John Tomsett (@johntomsett) header
John Tomsett (@johntomsett) profile picture

Education consultant, writer & blogger. Co-author of the Huh project with Mary Myatt. Erstwhile head teacher of Huntington School, York. All views are my own.

York, England
Joined July 2010
Photo by John Tomsett (@johntomsett)Photo by John Tomsett (@johntomsett)Photo by John Tomsett (@johntomsett)Photo by John Tomsett (@johntomsett)Photo by John Tomsett (@johntomsett)Photo by John Tomsett (@johntomsett)Photo by John Tomsett (@johntomsett)Photo by John Tomsett (@johntomsett)Photo by John Tomsett (@johntomsett)Photo by John Tomsett (@johntomsett)
I have returned to @CrownHousePub for my next two books, where I analyse what we can learn from 19 in-depth profiles of truly great teachers, with a foreword by @ProfCoe #GreatSecondaryTeachers #GreatPrimaryTeachers
11
11
1
49
11,107
Replying to @AlexJQuigley
@AlexJQuigley @lukejcr @johntomsett Hope you can share this
📢 We’re recruiting! Could you be our next Headteacher? Join Huntington School and lead a vibrant, ambitious school community where Respect, Honesty and Kindness are at the heart of everything we do. Find out more and apply here: huntingtonschool.co.uk/page/… #EducationJobs
1
341
📢 We’re recruiting! Could you be our next Headteacher? Join Huntington School and lead a vibrant, ambitious school community where Respect, Honesty and Kindness are at the heart of everything we do. Find out more and apply here: huntingtonschool.co.uk/page/… #EducationJobs
3
3
1
3,606
John Tomsett retweeted
“In my experience, 'making learning and thinking visible is truly essential in any classroom in which one is teaching students with global learning needs if those young people are to make progress and engage more fully with the school curriculum.” This is a really critical point Gail Naish makes in Cognitive Apprenticeship in Action about the importance of making expert thinking visible and accessible to students. @johntomsett When we make assumptions about what students should already know or be able to do based on our own expertise and our own curse of knowledge, it can harm all students, but the consequences are even greater for those with the largest gaps between novice and expert knowledge and thinking. Making expert thinking visible isn’t simply good instructional practice. It’s a matter of instructional equity. Every student deserves access to the knowledge, expertise, and thinking processes that allow them to become more capable learners.
2
2
1
21
1,764
Only one way to finish your blanket box for the newborn... @OdiesOil
1
1
6
838
John Tomsett retweeted
Lou Macari MBE ❤️ We're all incredibly proud of the enormous impact you've made, @LouMacari10! 👏

91
338
15
4,516
473,276
John Tomsett retweeted
So much this from @HaleDonal in @johntomsett’s Collins et al’s Cognitive Apprenticeship in Action. Only showing a worked example is not making expert thinking visible or accessible to apprentices. “Put simply, students are unlikely to make use of potential models of good writing acquired through reading because they have no understanding of how authors produced such text.” And one way to make this expert thinking visible? A lovely scripted commentary unpacking the question. ⬇️
2
4
910
John Tomsett retweeted
In this week’s episode of The Amol Rajan Connection: @daisychristo on how we’re messing up Education; the danger of the Stupidogenic Society; what technology does to our minds; long-term vs working memory; and how AI affects what children should learn. Out now on YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts and Amazon Music.
21
94
17
267
73,182
John Tomsett retweeted
Day 3 of teaching with a script for the first time. Today, I used a script to model how to rank the 10 oil-rich countries in Southwest Asia we have been studying based on the degree to which they have reinvested or concentrated the windfall from their oil wealth. The script guided my think-aloud, making explicit the questions I ask, the evidence I weigh, and the reasoning I use to arrive at a ranking. Two observations from today: 1. Scripts can help make expert thinking more explicit and repeatable. Today’s think-aloud connects directly to some reflecting I’ve been doing on making expert thinking visible, informed by Collins et al.’s research on cognitive apprenticeship and @johntomsett book Collins et al’s Cognitive Apprenticeship in Action. One of the challenges of teaching disciplinary thinking is that experts often perform complex mental processes without realizing how much they’re doing or how invisible those processes are to novices. When I rank countries, I’m drawing on knowledge, asking questions, weighing evidence, and making judgments that can easily remain hidden if I only model the finished product. The script helped me deliberately model those questions and decisions rather than simply explain the steps. It gave me a structure for making the thinking visible so students can begin to recognize and eventually use those same processes themselves. 2. Scripted thinking can risk making complex reasoning feel too linear. Ranking countries involves judgment, weighing competing evidence, and recognizing that a country’s position can change depending on the lens being applied. A script provides a clear pathway through that thinking, but I need to be careful that the modeling doesn’t make the process appear more straightforward or definitive than it actually is. My goal is to scaffold students’ thinking, not imply that there is always one obvious answer or a single correct path to a conclusion. Expert thinking needs to be made visible, but students also need to see how experts navigate uncertainty, competing evidence, and difficult decisions. Three days into the experiment, I’m thinking more about the relationship between scripting and cognitive apprenticeship. A script may help me make expert thinking visible and deliberate, but the test is whether that scripted modeling helps students develop the knowledge and thinking processes to do more of the work independently.
9
2
34
2,452
John Tomsett retweeted
“It’s really important that you don’t just present pre-prepared examples. Dare to fail, so that students can see that it is hard work, that it takes time to hone the skills.” “Remembering to give this kind of detailed metacognitive commentary about how you got to the correct working, before starting to present it, can really help students learn what they should be thinking (and doing)…” These are such important points about making expert thinking visible from Liz Dunbar and Tom Norris in Collins et al.’s Cognitive Apprenticeship in Action. I know I’ve certainly fallen prey to the worked-example trap of showing students what the finished expert product looks like and assuming they can make the massive leap from point A to point B. But making expert thinking visible isn’t just about showing students what an expert work looks like. It’s about showing them how the expert got there: the decisions, the reasoning, the knowledge, the seductive details, and all the messiness along the way. We need to model the process, not just present the product. If we wanted to teach someone to paint like Michelangelo, we wouldn’t show them one of his finished paintings and tell them to get to work. We’d make the process visible, demonstrating the techniques, explaining the decisions, and showing them how to work through the challenges that arise. And that means being willing to make mistakes in front of our students. Not because we need to manufacture failure, but because expert work is rarely as effortless as it appears in its finished form. Our students need to see what expertise looks like in action, not just what it looks like when the work is done. @johntomsett
2
5
1
15
2,448
John Tomsett retweeted
“We take no shortcuts. We work as hard as the students need to in order to make our expert thinking visible.” I really love this mindset from @HughJRichards in Collins et al.’s Cognitive Apprenticeship in Action. There’s the curse of knowledge, but there’s also the curse of expertise: we become so familiar with thinking within our domain that we lose sight of the knowledge, connections, and reasoning processes we draw upon to do the work. As experts, the work may feel relatively easy to us, and we can make critical assumptions about what students should know and be able to do without our guidance. We take for granted how much thinking we do automatically, how many steps we skip, and how many connections we make without even realizing it. My job is to make that thinking visible. To slow down, model the process, explain the decisions, and show students how to work through each step. I need to make explicit what expertise allows me to do implicitly. @johntomsett
1
4
15
1,159
John Tomsett retweeted
Although many people see DI as only a fast paced call and response classroom approach, my book explores its approach to curriculum sequencing and design
3
11
1
35
3,016
John Tomsett retweeted
NEW POST: The Untold Story of Bloom's Taxonomy and the Pyramid That Never Was. - link in reply ⤵️
🤖 Made with AI
16
88
29
265
57,009
John Tomsett retweeted
Defence Sec, Pete Hegseth promises the live streaming of an execution by firing squad. How much darker does the US get?
Hegseth on Nidal Hasan: "He's gonna get a firing squad of soldiers. As it should be. We'll make sure that people are able to watch it. That it's public. Because people need to understand that there's serious consequences for these types of things."
561
460
59
3,123
111,183
John Tomsett retweeted
👌Next week on HEPs Leadership 55 Mary will speak for Free live about the key principles of KS3 building on the ideas of the KS3 Alliance. The session will also include updates from the DFE and Ofsted @johntomsett @kst_trust @NetworkEDEM @NorthLondonRS @ProfCoe
2
1
487