John retweeted
'There are many curious facts about bees.'
S. Augustine the Oracle, On the Proceedings of Pelagius, ch. 18.
Shot 17 years ago today, and died on the 20th
He knew they wanted to kill him, and when the shooter entered his church and shouted his name, he came out of the altar and into the martyric contest to die for his Lord
Holy Hieromartyr Daniel, intercede with Christ for us!
"In the Godhead is the unity, but they whose Godhead it is are three in number.
Each is the one God, if you should talk of them singly."
- St Gregory the Theologian's poem, Poem on the Holy Spirit, PG 37:408-415
"Leave these men alone! Let them go! For if their purpose or activity is of human origin, it will fail. But if it is from God, you will not be able to stop these men; you will only find yourselves fighting against God.”
Acts 5:38b-39
Just a reminder that the uptick in WR hate this week is because of hangry ER people, all of whom have broken the fast by looking more intently at their neighbor's plates than their own
Replying to @Zalmoxis7534
It’s not “inherently” eastern (whatever that even means), but it is foreign to the West. The West already has venerable rites of its own. We don’t need to reinvent the wheel
"Christ and all the Apostles were foreign to the West"
Your first step here is googling where the two most glorious apostles died, and deleting this post
After that, go ahead and let the bishops know that they should stop using St James's liturgy bc its "reinventing the wheel"
Replying to @LatinAcolyte
You don’t know what inherently eastern means yet you agree with me about it? Christ and all of the Apostles were foreign to the West too. Apart from a handful, all Western Orthodox Christians have been “Byzantine Rite” since the great schism, so it’s you who’s trying to reinvent the wheel, and borrowing from the heterodox at the expense of your own tradition at that.
This idea that the liturgical customs of the West even need to be "recreated" or that we ought to avoid bringing them back into use is one of the most damaging things you could do to a budding Orthodox mission in North America
2
27
452
John retweeted
"Either way, we're cooked.."
St. Paisios of Mount Athos, Λόγοι Α΄: Με Πόνο και Αγάπη για τον Σύγχρονο Άνθρωπο [Words, Vol. 1: With Pain and Love for Contemporary Man] (Souroti, Thessaloniki: Holy Hesychasterion of the Evangelist John the Theologian, 1998), pg. 14.
John retweeted
Replying to @Zalmoxis7534
@Zalmoxis7534
For the quote by St. Cleopa,
"Children who die unbaptized, for reasons independent of the will of their parents or priests, may be considered partakers of the baptism of desire, just like the righteous of the Old Testament, or by analogy with the healings performed by Jesus Christ in response to the prayers of parents or friends. For God does not punish the innocent; on the contrary, He created man for happiness.
Nevertheless, the parents of these children shall confess, and a penance shall be assigned to them according to their degree of care or negligence. That is, they should baptize or raise a poor child, visit a holy place, give alms, perform prostrations, observe fasting, etc.
Here is what St. Cyril of Jerusalem says in his Third Catechetical Lecture, chapter 10: “If someone does not receive baptism, he is not saved, except for martyrs, who receive the Kingdom even without water (that is, without water baptism). When the Savior saved the world through the Cross, and when His side was pierced, He released blood and water, so that those who are baptized during times of persecution might be baptized with His blood. The Savior calls martyrdom baptism, for He says: [quotation omitted in the Romanian text].”
(Mark 10:38).
“The martyrs made their confession of faith, becoming a spectacle to the world, to angels, and to men.”
(1 Corinthians 4:9).
The Sixth Ecumenical Council, in Canon 83, states:
“The dead cannot be baptized, just as they cannot be given Holy Communion.”
"Therefore, aborted children, those born prematurely, those lost involuntarily through miscarriage, or those who die immediately after birth without receiving baptism cannot under any circumstances be baptized after death, because they are no longer alive. Neither can they be commemorated in the church, because they are unbaptized and have no names. They are not members of the Church of Christ."
St. Cleopa Ilie and Ioanichie Bălan, Lumina și faptele credinței: Convorbiri duhovnicești între Părintele Cleopa Ilie și Părintele Ioanichie Bălan, convorbirea a V-a, „Despre căsătorie, datoriile soților și copiilor,” întrebarea 144
A few things here, there was two ideas of baptism of desire, also:
„se pot considera părtași la botezul dorinței [...] sau prin analogie cu vindecările făcute de Iisus Hristos la rugăciunile părinților sau ale prietenilor.”
Cleopa does not say that the child is sacramentally baptized through the parent's faith. One possible interpretation is that he means the child may participate in the benefits of divine mercy, analogously to how Christ healed children in response to the intercessions of their parents (which we will show why)
Pr. Dr. Lucian Petroaia:
„În popor există o tradiție (greșită, într-adevăr!), conform căreia mama care a încercat să își boteze pruncul, dar nu a reușit din motive bine întemeiate, acel prunc ar putea fi socotit a fi primit botezul prin dorința sau prin credința mamei, cu care el este una.”
“Among the people there is a tradition (erroneous, indeed!) according to which a mother who attempted to baptize her child, but was unable to do so for justifiable reasons, could have that child considered to have received baptism through the mother's desire or faith, with whom the child is one.”
„Această tradiție [...] nu poate suplini slujba Botezului pentru prunc, întrucât «Botezul dorinței» este altceva decât se susține aici [...] iar «Botezul prin credința celuilalt» nu există în teologia creștină.”
“This tradition [...] cannot substitute for the baptismal service for the child, because ‘baptism of desire’ is something other than what is being asserted here [...] and ‘baptism through the faith of another’ does not exist in Christian theology.”
Now, Lucian himself says he did not teach this, Cleopa himself got it from Archimandrite Nicodim Sachelarie.
On page 119, Petroaia discusses the popular belief that a mother can supply baptism for an unbaptized child through her own faith and desire:
“The ‘baptism of desire’ is something different than what is claimed here.”
And
“‘Baptism by the faith of another’ does not exist in Christian theology.”
“In connection with this, the hieromonk Nicodim Sachelarie considers: ‘Children who die unbaptized for reasons beyond the control of their parents or the priest may be considered partakers of the baptism of desire, as are the righteous of the Old Testament or by analogy with the healings of Jesus at the request of parents and friends [...]’”
(Pravila bisericească, third edition, Editura Valea Plopului, 1999, paragraph 181, pp. 44–45.)
“Father Ilie Cleopa also expressed himself at one point concerning the fact that these infants do not go to torment. When questioned about this mystery, he answered that these infants ‘neither suffer torment nor rejoice, neither do they remain in darkness nor in light,’ but rather ‘they remain in the northern part of heaven, where there is a kind of mist, like the morning dew, when it has not yet become light.’”
(Ne vorbește Părintele Cleopa, vol. III, Editura Episcopiei Romanului, 2nd edition, 2001, p. 139.)
“This is another way of expressing a more subtle and more figurative saying attributed to St. Gregory of Nyssa, that these infants ‘rest in the radiance of the morning star,’ or the theological formulation, ‘Unbaptized infants who die do not partake of the light, but are honored with repose,’ which circulates among theological seminaries in the discipline of dogmatics when an explanation is sought for the state of infants belonging to this category.”
We see this in his other works, as well:
“Take heed, brethren, for the one who performs an abortion or otherwise hinders the birth of children is not just a murderer once, but twice over. The one who kills a baptized person can only kill their body, but if that person stood in the right faith and virtues, their soul will remain alive forever, for it passes from death into life. But those who kill children before Divine Baptism are twice murderers, for they deprive the children not only of their bodies but also of their souls’ eternal bliss, according to the testimony of the Savior, which states: “He who believes and is baptized will be saved; but he who does not believe will be condemned” (Mark 16:16).”
Archimandrite St. Cleopa Ilie of Sihastria, “Homily on the Nativity of the Theotokos”
134. What needs to be known about Baptism?
Baptism washes away at once two sins with which a child is born, that is, both original sin and the sin of conception in the womb. Indeed conception is also considered a sin, according to the word of Psalm 50, which says: For behold I was conceived in iniquities; and in sins did my mother conceive me. Therefore, children must be baptized...
St. Cleopa Ilie, Conversations with Father Joannicius
(This is all taken from Pr. Dr. Lucian Petroaia, “Problema înmormântării pruncilor nebotezați în Biserica Ortodoxă,” Glasul Bisericii 70, nos. 7–12 (2011): 232)
He says at the start, the following:
"According to Orthodox theology, unbaptized infants, as bearers of original sin, cannot enter the Kingdom of God; however, since they have no personal sins, they are spared eternal torments. Their salvation remains entirely in the care, judgment, and mercy of God. Therefore, it cannot be definitively asserted that, upon death, they are lost into nothingness."
We will now show the full passage on Baptism of Desire:
"Among the people there exists a tradition (erroneous, indeed!) according to which a mother who attempted to have her infant baptized but was unable to do so for legitimate reasons may consider that infant to have received baptism through the mother's desire or faith, with which the infant is one. This tradition emphasizes the essential unity between mother and infant and the mother's concern for her child, but it cannot substitute for the actual service of Baptism for the infant, since “Baptism of desire” is something different from what is being asserted here. “Baptism of necessity” or “emergency baptism”, recognized and frequently employed by the Church, but on the condition that the service is completed after the danger has passed, was not performed. And “Baptism through another person's faith” does not exist in Christian theology.
It is also incorrect for certain theologians to invoke “Baptism of blood,” arguing that unbaptized infants who die in accidents may be considered Christians through the suffering of their unjust and untimely deaths."
So, as we see, 1, he did not teach it, 2, he did not teach what you say he taught, since for some reason, you just went to doxologia(.)ro and did not study even a little bit of what you sent in your quote, you are very uneducated and dishonest. This book by Lucian was published under the oversight of † Daniel, Patriarch of Romania, Archbishop of Bucharest and Metropolitan of Muntenia and Dobrogea. † Casian, Archbishop of the Lower Danube, † Nifon of Târgoviște, and † Teodosie of Tomis.
According to ALL of the contemporary historians such as Chalkokondyles, Phrantzes, and Doukas, Constantinople was in communion with Rome when it fell, and had uniate metropolitans encouraging its troops before the final siege🧵
Even though many in the populace resented the union, they were powerless to stop it. The emperor went along with it, and allowed the exiled unionist patriarch to be included in the dyptichs along with the Pope.
Doukas, "Decline and Fall of the Bzyatine Empire," cap. XXXVI.
1
10
233






















