Pinned Tweet
For perspective:
Western philosophy basically began with Thales of Miletus.
Only 4 sentences that remained.
Post more bangers.
“In philosophy, the term "rationalism" is used to designate a broad school contrasted with "empiricism."
These are two technical terms standing for two schools of philosophy that have been at war with each other from ancient Greece to the present day.
Rationalists, roughly, are those philosophers who stress the role of reason or logic in the acquisition of knowledge while disparaging or denying the senses. They include thinkers like Plato, Augustine, and Descartes.
Empiricists, on the other hand, include people like John Locke, David Hume, and the modern pragmatists, all of whom stress the role of experience or sensory evidence while denying or minimizing logic.
As pure philosophy, both of these schools lead to disaster, and Objectivism rejects both camps.
Objectivist epistemology entirely repudiates the idea of reason versus observation because it says knowledge is acquired by the use of reason applied to observation.
Knowledge is thus the integration of logic and experience, not an either-or situation.”
Leonard Peikoff, Objective Communication
“We now turn to what you can call the quality of argument: your approach to argument as such.
In that context, I want to discuss the topic of rationalism.
This is the most widespread and harmful error of today's intellectuals. It is virtually inescapable by college students, certainly by graduate students in the humanities. It also has the effect of enormously alienating non-intellectuals or non-professionals in the field.
Rationalism is the arch disease of today's intellectuals. If you have not got it yourself, I congratulate you, but even if you have not, you still need to understand it. Otherwise, you will find today's intellectual world unintelligible.
If you understand this error, however, you can inoculate yourself against it and explain the countless forms of it you see around you.”
Leonard Peikoff
Objective Communication
“To summarize the four basic principles of communication that we are concerned with are:
motivation, delimitation, structure, and concretization.
- Motivation means the way in which you convince the audience to care about the subject.
- Delimitation means your recognition that A is A, that the crow epistemology is true, and therefore that the audience can retain only so much.
- Structure means having a logical sequence of presentation.
- Concretization refers to the balance of abstractions and concretes. You must go back and forth between giving examples of an abstract point and then tying them up abstractly."
Leonard Peikoff, Objective Communication
56
“The point is that every abstract paper should have some such element of concretization in it somewhere.
You should train yourself so that as soon as you utter a broad abstraction, that sets up a certain pressure in you, as though it is an IOU. You now have to pay off that IOU by concretizing and illustrating so that the audience gets the meaning in reality.
In short, you have to find a balance. You have to discover when it is necessary to come down to concrete examples to bring the discussion back down to your base in reality, and when to tie your concretes together with an abstraction (because your audience can hold only so much).
This shuttling back and forth between concretes and abstraction is a crucial requirement of the intellectual presentation.”
Leonard Peikoff, Objective Communication
"A concept is a condensation of concretes. It is a shorthand, and you must always remember that.
It is not automatically tied to the actual particulars in reality that it represents. Therefore, in your presentation, it is urgent that you keep any key idea or principle that you are focusing on, that your presentation is centered on, tied to reality, meaning to the perceptual level.
In other words, you have to bring it down to earth. Otherwise, you will have floating abstraction, and even if it is tied to reality in your own mind, in the audience's mind, it will not be.
The crucial method of tying abstractions to reality is to concretize by giving examples."
Leonard Peikoff, Objective Communication
Let’s take this gentleman’s argument at face value that anyone can throw money at rockets and get something like Starship, Falcon or Dragon.
Perhaps he can explain to everyone how SpaceX is able to catch giant starships from orbit with chopsticks and deliver 85% of all Earth payload to orbit with Falcon, while Blue Origin, which started before SpaceX and was funded by the immensely wealthy Jeff Bezos, is not yet able to launch reliably?
Also, why is it that Boeing and Lockheed received several times what SpaceX did from the government for development of their rockets and spacecraft, but the Boeing capsule is still not operational and ULA delivers less than 5% of SpaceX payload to orbit?
I am genuinely curious about these questions.
“You have to remember that as soon as you start to speak, you are setting up a certain tension in your listener.
They have to hold what you are saying, then connect it to the next point, and so on. You, in turn, have to keep tying it all up for them, reducing the number of units.
Consciousness is something, and that necessitates certain methods of dealing with it. If you violate these methods, you are assaulting human consciousness as such, and you therefore make communication impossible.
These three points (that knowledge is conceptual, that it is contextual, and that consciousness is limited) are the briefest I can make the philosophical base of this course.”
Leonard Peikoff, Objective Communication
"The third basic principle of effective communication is a metaphysical principle first defined by Aristotle:
the Law of Identity.
A is A.
Everything is something. It is what it is. It is definite. It has a nature. It is something specific.
To put it another way, everything that exists is limited.
There is no such thing as an infinite quantity or an infinite number of attributes because 'infinite' means a quantity without any specific identity.
According to Objectivism, this law applies as much to space and time as to every other aspect of the universe. A is A. Everything is limited.
Consciousness, too, is limited. It obeys the principle that A is A."
Leonard Peikoff, Objective Communication
"A second aspect of a conceptual consciousness, one that is essential to clarity on both proper thought and communication, is that human knowledge is contextual.
We do not acquire knowledge in a vacuum. Our knowledge is based on previous knowledge. Of course, we have to begin by sensory observation. Thereafter, though, we build a whole structure.
At any given point, there is a certain sum that represents what we know on a given topic, and that is what permits us to go on to learn more.
That sum, we say, is the context for the new point. The context means the cognitive sum that conditions everything that is still to come. It determines how we understand the new point, estimate it, interpret it, and apply it.
The point here is that, in all thought and communication, there is a context that conditions what is occurring.
Knowledge, to look at it another way, is relational. It is not a mosaic of independent, disconnected pieces, but a sum of interconnected elements, each bearing on and relevant to the others."
Leonard Peikoff
Objective Communication
“While it is true that concepts give us some magnificent advantages, they also create a problem, or, to put it another way, they impose a responsibility.
Animals may not get too far cognitively, but as far as they go, they are always clear.
On the perceptual level, you are automatically tied to entities out there in reality. If you look out there at a table, you see what you see. It is sharp and delimited. There is no effort required on your part. As an adult, you, or the dog, or the cat, or whatever, look and see that it is sharp and clear.
Concepts, however, as a shorthand, are a complex creation. They are neither automatically clear nor necessarily formed correctly, nor even necessarily tied to reality.”
Leonard Peikoff, Objective Communication
"There is no thought without words.
You can have images, emotions, percepts, or sensory data, but to know what you are perceiving, to identify the percepts, and to communicate your knowledge, you need words.
Every word is the symbol of a concept.
All human knowledge, thought, and communication is conceptual. That is the base of all communication theory."
Leonard Peikoff, Objective Communication
"I have found that I do not really understand something clearly until I try to give a formal presentation of it to others. The greatest selfish value of teaching, in my judgment, is the clarity that it induces in the teacher's own mind."
Leonard Peikoff, Objective Communication
"The future of the world depends on the spread of the right ideas.
That, in turn, requires that the advocates of those ideas understand them clearly in their own minds and then have the ability to communicate them effectively in whatever form is appropriate — whether in a cocktail party discussion, or to your child if he asks you whether there is a God, or to his teacher if he celebrates UN Day in grade three, or in a paper if you are a student, or to your club when it meets, or in a letter to the editor, or to Congress, or whatever.
All of these are practical daily means by which the world is changed and saved, saved if what you present is correct.
But all of this requires, on the part of the people with the right ideas, inner clarity and the ability to communicate ideas effectively."
Leonard Peikoff
Objective Communication
I love this song.
And I also believe that it is a concrete example of what Ayn Rand called a “Sense of Life.”
I’m also curious how it makes people feel when they hear it without words. The song’s melody matches its philosophy.
music.youtube.com/watch?v=Jn…
48
"The hallmark of meritocracy is creating opportunities that enable each person to use their skills to accomplish whatever they imagine. Everyone deserves access to these opportunities, and technological growth can help ensure that each of us is able to maximize our most limited resource: time."
Elon Musk, The Book of Elon, Eric Jorgensen
39
"Eventually, self-driving cars will take the form of a shared autonomous fleet. You buy your car, and you could choose to use your car exclusively yourself, have it used only by friends and family, or only by other drivers who are rated 5 stars. You can choose to share it sometimes, but not other times. That's 100% what will occur. It's just a question of when. I can't say enough about the profundity of self-driving. It will be one of the biggest changes in history. It's not just some feature. It is as profound as electrification. We already have millions of cars on the road now able to achieve this with the right software update."
Elon Musk, The Book of Elon, Eric Jorgensen.
P.S. Driving around Las Vegas. I look forward to a future of full autonomy.
37
"Your brain has to work to compress a bunch of concepts in your head into this incredibly low data rate format called speech or typing. That's what language is - a compression algorithm on thought to transfer a concept.
Then it's got to listen and decompress what's coming in. Both of these steps are very lossy. If you have two direct brain interfaces, you could do an uncompressed direct conceptual communication with another person, like consensual telepathy. The conversation would be a conceptual interaction on a level that's difficult to conceive of right now."
Elon Musk, The Book of Elon, Eric Jorgensen
PS.
Ayn Rand’s theory of concept formation in epistemology-concepts are compression algorithms.
1
80
"Some people think technology automatically gets better every year. It does not. It only gets better if smart people work like crazy to make it better.
We need strong engineering talent applied to problems. That's how any technology actually gets better. If people don't work on technology, it actually will decline."
Elon Musk, The Book of Elon, Eric Jorgensen
40
"There is nothing wrong with profit. Profit just means people are paying you more for whatever you're creating than you're spending to create it. That's a good thing.
If that's not the case, you'll soon be out of business, and rightfully so, because you are not adding enough value.
If you create great products and services that create wealth, that should be applauded. You increased the standard of living of the country and perhaps of the world."
Elon Musk, The Book of Elon, Eric Jorgensen
45



















