fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
In 1974 Deligne proved the last of the four Weil conjectures—an analogue of the Riemann hypothesis in a world where some prime number has been set to zero. While Deligne’s work was celebrated, his doctoral advisor, Grothendieck, was unhappy. Can solving a problem be bad? I think not, but I want to explain my understanding of the story, which in my view sheds some light on the present moment.
In his memoir, “Récoltes et Semailles” (Reaping and Sowing), Grothendieck explains his approach to problem solving and mathematics more generally: "The unknown thing to be known appeared to me as some stretch of earth or hard marl, resisting penetration… the sea advances insensibly in silence, nothing seems to happen, nothing moves, the water is so far off you hardly hear it... yet it finally surrounds the resistant substance." He compared a precise mathematical question to a nut, which, rather than being cracked open by a chisel, yields at the perfect time to simple hand pressure once it has been soaked in the ocean of mathematical understanding. According to this account of mathematical progress, solutions, though important, are ancillary to the advance of the rising sea of mathematical understanding. At best they measure it to some extent, but the goal is to raise the water level.
Grothendieck had laid out a program to resolve the Weil conjectures: the standard conjectures, which are part of the philosophy of motives. The proof circumvented this program. Deligne characterized Grothendieck's reaction as "he did not care...the proof was a trick" but in fact Grothendieck excoriated Deligne in his memoir, claiming Deligne and others tried to "bury" the theory of motives, and Grothendieck himself. The standard conjectures remain open today.
Deligne's result relied on a lot of work that was not yet well-exposited in the literature, around the theory of étale cohomology. Deligne himself wrote an exposition of this in SGA 4.5, and Illusie contributed additional necessary material in SGA 5. Some have referred to this additional work as "thankless," but it was completed.
While Grothendieck is one of my heroes, and I find his view of mathematics very appealing, I think he was wrong here. Though the standard conjectures are still open, there is an immense amount of work on the theory of motives. People worked very hard to clarify the issues left unclear by Deligne's argument. And crucially, Deligne followed up on his work with a different proof, in "La conjecture de Weil II," that completely revolutionized arithmetic geometry, in many ways going beyond the philosophy of motives as it existed at that time.
I think Grothendieck's view that the first proof Deligne provided was insufficient was, in some sense, correct. But he was wrong about the fact that the theory he so desired, and the attendant quest for understanding, would be abandoned, and that his ideas would be buried. I don't think anything can stop us from trying to understand.
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
10 remarks on AI and math that can be true all at once:
1. The recent progress is stunning and exciting.
2. The Quasi-Riemann Hypothesis is arguably Fields-medal level.
3. Mathematics is being transformed and there is no way back.
4. OpenAI doesn't give a fuck about the future of mathematics.
5. Half-baked unreadable preprints claiming major results can effectively stall mathematical progress.
6. Some mathematicians are responding with naive, overly defensive comments.
7. The social-media wankers framing this as "OpenAI tramples gatekeeping" have no experience of mathematical research.
8. The product of mathematics is clarity and understanding. Not theorems, by themselves.
9. Mathematics is a critical infrastructure of human cognition. The human need for understanding isn't obsolete and it can't be offloaded to machines.
10. We haven't "solved" mathematics and we won't get there before the Sun burns out.
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
Fun fact: they were invented in a nazi prisoners' camp, where Leray (an analyist and expert in fluid mechanics) was pretending to be a topologist in order to avoid nazis to make him collaborate with them. He got so into the role that he ended up revolutionizing algebraic topology
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
The vibe on here re: AIxMath is kind of apocalyptic, and what’s true is that highly capable AI models have significant impacts on (non-mathematical!) questions around hiring, journals, etc. But if you just log off in fact the day to day of doing math research is really not so different, except that you can talk to your computer about it and sometimes it’s helpful.
What does this help look like? In practice high quality math research has never looked like “run a for loop through open conjectures and try to resolve them all,” and it still doesn’t. Most interesting work does not have the form of a problem set, but is rather an open-ended exploration of some phenomenon. There are lots of ways talking to one’s computer can help with this, but I don’t feel particularly worried that it will be automated. After all, it’s a process that is only done when I say it is!
Anyway, it’s a great time to be a congenitally calm mathematician.
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
I keep seeing things like this, and it's important to dismantle. I don't care about this particular post, but am using it as an example.
There is an extremely important distinction between delight in an enlargement of mathematical understanding and delight in the imagined humiliation of mathematicians and what you think they represent.
There is another difference between welcoming a discovery that happens to be humbling and welcoming it because someone is being humbled.
If you've done math for decades, you're used to being humbled and feeling dumb. Being wrong, spending months or years on something that turns out to be nothing like you thought, this is ordinary life when you do math for a living.
The widespread responses to all this ai math that say things like "cope", "get f**ked", "they're just mad because something is better than them" have an uncanny resemblance to classic revenge against distinction, as though someone else's mathematical achievement and passion had been an injury, and its supposed devaluation were a form of redress.
Notice what's nearly always missing from these sorts of responses: any interest in the math. What is interesting about the result? What do we understand now that we didn't before? How, concretely, does this show that now more people can participate? Instead, the first and loudest response is glee at somebody else's perceived loss of standing. This is what "cope", "permanent underclass", and all those sorts of snarky responses mean. Not "now more of us can do math, awesome!", but "now your math does not make you anything special."
This should feel familiar, it's pretty textbook. Nietzsche described this very clearly: someone "who does not possess enough intellect to enjoy it, and just enough education to know this--bored, disgusted, contemptuous of himself." What does this sort of person need? Revenge. This sort of perverse delight in the perceived humiliation of somebody else is a way for them to feel superior to those whose abilities they resent.
Finally, they have "found a standard before which even the intellectually gifted are no better than oneself." Equality before the machine.
Let me be clear, because this is much much larger than math and this battle will keep recurring as ai appears to eat more and more of human life. At its limit, this sort of response is a verdict on humanity itself: collective self-contempt becomes their final source of pride.
This is a war between the will to humanity's self-belittlement and love of humanity and the conviction that such love is one of the foundations of rationality (not its enemy).
If your picture of the world comes from trash romantic accounts of the enlightenment, or their residue absorbed by osmosis, you have probably learned to equate rationality and objectivity with showing that humanity is nothing special. In that fairy-tale, each successive humiliation is seen as another victory for reason.
Get off x and out of your bubble and live a real life. Forge bonds with real, complex human beings. Realize how much you and everything you fight for, everything you desire, your dreams, are bound up with other human beings and our fate. You are living through one of the most interesting times in human history. WAKE UP. It's not cool to be cynical anymore.
Spinoza is a nice antidote to the idiotic romantic fairy-tale. He showed why we do not have to choose between an unsparing understanding of nature as it really is (where we are not exceptional) and an affirmative attitude toward human life and our right to take special interest in it.
Humiliation, especially of humanity itself, does not arise from reason. If you correctly understand something more powerful than ourselves, it helps you understand ourselves more clearly, and assists our power of acting. It even helps us love ourselves more, which is a requirement of reason. It doesn't lead to reveling in our own lack of power.
Understanding our limits is not the same thing as learning to despise ourselves, and there is nothing rational or objective about delight in perceived humiliation of people. And contempt for human beings is not a qualification for deciding what should happen to them.
This is about power, in the end. Do we still have any power to decide how this is all going to turn out? Of course we do.
If you are feeling defeated by all this stuff, try to remember what an extraordinary gift so much of this can be. There's so much you can now do with all of this to enhance your powers and share those powers with others. For every perceived demonstration of our limitations, 50 other limitations have been lifted. Wake up with a burning desire to explore those. Discovering that we are less powerful than we supposed (at least in certain areas) does not have to make us less capable than we were.
And if people at the top of their field, who have lived and breathed math for their entire lives, who feel connected to it in a way you probably do not fathom and who have accomplished extraordinary things, are attempting to express a serious misalignment between a new technology and their practice, it makes sense to listen, even if it's not always expressed in your preferred way.
If you are one of the "cope" people or think this is just about humbling some people and it's your job to point out what you take to be their humiliation, know that that is about YOU. And take comfort in the following: whatever bulldozer you think you see coming, it's coming for you too; and, if you had your way, for all things human. But YOU knew that already, you want that, and you may even believe that shepherding it in helps you signal your rationality. But is is just the will to self-destruction, which is always irrational.
Nobody serious judges a mathematical result by whether it flatter humanity. But whether certain developments are desirable for human beings, this cannot be settled by showing how it punctures a flattering belief.
If you are a mathematician, you need to be very careful right now to not internalize someone else's resentment into our own self-contempt, and let it diminish our powers. Seize the parts of those tools that genuinely enlarge what we can understand, create, and share and go all in on that. Ignore the resentment and extinctionist rhetoric. The goal of all that is to make you feel powerless, and there is no ultimate goal of those people other than to bring about the end of humanity.
Rather than rage against the people who take glee in pointing to these new powers as evidence that you have none, ignore them, and rage to use these newfound powers to enhance our powers and humanity.
One last thing: if you hate humanity, if the first thing you see in all the debate these new discoveries creates is a chance to take delight in humbling somebody else or a group of people, if you are compelled to say things like “cope” when someone expresses concern about where some developments seem to be going, if yu are a nepobaby who has never experienced anything real of life or suffering or the depth and stunning expressiveness of human beings, KEEP YOUR HANDS AWAY FROM ALIGNMENT and any discussions of what we're supposed to do with all this.
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
On top of the old arguments, here's a new one: mathematical training makes you a much stronger LLM user, even when the topic has no math in it.
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
Breaking: a team of human mathematicians working in secret over the last 3 years, and at least two frontier AI labs with 7-figure budgets, are believed to be neck-and-neck in a race to determine whether the Birch-Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture was posed by three people, or just two.
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
I recently came across an excellent dive into Qantas Flight 32 and the investigation into what caused the accident.
* An engine exploded
* Because a drive arm broke, allowing a turbine disk to overspeed
* Because a fire burned through the drive arm
* Because an oil pipe cracked, releasing hot oil that caught fire
* Because the wall of the oil pipe was too thin
* Because it had been misaligned by half a millimeter in the machine that manufactured it
* Because the manufacturing process required a realignment of certain clamps partway through the machining, and the part could shift during this process
* Because the correct part position had not been specified in the manufacturing documents
* Because the original manufacturing design had prevented this problem, and thus didn't need to specify a required measurement, and then the process was tweaked without catching this
* Because the product inspections were performed against the manufacturing drawings rather than the design drawings, thus no discrepancy was noticed
* Because there was "widespread procedural non-compliance" among the employees at the facility
* Because the company did not act on an internal review from 2 years earlier which had found that the facility lacked a “strong focus on quality within the business".
This is the level of investigation into root causes that you get when the people involved are competent and making a serious attempt to keep the public safe.
And the original accident didn't hurt a single person!
admiralcloudberg.medium.com/…
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
This is also why I've been so persistent in saying anti-institutionalism is the biggest theat to American politics today, bc it transcend left vs right, socialism vs capitalism and any other ideological conflict, since if there's no trust, what difference does it make?
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
7. It's also why you have to look at Covid, the Affordability Crisis and every other thing that drives Americans nuts about their standard of living as continuations of the GFC that we've never gotten over, on either side of aisle. And that happened nearly 20 yrs ago.
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
One thing I find obnoxious about “hitting a ceiling in math” discourse is that it’s mostly based on people’s self-reports of having found some topic too hard. But my experience teaching math is that people are often wrong when they make such claims!
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
Don't use AI for writing until you develop your own taste and voice
Using AI to write isn't inherently bad. The danger is using AI to write before you've developed your taste for what is good content. If the AI produces slop, you won't even recognize it as slop
Read a lot to figure out what good looks like. Write a lot to know what your voice sounds like. Only then, use AI to help you write, but make sure it actually sounds like you
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
The popular conversation around AI in America looks nothing like the narratives the elites are driving.
For our new research, we analyzed 25,000 TikTok and YouTube videos about AI---and watched thousands of them ourselves---to understand how Americans are encountering AI in their everyday lives.
Despite an elite conversation focused largely on backlash, AI videos embracing AI outnumber videos about resisting AI 3 to 1.
These "adopter" videos don't focus on the things elites talk about: they talk about funny memes and effects AI can help make and ways you can use AI to help you with your job search.
There is a significant and organized social media community focused on resisting AI, but surprisingly, it's not mainly about job loss, data centers, or existential risk. Instead, it's about creative theft and the erosion of human-made art. This has all the hallmarks of a genuine movement---with organized efforts to support human artists, to report AI-generated content, and to oppose the technology in the real world.
All in all, when we look past the efforts of the labs and the media to impose a top-down narrative around job loss and existential risk, we find everyday Americans having a far different and in many ways more "normal" conversation (@random_walker)---one in which AI offers immediate and personal opportunities and challenges all at the same time.
Check out the full research piece, which is loaded with interesting real example videos, here:
freesystems.substack.com/p/m…
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
I've said this before but worth saying again now:
"Every post-trained model encodes choices. Which facts it will state plainly and which it will hedge. Which aesthetic defaults it reaches for when asked to write. Which values get framed as common sense and which get framed as controversial. Which questions it will engage and which it will refuse. Rather than being malicious decisions, they are the unavoidable residue of training, and the people making them are serious and thoughtful. But the choices are still being made, and they are being made by a very small number of people at a very small number of institutions.
If two companies' post-training decisions become the default interface through which a billion people query the world, that is an unprecedented centralisation of epistemic authority. No religious institution, no state broadcaster, no newspaper chain in the history of the world has mediated as much of human cognition as a dominant AI system would. And the risk is not that the people at those companies are bad curators. The risk is that any single curator of humanity's intelligence layer is a structural failure mode, regardless of who holds the position. Monocultures are fragile to the specific blind spots of their curators in ways that diverse ecosystems are not, and they are fragile in ways that are difficult to detect from inside them.
A healthy society has diverse epistemic sources. The democratic world of AI has models trained on different corpora, by different communities, for different contexts. Some might say it is balkanization, but to me it's pluralism. And pluralism is the principle that has always made distributed epistemic systems more resilient than centralised ones, applied to the intelligence infrastructure we are building now."
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
When a generation's suffering is rewarded, it produces moralists. When a generation's suffering is ignored, it produces nihilists.
We should not be surprised by what we have cultivated.
A ruling generation that mistakes its own luck for universal law will usually mistake the next generation's despair for weakness.
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
Try to read this and feel your eyes glaze over the mind numbing detail that's so boring you just want to jump off a building.
Then, and only then, you will begin to appreciate what real AI coding / software engineering in the real world looks like.
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
If there is one job that shouldbe entirely replaced with AI, its Tech CEO. The AI is more than capable of coming up with vapid ideas and pitching them to venture capitalists with technobauble word salads, the AI can easily generate the shitty base code that will eventually be replaced by experienced developers, the AI will even do a better job at pretending to be human than soulless abominations like Altman, Andreessen and Karp do.
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
🦔Standard Chartered CEO Bill Winters told investors Monday that the bank will cut 7,000 jobs by 2030 and called the affected workers "low-value human capital" being replaced with "financial and investment capital." The cuts hit back-office staff in Chennai, Bengaluru, Kuala Lumpur, and Warsaw. Standard Chartered just posted $2.45 billion in Q1 profits, well above the $2.09 billion expected.
My Take
Winters picked "low-value human capital" on purpose. He had every standard corporate phrasing available and chose the one that strips away any pretense about how the bank sees the people who built its operations. I cover a lot of layoff announcements and most of them at least try to sound human. This one did not. The workers being thrown out are the same ones Standard Chartered moved offshore in the 2000s to save money the first time. The bank got cheap labor for two decades and is now calling that labor worthless on the way out the door.
Bank CEOs feel safe saying the quiet part out loud now, which says investor pressure to humanize layoffs has collapsed. Standard Chartered wants 15% return on tangible equity by 2028, and Winters just told you exactly how he plans to get there. The offshore hubs go first because they are easier to cut than the London and Singapore staff who sit closer to him. Watch which other banks copy the language over the next two quarters, because once one CEO calls workers "low-value capital" without his stock getting punished, the rest of the sector follows fast.
Hedgie🤗
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
Smartphones are not the explanation for the recent decline in fertility. Instead, they are an accelerator of deeper forces already at work.
Let’s start with the facts. Fertility is falling almost everywhere: in rich, middle-income, and poor countries; in secular and religious countries; and in countries with high and low levels of gender equality.
The decline accelerated around 2014. So, no country-specific explanation will work unless you are willing to believe that 200 distinct country-specific explanations arrived at roughly the same time.
Smartphones look like the obvious candidate: the first iPhone was released in 2007, and global adoption has been astonishingly fast.
Economists understand the first major decline in fertility in advanced economies, from 6 or 7 children per woman throughout most of human history to about 1.8, that occurred between the early 1800s and roughly 1970, well before smartphones. The main drivers were a sharp fall in child mortality (effective fertility was rarely above 3 and often close to 2) and the shift from a low-skill, rural agrarian economy to a high-skill, urban industrial one. We have quantitative models that fit these facts well.
Country-specific factors mattered too, of course. Proximity to low-fertility neighbors accelerated Hungary’s decline, while fragmented landowning structures accelerated France’s. But these were second-order mechanisms.
This is also why most economists long considered Paul Ehrlich’s doom scenarios implausible. We forecast that fertility in middle- and low-income economies would follow the same path as in the rich, probably faster, because reductions in child mortality reached India or Africa at lower income levels (medical technology is nearly universal, and most gains come from handwashing and cheap antibiotics, not Mayo Clinic-level care). Much of what we see in Africa or parts of Latin America today is still that old story.
But in the 1980s, a new pattern appeared. Japan and Italy fell below 1.8, the level we had thought was the new floor. By 1990, Japan was at 1.54 and Italy at 1.36.
This second fertility decline began in Japan and Italy earlier than elsewhere, driven by country-specific factors, but the underlying dynamics were widespread: secularization, an education arms race, expensive housing, the dissolution of old social networks, and the shift to a service economy in which women’s bargaining power within the household is higher. The U.S. lagged because secularization came later, suburban housing remained relatively cheap, and African American fertility was still high. U.S. demographic patterns are exceptional and skew how academics (most of whom are in the U.S.) and the New York Times see the world.
My best guess is that, without smartphones, Italy’s 2025 fertility rate would be about 1.24 rather than 1.14. I doubt anyone will document an effect larger than 0.1-0.2. Italy was at 1.19 in 1995, not far from today’s 1.14. The TFR is cyclical due to tempo effects, so I do not read too much into the rise between 1995 and 2007 or the decline from 1.27 in 2019 to 1.14 today. The direct effect of smartphones is not zero, but it is not, by itself, that large.
Where social media, in general, and smartphones, in particular, matter is in the diffusion of social norms. What would have taken 25 years now happens in 10. Social media are not the cause of fertility decline; modernity is. But they are a very fast accelerator.
That is why social media are a major part of the story behind Guatemala (yes, Guatemala) going from 3.8 children per woman in 2005 to 1.9 in 2025. Without them, Guatemala would also have reached 1.9, just 20 years later.
Modernity, in its current form, is incompatible with replacement-level fertility. By modernity, I do not mean capitalism: fertility fell earlier and faster in socialist economies than in market economies. Socialist Hungary fell below replacement in 1960, and socialist Czechoslovakia in 1966 (both experienced small, short-lived baby booms in the mid-1970s). By modernity, I mean a society organized around rational, large-scale systems and formalized knowledge.
Countries will not converge to the same fertility rate. East Asia is likely stuck near 1, possibly below, given its unbalanced gender norms and toxic education systems. Latin America faces the same gender problem plus weak growth prospects, so I expect something around 1.2. Northern Europe has more egalitarian family structures and might hold near 1.5. The very religious societies are probably the only ones that will sustain 1.8.
All of this could change with AI or changes in population composition. We will see. But on the current evidence, deep sub-replacement fertility is the “new new normal.” Unless we reorganize our societies, better learn to handle it as best we can.
fibonacci's wabbit retweeted
Any arguments against open source and open weights are mendacious and malicious by their very nature.
Open source is the foundation of modern society worth 8.8 trillion to the economy and the foundation of every major cloud, your home router, your phone, your operating system and more.
These anti-open source anti-freedom arguments are especially nasty when they use weaselly hawk coded words like "dual use."
Linux is dual use. So is your operating system. So is your phone. So is your kitchen knife.
Dual use was used against encryption. Once this stupid and spurious restriction was lifted eCommerce took off like a rocket and was worth trillions to society.
Choke points, gates and centralized controls are inherently limiting and benefit the few at the expense of the many. They choke out growth and development in society.
We don't need monks in a cave deciding what books to copy.
We need the printing press.
Anti-open source arguments have no moral ground to stand on. They are inherently self-serving and have no other purpose than to create centrally dominated monopolies and regulatory capture in an underhanded, unscrupulous way.





























