ItsJustWhoTV

everyone right now keeps saying #ahs13 ruined judy martin. let me break it down. judy was never some pure saint corrupted by satan out of nowhere. in asylum she’s a woman with a dark, messy history. a nightclub singer, an alcoholic who hit a kid and fled to church for redemption. then she became sister jude running briarcliff and causing genuine harm. you shouldn’t oversimplify her story. she’s not just a evil woman getting punished. she’s both accountable for her choices and a victim of manipulation and cruel circumstances. this duality is what makes her brilliant. making her carry satan’s bloodline doesn’t ruin her, it adds depth to her tragedy. after trying to change her life, satan comes back to her not to grant peace, but for pure vengeance and lineage. it aligns completely with ahs dark narrative logic. mr. nas appearing to judy in 1964 is satan taking raw revenge after she ruined his briarcliff blueprint and got him cast back into hell or the apollyon by monsignor timothy howard. all through asylum, judy wages war against possessed mary eunice, fighting the darkness inside the asylum. under s13 lore that battle becomes personal, she was directly defying satan. mary eunice’s death destroys his vessel, forcing satan back to hell/apollyon. but he comes right back in 1964 as mr. nas to inflict the ultimate twisted payback on judy. by impregnating a devout, god-fearing woman he leaves behind two daughters who link directly into witch history and the langdon storylines. he doesn’t just break judy, he turns her body into the vessel for his multi generational satanic curse.

⁠#ahs13 the biggest explanation about satanic bloodline: judy martin, fiona goode, constance langdon. fiona was adopted and she didn’t know it, can you all use your brains maybe? you think she just got thrown to the street as a baby and all of a sudden she became the supreme? without a mother to teach her?⁠ we literally just found out yesterday that fiona was born in briarcliff, just like constance. pepper handed newborn fiona over to the academy, constance was sold to a married couple in virginia, and nothing prevents that jewelry from being right next to baby fiona in the cradle or towel.⁠ remember fiona gave that jewelry to cordelia in coven, saying this belonged to her mother, and since she knew zero facts about her biological parents, she was obviously adopted. it doesn’t even mean the jewelry originally belonged to judy anyway.⁠ fiona was raised at robichaux academy from infancy, and to avoid traumatizing a growing child, regular witches and warlocks stepped up to be her foster parents.⁠ let’s not pretend like we know every single microscopic detail of fiona’s and constance’s childhood and past... we literally don’t have an exact chronology of events after their birth in briarcliff. the sequence gets lost right after, and even 10 years from now we could still learn new details about both of their biographies.⁠ and another thing, y’all seem to forget that fiona and constance are satan’s daughters... they carry angelic/demonic/satanic blood, which means they could easily age and grow at an abnormal speed, literally just like michael and the demonic entities in delicate.⁠ and for anyone who’s still confused about judy having syphilis and supposedly not being able to have kids, remember what myrtle herself said (the one who literally dropped this whole family secret)... she said the devil got his way in the end. he doesn’t care if judy is sick, he’s literally a supernatural entity with powers and magic. impregnating someone or curing human illnesses is nothing to him, he can literally create diseases himself. it’s literally the devil.⁠ saying that none of this makes sense is honestly sickening at this point. if you’re actually engaged in detailed viewing, what’s stopping you from headcanoning something like this when IT DOESN’T BREAK CANON, it literally doesn’t, canon simply doesn’t exist anymore (just like fiona’s and constance’s entire backstories)⁠