Even the humanities only functions to serve itself: with a degree in the humanities, you can really only get a job...teaching humanities.
The best way to build a career as a writer is to write. The best way to build a career as a filmmaker is to film things...if, instead of spending $200K on film studies, you were to buy lights and cameras and a MacBook Pro for editing, you would be light years ahead within 8 months, while the film student languishes in GE class purgatory, only to find themselves suffering further once they get to their major classes 2 years later, and they're being forced to memorize nonsensical esoteric concepts like "syuzhet" and "fabula", and they still haven't touched a camera once.
After suffering through 4 years of overpriced adult daycare, they enter the job market, have no bearings, no market value in the private sector, but because they have a fancy degree, they feel that their pedigree is supposed to automagically confer some advanced level of wealth and status...they should be living in a penthouse apartment in Manhattan, and taking annual ski trips to the dolomites...but the only institution that will take a gender studies graduate is a scammy NPO or a Starbucks.
They will never evaluate their life choices rationally...most people are incapable of critical self-reflection. Instead, they will continue to feel entitled, and thus angry at "the system" for robbing them of the promise of higher education...so they must dismantle the system because they can't dismantle their own ego. Thus you get...the communist malcontent.
All the while, the blue collar guy who knows how to plumb a septic system has perpetual real world value, and – as long as he lives within his means – will be permanently content and hold gratitude for his country. In the old days, most people took this route...it was mostly just the doctors and lawyers and engineers and businessmen went to University, and things were balanced. But the propaganda in recent decades from the university system has been so effective, a bunch of people who really ought to be solvent welding PVC pipes are now sacrificing their lives to pay for the inflated costs of elite universities, only to get rug-pulled with a mortarboard and gown.
Wild to see. Go to a trade school. Universities have become a total scam.
Anthony DiGiorgio, DO, MHA retweeted
“ Basically, the stupidity of the American voter, or whatever.” Jonathan Gruber, ACA/Obamacare designer.
I agree with @awgaffney that cutting paperwork will free up doctors to see more patients. I don’t see Medicare for all cutting paperwork. It will increase demand for healthcare services. This is modeled in CBO projections and experimentally demonstrated in numerous studies.
Expecting doctors to stop doing low value services to free up additional capacity is an unrealistic solution.
Doctors do things because they see an indication and they are financially incentivized to do the thing (and also to avoid lawsuits).
We already have huge capacity problems now. If you have medicaid, you’re facing wait times of 20 hours for the ER, 6 months for primary care, and 2 years for an ortho procedure. Is that all because doctors are doing low value care? Does it take a year to see a neurosurgeon in Canada because they’re all doing unindicated lumbar fusions for back pain?
If you want cardiologists to stop doing left atrial appendage closure devices, you can stop paying for it (which means nobody gets it even if they need it) or you make the doctor fill out paperwork to justify it (which adds back the admin burden you thought you were eliminating). The same goes for every procedure you think is “low value.”
You still can’t eliminate the “low value” clinic and ER visits. Unless, of course, you get like Canada, where millions go without care because the wait is too long. You have to really want that neurosurgeon visit to wait a year.
“Willingness to pay” may seem like a brutal way to ration care. “Willingness to wait” is just as bad.
Anthony DiGiorgio, DO, MHA retweeted
You got a source for that statistic?
Because 50% of Canadians have avoided seeking healthcare due to long wait times.
90% think the system is fundamentally broken.
And 61% want to be able to pay out of pocket for better care.
iedm.org/poll-half-of-canadi…
Anthony DiGiorgio, DO, MHA retweeted
People have no idea how the VA actually operates.
In FY2024, the VA spent an average of $20,594 per patient.
For comparison, annual spending per enrollee was:
Medicare: $16,779
Medicaid: $11,050
Private insurance: $7,676
These aren’t perfectly comparable populations, but the difference is substantial.
In FY2026, approximately 45% of VA appointments were delivered through outside community care providers.
In 2024, 26.4% of surgical specialty referrals went to community providers.
The VA relies heavily on private healthcare, particularly for specialty services.
And then there’s vendor spending.
I think the amount of money the VA wastes on vendors is staggering. That deserves its own investigative piece.
The GAO found that the VA couldn’t reliably track item-level prices paid for surgical implants or determine the savings achieved through its purchasing contracts.
Think about that. An enormous federal healthcare system without reliable data on what it’s paying for surgical implants or whether its contracts actually save money.
(Before any body starts throwing out crazy accusations I am a service connected vet)
Anthony DiGiorgio, DO, MHA retweeted
Why are a healthy 32 year old’s premium $7200/year with a $6000 deductible?
Gruber, ACA designer on passing Obamacare:
“Lack of transparency is an advantage”
“If we explicitly said healthy people had to pay for the sick, the bill doesn’t pass ..”






























