Pinned Tweet
2025 books read. Not pictured, Lutz’s Backwardness. Best of the year: The Mountain Lion by Jean Stafford, with Purdy’s Cabot Wright Begins close behind.
Criticism 101: Read the book before critiquing it.
A science fiction novel just won The Booker Prize.
On the surface, this seems like a win—one might conclude that the literary establishment has finally stopped being pretentious about the arbitrary genre lines it's imposed on contemporary fiction.
From the sample available online, however, it becomes clear that this book features the same sort of plotless, pretentious ramblings popular in contemporary literary fiction. While the writing itself is superb, the novel could not be more dull.
Granted, I've only read the first 20 pages, so I'll reserve my final judgment until I've finished the book, but before we celebrate this year's Booker Prize as a victory for science fiction, it's worth noting that this one is really just another highbrow literary novel dressed up as science fiction.
Tell us you haven't read the book (or article) without telling us.
Sorry but 'baffling but brilliant' is not the basis of a good novel. Or at least it shouldn't be.
Orwell once argued that 'good prose is clear as a windowpane'.
Dostoevsky, Turgenev, Hemingway, Dos Passos, Faulkner, Raymond Carver, and in Scotland our own William McIlvaney would be turning in their graves.
The state of literature reflects the state of society in any given time. With this metric in mind, we are in a time of monsters.
38
1,009
Eleventh Volume retweeted
great and legitimately surprising result
Author M John Harrison wins Booker Prize 2026, becoming oldest recipient of award aged 81 bbc.in/4kBfOsY
I wrote a 2,000 word review on Humboldt’s Gift interrelation with JR.
You can read it here: goodreads.com/review/show/90…
Shameless self-promotion. I was recently published in Wintersweet Magazine’s first issue. Snippet and link below.
wintersweetslitmag.com/issue…
I don't resile from this.
Replying to @nosubstance
Alexis is more of the cultural moment and I can see her being picked over Murnane for that reason. Her fiction of course is fantastic, but my sensibilities favour Murnane.
1
2
650
As of this morning, there are now two books that have made me miss my bus stop: White Noise by DeLillo and Brideshead Revisted by Waugh.
11
466





















