'Ana' retweeted
the older i get, the more i realize that being slightly obsessed with something is the only thing keeping life interesting
'Ana' retweeted
ao3 slow as hell but that's okay u don't expect someone who just woke up from a coma to go on a marathon. take ur time baby <3
'Ana' retweeted
sinceramente, odio que hayamos normalizado la idea de que todas las opiniones son válidas. Creo que deberíamos volver a decirle a la gente que está mal informada y es ignorante.
'Ana' retweeted
all newjeans drags are so stupid. yes my favs aren’t absurdly underweight?? yes my favs stood up against mistreatment?? what i am supposed to get mad at??
Uhmm okay so reading the whole verdict, the belift ruling was quite conservative. The judge found an middle spot and stay there. He could have been more aggressive into one side or another but he chose to basically dismiss it
Why Did the Court Dismiss Both BELIFT LAB’s and Min Hee-jin’s Claims? [On-Site EN: Comprehensive]
nocutnews.co.kr/news/6606864
CBS No Cut News Reporter Kim Soo-jung
Key Takeaways
- Court rules against BELIFT LAB and SOURCE MUSIC in their first-instance damages lawsuits against former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin.
- Court considers many of Min’s statements at her press conference, including the use of the word “plagiarism,” to be expressions of opinion.
- Court reasons that punishing such statements could stifle the healthy development and critical evaluation of popular culture and the arts.
- However, the court explicitly states that “NewJeans’ achievements do not belong to Min Hee-jin personally.”
BELIFT LAB and SOURCE MUSIC, HYBE-affiliated labels representing the groups LE SSERAFIM and ILLIT, respectively, have both lost their damages lawsuits against former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin (currently CEO of OK Records).
The court consistently maintained that “statements of fact” must be distinguished from “expressions of opinion.” It expressed concern that recognizing defamation and imposing punishment based solely on expressions of opinion containing subjective evaluations could have the adverse effect of discouraging public discourse and hindering the development of culture and the arts.
The Seoul Western District Court’s 12th Civil Division delivered its first-instance rulings on the damages lawsuits filed separately by BELIFT LAB and SOURCE MUSIC against Min on the afternoon of the 13th.
In the former case, the court ruled, “Both parties’ claims are dismissed. The plaintiff shall bear the costs arising from the main action, while the defendant shall bear the costs arising from the counterclaim.”
In the latter case, the court ruled, “The plaintiff’s claim is dismissed. The plaintiff shall bear the litigation costs.”
The hearings, which began at 5 p.m. that afternoon, lasted approximately 26 minutes as the court explained its legal interpretation of the arguments presented by both the plaintiffs and the defendant. The court viewed most of Min’s statements in ADOR’s official statement released on April 24, 2024, and at her press conference held on April 25, 2024, as “expressions of opinion” containing subjective evaluations, emphasizing the importance of “freedom of expression.”
Neither “Min Hee-jin’s Dissemination of False Information” nor “BELIFT LAB’s Business Interference” Was Established
At the time, ADOR’s official statement included expressions such as, “They are copying NewJeans in every area of their entertainment activities, including hair, makeup, clothing, choreography, photography, videos, and event appearances,” and “ILLIT is being described as ‘Min Hee-jin-esque,’ ‘in the style of Min Hee-jin,’ and ‘an imitation of NewJeans,’ among other things.”
During her press conference, Min said, “(ILLIT) copied our production formula far too much,” adding, “If everyone starts thinking, ‘Why not just copy something that has already succeeded?’ then everyone will become NewJeans. This is what ruins the industry.”
Min also said, “There shouldn't be copying. When copying happens, aren't we just cannibalizing one another? At first, I thought they were deliberately trying to destroy NewJeans.”
BELIFT LAB filed a ₩2 billion lawsuit, arguing that it had suffered damages as a result of Min’s dissemination of false information and that she should therefore be held liable for compensation.
The court noted that the Supreme Court has held that defamation can only be established through “statements of fact,” rather than “expressions of opinion.”
“The Constitution of the Republic of Korea guarantees freedom of expression and freedom of the arts. Works of popular culture and art, such as K-pop, become subjects of appreciation and interpretation by a wide range of audiences from the moment they are made public,” the court said. “The communication of information about creative works, public criticism, and the free exchange of opinions are all important.”
In other words, the court's position was that if simply “evaluating” a creative work could give rise to legal liability, “the public forum for discussion would be stifled, ultimately hindering the development of the arts.”
The court explained that freedom of expression in popular culture and the arts applies to everyone involved, including creators, those who communicate or present the works, and audiences. It added that “expressions or statements that inevitably involve evaluative elements should not be casually treated as statements of fact.”
The court also provided examples.
“‘Plagiarism’ and ‘copying’ can mean unlawful imitation, but they are also used to convey moral or ethical criticism that someone has followed the image or style of another work. The expression ‘imitation’ inherently contains a value judgment,” the court said, viewing Min’s remarks as “subjective and rhetorical expressions.”
The court continued, “Since audiences were able to view the resulting works and independently decide whether they agreed with the defendant’s (Min Hee-jin’s) evaluation, it is reasonable to regard her statements as expressions of opinion.”
The court also explained that determining whether a particular expression constitutes a “statement of fact” requires examining its meaning. Furthermore, when assessing whether defamation has occurred, it is necessary to consider who made the statement, who it was directed at, and the positions held by the parties.
It went on to say, “Even before the defendant made these statements, there had already been considerable public reaction concerning the similarities between ILLIT and NewJeans. Rather than revealing new facts for the first time, the defendant was adding her own evaluation.”
The court expressed concern that “if legal liability were imposed for such statements, everyone who expressed an opinion about imitation or plagiarism in creative works would feel burdened, causing such discussions to disappear from the public forum. This could discourage criticism of creative works and the raising of concerns about them.”
Regarding BELIFT LAB’s argument that “Min disseminated false information and interfered with its business,” the court stated, “Since the statements constitute expressions of opinion rather than statements of fact, they cannot be regarded as the dissemination of false information. Furthermore, it is difficult to find that they were unlawful. Accordingly, the plaintiff’s arguments cannot be accepted.”
The court also dismissed the ₩5 billion counterclaim Min filed in response to the main lawsuit.
Min argued that BELIFT LAB had infringed upon the interests associated with the achievements she had built by planning and debuting ILLIT through imitation of NewJeans.
However, the court ruled:
“Taking into account the various circumstances, including the roles and contributions of NewJeans, SOURCE MUSIC, ADOR, and the defendant (Min Hee-jin), the achievements created through NewJeans should be regarded as the result of the efforts of multiple parties, including ADOR and the corporations that invested in the formation and debut of NewJeans, rather than the defendant personally. Therefore, it is difficult to regard them as achievements personally built by the defendant. We cannot accept the argument that NewJeans’ achievements are the personal achievements of the defendant.”
Regarding the claim that planning and debuting ILLIT by imitating NewJeans constituted business interference, the court stated:
“The plaintiff (BELIFT LAB) planning and producing ILLIT was merely conducting its own business and cannot be seen as obstruction through deception, coercion, false information, or other methods. While it is argued that the value of achievements related to NewJeans was damaged (by ILLIT’s debut), considering that the achievements of NewJeans belong to ADOR and others rather than the defendant as an individual, it cannot be considered that liability for damages against the plaintiff has been established.”
In her counterclaim, Min also sought a correction notice regarding BELIFT LAB’s official statements and YouTube posts claiming that ILLIT had not plagiarized or imitated NewJeans.
However, applying the same reasoning it used in the main lawsuit, the court rejected Min’s request, stating that BELIFT LAB had also expressed its opinions and presented its own interpretations rather than making specific statements of fact.
Why Was SOURCE MUSIC’s Ruling a “Complete Defeat,” Including the Order to Bear All Litigation Costs?
Previously, SOURCE MUSIC filed a ₩500 million damages lawsuit against Min, arguing that several of her statements were false. These included her claims that:
She personally cast the NewJeans members.
HYBE unilaterally broke its promise to debut NewJeans as HYBE’s first girl group.
SOURCE MUSIC neglected the NewJeans members.
The essence of SOURCE MUSIC’s arguments was similar to BELIFT LAB’s: Min had allegedly committed an unlawful act by disseminating false information and interfering with its business.
The court reiterated that defamation cannot be established when a statement is an expression of opinion rather than a statement of fact.
It then explained:
“In cases of defamation through the dissemination of false information, if the essential parts of the statement are consistent with objective facts, minor discrepancies in details or somewhat exaggerated expressions do not make the statement ‘false information.’
“Even when defamation arises from a statement of fact, there is no unlawfulness if the statement was made in the public interest and the facts stated are true, or if the person making the statement believed them to be true or had reasonable grounds to believe they were true.”
The court pointed out that the statements SOURCE MUSIC challenged were made during Min’s press conference on April 25, 2024, which lasted more than two hours.
“Considering these circumstances, the meaning of the defendant’s statements should be determined not by looking only at the specific phrases challenged by the plaintiff, but by considering how an ordinary viewer who watched the entire press conference would have understood them,” the court said.
The court determined that most of Min’s statements were expressions of opinion. These included:
SOURCE MUSIC is a label that has not established a strong brand identity.
The members other than Minji were cast after seeing the prospect of becoming HYBE’s first girl group.
One member’s mother would not have allowed her to join if the company had been BELIFT LAB.
“I was the one who cast them. I was the one who did those things.”
The court explained:
“Rather than stating as a fact that the defendant (Min Hee-jin) independently discovered and recruited the NewJeans members without any assistance from the plaintiff (SOURCE MUSIC), she appears to have been conveying that her reputation influenced the trainee selection and casting process, and that she exercised primary decision-making authority throughout the entire process, including trainee selection and evaluations.”
What about the highly contested issue of the “debut order”?
The court stated, “Our understanding is that the original plan was to debut Team N (NewJeans) as HYBE’s first girl group, but the decision was subsequently changed to debut Team S (LE SSERAFIM) first, and this change was communicated to the defendant.”
It continued:
“According to the records, it is established that the plaintiff initially intended to debut the NewJeans members first, but later changed its plans due to changed circumstances and decided to debut Team S first. There is no evidence showing that the defendant exercised decision-making authority over this change in plans. On the contrary, the evidence only supports that the defendant strongly protested the decision. Considering these circumstances, it is difficult to conclude that her statements on this matter constituted false statements of fact.”
Furthermore, the court stated:
“Even if the defendant’s statements made thus far contained information capable of lowering the plaintiff’s social reputation, the statements were made in the public interest, and the information was either true or there were reasonable grounds to believe it was true. In light of the legal principle that such circumstances do not constitute unlawfulness, it appears that no unlawful conduct occurred.”
Regarding the claim that the term “yangachi” (a derogatory term roughly meaning “thug” or “low-life”) was insulting, the court said:
“Although ‘yangachi’ is a vulgar expression used to demean another person, it appears that the term was directed at HYBE, rather than the plaintiff, or possibly at the change in NewJeans’ debut order made by the plaintiff at HYBE’s direction. It cannot be said that this expression significantly diminished the plaintiff’s social reputation.”
Finally, regarding the business-interference claim, the court rejected SOURCE MUSIC’s argument, stating:
“For the dissemination of false information to constitute an unlawful act of business interference, it must be established that information that is objectively untrue was disseminated. However, it cannot be said that the defendant disseminated false information through her press conference. Therefore, the plaintiff’s argument on this point is also without merit.”
Immediately after the first-instance ruling, Min’s side welcomed the decision, stating:
“The key point of this ruling is the clear fact that all of the plaintiffs’ claims were dismissed as without merit. We view this as the judiciary delivering a common-sense judgment in response to excessive legal attacks and attempts to shift responsibility.”
BELIFT LAB and SOURCE MUSIC, on the other hand, announced that they would immediately appeal.
BELIFT LAB stated, “We are deeply disappointed that the ruling effectively suggests that there are victims but no perpetrators.”
SOURCE MUSIC said, “We feel disappointed and helpless in facing the reality that, despite the evidence we submitted pointing to the clear truth, we were unable to receive the protection of the law.”
Meanwhile, the Seoul Western District Court’s 12th Civil Division, which ruled in favor of Min in the BELIFT LAB and SOURCE MUSIC damages lawsuits, also delivered another high-profile ruling on the same day. The court ruled against broadcaster Park Soo-hong in his damages lawsuit against his older brother, Park (surname only), and his sister-in-law, Lee (surname only), and ordered Park Soo-hong to bear the litigation costs as well.
1
113
Hybe truly loves to waste money… Like this whole circus must be so expensive but they keep on pushing 🥴 for what? Like I don’t see any of this worth it for them 😬
Min Heejin winning against Belift & Source Music
Both 🤡🤡will appeal saying
Belift: We did not even have the opportunity to have the crucial new evidence we obtained and submitted examined.
Source: Min Hee-jin's reckless and indiscriminate false statements caused enormous damage to a label where trust with its trainees and artists is absolutely essential.
The court sided only with Min Hee-jin's position and turned a blind eye to actions that inflicted irreparable emotional wounds on artists who were not even direct parties to the dispute.
the fact that hybe, belift lab, source music, serian heu, and employee b have all lost to min heejin in court proves that only reason newjeans’ entire lives and careers have been derailed is because of a slave contract that takes all their rights away. NEWJEANS WAS NEVER WRONG.






































