The McEwnian Way (@CharMcew) header
The McEwnian Way (@CharMcew) profile picture

Curmudgeon

Joined November 2009
Photo by The McEwnian Way (@CharMcew)Photo by The McEwnian Way (@CharMcew)Photo by The McEwnian Way (@CharMcew)Photo by The McEwnian Way (@CharMcew)Photo by The McEwnian Way (@CharMcew)Photo by The McEwnian Way (@CharMcew)Photo by The McEwnian Way (@CharMcew)Photo by The McEwnian Way (@CharMcew)Photo by The McEwnian Way (@CharMcew)Photo by The McEwnian Way (@CharMcew)
The McEwnian Way retweeted
After FullFact’s revelation yesterday that the Milburn report was wrong about GP sick notes, I thought every claim in the report required careful fact checking. This thread will contain fact checking as far as I can muster.
22
452
49
1,134
33,612
Funny that the media isn’t talking about this, isn’t it?🚨 jujuliagrace.substack.com
43
1,441
33
2,296
19,267
I'm 34. I learnt to 'speak professionally' at 18 when I worked cashier desk at RBS. By 22, I managed a caseload at a call centre. By the time I was pushing 30 I was call monitoring for compliance. All 3 of those roles no longer exist. 2x now closed and 1x now ai-automated.
"They don't know how to pick up a phone, speak professionally..." Tina McKenzie, Chair of the Federation of Small Businesses, says some young people are "losing out" as they haven't developed the skills to enter the jobs market. #Newsnight
24
205
2
2,617
67,225
Same with the Fonagy report... Do we think for a second that would have been buried if it had said 'actually, it does appear as though there is a teeny, tiny spike in neurodivergent diagnoses...' This has been meticulously planned to be this way, inc. Burnhams faux compassion.
It's a pretty obvious point, but it's worth repeating. If Alan Milburn wasn't going to propose the policy recommendations he proposed, he would never have been chosen to propose in the first place.
6
10
372
Keir Starmer was an open blairite. Andy Burnham recognises the baggage being open about it brings. Literally the only meaningful difference between the two. Its why Milburn 'felt' more from Burnham... Burnham knows how to spin.
"Keir Starmer was an unusual politician – in that he wasn't particularly one." Alan Milburn, who today published his report into young people, work and benefits, tells @lewis_goodall why he has "no doubt" Andy Burnham can pull off the changes he recommends
2
1
17
799
"Actually, what we're now doing is targeting the disabled... but Manchesterly. This is an important step forward and one which I welcome.'
I very much welcome the proposals to help more young people into work. As the Prime Minister said, they should be our priority for investment – not the target for cuts. Let's get young people into the employment, education or training they deserve. bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ck79…
1
6
24
379
No, coz he's not got Alan to do the shrugging, nor the balls to stand behind what he's about to do the people.
Louisa James: "I also asked the PM when some young people would start to see cuts to their benefits.. but he really didn't want to talk about the idea of anybody being worse off.." #GMB
51
Does kinda wind me up this question atp. No. He couldnt. We know he couldnt. He knows that not only could he not, he WOULDNT entertain it in a million yrs. But it does NOTHING to their careers because the people asking the question have always already let too much slide.
"Could you live off £80 a week?” Employment Minister Andrew Western is asked whether he could live on the support some young disabled people could face under proposals from the Milburn Review. #Newsnight
3
9
63
995
The McEwnian Way retweeted
If MPs care so much about getting neurodivergent young people into work then I say this. I am a 25, Autistic and ADHD. My life goal is to work in politics. Offer me an entry level role with you that allows accommodations. Prove you mean it and I'll forever sing your praise
"We've got to stop assuming that just because a young person has anxiety or ADHD that they cannot work." Former health secretary Alan Milburn has called for a different model to support young people with poor mental health into work. trib.al/ahvLynG 📺 Sky 501
185
35
24
610
261,918
The McEwnian Way retweeted
I've been skimming through the Milburn Review, and I genuinely struggle to comprehend the sheer SHORT-SIGHTEDNESS of what's being proposed. And, of course, @Helen_Whately, below, is already salivating at the prospect of slashing sickness benefits, like some sadistic accountant who sees human suffering as an opportunity to balance the books. But let's look at what's actually being proposed... We're talking about fundamentally restructuring the welfare system for under-25s, stripping disabled young people of vital financial support, while simultaneously handing taxpayers' money to private employers to incentivise recruitment. And here's the staggering part. Employers receiving the government's £3,000 Youth Jobs Grant are NOT required to retain employees for any minimum period. They're not even required to demonstrate they've created an additional job! This is one enormous WEALTH TRANSFER. Taking financial security away from some of the most vulnerable people in society, while funnelling public money towards private employers without sufficient guarantees of sustainable employment. So what exactly are WE being asked to fund? Genuine pathways out of poverty? Or a revolving door of subsidised employment, with vulnerable young people potentially dumped straight back into unemployment and financial insecurity? And those who genuinely can't work? Are we simply prepared to push them further into poverty from the outset? WHERE THE FUCK IS THE ACCOUNTABILITY? What happens when the subsidies end? How many of these young people will still be employed in 12 months? Two years? Five years? We're talking about the future of an entire generation, yet still confusing short-term corporate initiatives with the fundamental economic transformation that's desperately needed. And perhaps most absurdly, why should a disabled 24-year-old receive fundamentally different financial protection from a disabled 26-year-old? Does their disability suddenly become more expensive at 25? Does their rent change? Their food bills? Their need for dignity and independence? OF COURSE IT FUCKING DOESN'T! Yet we're contemplating a system that transfers financial security away from vulnerable young people, while directing public money towards employers without adequate guarantees of lasting employment. This is the fundamental problem with treating welfare primarily as a COST to be reduced, rather than social protection that allows people to live with dignity. Where's the long-term vision? Where's the investment in genuinely sustainable employment, education, healthcare, infrastructure and an economy that creates opportunities for EVERYONE? Where's the commitment to protecting those who simply cannot work? Instead, we're in danger of weaponising poverty as an incentive to force people into employment, while rewarding businesses for offering opportunities that will most likely disappear as soon as the financial incentives do. A functioning welfare state protects people from poverty. A functioning economy provides meaningful opportunities. WE NEED BOTH. Otherwise, we're not fixing the crisis. We're simply recycling it, at an enormous human cost. And politicians celebrating the prospect of cutting support for vulnerable people should seriously question what the hell they've come into politics to achieve. #MilburnReview @ZackPolanski @TheGreenParty @andyburnham @UKLabour
What’s in the Milburn Review? (Mostly) the right diagnosis, bold ideas copying our plans on sickness benefits – but an unprecedented expansion of the role of the state and no plan to get the benefits bill down. A thread🧵
44
480
36
1,038
26,439
Real example; 19yo recently sanctioned for 'refusing work'. He never. He said he couldn't do ONE of the shift patterns HE WASN'T EVEN APPLYING FOR. Employer said he turned work down... He just simply told them what time the buses start from near him.
‘If you’re offered a job and don’t take it, there should be consequences.’ Former PM David Cameron tells @NickFerrariLBC that we shouldn’t underestimate the ‘fury’ felt by the public when people ‘cheat the benefits system’.
27
223
1
2,599
118,022
Aye, it's almost like he's just strolled into every newsroom, been thrown a few softballs and set up for soundbites rather than having been challenged on anything. Glad we know what 'complex case' means, coz that's actually REALLY important. Existential to many, in fact.
Lots to say about Milburn’s report when it drops but, one thing is for sure - this has been a masterclass in political communication. Milburn has set the agenda, made NEETs a defining issue and told a compelling story about why it matters.
6
30
408
Hi @patmcfaddenmp, Found one of those people you were saying are creating a narrative that the young are workshy and lazy... Also, just while I have you. You know your expenses total more than my annual salary... in your job that already pays 3x my annual salary.
"We've had a lot of emails from people saying, the problem is young people just don't want to do certain jobs.. lots of people saying, take a job even if its not your ultimate career job.." Milburn: "Yes & I think that is right"
4
135
'I know of many cases...' No you dont. You work in a chamber of 650 who judge the country by the standards they have for themselves... hence you think everybody is on the grift. Because you lot are. PIP fraud is about 1% of all claims. What about MP expenses?
PIP helps many disabled people work & under Milburn it will be replaced with other support for those with additional expense. But PIP isn’t an in or out of work benefit. I know of many cases where it acts as a disincentive to work & in process damages life chances of our young.
2
33
185
1,642
Yeah, but it shouldnt be anybody's view, you self-important tosser. This is the entire problem with the living you're stealing. You shouldn't legislate based on vibes. 'Which, from in-depth assessments and consultations with impacted parties...' said no report ever...
Replying to @alassmith
Those with more complex needs will receive the severe disability benefit which in my view will cause no more worry.
37
Love how this is viewed as 'idealistic' because it's not the old way of doing things (i.e. isn't Trump-approved), but slashing benefits, making vulnerable people worse off and pumping billions into workfare is 'bold and pragmatic'.
Replying to @ZackPolanski
We have a genuine opportunity here - from building clean power tech to heat-proofing our homes to bring down bills, we need millions of skilled workers to fuel the booming green economy. We should be straining every sinew to train and support young people to take up these jobs.
1
11
318
You can tell how desperate MOST of the press are about these reforms that Nick fucking Ferrari comes across as compassionate in this snippet. Milburn looks and sounds like a cartoon villain, with reference points from another reality altogether. How is this 'impressive comms'!?
"It's a stepping stone towards a job." Alan Milburn insists that getting part-time work or doing community service is a 'much better choice than doom-scrolling in your bedroom'.
1
53
Interesting of the press to refer to Alan Milburn as 'former health secretary', because when he WAS the health sec he was stealing tens of thousands in taxpayer money while selling off parts of the NHS that are amongst its biggest financial challenges today.
5
87
1
220
1,840
'Former health secretary' because they need to try and make out he has medical qualifications for the anti-science his report delivers. Never let it be said the press in the UK are useless. They do EXACTLY what they are there to do...
BREAKING: Former health secretary Alan Milburn has arrived at Downing Street for a Cabinet meeting ahead of the release of his report on youth unemployment. trib.al/Pg9ZwcH 📺 Sky 501, Virgin 602, Freeview 233 and YouTube
2
103
1
570
6,357