
A deep dive into The Case Podcast. @thecasepodcast
Joined February 2021
- Tweets556
- Following109
- Followers1.7K
- Likes204
I don’t understand this. Can’t the machine record & hold multiple messages?
@davecullinane said the bought that model. Can it hold multiple messages? Why not just leave it as is. The original message would have stayed. Who goes into the son in law’s house and deletes a message
Brad Dunlap left a message on the Barber’s answering machine at 5:30pm on the day his wife went missing.
When he got home, he turned off the answering machine and left a note that read “do not touch or unplug.”
Subscribe:
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcas…
2
6
2,401
Ads v reads
true crime is challenging for brands. They’re wary of having a product spot coming right after serious content.
@thecasepodcast’s shift from @kirkmin live reads to independent ad cuts creates distance. It’s clunky, but probably easier for @barstoolsports to sell
3
610
Listener notes S3E2: back on track
Season 2 was hard to follow. It was active investigation speghetti against a wall
This @thecasepodcast episode was classic @kirkmin - step by step detail and discussion laying out the argument cleanly & clearly with producer @davecullinane
Listener notes S2E1: suspense at the expense of timeline
It was a bit hard to follow. I think @kirkmin could have started with Sandra's movements on Jan 31 & taken the listener through the well being check on Feb 4 instead of breaking it up & returning to it later in episode
True crime deep dives
“We [@thecasepodcast] are not a Wikipedia true crime podcast. We like to do the research” - @kirkmin after the Mathew Farwell guilty verdict
13
614
Behind The Case retweeted
🚨 GUILTY ON BOTH COUNTS: Federal jury has convicted former Stoughton Police Officer Matthew Farwell of murdering Sandra Birchmore and causing death of her unborn child.
If the schedule holds, the father of Birchmore’s unborn child takes the stand tomorrow
— US Army Recruiter Will Take Stand Against Cop Accused of Killing Sandra Birchmore —
@kirkmin @thecasepodcast @davecullinane
lamag.com/general/us-army-re…
2
311
Trooper Dunne today:
Initial Farwell interview lasted 15 min & was outside. Police did not take notes, record the conversation, look at his phone or check for any injuries (scratches, bruises)
This was “tactical” to not show suspicion
@kirkmin @thecasepodcast @davecullinane
1
483
When Farwell entered Birchmore’s building he was masked up
Stoughton police detective Heather Cheever testified that she never saw him wear a mask at the station he didn’t take Covid seriously.
So why the mask in the video @kirkmin uncovered?
@thecasepodcast @davecullinane
Did local police rush a suicide conclusion in Birchmore’s death? In opening statements, prosecutors allege that investigators said TO FAREWELL’s TWIN BROTHER !! they needed another investigation like they needed “a bullet in the head”
@thecasepodcast @kirkmin @davecullinane
Farwell attorney admits it is him in the video @kirkmin & @davecullinane helped uncover during season 2 of @thecasepodcast
Replying to @ameliarstern1
Farwell’s defense just admitted that the person in the video entering Birchmore’s apartment days before her death is Farwell. However, they object to the accuracy of the time stamps on the video.
Stoughton police chief accuses town of retaliation for involvement in Sandra Birchmore case
“.. because of her refusal of Calter’s demands that she destroy an investigation report done involving Sandra Birchmore”
@kirkmin @davecullinane @thecasepodcast
whdh.com/news/stoughton-poli…
🚨The Case is not being sold to its most likely supporters 🚨
@thecasepodcast advertising brought in house at @kirkminshow because @barstoolsports sales isn’t pitching the podcast
BUT- KMS sales person can’t approach existing barstool advertisers
@kirkmin @davecullinane
police reports reveal a female coworker of Brad’s has come forward to say she was having a sexual relationship with Brad in the period surrounding Anne’s murder
It’s unknown whether @kirkmin @davecullinane found this woman but we should find out on this season of @thecasepodcast
2
786
Ep1 was rushed out because “time became a factor”. A “local reporter in Minneapolis . . . was going to go forward with the story in the next few days”
Apparently the reporter got a tip from @kirkmin @davecullinane &“did some digging” - it is unknown if additional info was found
In the first episode of Season 3, @kirkmin reports that Brad Dunlap was involved in a sexual relationship with a coworker before and after Anne Dunlap's murder — a detail that was not publicly known.
Subscribe to Season 3 of The Case now:
apple.co/43FNDzo
2
601
The first 5 minutes (which I believe is too long) are spent setting the current scene. Unless Julie Hallmark of Hallmark Interior Design is a character later in the season, I think it’s a detail that isn’t necessary & detracts from the more important items.
Does @kirkmin need a narrative producer to help construct a storyline?
Kirk is an incredible investigator & @davecullinane is a great producer, but I had trouble following this episode.
So much data (dates, names, police reports, interviews, news) to organize into a timeline
1
505
Does @kirkmin need a narrative producer to help construct a storyline?
Kirk is an incredible investigator & @davecullinane is a great producer, but I had trouble following this episode.
So much data (dates, names, police reports, interviews, news) to organize into a timeline
Seems like a very thorough article by @CNN - they talked to everyone BUT the people responsible for keeping this in the public view.
Without @kirkmin @davecullinane @thecasepodcast this would still be considered a suicide
cnn.com/2026/05/26/us/sandra…
Farwell’s DNA was found on the ligature that tied Birchmore’s neck to a closet door handle
@kirkmin @davecullinane @thecasepodcast nbcboston.com/news/local/new…
1
5
286




