
Two under three | Building the greatest learning app for AP https://teapaw.org/t.co/SnVAXpsBye | Leading the EdTech Revolution with @Superbuilders | Cohort 2 @joingauntletai
Joined February 2021
- Tweets2.7K
- Following726
- Followers778
- Likes93.2K
Recently found out I am a product of DI! My mom used "Teach Your Child to Read in 100 Easy Lessons" on all of us kids.
The latest Sold a Story episode was great! I especially liked @C_Hendrick's comments about the beginner vs the expert. Students struggle at the complex stuff if they lack the knowledge of the fundamentals.
We built our AP Physics course with this in mind. We assume virtually no physics experience (sometimes AP is the first physics class students take). So we start with the fundamentals, then build up to complex problem solving. Some lessons might seem very basic to an outsider, but if students don't have a firm grasp on things like acceleration or forces, the tough stuff is out of their reach.
My biggest takeaway from Theory of Instruction is that it's possible to design a lesson that ensures a student walks away with exactly the concept you intend to teach.
No need to guess or hope that some explanation or activity will just click for them all.
mcbagz | edu/acc retweeted
Error correction often ends at giving the right answer and moving on. This post by @DaveVanStory talks about the Direct Instruction correction procedures, and what changes with "Repeat until firm." Thanks to @stein_marc36792 for reviewing.
And Engelmann is even more strict about it than I laid out. Within the very first teaching sequence, you want the examples to avoid misrules as soon as possible.
If you show: 1/3, 1/5, 2/6, 5/9, 5/3 - you are risking a misrule from the first few examples. It likely isn't deeply set yet, but you don't want a student to have to keep updating the rule throughout the lesson. That's inefficient and confusing.
Vary the example as much as possible, as soon as possible. Make the rule unmistakeable from the start, and the lesson will make sure it is firm.
Finally listened to Sold a Story. One of the most insightful things I've found in DI had a brief mention in episode 2: the misrule.
It's probably a natural instinct that has to be suppressed. It feels like it would be better to teach a simple or narrow set of examples first, then broaden it. But without enough variance or juxtaposition in the initial teaching, students will pick up on an incorrect definition or rule, a misrule.
The example in the episode was fractions. What are fractions? Well, here are some examples:
1/2, 1/3, 1/4, 1/5 - obvious misrule: "a fraction has 1 on top." Let's refine it:
1/2, 3/5, 2/4, 7/9 - less obvious misrule: "a fraction has the smaller number on top." Refine again:
1/3, 7/2, 5/8, 6/3 - there might still be some misrules; it's hard to know everything a student might accidentally pick up. For instant, none of these examples use double digit numbers, or have the same number on top and bottom.
I don't want it to seem futile. It's true that there are likely misrules you won't be able to identify until you put the lesson in front of students. But I've found it helpful to look at the whole course, or the assessment.
Will students need to recognize something like 7/3 as a fraction later on? Well, when I teach them to recognize fractions (or what a fraction is), I should make sure they can recognize something like 7/3 as a fraction. If I don't, I'll not only have to teach it again later, but also un-teach the misrule the students picked up.
Finally listened to Sold a Story. One of the most insightful things I've found in DI had a brief mention in episode 2: the misrule.
It's probably a natural instinct that has to be suppressed. It feels like it would be better to teach a simple or narrow set of examples first, then broaden it. But without enough variance or juxtaposition in the initial teaching, students will pick up on an incorrect definition or rule, a misrule.
The example in the episode was fractions. What are fractions? Well, here are some examples:
1/2, 1/3, 1/4, 1/5 - obvious misrule: "a fraction has 1 on top." Let's refine it:
1/2, 3/5, 2/4, 7/9 - less obvious misrule: "a fraction has the smaller number on top." Refine again:
1/3, 7/2, 5/8, 6/3 - there might still be some misrules; it's hard to know everything a student might accidentally pick up. For instant, none of these examples use double digit numbers, or have the same number on top and bottom.
I don't want it to seem futile. It's true that there are likely misrules you won't be able to identify until you put the lesson in front of students. But I've found it helpful to look at the whole course, or the assessment.
Will students need to recognize something like 7/3 as a fraction later on? Well, when I teach them to recognize fractions (or what a fraction is), I should make sure they can recognize something like 7/3 as a fraction. If I don't, I'll not only have to teach it again later, but also un-teach the misrule the students picked up.
It's clear that the EdTech apps that will be most successful will use Direct Instruction. It's the most efficient way to teach, so it'll always win against other methods.
My wife has been doing bits of homeschooling with the toddler, and she asked me for ideas on things they should cover. I found the Core Knowledge curriculum, and I like it!
They have a set of standards for PreK. Within each category, there are some my daughter is already hitting, so it's clear what needs to be taught. It seems like a good scope and range of topics.
Link to free download, if people are interested. coreknowledge.org/free-resou…
1
10
764
One thing I like in the PreK standards is the two separate levels. My daughter can count to 4. My wife and I discussed whether to keep teaching more numbers or make sure 1-4 is solid.
We didn't have a good idea on what "solid" should entail. But these standards are helpful! In Level I, there are a handful of things you should be able to do with 1-4. They show an understanding of what the numbers are, not just naming them and reciting them in order.
My wife has been doing bits of homeschooling with the toddler, and she asked me for ideas on things they should cover. I found the Core Knowledge curriculum, and I like it!
They have a set of standards for PreK. Within each category, there are some my daughter is already hitting, so it's clear what needs to be taught. It seems like a good scope and range of topics.
It's crazy to take a step back and realize how far the models have come. Even Haiku 5.5 is far superior to any model we had access to a year ago during @gauntletai
1
14
389
I can't wait for the day that a NeuraLink chip in my brain will just pick up a subconscious thought about improving the project, send out cloud agents to make the improvement, so when I finally boot up my computer the project is already built to my perfect specification.
7
211
Ready for OpenAI to dedicate 100,000 GPUs and 100 experts to discovering a room temperature superconductor. Come on, you can't have Claude winning on materials research!
For decades, researchers have sought materials that sort electrons by spin while their magnetism cancels.
In 3 days, 90+ Opus 5.5 agents helped us uncover two room-temperature magnetic semiconductor candidates in simulations: YBaMnFeO₅ and KV[Cr(CN)₆].
KV[Cr(CN)₆] was synthesized back in 1999. Its predicted ability to sort electrons by spin appears to have been hiding in plain sight for 27 years.
2
214
I was quite impressed when my 2 year old pointed to a few 'O's and said "O" for each one.
It's nice to have validation from the experts in my feeling impressed. I was worried it was just because I'm her dad that I felt that way.
Replying to @NielsHoven
It's not developmentally appropriate for a child to learn individual letters at 2½ or 3, says Susan Neuman, a professor of childhood and literacy education at New York University
(4/n)
1
5
901
This work inspired the development of the Force Concept Inventory. It's really a great test with approachable language that will very clearly tell whether or not someone has a correct understanding of physics.
Back in the 80s a study found that the highest predictor of success in a physics class was having an intuitive understanding of physics concepts.
Math skills were a close second. Previous math or physics classes had much less impact on student success.
4
520
My favorite part of this study is that it found incredibly low growth in conceptual understanding after completing the physics course. These students spent a semester solving physics problems for class, but left with the same misconceptions they had at the beginning.
Back in the 80s a study found that the highest predictor of success in a physics class was having an intuitive understanding of physics concepts.
Math skills were a close second. Previous math or physics classes had much less impact on student success.
1
6
558














