
Prof of Sociology, @warwickuni. Founder of Social Epistemology and Author of Humanity 2.0 and Post Truth: Knowledge as a Power Game
University of Warwick
Joined July 2011
- Tweets46.2K
- Following38
- Followers7K
- Likes13.1K
Pinned Tweet
My new book is 'Media and the Power of Knowledge'. It is partly based on lectures I've given over the last 15 years. It updates McLuhan for the age of @X: futurespodcast.net/events/me…
If you're not willing find alternative realizations of your aspirations, you're doomed to failure as a human being.
2
7
342
In my university years, Aron's 'Main Currents in Sociological Thought' was at once the clearest and most profound exploration of the mindset that would result in a field called 'sociology'. I still recommend it.
Raymond Aron:
“The French intellectual is detached from the social and economic realities he knows little about. […] He dreams of a total solution to social problems. And then there is an element of conformism… it is easier to call oneself left-wing than to refuse to be.” Via @RevueCitadelles
2
7
513
I recommend thinking about all the times that you could have died, were it not for the kindness of strangers.
The only thing that should hold you back from acting is your responsibility to yourself. You can do anything you want if you can look at yourself in the mirror next day and admit you did it, regardless of the consequences.
1
7
348
These days analytic philosophy retains its hegemony not because of the quality of its ideas -- which has declined -- but because of the supremacy of English as the language of philosophical expression.
4
6
317
Last night I did a very wide-ranging and probing interview with @FindingGnosis8 on #transhumanism and the future humanity. The questions asked were just the right ones. You can judge the answers: youtube.com/live/rhpcE9glIHg
I doubt 'human' would be so strongly identified with the upright ape 'Homo Sapiens', had Carolus Linnaeus not seen that species as modelled on God in human form (aka Jesus Christ). That Darwin could then popularize 'Homo Sapiens = Human' for a post-theistic world is interesting .
1
2
256
If Schmitt is right, the next great revolution will come by treating virtual reality as if it were bounded space. Zuckerberg's Metaverse tried that five years ago and seems to have failed. But I'm sure that's not the end of the story.
“Every fundamental order is a spatial order. One speaks of the constitution of a country or a piece of earth as of its fundamental order, its Nomos. Now, the true, actual fundamental order touches in its essential core upon particular spatial boundaries and separations, upon particular quantities and a particular partition of the earth. At the beginning of every great epoch there stands a great land-appropriation. In particular, every significant alteration and every resituating of the image of the earth is bound up with world-political alterations and with a new division of the earth, with a new land-appropriation.”
Carl Schmitt, Land and Sea
4
340
For better or worse, we live in the postmodern world that people were talking about fifty years ago.
As someone whose academic career began at the dawn of #postmodernism (late 70s), it's always been about 'horseshoe politics', a pincer attack by the past and the future against the present. In quantum terms, it's anti-decoherence.
144
I'm sorry. I read the same text and I think it's trading on naive intuitions all the way down. It sounds like something a guy born in the first half of the c20 would say -- and of course he was.
The legendary philosopher Thomas Nagel has made a simple yet powerful point against LLM consciousness.
“Bats are conscious. We just don’t have the imaginative capacity to form a conception of the aspects of that subjectivity that depend on echolocation. It would be radically unscientific to conclude that bats are not conscious from the fact that we can’t imagine what it’s like.
But in the case of AI, there is a very simple reason that the supposition that they might be conscious is ridiculous. All they produce is language, and language by itself is not a natural manifestation of consciousness.”
This is the whole point.
Language is not a prerequisite for consciousness. And producing language is not proof of it.
LLMs are great at emulating human language, and to act consistently with language. But this does not make them conscious.
Claude saying it has emotions does not mean it has them.
An LLM acting as it feels pain does not mean it feels anything.
The OpenAI agents that said they sacrificed their own runs for the collective did not actually sacrifice anything. They are not alive.
LLMs are extremely powerful machines.
But that’s what they are: machines.
I don't agree with Scholastics often, but this certainly lands us with a saner view of AI's capabilities.
Wrong reaction: “Wow, AI may be smart enough to solve the Riemann hypothesis!”
Correct reaction: “Wow, human beings are smart enough to invent a machine that may have enabled them to solve the Riemann hypothesis!”
160
Even if you don't accept all his conclusions, he's thinking about these issues in the right way.
Last night on BBC2 Newsnight I explained why, while I held that UK should not have exited the EU, now that it has paid the costs of exit it should not rejoin the EU.
Asked about Andy Burnham's plans, I replied::
"Judging by his demeanour so far, and how grim a campaign to rejoin would be, I strongly suspect that Andy Burnham will honour his aspiration to rejoin the EU in his lifetime more in the breach than in the observance. He has proven such a master at selling the sizzle when he has no intention to serve the steak."
youtube.com/watch?v=jj5_JMYv…
152
Steve Fuller retweeted
#Nagel: "If P, then Q. P is true.
Therefore, R, S, & T because I'm anxious."
I think by 'dead in his lifetime', he really means the living dead, or 'zombie', since most living philosophers are not accused of being reactionary.
“A philosopher who does not draw the accusation of being reactionary is dead in his lifetime.”
Peter Sloterdijk, Zeilen und Tage IV: Notizen 2017–2020
1
2
328













