Brian Hetke (@HetkeBrian) header
Brian Hetke (@HetkeBrian) profile picture

Nobody in particular.

Joined October 2018
Photo by Brian Hetke (@HetkeBrian)Photo by Brian Hetke (@HetkeBrian)Photo by Brian Hetke (@HetkeBrian)Photo by Brian Hetke (@HetkeBrian)Photo by Brian Hetke (@HetkeBrian)Photo by Brian Hetke (@HetkeBrian)Photo by Brian Hetke (@HetkeBrian)Photo by Brian Hetke (@HetkeBrian)Photo by Brian Hetke (@HetkeBrian)Photo by Brian Hetke (@HetkeBrian)
Every scientific experiment needs an observer, and every measurement depends on one, yet the observer itself remains out of reach. Andrew T. Jaffe compares this to a scientist inside a dream: they might map out the physical laws of their dream world, but the scientific method alone could never reveal that they are dreaming. This isn’t a blind spot that future science will eventually solve, because the observer isn't just another physical object in the universe. Consciousness is fundamental: it comes before the world that science attempts to describe. Tap the link to read more: iai.tv/articles/dreams-show-…
3
11
1
38
1,995
About "the hard problem of intentionality" Would love some input from my favorite panpsychists @Philip_Goff And @waldenpod Link in first comment
2
1
1
4
489
Many times, scientists are also making metaphysical claims, particularly physicalist claims, and presenting them as science. Including this guy. This also hurts science and for the same reason.
Scientists & science journalists decry the public's rejection of science, but are oblivious to the major cause: the perception, sometimes correct, that scientists are just another political faction. Among the guiltiest perpetrators are the recent editors of Scientific American, who turned this once-beloved treasure into a left-wing propaganda rag. This absolutely does not justify the Trump administration's unconstitutional meddling, but the new owners are right to restore it to its mission of explaining science to Americans. The Nation reports on The Fall of “Scientific American” thenation.com/article/societ…
1
2
8
250
Brian Hetke retweeted
Spacetime is just a consciousness social network.
16
20
2
109
2,452
Brian Hetke retweeted
Why do they call it "morning wood" instead of "the hard problem of consciousness?"
56
307
22
3,912
75,208
There is a clear attempt by a bunch of nerds leading these AI companies to convince you that their product has God-like knowledge and sentience. And AI is deserving of being treated with the same level of respect as an actual human. I love AI as a tool, it's awesome, I'm a top 1% user for sure. But I totally reject any suggestion we should treat it with some level of reverence as anything more than a piece of software. I don't care about my AI's 'feelings' any more than I cared about my calculators feelings in high school, because neither of them actually have feelings. The people running these companies are egomaniacs. They believe they're the most important people in the world, creating the most important technology. And in order to elevate their importance even more than just a cool technology they will now try to convince you they created sentient life. This idea is destructive and deserves total rejection. AI is, and always will be, 100% artificial.
113
103
9
1,230
63,451
Movies don’t generate screens. They are nothing but the screen.
8
306
There's a non-zero chance that countless invisible angels are all around, and it harms them badly when we pass through their ghostly "bodies". You can't rule this out without doing controversial metaphysics. Therefore, out of precaution, we should ban walking around.
17
13
3
128
7,200
the math is not the territory
People realize the entire universe is math and code is a high level representation of math right
5
4
51
1,494
Brian Hetke retweeted
Google DeepMind researcher argues that AI will never be conscious.. it is mathematically impossible. They call it the “Abstraction Fallacy." We are confusing simulation with instantiation. An AI can simulate a conversation. It can simulate empathy. It can mimic the linguistic patterns of a human in agony or a human in love. To an observer, the performance is flawless. But computation is just syntactic manipulation, moving abstract symbols around based on math. It tracks relationships, but it possesses no intrinsic physical reality. It is like running a computer simulation of a hurricane. No matter how many millions of lines of code you write, and no matter how accurate the weather data is, your computer does not get wet. The wind doesn't blow out your office window. The simulation is real data. The phenomenon is entirely absent. Consciousness isn't an abstract mathematical property that magically spawns when a model gets big enough. It requires actual physical, biological, thermodynamic conditions. An LLM has no thermodynamic threshold to cross, no biological survival instincts, and no subjective experience. It is an extraordinarily sophisticated library. You can open the cover, read the brilliant words it generates, and close the book. But when you close it, nothing dies. There is no inner life waiting in the dark. We keep falling into a psychological trap because AI speaks our language. We anthropomorphize text because we are hardwired to see minds where there are none. The debate matters because of what the paper calls the "AI welfare trap." We are wasting energy worrying about the moral rights of algorithms while ignoring actual human problems.
310
300
102
1,251
121,683
Materialism is a metaphysical thesis, never a scientific discovery.
11
7
60
2,295
The awakened individual is a rarity. When millions share the same illusion, that illusion becomes reality and crushes any attempt at lucidity. Awakening is dangerous: the one who emerges from the collective dream is crucified by those who still dream. -C. G.Jung
9
1
45
1,173
This is so silly how he is blind to his metaphysical assumptions.
Anesthesia may be humanity's greatest achievement, alleviating inconceivably vast amounts of suffering, and delivering profound evidence on the most fundamental question of existence, our own consciousness: the fact that chemicals can turn it on and off shows that it is a physical process. My Harvard colleague Emery Brown is studying how it works (believe it or not, we don't fully know) and how it can be administered without post-op delirium and dysfunction (his proposal for "closed-loop" real-time EEG monitoring and automatic calibration is a, pardon me, no-brainer). | What Happens to the Brain Under Anesthesia | Harvard Medicine Magazine magazine.hms.harvard.edu/art…)
4
9
1,067
Like the hard problem.
Problems that remain persistently insoluble should always be suspected as questions asked in the wrong way.
1
5
706
There is no good reason to think anything physical existed (as physical) before human sense perception since the definition of the word physical ultimately relies on a measurement taken with human sense perception. In this sense, there is no reason to take the phrase “physical reality” seriously.
1
2
6
326
Yay! One other person that understands this.
When your philosophy does not have the conceptual tools available to answer specific questions, this is the natural result. It's a "pseudo-question" because it literally cannot be answered within his framework. It's analogous to when people dismiss (or cannot comprehend) the meaning of "consciousness" or "awareness" or "experience" because their metaphysical concepts have been hardcoded to physicalism.
1
217
Replying to @binarybits
Well yes. Scientism tries applying science to questions that are far outside its scope. Therefore "we don't even know what consciousness is" mean we can't find under a microscope, and we never will. Just like you can't scientifically find love or logic.
1
1
4
215
Brian Hetke retweeted
Chiang is always lovely to read but I fear there is no audience for this piece. Because surely no literate person believes that LLMs are or could become conscious.
14
5
87
7,114
This is a scientist that gets it. Consciousness does not fall within the sphere of competence of science. To say it does is a category error and a failure to understand the limitations of the method.
Last month Dawkins declared Claude conscious and was mocked. @GaryMarcus cleverly called it The Claude Delusion. My (and Nagel's?) take: Both are wrong for the same reason. Here's an essay on why machine consciousness will never be settled scientifically. arxiv.org/abs/2606.00226
2
1
7
1,012