Pinned Tweet
Part - 1
Critical analysis of Avatartva of Madhwacharya : shorturl.at/rIjLj
Critical analysis of Avatartva of Shankaracharya and Dvaitaadvaita Khandana will follow soon.
@pratyaksha321 @Kul_Mimansaka @kpp0915
Dr. Basavaraj Hiremath retweeted
Save the dates. Koppala Shree Gavisiddeshwara Jatre will be on Sunday, January 24th, 2027. 😊 🙏
🤖 Made with AI
Absolute state of Hindus. Bro wants hindus to when Dvaitis like you call your own brahmin Shankaracharya as Jaara Putra (b*s*rd) as shastra sammatha 😂😂
🤣🤣🤣 this dvaiti believes that calling Shankaracharya as jaara putra is shastra sammatha 😂😂 these dvaitaadvaitis you know 😂😂😂 @kpp0915 @Kul_Mimansaka agree with your fellow brahmin dvaiti? 😂😂
Absolute state of Hindus. Bro wants Hindus to unite when criticisms (shāstra-sammatha) happens against Adi Shankaracharya. But Bro's favorite politician establishes pancha-teerth to worship some-vidhaan maker who insulted Rama, Krishna and entire Hinduism.
1
1
227
🤣🤣 as I said earlier their flawed dvaita philosophy continues to get bashing
Even if we accept the dual split (Svatantra & Asvatantra), why restrict Svatantra to one? Asvatantra entities have bahutva . By the same, why not multiple Svatantras? Why only Hari, and not Śiva too? 🧵n/1 @pratyaksha321 @Agnidhra_ @Basavarajhmath @amaresh28447 @TheLogicMonk
1
6
396
Dr. Basavaraj Hiremath retweeted
Even if we accept the dual split (Svatantra & Asvatantra), why restrict Svatantra to one? Asvatantra entities have bahutva . By the same, why not multiple Svatantras? Why only Hari, and not Śiva too? 🧵n/1 @pratyaksha321 @Agnidhra_ @Basavarajhmath @amaresh28447 @TheLogicMonk
Funny but you are the one who participate the debate no? It should apply to you also 🤣🤣😀😀
जालवीरविडम्बनम् (Jaalaveera-vidambanam - mockery of internet warriors (vedanta debate warriors 😊)
A short Sanskrit ashtakam on Internet Vedanta debates and why Shri Hari probably watches our timeline debates with a gentle smile.
A thread 👇
1
45
Dr. Basavaraj Hiremath retweeted
जालवीरविडम्बनम् (Jaalaveera-vidambanam - mockery of internet warriors (vedanta debate warriors 😊)
A short Sanskrit ashtakam on Internet Vedanta debates and why Shri Hari probably watches our timeline debates with a gentle smile.
A thread 👇
Dr. Basavaraj Hiremath retweeted
ಬಸವಣ್ಣನವರಿಗೆ ಅಪಮಾನ ಮಾಡಿದವರ ವಿರುದ್ಧ ಮಹಾರಾಷ್ಟ್ರದಲ್ಲಿ ತೀವ್ರ ವಿರೋಧ
#IStandWithBasavanna
#ಸಾಂಸ್ಕೃತಿಕನಾಯಕಬಸವಣ್ಣ
1/5
At Pañcabheda Palace, a student held a pot and fainted—trying to cognize its "essence-difference" from the whole universe. The guest smiled:
घटो यदि स्वतो भेदः पश्यन् घटं जगत् स्मरेत् ।
नो चेद् घटं न जानीयाद् द्वैतवादस्य कौतुकम् ॥
4/5
In the locked Andhatamas cellar sat a soul wired to Hari's power, holding a prescription that can't cure him. "No blame!" beamed the Paṇḍita. "Hari is impartial as rain!"
सङ्कल्पोऽपि हरेः शक्त्या तमोऽनादि सुनिश्चितम् ।
तथापि नैव वैषम्यं पर्जन्योऽयं दयानिधिः ॥
1
2
71
Dr. Basavaraj Hiremath retweeted
Here is my refutation of Tattva Vada.
By Axioms 1 and 2, all eternal reality consists strictly of three categories: Hari (Svatantra), Prakriti (Jada), and Jiva (Chetana). Nothing exists outside these three. n.1
AXIOMS OF TATTVAVADA
Definitions
D1. Svatantra: that entity which depends on nothing else for its sattaa (existence), pratiti (cognition) and pravrtti (functioning).
D2. Paratantra: that which depends on the Svatantra for all three.
Having one's own sankalpa is neither. It is a property of chetana, not of svatantra.
Axioms
1. Hari alone is Svatantra. Everything else is Paratantra.
2. Paratantra is chetana (jiva) or jada. Jivas are many, anadi, nitya, never created.
3. Bheda is the svarupa of each entity, not a relation added on top. It is real and eternal.
4. Each jiva has its own anadi svabhava and yogyata. Hari does not author it.
5. The sankalpa is the jiva's. The samarthya is Hari's.
6. Hari empowers each jiva according to its own svabhava, by His own will.
7. The jiva is karta because the sankalpa is its own, not because it functions on its own. Its willing and acting both depend on Hari. Phala follows sankalpa, so the karta is the bhokta.
8. Shastra is Hari's instruction for the jiva's good, not a statement of His sankalpa. Nothing happens against His sankalpa.
9. Hari is impartial. He shows no preference in bringing out any jiva's svabhava. Differences among jivas come from their own anadi svabhava, not from Him. His prasada follows bhakti, not favour.
10. Bandha is prakriti-bandha rooted in anadi ajnana, whose core is svatantrya-abhimana. Anadi, not ananta.
11. Moksha is release from bandha by Hari's prasada, through jnana and bhakti. Bheda and paratantrya remain. Svarupa-ananda manifests.
12. Pramanas: pratyaksha, anumana, agama. The sakshi is infallible. Pramanya is svatah.
WORKED EXAMPLES
Example 1: A tamasika jiva commits adharma.
What is actually happening:
- The sankalpa is the jiva's, arising from its own anadi svabhava.
- Hari empowers it according to that svabhava, by His own will. Nobody compels Him.
- Shastra had forbidden it. That was instruction, not His sankalpa. His sankalpa was to empower per svabhava, and that is exactly what happened. Nothing went against His sankalpa.
- The phala follows the sankalpa. The jiva who willed it bears it.
Why it doesn't bind Hari:
He supplied the power, not the direction. Rain falls equally on every seed. The neem grows bitter and the mango sweet. Rain is responsible for neither the bitterness nor the sweetness. Without rain, neither seed's svabhava would be expressed.
Example 2: A sattvika jiva gives in charity.
Same structure. The sankalpa is the jiva's. The samarthya is Hari's. The phala is the jiva's.
But if the jiva says "I did this on my own," that is svatantrya-abhimana. Success is just as dependent as failure.
Example 3: Why does a sattvika jiva suffer harm from a tamasika jiva's adharma? It was not his sankalpa.
He undergoes it for two reasons:
1. It is the phala of his own anadi karma. Hari, as karma-phala-data, connects karma to its phala. Karma is anadi, so there was never a first undeserved suffering.
2. His ajnana: the abhimana that takes the body and mind as his own. The harm is done to prakriti. But because he owns that prakriti as "mine," he owns the harm done to it and experiences it. The jiva's svarupa itself can never be touched or harmed by anyone.
What follows:
- This does not excuse the perpetrator. The victim's suffering is the victim's prarabdha. The perpetrator's sankalpa is still his own, and he bears its phala. One jiva's karma never excuses another's sankalpa.
- Karma explains why it happened. It does not justify the act, and it does not blame the victim.
@TheLogicMonk
@kpp0915
Dr. Basavaraj Hiremath retweeted
Body with its name is eternal - A dvaitin! 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Replying to @TheLogicMonk
You skipped my question.
Jumping from a simple clay pot to a complex human body doesn't change the premise. More parts, same logic.
The name Vaaman exists eternally as a form. Throw away the letters, and anyone can arrange them in that form again and it comes back. So with the body's form.
Birth is about matter coming together in that form, here and now. The union is the event. Change of state, not creation from nothing.
So answer me what makes potness as not real as clay? We can go to complex systems accounting later.
Dr. Basavaraj Hiremath retweeted
Replying to @pratyaksha321
Vaaman avare, agreed there were citations mistakes. I didn't intend any mischief there. Now let's stick strictly to the exact Madhva lines you quoted, standard Gītā & Brahma-Sūtra verses, your earlier reply to me. Even on your own texts, the core problems haven't moved an inch.
This was the mindset of Brahmins 1000 years before and continues till today. Some of them now pretend they have changed but they didn't. Atleast should appreciate Mr. Kulkarni for open admission
Those who think eating besides others is some revolutionary task cannot uplift other nor can be uplifted
Pankti bheda is necessary and no sane dharmika thinks of it as injustice. Those who think are not dharmikas to begin with.
1
3
617
🤣🤣🍿🤣🤣
If time exists because of avidya, time depends on avidya, not the other way round. Then avidya can't be removed at a particular moment.
If it is removed at a moment, time was there independently. Then "time vanishes in liberation" just means failing to see a time that is there. Hiding what is there is your own definition of avidya.
Its Either avidya can't be removed, or your liberation is a new avidya.
76
















