Subroto Chattopadhyay (@CitizenSubroto) header
Subroto Chattopadhyay (@CitizenSubroto) profile picture

Author: Bangladesh — Humiliation, Carnage, Liberation, Chaos. Corporate Leader, Chairman, The Peninsula Studios

India
Joined April 2009
Photo by Subroto Chattopadhyay (@CitizenSubroto)Photo by Subroto Chattopadhyay (@CitizenSubroto)Photo by Subroto Chattopadhyay (@CitizenSubroto)Photo by Subroto Chattopadhyay (@CitizenSubroto)Photo by Subroto Chattopadhyay (@CitizenSubroto)Photo by Subroto Chattopadhyay (@CitizenSubroto)Photo by Subroto Chattopadhyay (@CitizenSubroto)
Thank you, Army War College, Mhow, for the opportunity to present Vision to Victory. The future leadership performed brilliantly in the decision-makers’ chair. AWC is a fine institution — we need institutions of such quality to shape the leaders of tomorrow. @ia_awc @AnilPDere62
#AWCIndia hosted a thought provoking session for Mhow station titled “Vision to Victory”, revisiting India’s historic 1971 victory. Maj Gen Anil P Dere (Retired) and Shri Subroto Chattopadhyay brought alive the Strategic, Operational and Leadership lessons of the campaign through archival narratives and battlefield experiences. #Leadership
1
2
3
275
Pakistan's plan for Yahya was built on Nixon's China opening. Nixon needed Yahya cooperative. An official approach to China would have looked like weakness. He chose Yahya Khan as the intermediary. @AnilPDere62 @StudioTPS @zahidkhan070 #BangladeshHCLC
1
1
3
19
The intermediary who carries a superpower's secret is briefly indispensable. He pays a heavy price when the secret is no longer needed. @AnilPDere62 @StudioTPS @zahidkhan070 #BangladeshHCLC #Bangladesh1971
1
1
3
Yahya knew East Pakistan was militarily indefensible. He opened the western front in December 1971 anyway — to save face. They started a war they knew they would lose. That is the most expensive form of face-saving in statecraft. @AnilPDere62 @StudioTPS #Bangladesh1971
1
1
2
14
On Mrs G’s birth anniversary- the picture says it all. around this date the Indian-forces closed into Garibpur and Boyra in Nov 71 in 4 weeks she helped liberate #Bangladesh. #IndiraGandhiJayanti
1
2
33
History remembers December 1971. The nine months before it are barely studied. The single most consequential decision of those nine months was made not in Delhi or Calcutta but in a city most accounts never mention. The book names it and the decision. @AnilPDere62 #Bangladesh1971
1
1
31
Not a bad idea to read about #Nehru to discover what he thought, say and did. In a word he was “great”. On his birthday
1
1
38
Vintage @DeShobhaa what a book review. 🥂🤣 how I miss reading Stardust . As Vazier of Oudh in Shatranj ke Khiladi would have asked, @SoniaGandhi ji Stardust pardti hain kya? Better than asking Aap ko kaunsa aam pasand hai ? Well done Shobha maam
Shobhaa De has read the book better than most political commentators filling the pages with their weird takes.
26
The R&AW operation to release Mujib from Pakistani imprisonment was not conducted through military pressure or prisoner exchange. It was conducted through a conversation in a transit lounge at Heathrow Airport. @AnilPDere62 @StudioTPS @zahidkhan070 #BangladeshHCLC
2
2
3
82
The name of the man who had that conversation at Heathrow has never appeared in any published account. He is named in this book. He is still alive. He agreed to be named. @AnilPDere62 @StudioTPS @zahidkhan070 #BangladeshHCLC #Bangladesh1971
2
2
46
Try RAdm @MontyKhanna2308 on evolution of Chinese maritime capabilities. The Chinese seem to have covered more ground than what we care to acknowledge. A serious piece by a quality professional.
1
20
Adm @arunp2810 is an institution builder and he believes investment in Human Resources should be appropriate to the role an organisation should serve. His piece this morning deserves a slow read
Some thoughts on Agnipath in The Tribune.
1
1
1
50
Mujib's government drafted the 1972 Bangladesh constitution. In 1975 Mujib amended it to establish a one-party presidential system. The vote in the National Assembly was 294 to zero. The architect of liberation had become the architect of its undoing. @AnilPDere62 @StudioTPS
1
1
2
30
'Khadim, it is tonight.' On the afternoon of 25 March 1971, the officers who would launch Operation Searchlight joined their wives for tea. History records the operation. It rarely records the ordinary afternoon before it. @AnilPDere62 @StudioTPS @zahidkhan070 #Bangladesh1971
2
2
3
34
Subroto Chattopadhyay retweeted
This is fascinating… Source : dear data
122
709
87
3,361
319,491
As Kissinger's plane lifted off from Beijing military airport, Yahya Khan's special usefulness to the United States expired. From that moment, America had no further strategic reason to protect Pakistan's conduct in East Pakistan. @AnilPDere62 @StudioTPS #BangladeshHCLC
2
1
1
32
The state whose strategic utility to a great power expires loses its protection instantly. Pakistan 1971 is the clearest proof in modern history. Every current American ally in a contested region is inside the same mechanism. @AnilPDere62 @StudioTPS @zahidkhan070 #Bangladesh1971
1
2
3
23
The Zhenbao Island clash in 1969 convinced Nixon the Soviets might strike China first. That fear drove the China opening. The opening required Yahya. Yahya required protecting Pakistan. Ten million refugees paid the cost. @AnilPDere62 @StudioTPS @zahidkhan070 #Bangladesh1971
2
3
50
Amongst the greatest tragedies in history of mankind 😢#partition of #India
Must-watch: Channel 4 documentary India 1947, Partition in Colour. Drawing on interviews with historians, academics and descendants of those directly involved in the decision-making, as well as contemporary transcripts and archived audio recordings of eyewitnesses, it reconstructs the events that led to Partition. It demolishes the shibboleth that Pakistan was created by the British as a buffer state for the West. What emerges instead is a story of political miscalculation, personal animosity and imperial haste. Mountbatten’s vanity, his deep-seated antipathy towards Jinnah, and his decision to compress the transfer of power into ten weeks helped turn Partition into a catastrophe. The result was one of the greatest human tragedies of the twentieth century, with hundreds of thousands massacred and millions uprooted. youtube.com/watch?v=ZXngSwZG…
32