Coby retweeted
I feel incredibly lucky to get to build a village in such a beautiful place
Grateful to everyone who supported Esmeralda these past few years to make last week's final approvals (!!!) possible teapaw.org/devonzuegel/status/212…
A glimpse of @esmeralda_inst's land – Sonoma County, CA:
Coby retweeted
It feels demeaning to even have to explain this, but:
Amazon is *valued by investors* at about $2.8 trillion, which means they’re willing to buy, say, a 1% ownership share for $28 billion. It does not mean they have a $2.8 trillion pile of gold coins. It’s based on the value of expected future profits. It’s a prediction, not a tangible thing.
Amazon’s *profit margins* are extremely low. The consumer marketplace (how most people interact with amazon) has margins around 4%. (Amazon Web Services has a much higher margin, but almost all their customers are other giant corporations that Mamdani also hates). Furthermore, much of that marketplace revenue is advertising. Stripping this out, direct, conventional margins on Amazon sold products are essentially zero. Think about what that means: Amazon found a way to run a business delivering goods to consumer’s doors at cost. They’ve already achieved the communist dream for regular consumers: giving you what you want, overnight, at cost. And they make a profit at the same time!
How can they be worth so much on margins that thin? Scale! They serve hundreds of millions of consumers, so making even small amounts per consumer translates into a giant total figure.
But that also means that any reduction in their tiny margins tanks the entire business overnight. If government regulation turns the tiny fraction of profit they skim off their huge gross revenue from positive to negative (which, again, would require only a couple-percent tax) then suddenly that entire fraction of their business becomes worthless overnight. Investors leave, amazon shrinks to being just a cloud services provider, and Americans can no longer get overnight delivery of literally anything on Earth - AT COST - overnight. The reason for the investor valuations -expected future profits - collapses, and their is no dragon hoard of gold coins to loot anymore. Poof. You won’t have redistributed trillions. You’ll have deleted it from existence.
It’s not that Mamdani doesn’t understand this, or that he does. He doesn’t have a worldview at all. He is a rhetoric machine designed to optimize his personal power. He doesn’t know or care about the concepts of “outcomes” or “consequences”. The final form of a politician in a mass democracy.
Coby retweeted
So Flagstar bank, formerly known as New York's top Rent Stabilized apartment house lender New York Community Bank, has closed its window. The inaccessibility of normal debt financing for this kind of workforce housing represents another twist of the vise into which its providers were placed by the radical ideologues on New York State Senate's Housing Committee.
For my readers who know nothing about this, a primer. In 1974, as a reaction to the trifecta of hyperinflation caused by the Vietnam War, LBJ's Great Society overspending and OPEC's retaliatory Oil Shocks, New York State enacted the ETPA, known colloquially as Rent Stabilization, which limited rent increases (including upon vacancy) on all market rate rental buildings to an annual percentage established by a politically motivated board. By 1977, persistent inflation and inadequate legal rent increases caused the decimation of the housing stock with 200,000 units destroyed by flood and fire and 500,000 displaced residents. Tragi-poetically, the Bronx was shown engulfed in flames in the background of a nationally televised Yankees World Series game. Finally in 1994, with many neighborhoods like the South Bronx and Bushwick almost totally reduced to rubble, New York's political leadership confessed the need for reforms and offered the remaining beleaguered Rent Stabilized housing providers a path to reinvestment and restoration via "Luxury Decontrol" which enabled units renting above $2,000/mo which equated to about 250% x 1/3 of the then current median income. Manhattan landlords rejoiced as they performed thousands of vacated apartment improvements to raise legal rents (using the ETPAs formulae) and gradually decontrolled the fancy parts of the City. The reforms also offered a modest, but better-than-nothing vacancy bonus of 20% on any unit that had been occupied for a long time. Throughout the city, housing providers could at least breath again. The era of The Warriors and Death Wish was over. The residential real estate taxes on the improved buildings grew and the City's distressed financial status was also resolved.
Unfortunately in 2018, a large number of emboldened ideologues were elected to the State Senate, bent on revenge against the unseated moderate "independent" Democrats who they felt had stymied their dogmatic leftist agenda. Part of this agenda is the so-called "decommodification" of housing and conversion to public ownership for reallocation, subsequent to bankruptcy and tax foreclosure. So in 2019, they enacted the HSTPA, a series of 9 laws, proudly signed by Governor Andyboy Cuomo, among which the worst features were the imposition of a NEGATIVE rate of return on apartment and building-wide capital reinvestments. For 8 years, the old buildings were then subjected to 34% inflation while the politically determined legal rent increases were only 12%. By 2025, 15% of the buildings, mostly in the Bronx and Upper Manhattan, representing around 150,000 apartments were losing money on operations before debt service. And then came the famous "freeze the rent".
The exuberant radicals who now run the City and the State's Legislatures fantasize that persistent imposition of revenue starvation will result in hundreds of tidy buildings being delivered for free to preferred NGOs (Copa/Topa) and new Public Agencies (NYSHDA). They also imagine that there are no implications to the NGOs who rely on the same redlined mortgage financing. And here is the very worst part, they are too busy spiking the football and doing touchdown dances over their radical victory to listen to any constructive suggestions or offer beleaguered owners a dignified offramp.
1/2
commercialobserver.com/2026/…
Coby retweeted
Frank Braconi, who is an actual economist, inadvertently asked me a softball question about why the operating expenses of non-profit housing owners are usually double those of for-profit owners. I also note that public housing operating expenses are usually triple those of private, for-profit owners. Amazingly, even with the orders of magnitude of additional spending, the non-profit buildings tend to have worse physical conditions and the public housing buildings are well known to be the worst of all. With apologies in advance that this post may be too technical and into the weeds for some, here we go.
As Frank surely knows, there are these standard economic concepts called Principal Agent and Moral Hazard. Let's examine these in terms of the three kinds of housing ownership.
In for-profit housing, the owner/manager is the Principal Agent and its motivation is the long term maximization of income and return on capital reinvestments. When it comes to "purchased items" this owner carefully negotiates and bids costs with suppliers, minimizes waste, avoids costly violations and fines, fears foreclosure and litigation and reserves capital to reinvest in well-planned component replacement and money saving innovations. Examples include heat timers, utility submetering and complex self-insurance structures, to key off Frank's questions below. Utility submetering, for one, reduces consumption by 2/3 in practice: a huge savings! There is very little Moral Hazard here because the Principal Agent is the direct beneficiary of the cost savings and it is not a judgment-proof entity.
In non-profit housing, we encounter our first Moral Hazard. The owner is an entity that by virtue of being the owner of last-resort, has an soft loss backstop from the public. The non-profit's manager, acting as Principal Agent, still has to do all the work of a manager but is only compensated by a salary, also a hazard. So in the non-profit scenario, the manager will do everything to maximize its salary but only impose as much careful effort as is needed to prevent the building from literally collapsing. Since this type of property doesn't have to pay real estate taxes, an amount which usually would be around half of net income, all of that money can be squandered on careless and indifferent negotiation and purchasing with suppliers. It should surprise no one that careless purchasing often comes with emoluments for the Principal Agent, another Moral Hazard. This owner is also less risk averse, because when fines and violations arrive resulting in eventual litigation judgments, there is no owner to worry about the outcome. They become just another delayable payable. Conditions naturally deteriorate but at least the building doesn't fall over.
And finally we have the public owner who truly has no "skin in the game." Perversely, the public owner cares mostly about how to MAXIMIZE the operating costs because the Principal Agent and Moral Hazard problems are here in full effect. The salary to manage public housing is a pittance, so the Principal Agent may only earn their fair compensation through emoluments. The legendary graft at agencies like NYCHA is well documented and consistent at public housing throughout the world. Moreover, prevailing wage regulations already force any operating expense that includes a service to cost at least double, even before any mischief takes place. Of recent note, the well publicized case of the NYCHA employee-plumber Jakub Markowski who allegedly earned $465k via overtime rigging. When the property earns fines and violations, develops truly dangerous conditions or employees behave with utter gross negligence, only the taxpayer is on the hook and no one ever loses their job or pension thanks to the representatiion of powerful labor syndicates. With this incentive structure, it should be no surprise at all that building conditions are atrocious and it costs $527k to renovate a single public housing unit.
Replying to @Jamie_LeFrak @IamSean90
Any idea why non-profit operating costs would be 2x that of for-profit owners? A lot of operating costs are just purchased items, like heating oil, water, electricity, insurance, etc.
Coby retweeted
New rowhouses in Drøbak, Norway.
The execution and level of detailing is brilliant!
All the eight homes sold quickly in an otherwise slow marked.
Architect: QDP
Utbygger: Tristein
Coby retweeted
Avant 2021 / Après 2026 Place Saint-Gervais, Paris Centre. En 2025, un jardin commémorant les attentats de Novembre 2015 a remplacé l'ancien parking. Notez qu'il est rare de trouver une vieille photo d'un lieu si peu remarquable à l'époque (source Chabe01 sur Wikimedia Commons)
Coby retweeted
wild ruling out of Seattle that @PHLCouncil needs to read. a builder put $39M into 254 low-income apartments locked at 60% AMI for 30 years. from 2015 to 2018 it worked, collecting ~94% of rent.
then Seattle stacked on "tenant protections": banned criminal background checks, banned winter evictions, required 180 days notice for rent hikes + 3 months relocation pay, and forced the owner to let unscreened roommates move in and take over leases.
result: rent collections dropped from 93.9% to 44.1%!!! the building lost nearly $6M through 2023 ($2.7M in 2023 alone) and is now appraised as functionally worthless. the city bankrupted actual affordable housing lol.
the appeals court just ruled the owner can sue Seattle for an unconstitutional taking. when you strip a landlord's right to screen, collect rent or remove non-paying tenants, it's not "regulation" anymore, you took the building…. Philly has half these laws already 🙄 courts.wa.gov/opinions/pdf/8…
Coby retweeted
I think the thing that kills me the most about towns/cities permitting departments…is they make ‘doing it the right way’ so unbelievably difficult sometimes.
Example: I am trying to install new digital menu boards. Simply replacing the old static ones for new digital ones.
Town:
-oh we need to run all new light pollution studies then
-oh we’re gonna check all your parking lot lights while we’re at it
-oh we need to double check this doesn’t hinder a ladder truck from driving over your building
-oh we need to inspect the footers before you pour any concrete
-no you absolutely can not assign the permit to a new certified vendor doing the identical work
-how many seats did you say were in the dining room? Might need to add a sprinkler system
-we need to bring in the signage department now too because digital menu boards are now considered signage
-are you bricking up the base of the footers? It’s not required by code, but we’re requiring it 🤗
Could have just done the whole thing in an afternoon & never heard a peep.
Now this project is on month 13, with 4 different permit offices involved, 3 engineers, and no end in sight
Coby retweeted
If you truly *love* American cities, you MUST support strict enforcement of laws against anti-social behavior. Paying bus fares, red light cameras, camping on sidewalks, smoking on trains, off-leash dogs, etc etc
If people want to do whatever they want, that’s FINE in the suburbs or the country on your own land. But it, fundamentally, cannot work in our densest places where people all have to co-operate in proximity.
If we do not, it means cities will continue to be primarily for those able to avoid the annoyances ... the wealthy and/or child-free.
If we don’t change this … in 40 years we will look back on allowing dogs in downtowns the same way we look at cars:
As a terrible mistake for how it molded dense urban environment for the benefit of a few ... by not properly pricing in public costs of the "free rider" dog owners and by changing the entire culture to accommodate them.
My fear is by then (like with cars today) there will be too many ppl accustomed to the private benefits and impunity of living downtown with their dogs so we're only able to make marginal changes
And that negative downstream effects (fewer kids, playgrounds, dirty sidewalks, dog attacks) will be baked in
Coby retweeted
Can we afford to build beautifully?
I believe that decades of inflation and failed fiscal policy have forced the real estate industry into short-termism. Viability is so tight that developers find themselves with two options: hike prices, or squeeze every possible cost out of a building’s design, materials and, ultimately, its soul.
While I think we all innately feel like the modern built environment is lacking something, this idea was explained in a book I’m reading called The Great Wave.
In it, the author David Hackett Fischer investigates the major price fluctuations in history. These are waves of high inflation - socially and politically corrosive - followed by price equilibrium.
Fischer shows how these waves leave their mark on our buildings. He describes the windows of price stability as fertile ground for building – and, I'd argue, for a kind of speculation that wouldn't be possible during inflation.
The churches, homes and civic buildings of those periods capture the optimism and prosperity of their time, evoking emotion through beautiful architecture that we prize and go to great lengths to preserve.
I’m writing a separate essay on this idea that will be published shortly. As part of the research for the piece, I wanted to speak to people in real estate who may not share this monetary thesis, but who are vocal about current development.
@Cobylefko is an urbanist, real estate developer, lecturer and author of Building Optimism: Why Our World Looks the Way It Does, and How to Make It Better.
Here's a short trailer from our discussion on creating beautiful buildings: structures that aren’t just aesthetically pleasing, but that meet our needs in different and harder-to-name ways.
Coby is an old romantic in a world of yields, and IRR, and price per sq ft. That’s not to say he’s naïve; listen and you’ll hear a commercially savvy operator, but he’s also alive to what we lose when we settle for - in his words - “sad and dreary places”.
Coby retweeted
The Four Corners in Kingston, NY is the only intersection in the United States in which all four structures date before the American Revolution.
The oldest, the Jansen House, was built between 1663 and 1667 when the region was part of the New Netherlands colony.
Coby retweeted
We need a Giving Pledge for architecture.
Not a percentage of wealth, but something simple, like: commit to funding one public building of ambition in your lifetime.
It could be a library, concert hall, school, civic hall, house of worship, train station, or a partially public corporate headquarters.
A charter can define what counts. The building should be permanent, follow community preference, provide a meaningful budget for craft and ornament, perhaps an endowment for upkeep.
The wealthy compete on beauty and impact.
Cities should compete too to host buildings: donate land, fast-track approvals, and make operating committments. Thinking about the Carnegie libraries approach.
Call it the Cornerstone Pledge. Lay the cornerstone within 7 years of signing. Perhaps something like: "I pledge to give my community at least one building of lasting beauty, built to stand for centuries, open to all..."
Coby retweeted
There is no correlation at all between how much a school district spends and how well its students perform.
Coby retweeted
To give you an idea of how circular New York’s housing policy is. We’ll invest 4 billion in pension funds into building $700,000 per unit apartments before letting rent stabilized buildings put 60,000 currently vacant and unprofitable apartments back on the market at no cost to current renters, pension systems, or taxpayers while keeping them permanently rent stabilized.
And the number of vacancies grows every year.
Nothing makes sense.
NYC pension funds make $300M affordable housing investment to help solve apartment shortage
gothamist.com/news/nyc-pensi…
Coby retweeted
Frustrated by inaction on the threat of cars, the 1970s residents of Delft's Tuinstraat illicitly erected barriers to curb traffic.
An act of rebellion became a global revolution—inventing the woonerf (living street): a common space for recreation, vegetation, and socialization.












































