Bradley Campbell retweeted
Successful panel of @HdxAcademy criminologists at @ASCRM41 annual meeting #ASC2026 @CampbellSocProf @ashleytrubin @lonecrim @JukkaSavo – at Chicago, IL
Bradley Campbell retweeted
The problem with Nagel is that he’s the best living philosopher and sort of expects you to follow along. That doesn’t mean he’s right about everything. But the idea that he’s just making some obvious mistake with his denial of LLM consciousness is just nonsense.
Nagel isn’t making some dumb mistake. No one seems to understand what “natural manifestation” means.
He likely means two things, both of which are coherent.
(1) consciousness comes before language, and language is an abstraction of it.
(2) there is no such thing as a “purely linguistic experience” for humans, in that language does not naturally manifest in consciousness. You are conscious of language as heard words (LLMs can’t hear) or as it relates to the actions and dispositions of your embodied self (they aren’t embodied either).
Bradley Campbell retweeted
Defining genocide, with @CampbellSocProf on an HxA panel at the ASC meetings.
Bradley Campbell retweeted
Published in 2018.
It was good to see @lonecrim pontificating at the very excellent ASC author-meets-critics session on his new book.
Bradley Campbell retweeted
Nagel isn’t making some dumb mistake. No one seems to understand what “natural manifestation” means.
He likely means two things, both of which are coherent.
(1) consciousness comes before language, and language is an abstraction of it.
(2) there is no such thing as a “purely linguistic experience” for humans, in that language does not naturally manifest in consciousness. You are conscious of language as heard words (LLMs can’t hear) or as it relates to the actions and dispositions of your embodied self (they aren’t embodied either).
Bradley Campbell retweeted
[Mos Eisley] "We don't serve their kind."
Replying to @CampbellSocProf
Broke: It's a hamfisted allegory for Jim Crow
Woke: It's a prescient view of life with AI
Bespoke: A full Butlerian Jihad is an insurmountable collective action problem, but local preservation of humans-only spaces presents a different set of incentives. In this essay... (1/162).
Bradley Campbell retweeted
Replying to @CampbellSocProf
Broke: It's a hamfisted allegory for Jim Crow
Woke: It's a prescient view of life with AI
Bespoke: A full Butlerian Jihad is an insurmountable collective action problem, but local preservation of humans-only spaces presents a different set of incentives. In this essay... (1/162).
Bradley Campbell retweeted
Replying to @JensChristianh6
A significant portion of AI developers are in an anti-human, pro-extinction cult, variously called e/acc, accelerationism, or successionism.
Of course they generally hide that from ordinary humans, who might disagree...
Remember when it seemed like some strange local quirk that they wouldn't let droids into the Mos Eisley Cantina?
Now that the AIs are here, I get it.
2
6
294
Bradley Campbell retweeted
From the archives: "When Is a Riot Not a Riot?" Published at Areo (RIP) during the summer of love. @CampbellSocProf
jasonmanning.substack.com/p/…
As Sean Carroll has said, “Attempts to derive ought from is are like attempts to reach an odd number by adding together even numbers. If someone claims they’ve done it, you don’t have to check their math; you know that they’ve made a mistake.”
Yes, in the chapter on Moral Truths in my latest book, Truth, I claim that one can derive an ought from is. Here is how:
It is my hypothesis that in the same way that Galileo and Newton discovered physical laws and principles about the natural world that really are out there, so too have social scientists discovered moral laws and principles about human nature and society that really do exist.
Just as it was inevitable that the astronomer Johannes Kepler would discover that planets have elliptical orbits—given that he was making accurate astronomical measurements, and given that planets really do travel in elliptical orbits, he could hardly have discovered anything else—scientists studying political, economic, social, and moral subjects will discover certain things that are true in these fields of inquiry.
For example, that democracies are better than autocracies, that market economies are superior to command economies, that torture and the death penalty do not curb crime, that burning women as witches is a fallacious idea, that women are not too weak and emotional to run companies or countries, and, most poignantly here, that blacks do not like being enslaved and that the Jews do not want to be exterminated.
Why do blacks not want to be enslaved? Why do Jews not want to be exterminated? The answer is in my moral starting point of the survival and flourishing of individual sentient beings. Any organism subject to natural selection will by necessity have this drive to survive and flourish. If it didn’t, it would not live long enough to reproduce and would no longer be subject to natural selection. Why?
The answer is found in the deepest purpose of life: to push back against the entropy of nature, as described by the Second Law of Thermodynamics, which is the first law of life. If you do nothing, entropy will take its course and you will move toward a higher state of disorder (ultimately causing your demise). So the most basic purpose in life is to combat entropy by doing something extropic—expending energy to survive, reproduce, and flourish.
I suppose it is possible that one day scientists may discover that humans do not have an instinct to survive and flourish, that most people do not want freedom, autonomy, and prosperity, that they don’t mind starving and being disease ridden and in pain, that they prefer ignorance to education and illiteracy to literacy, that women want to be lorded over by men, that some people like being enslaved, and that large populations of people don’t object to being liquidated in gas chambers.
But I doubt it.
Bradley Campbell retweeted
AI has gotten so good at spitting out correct answers to homework assignment prompts--no matter how cleverly the assignment is phrased or designed--that it's shocking to me universities aren't diverting major administrative resources to optimizing and expanding infrastructure for in-class testing (EG computer labs where students are separated into cubicles and do their tests on AI-free computers or with assigned physical materials like paper and ruler). Instead unis are still committing virtually the entire administrative load towards dumb, irrelevant initiatives from last decade.
(Or worse, if there are "new" initiatives, they concern "access"--which actually turns out to mean disincentivizing showing visual materials in class ever. EG I'm no longer able to upload a map to Canvas without the file being "flagged" for being "too visual" and therefore "bad for access." Similarly, @omni_american was recently talking about how he couldn't upload a jpg of a famous painting to his department's website, because a painting is "too visual" and thus "bad for access." This is where bureaucratic oversight energy is going! During a time when there's an urgent, existential need to redesign student evaluation infrastructure in a way that deals with the reality of AI. @anecdotal has talked about the new, ill-conceived "access" push too.)
I think the student evaluation issue is fixable problem. But the people with power over how academic resources are distributed have to actually show leadership and divert resources towards the sensible things (better in-class testing infrastructure) and away from the idiotic things (new "access" rules which ban maps and paintings; the citational justice push which was was trendy a couple years ago; etc.).
It's already normalized. Just stay in the seat you paid for. You have to ignore the jerks trying to tell you otherwise.
Can we normalize not making people feel guilty for refusing to switch seats on airplanes? I specifically booked and paid for a window seat. You can’t show up with a family of five, discover you’re all sitting in different rows, and expect strangers to fix the situation. I’ll happily help someone when I can, but I’m not giving up something I paid extra for just because you asked.
2
350
Bradley Campbell retweeted
Replying to @anecdotal @sfmcguire79
Zoomed way out, these are different aspects of the same problem, which is that institution rewards formula over thought. Ideological homogenization "wins" because it means repeating a formula. Cookie-cutter online courses "win" because they repeat a formula.
The stupid, or at least midwit, are given a way to be "just as good" as the samrt: repeat this formula and you're just as good! It's a lie of course, and the smart know it's a lie, but they usually go along with it because they have just enough of their own stake in the system that revolting against it completely appears unwise.
Bradley Campbell retweeted
Not only have conservatives become vanishingly rare in academia, so have centrists. That’s how complete the left’s dominance is: Even moderates are now a fringe group in academia.
stevestewartwilliams.com/p/a…

























