Elfriede (@8Sigils) header
Elfriede (@8Sigils) profile picture

Chaotic Neutral Philosopher 20 Non-Binary (greygender) AroPan Interests: ethics, left-libertarianism, feminism, ethical veganism, atheism, anti-capitalism They

Joined January 2023
Photo by Elfriede (@8Sigils)Photo by Elfriede (@8Sigils)
Trying to explain ethics to a numbskull like they don't genuinely believe in divine command theory or natural law
1
16
You make a comparison between two groups who are systematically abused and exploited for self-service and the opps look at you with a straight face and tell you that one is okay because they're tasty.
unavailable
15
Theists who run moral critiques of atheists are utterly clueless of normative ethics and metaethics that they think this is a good question. I wish more ordinary people were at least informed on basic moral philosophy so that this question gets rightfully shut down.
a classic from the vault
1
23
Easy answer (not my view, but it suffices): an action A is wrong iff A is prohibited by a set of rules, where the rules are chosen based on how much they violate the rights of others.
1
10
If chickens have a basic set of rights to not be killed, violated and then eaten, then it is prohibited by the rules to do those actions insofar as the rights of the chickens are violated. Easy answer (leaving aside whether chickens have such rights).
5
What's the point of being against The-Animal-Killing-Machine and not the Group-Who-Does-The-Killing?
This quoted post is unavailable.
1
14
180
Had the misfortune of giving my take on one anti-vegan post and now every time I open Twitter it's this shitty "white vegan" strawman from "leftists". Ethical veganism is the biggest litmus test ever, holy shit...
1
6
98
1,030
Polly posts an obviously correct satirical depiction of the contradictory position of anti-oppression speciesists and gets hit with people fundamentally misunderstanding analogical reasoning...
This quoted post is unavailable.
12
16
3
267
3,621
Even worse for the depicted person: this person is not only complicit in the conditions of oppression but is supposed to *detect* when one is complicit, yet can't detect their own complicity. This person clearly fails to achieve what they're committed to.
1
10
361
The trilemma is: (1) Be unknowingly self-defeating to one's own commitments, or (2) Explicitly self-defeat one's own commitments, or (3) Alter one's own commitments for exclusionary purposes. Every one of these options is a reason in favor of the vegan position here.
10
325
Forgot how unwoke Instagram is that I got blindsided by someone I follow comparing Elon Musk's 'autistic' nazi salute to a guy with Tourette's saying n1gger. No elaboration, no explanation, just spouting that they will not fall for 'it'.
66
Just got called a "locking predscan" on Mcree... Overwatch is such an interesting game.
71
"If I didn't do it, they would've been worse off, so it was for the better" Seems like the same type of justification for beating your child. This paternalistm rests on a couple moral and empirical questions that never seem to be adequately answered by their proponents...
One of the core tenets of bullying that no one wants to admit is that the tradeoff for the trauma was nipping the edgy bullshit in the bud and stopping the dweeb routine cold.
1
1
2
419
Why is it that one can't defend any retributive moral theory without defending, at the same time, an obviously and equally undesirable conclusion on the same principles??
56
I find it interesting how an overarching narrative of 'being a proper adult' is to let yourself be disrespected without feeling anything. Lots of 'adults' with their 'appropriate' responses want others to be mindless maturity machines to the point of suppressing your emotions.
This quoted post is unavailable.
94
How did so many people mistake her expressing sympathy for 'Twitter American whitey tries to do politics from the armchair'?
This quoted post is unavailable.
28