Abdullah (@AbdullahReads_) header
Abdullah (@AbdullahReads_) profile picture

Researcher & student, pursuing the depths of Islamic tradition & sharing from the path of Sacred Knowledge - bridging classical texts & modern academic thought

Joined July 2023
Let’s be clear about the nature of this platform: X is not the venue for serious academic discourse. Deep research, debate, and bahth require a level of rigour, patience, and a specific audience that can not be found here.
2
4
30
14,728
Not opposition to Atharism, but four elders of our Deobandi tradition have been misrepresented. I knew three: Shaykh Yunus, my dearest teacher and first Shaykh in tasawwuf; Mawlana Abdullah Kapodrawi; and my teacher, Mawlana Aqil. They and Mawlana Sarfraz Khan were not Athari.
Replying to @BroHajji
*Hanafi scholars that followed the creed of Ahl al-Hadith:* 1. Imam Abu Yusuf al-Ansari (d. 182 AH) 2. Imam Muhammad ibn al-Hasan al-Shaybani (d. 189 AH) 3. Imam Abu Sulayman al-Jawzjani (d. after 200 AH) 4. Imam Muʿalla ibn Mansur al-Razi (d. 211 AH) 5. Imam ʿAbd Allah ibn Dawud al-Khuraybi (d. 213 AH) 6. Imam Yahya ibn Maʿin (d. 233 AH) 7. Imam Ibrahim ibn Yusuf al-Bahili al-Balkhi (d. 239 or 241 AH) 8. Imam Yahya ibn Aktham al-Tamimi (d. 242 or 243 AH) 9. Imam Ahmad ibn Abi ʿImran al-Hanafi (d. 280 AH) 10. Imam al-Hakam ibn Maʿbad al-Khuzaʿi (d. 295 AH) 11. Imam Abu Jaʿfar al-Tahawi (d. 321 AH) 12. Imam Muhammad ibn al-Fadl al-Balkhi (d. approximately 419 AH) 13. Imam Abu Nasr al-Sijzi (d. 444 AH) 14. Imam al-Hasan ibn Abi Bakr al-Naysaburi (active around 538 AH; death date unverified) 15. Imam Abu ʿAbd Allah Muhammad ibn Yahya al-Zubaydi (d. 550 AH) 16. Imam Abu al-Yaman Taj al-Din al-Kindi (d. 613 AH) 17. Imam Ibn Abi al-ʿIzz al-Hanafi (d. 792 AH) 18. Shaykh Muhammad Saʿid Safar al-Madani (d. 1192 AH) 19. Shaykh Muhammad Amin al-Waʿiz al-Hanafi (d. 1273 AH) 20. Shaykh Nuʿman Khayr al-Din al-Alusi (d. 1317 AH) 21. Shaykh Mahmud Shukri al-Alusi (d. 1342 AH) 22. Mawlana Sayyid Sulayman Nadwi (d. 1373 AH) 23. Mawlana Abu al-Kalam Azad (d. 1377 AH) 24. Shaykh Ahmad Muhammad Shakir (d. 1377 AH) 25. Shaykh Muhammad Bahjat al-Athari (d. 1416 AH) 26. Shaykh ʿAbd al-Qadir al-Arnaʾut (d. 1425 AH) 27. Shaykh Sarfraz Khan Safdar (d. 1430 AH) 28. Shaykh Dr ʿAbd Allah Jahangir (d. 1437 AH) 29. Shaykh Muhammad Yunus Jawnpuri (d. 1438 AH) 30. Shaykh Shuʿayb al-Arnaʾut (d. 1438 AH) 31. Shaykh ʿAbd Allah Kapodrawi (d. 1439 AH) 32. Shaykh Dilwar Hussain Sayeedi (d. 1445 AH) 33. Shaykh Muhammad ʿAqil Saharanpuri (d. 1446 AH) *Contemporary scholars:* 34. Shaykh Dr Muhammad Akram Nadwi 35. Shaykh Hussam al-Humaydah 36. Shaykh ʿAbd al-Qayyum al-Athari 37. Shaykh Abu ʿUbayd al-Athari 38. Shaykh Dr Raʾid ibn ʿAbd Allah al-Mulla 39. Shaykh Ahmadullah al-Hanafi 40. Shaykh Mufti Tariq Masood 41. Shaykh Sayyid Muʿin al-Din al-Hanafi 42. Shaykh ʿAdil al-Mutayrat al-Kuwaiti 43. Shaykh Anwarullah Ludin 44. Shaykh Jaʿfaruddin al-Kamali 45. Shaykh Ismail Kamdar 46. Shaykh Mawlana Makki al-Hijazi 47. Shaykh Dr Ibrahim Shasho al-Halabi 3/3
3
2
26
1,363
Shaykh rahimahullah, Mawlana 'Āqil and Mawlana Abdullah Kapodrawi were also upon this creed. Those individuals that have watched a 1 minute clip of Shaykh saying hadith e rahmah affirms 'uluww shows he was athari is disrespectful to those who sat at his feet
1
3
213
I do not believe the two brothers @BroHajji and @KashmiriHanbali had any bad intentions though. I do not desire to address the list either or oppose atharism, but only to clarify the misrepresented positions of my elders - especially those of my two beloved late teachers
1
5
219
Finally got around to watching this. What's the problem?
Shaykh Taqi Usmani has done his job. Has written excellent books. It’s time for him to retire from this kind of interactions. He is on the road to senility. His English is not that good. His generation does not understand Palantir and its trans humanist agenda. It’s not a stock or a company. It’s Evil incarnate. Example of “halal meat and haram meat” from medieval texts are not going to cut it, most respectfully. I see elderly scholars undoing their great legacies by not retiring on time. Time for his students to come forward and communicate what they have learned with impeccable language skills, and transcending the “contract is valid” trap and see the forest for the trees, and save fiqh before it becomes too late.
1
8
932
“Were all of the contradicting opinions following the sunnah?” Is it possible “sheikh” that two different groups can interpret the same text differently? Didn’t the salaf say that the one who is ignorant of the differences of opinion of the ulema is not allowed to give fatwa???
The 4 schools of thought had different opinions and verdicts. Were all these contradicting opinions following the sunnah?? Of course not as the sunnah is one and not many! This means that they did their best but failed and only one was in accordance to the sunnah. This is why Allah ordered us in the Quran to refer to Allah and His Messenger if ever there was a dispute over a ruling, which is the Quran and sunnah, and this is what the 4 great Imams of these schools of thought had ordered their followers. They clearly said that whenever what I say goes against the sunnah, disregard what I say and follow the sunnah. Unfortunately ignorant people and blind followers don’t know this but they are very good in showing the world how ignorant they are! Allah has said this clearly in the Quran and that would have been sufficient for anyone claiming to be Muslim: “And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allāh and the Messenger, if you should believe in Allāh and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and best in result”. 4:59
3
13
127
3,210
He is basically denying that no Ikhtilaaf exists. But what about this? Salafism has 100× times more Ikhtilaaf among themselves than it is among any 4 Madhhab within themselves.
The 4 schools of thought had different opinions and verdicts. Were all these contradicting opinions following the sunnah?? Of course not as the sunnah is one and not many! This means that they did their best but failed and only one was in accordance to the sunnah. This is why Allah ordered us in the Quran to refer to Allah and His Messenger if ever there was a dispute over a ruling, which is the Quran and sunnah, and this is what the 4 great Imams of these schools of thought had ordered their followers. They clearly said that whenever what I say goes against the sunnah, disregard what I say and follow the sunnah. Unfortunately ignorant people and blind followers don’t know this but they are very good in showing the world how ignorant they are! Allah has said this clearly in the Quran and that would have been sufficient for anyone claiming to be Muslim: “And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allāh and the Messenger, if you should believe in Allāh and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and best in result”. 4:59
13
38
1
370
23,935
How is helping women in your family/community get married being a cuck? What's wrong with people these days?
Massive L ngl and cucked
5
13
1,014
As an imam, plenty of people come to me asking about marriage. I guess next time I'll them I'm not a cuck so I can't help them
1
8
225
Replying to @HussainKamani
@HussainKamani would hazrat mawlana yusuf motala rh approve of this?
2
3
1
11
4,472
Shaykh al-Arnaut: the 20 rak'āt riwayah of Sa'ib ibn Yazid meets Bukhari’s criteria. Allamah Kashmiri: those rejecting the majority opinion and practice of 20, while labelling the Sahaba’s practice of 20 as bid'ah should fear for their end.
3
9
2
63
2,167
How we spend our Friday nights...
10
26
2
365
11,286
Some people think they know it all. We had a student in madrassah regarding whom I received complaints from senior students that he would make all sorts of controversial claims, picked up online. He left, and I hear things aren't going well. May Allah guide him. Always be humble.
3
2
29
2,009
Especially before your teachers and those senior in knowledge.
1
16
340
Some Reflections on the Bajan Muslim Community Alhamdulillah, this past summer I had the fortune to visit the island of Barbados, Home to around 280,000 people, 5,500 of whom are Muslims, majority being Indian Gujuratis who settled in the early 20th century.
3
3
13
1,285
I always miss teaching maktab. I am obviously grateful for the opportunity to teach Arabic, fiqh, hadith and tafsir, but I do really miss teaching children.
I remember when I stopped teaching maktab. One student asked, “Mawlana, will I see you again?” I was close to crying, so I stayed quiet. Students always have a place in their heart for teachers, but I promise you that students affect us more than they ever realise.
1
1
40
1,321
I remember when I stopped teaching maktab. One student asked, “Mawlana, will I see you again?” I was close to crying, so I stayed quiet. Students always have a place in their heart for teachers, but I promise you that students affect us more than they ever realise.
Last day of Maktab today.. I called my students in for a little farewell speech, just to give them some advice for the holidays and the coming year. They all sat down, ready to listen to what I had to say...
8
4
49
4,058