Keima Payton (@KeimaPayton) header
Keima Payton (@KeimaPayton) profile picture

Criminal Defence Solicitor & HCA Payton's Solicitors 0207 405 1999

London
Joined March 2009
Photo by Keima Payton (@KeimaPayton)Photo by Keima Payton (@KeimaPayton)Photo by Keima Payton (@KeimaPayton)Photo by Keima Payton (@KeimaPayton)Photo by Keima Payton (@KeimaPayton)Photo by Keima Payton (@KeimaPayton)Photo by Keima Payton (@KeimaPayton)Photo by Keima Payton (@KeimaPayton)Photo by Keima Payton (@KeimaPayton)Photo by Keima Payton (@KeimaPayton)
Finally reopening commissions after sadly losing Mom in August 24 . She was my number 1 fan , and it’s taken me a long time to try to readjust to life without her . I know she would want me to carry on with what I loved - pleas spread the word . Beth xx
4
4
232
Keima Payton retweeted
A sitting judge says: Sir Stephen Mitchell is correct when he says that the restriction of jury trials will fail to cut the staggering backlog of crown court cases (“Judges are being silenced on vandalism of curbing jury trials”, Apr 26). Joanna Korner KC The Hague, Netherlands
3
44
3
99
5,869
Keima Payton retweeted
Bottarelli [2026] 𝐄𝐖𝐂𝐀 𝐂𝐫𝐢𝐦 383 The Court of Appeal dismissed Matteo Bottarelli’s appeal against conviction for attempted murder and refused leave to appeal his 30-year sentence, save that it corrected the disposal on two alternative counts by ordering them to lie on file. Bottarelli had pleaded guilty to two counts of wounding with intent, affray, and possession of an offensive weapon, but was tried on counts including three attempted murders. The attacks took place at Central Middlesex Hospital in June 2023, where he assaulted three colleagues using a mattock and a scalpel. His case on appeal was that the trial judge had failed adequately to direct the jury on voluntary intoxication when considering specific intent for attempted murder. The Court of Appeal accepted the legal principles on intoxication in specific intent offences, including those discussed in R v Sheehan and Moore (1974) 60 Cr App R 308 and R v Aidid [2021] EWCA Crim 581. However, the court held that, on the facts, no further intoxication direction was required because Bottarelli had clearly accepted in his guilty pleas and defence statements that he knew what he was doing and intended to cause really serious harm. The court found there was no real evidence that intoxication prevented him from forming the intent required for attempted murder. In any event, even if a more explicit direction had been appropriate, the omission did not render the convictions unsafe. On sentence, the court held that the judge had properly considered the psychiatric evidence, including his addiction and likely underlying psychotic illness, and that the 30-year sentence was not manifestly excessive. The only correction made was procedural: on the alternative counts of wounding with intent, the trial judge should have ordered them to lie on file rather than imposing “no separate penalty”, following R v Butler [2023] EWCA Crim 676. crimeline.co.uk/bottarelli-2…
1
1
1,650
Keima Payton retweeted
Jury trials under threat? The Courts and Tribunals Bill explained – Parliament Matters podcast, Episode 136 crimeline.co.uk/jury-trials-…
1
498
Keima Payton retweeted
Yet another one. Until prisoner governors are sent to jail for contempt they will just continue to ignore clear laws. crimeline.co.uk/jayden-gambr…
3
1
5
2,620
Keima Payton retweeted
If you think the proposed curtailing of right to a jury is "helping victims" Sir Alan Bates would have had his fate decided by a Magistrate. He would have had no right to appeal. We would never have known of the Post Office scandal.
26
596
8
1,554
16,612
Keima Payton retweeted
Look at the smirking imbeciles on the other side of this masterclass in oratory, giggling at a demonstration of an ability none of them could ever hope to possess. This is why they dismiss and undermine the world class justice system we once had. Because it was beyond them.
It’s a lengthy but this is magnificent from @Geoffrey_cox on the importance of jury trials. A true orator among giggling simpletons
39
290
8
1,566
25,214
I love this post. Read it! It makes sense, and it's amusing, but also terrifying! Losing jury trials scares me and every single criminal lawyer I know!
Suggesting that Judges decide verdicts in thousands of cases is Peak Starmer. Lawyer MPs recommending that other lawyers decide things under the leadership of a lawyer leader. Lawyers, lawyers, lawyers. Above ordinary people. Well, let me tell you a secret about lawyers… 🧵
2
209
Keima Payton retweeted
Crown Courts have a backlog of 80,000 cases because the justice system has been underfunded for decades. Not because people have the right to a jury trial.
21
445
6
1,424
26,157
Keima Payton retweeted
As ever, Joanne makes the point more eloquently & with far more class than I could achieve. Please read But know this as you do: in 24 years at the Bar, I’ve overturned 3 jury convictions on appeal In my first 2 years, I overturned 14 magistrates convictions Which seems safer?
Your local friendly criminal barrister here! 👋 I need you to know that anything up to a three year prison sentence imposed without a jury trial is really not the same thing as scraping your knee without seeing a consultant.
7
135
2
445
15,662
Keima Payton retweeted
Tolerating always turns to resentment. At first, you call it patience, then love. But what it really is, is self-abandonment. Every time you swallow a boundary, excuse a pattern, or silence your discomfort, something inside you keeps score. And eventually, the bill comes due.
79
9,004
318
32,940
618,414
🚨 Judge Only Trials 🚨 The law of unintended (👀) consequences. An old-fashioned long thread. And a prediction. 👇🏼🪡 🧵
15
175
23
390
126,399
No MP should be allowed to vote on the government’s plan to abolish trial by jury in thousands of cases until and unless they have read this thread. 👇
🚨 Judge Only Trials 🚨 The law of unintended (👀) consequences. An old-fashioned long thread. And a prediction. 👇🏼🪡 🧵
5
167
4
423
42,625
Keima Payton retweeted
10 days till MPs vote to remove the right to trial by jury. 10 days till MPs vote for serious and complex trials to be dealt with by Magistrates in just 4 hours.
Just like magic, the work will disappear! The Impact Assessment for the Courts Bill 2026 claims that the Magistrates' Courts will be able to complete cases THREE TIMES FASTER than the Crown Court. It assumes that work which is currently taking 24,000 sitting days in the Crown Court, staffed by professional judges, will be completed within 8,500 sitting days in the Magistrates' Court, staffed by volunteer magistrates. How can that be so? Well, the IA goes on to say that it is assumed that magistrates will be able to complete the more serious and complex trials which would now been allocated to them within an average of 4 hours. Guilty pleas will take 30 minutes. So under this new system a defendant will have 4 hours to challenge the case against them (including time for resolving applications such as disclosure, bad character, hearsay, s.41 etc), when facing a prison sentence of 18 months or 2 years. Either this is going to be rough justice, or the assumptions in the IA are deeply flawed.
8
160
4
280
40,621
Keima Payton retweeted
Just like magic, the work will disappear! The Impact Assessment for the Courts Bill 2026 claims that the Magistrates' Courts will be able to complete cases THREE TIMES FASTER than the Crown Court. It assumes that work which is currently taking 24,000 sitting days in the Crown Court, staffed by professional judges, will be completed within 8,500 sitting days in the Magistrates' Court, staffed by volunteer magistrates. How can that be so? Well, the IA goes on to say that it is assumed that magistrates will be able to complete the more serious and complex trials which would now been allocated to them within an average of 4 hours. Guilty pleas will take 30 minutes. So under this new system a defendant will have 4 hours to challenge the case against them (including time for resolving applications such as disclosure, bad character, hearsay, s.41 etc), when facing a prison sentence of 18 months or 2 years. Either this is going to be rough justice, or the assumptions in the IA are deeply flawed.
11
72
5
109
29,461
When the Lady Chief Justice wisely says that changes should be considered and thought through carefully, I imagine she wasn't referring to the Government irresponsibly ramming a 100 page bill to abolish jury trial through the commons so quickly MPs hardly have time to read it.
24
1
66
2,250
Keima Payton retweeted
It’s not just juries. Wow. s.41 YJCEA 1999 is to apply to ANY offence (see clause 8). Bonkers. Think of all that extra work. It is criminal that they are trying to rush this stuff through.
One upshot of Labour’s proposal for jury trials is that a first-time suspect might be denied a jury whereas a hardened criminal with 20 previous convictions accused of *exactly the same thing* might get a jury because *his* sentence would be 3 years+. Well done everybody! 👏
3
23
1
46
5,275
Keima Payton retweeted
The long awaited impact assessment on proposed changes to Jury Trials is here assets.publishing.service.go… This document fails on page 2 because the policy objectives are about speed, efficiency etc, and NOT securing a fair trial for serious offences.
4
39
1
105
3,192
One upshot of Labour’s proposal for jury trials is that a first-time suspect might be denied a jury whereas a hardened criminal with 20 previous convictions accused of *exactly the same thing* might get a jury because *his* sentence would be 3 years+. Well done everybody! 👏
13
136
9
338
34,727