$fnma | $fmcc
I just watched Skywalkers on Netflix. It’s about people who climb to the top of large buildings as a stunt. Seeing them climb, gives me that anxious pit in my stomach. I’ve come to realize it’s not a fear of heights that makes me anxious, it’s that I don’t have confidence in their ability and that they won’t fall.
Tonight @AlexHonnold will climb Tapai 101 live on Netflix as well. I won’t get that same pit in my stomach watching him. I never do anymore. Thats because I’ve watched him for almost 10 years now, I understand his skill/preparation/confidence, and it translates into my own confidence watching him.
If you’re feeling anxious over $fnma and $fmcc recent price volatility it’s because you lack confidence in the end result. I have no pit in my stomach over the twins.
(And Yes, everything must always come back to Fannie and Freddie)
14
1,044
$fnma | $fmcc
For all those claiming @BillAckman is on his pro Fannie/Freddie tour to salvage a lost cause…there’s zero logic behind that claim. At worst, he knows nothing other than this is a critical juncture and using his opportunity to make his closing statement. At best, he’s sees where Trump and Bessent are heading anyway and is helping define the details to see it though.
If he knew that Trump/Bessent were heading towards an SPS conversion I think the last thing he would do is double down and highlight himself as the captain of a sinking ship. Not to mention put himself on bad footing with an administration he clearly respects.
“But, he has no choice because he can’t unload his position”. That also seems illogical. Sure, he couldn’t unload all of them. But he could certainly start to divest and minimize his loss. Isn’t his basis $3. He’s got plenty of room to start selling and wouldn’t be acting a fiduciary to his investors if he was aware of an impending bad outcome and didn’t act on it.
$fnma | $fmcc
I’m not saying he’s the reason for the drop today but I blame @pulte nonetheless. 50-Year mortgages?!
The guy is trying to do too much. He’s fallen trap to the halls of power and forgotten his primary role should be reverting back to limited government intervention in US housing starting with the the re-privatization of the key source of mortgage liquidity. He’s doing the opposite. Everything he proposes is just more government intervention. Get back to the fundamentals and remember that the best thing you can do is get out of the way.
"The nine most terrifying words in the English language are: I'm from the government, and I'm here to help," - Reagan.
3
737
$fnma | $fmcc
I’m not as financially savvy as my X peers, so take this with a grain of salt. Here’s how I look at investing in commons today….
There are many pricing scenario for commons at/post IPO. Some of them have a potential worst case scenario of SPS conversion leading to total wipeout of existing value - low single digit value at IPO. Logically, I just can’t envisions a scenario where you have all of the Trump hype + two of the biggest companies in the world, and they are trading at penny stock pricing. It just seems comical from a pure optics perspective so I don’t see a world in where Trump dilutes existing commons to that extent.
I believe a more plausible downside scenario is a 50% loss on current value - IPO pricing in the $5 range. From there, it’s reasonable to assume the stock price at least doubles over a 5 year period, back to today’s existing value.
Breaking even on a 5 year investment isn’t a good outcome, I recognize that. But when compared to the upside scenario of say 4x+, the commons still represent a worthwhile asymmetric opportunity.
$fnma | $fmcc
@midas79_ , we may butt heads, but i consider you my X buddy.
Help me understand this one…
If SPS are going to be waived, I can make the argument for why we wouldn’t have heard so yet. Too much excitement early on could push the price near or above a fair IPO starting point and leave less room to run for the actual big reveal. As you’ve said, lower price is better for those institutions that can only get in once they’re off the OTC.
But if they’re not going to waive. What’s the logic for not hinting at it now and at least allowing some time for the uproar of existing common holders to settle before the IPO?
At least when Pulte gave another “consider the risks” warning this evening, he did so after the post below. Last time it was out of the blue, no context, and cryptic. This time he’s clearly pumping the stock and making sure to include the standard risk caveat. I’ve said it before, with this type of messaging, even with the warning to follow, a full commons dilution would be borderline criminal. Or, at least, just a really shitty thing to do.
$fnma | $fmcc
I really have no idea why there is so much speculation on what Trump will do with Fannie and Freddie Senior preferred…he told us with zero ambiguity in his letter to Rand Paul. “Obama/Biden scam allowed the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) to steal the retirement savings of hardworking Americans who had invested in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac…The idea that the government can steal money from its citizens is socialism and is a travesty brought to you by the Obama/Biden administration. My Administration was denied the time it needed to fix this problem.”
If Trump ultimately serves as the conduit to formalize the theft he railed against he will go down as the biggest Hypocrite of all time (@Trumpo_the_Hippo[crite]). Democrats can and will troll him with this letter until the end of time; millions of conservatives who trusted him will join in the Chorus. And, to add to his legacy on this issue, he will have botched what could have been the great rebirth of these incredible companies as the scar of this unsettled issue resurfaces over and over.
@BillAckman, I understand why you can’t say this yourself, but please consider retweeting it. Trump can’t get mad at the messenger who showed him how a massive cohort of his supporters feel about his next move.
$FNMA | $FMCC
To the Junior Preferred advocates… While I support @BillAckman thesis that SPS conversion is not in fact more profitable for treasury, I can appreciate your argument in the other direction. Whats not clear to me is, are you also arguing that the cash sweep was not in fact payment towards the SPS? If not, how should that additional treasury income be accounted for?
If however, you do agree that sweep should have been applied to the SPS but predict Pulte, Bessent, and Trump will ignore that because they can do what they please and make “more” for the taxpayers by ignoring, can you at least acknowledge that the precedent set by that action has its own shortfalls? “More” isn’t always “better”… I don’t think you can ignore the net negative created when even the supposed biggest advocates of free markets expose their willingness for government overreach. From Trumps own mouth, it was “theft”. It’s a slippery slope, to say the least.
That “more” you all often reference will barely be a drop in the bucket in solving the existing U.S deficit. Whats most important for long term U.S financial success is the foundation this administrations sets for continued long term innovation and GDP growth, within the private sector. The action you suggest they will take with regard to the SPS is a huge step backwards in the progress that needs to be made.
$fnma $fmcc
@MariaBartiromo framed the question to Bessent perfectly yesterday. “Is this a good investment for people” seems like pretty deliberate way of asking about the SPS. Bessent had the opportunity to respond that there is still a lot of details to work out and thus remains a risky investment today. He didn’t. Once again, every day that goes by with this messaging makes them more culpable for potential losses to investors who buy in pre-IPO.
$fnma $fmcc
Admittedly, most of the JPS advocates on X are smarter than me, financially speaking. But I think they are ignoring the importance of a political win and the optics of a massive common dilution.
I can see the headlines now under their proposed scenario…”Trumps ‘Great’ IPO trades in single digits; 75% below pre IPO level”. I get that you all understand the nuances behind that, but 99% of America does not, including millions of retail investors who bought the stock over the last 3 months, BECAUSE THE ADMINISTRATION GAVE THEM THE GREEN LIGHT.
The defense will be, ya but now we own 95% of them and most of America will say, ya, but weren’t these government entities that we owned 100% before you did this.
The media will then have a field day claiming Trump committed a pump and dump on millions of retail investors. They wouldn’t be wrong. Pulte, Bessent, Lutnick, and Trump himself have been pumping up these companies the last few months. They’ve seen the price movement and encouraged it. Millions have bought in without the full picture, but they didn’t need to look for it because the administration was giving their blessing, why wouldn’t you buy the ticker. Not once have they caveated the risks or that the same people encouraging people to buy in were the real risk all along and getting ready to hit them over the head with the hammer.
There is no way, at the very least, the administration wouldn’t be tampering down the excitement once the pre IPO price reached or exceeded their post IPO expectations. Well, they were still going hard at $10, $11, $12…
Totally idiotic execution if their massive hype leads to massive losses. For Fuck sake, they printed a Great American Mortgage Company advertisement. And I didn’t see the “past performance isn’t indicative of future outcome” caveat.
Trump wants a huge payday for America and the largest IPO in history. Well, they can achieve the same outcome without all the justified backlash.
$fnma $fmcc
The debate between commons and JPS has been a long standing one. The JPS proponents have disgraced themselves though over the last month. I used to appreciate the diverse set of opinions; I found it informative and even bought some JPS ($FNMAS). But now many of the “pro-JPS” X users are showing their true colors and it seems driven by envy. They’re no longer just JPS advocates, they’re anti Commons. Why? Is it not okay for both shareholders to win? You’ll only be happy with a positive release if you’re the only one who benefits from it.
The latest terrible argument I heard is that Trump won’t walk away from the SPS because he wants to maximize value for the government. Stop and think. Even if that does in fact maximize value for the government (I don’t think it does), the real benefit goes to future administrations selling off their interest for the next 10+ years to come. Do you really think Trump is motivated to set up future administrations and forgo the more immediate return and spectacle he stands to achieve for his own administration by limiting dilution and maximizing the near term IPO.
I’d welcome a convincing argument, but not one steeped in irrational envy.
$FNMA $FMCC
Another lazy hit piece from someone without any clear knowledge of the situation.
So when a company is too big to fail, they’re automatically excluded from “private” status. How about all of the SIFI’s (Systematically Important Financial Institutions) who would have the same level of support in a crisis. Do you think the government would let any of the major money center banks fail? Are they not private entities?
If I had to guess, this writer is on the left and loves big government, which makes this article one of total hypocrisy. If you appreciate government spending and government intervention, how can you not support it when said intervention protects the individual American people from the total financial ruin that would take place if one of these institutions failed.
nationalreview.com/2025/08/d…
$fnma | $fmcc
Good news for the twins today but the question of senior preferred waiver still remains.
I’m relying on the notion that not waiving would have major legal implications that hang over an IPO.
But more importantly, should legal battles ensue over treatment of the Senior, it’s very possible that the success of all of this ultimately rests in the hands of a select few judges. We’ve seen how Trumps relationships with the courts has played out. Would he really take that risk?
Even those with no real interest in the IPO will take the side of common share holders just to see Trump endeavor on this matter fail.
I hope he doesn’t give them that satisfaction.
12
807
$fnma | $fmcc
On one hand I’ve become impatient waiting for progress on the twins release. On the other, it’s dawned on me that Trumps only been in office for a little over 6 months (15% of his terms). The pace of his administration leaves one feeling he’s already been there for 3.5 years.
The commentary and progress to-date has been meaningful and there is plenty of runway for Trump to see this through.
I expect there there will continue to be gaps inbetween commentary/action where momentum lulls and the price recedes. I think these are just further buy-in opportunities for those who understand the dynamics at play and received interim validation from said prior commentary/action.
$FNMA $FMCC
The latest Bloomberg article is just another great example of lazy journalism. The just of it - “anything could happened and Trump may wipe out existing shareholders”.
Great, thanks for the unthoughtful open ended analysis that leaves you “correct” in any which way this unfolds, but is devoid of any material facts that might lend itself to understanding the true probability of the many paths this could take.
We can start and end at the most obvious…Trumps letter to Rand Paul. How can you completely brush over Trumps explicit acknowledgement of the governments “theft” from shareholders the weight of that fact relative to your insinuation that Trump has no reason to forgive unjustly “owed” dollars.
@BillAckman could be wrong in predictions, but at least he is providing the full facts and full context.
assets.realclear.com/files/2…
$fnma $fmcc
Credit to @MariaBartiromo for being one of the very few journalist to actually ask a direct question about the potential Fannie and Freddie exit, specifically in the context of it currently being a publicly traded company.
Given the magnitude of this topic, it’s been amazing to see the lack of interest from the media. The few times it’s been raised, it’s only ever been a binary “Yes/No, will they be released”; no details ever requested about how it will happened, existing shareholders, etc.
I don’t blame the administration about the lack of transparency on this matter, because no one is really asking them about it.
GM don't miss my interview coming up w the head of @FannieMae & @FreddieMac after his shakeup in 10-mins what will The #Trump administration do w the #mortgage originators - @pulte will tell us next @MorningsMaria @FoxBusiness
GSE Hotline retweeted
Capital Group Increases Fannie Mae Holdings; Now Exceeds 100 Million Shares $FNMA



