Merger Monkey (@LeveredMonkey) header
Merger Monkey (@LeveredMonkey) profile picture
New York, USA
Joined August 2020
Photo by Merger Monkey (@LeveredMonkey)Photo by Merger Monkey (@LeveredMonkey)Photo by Merger Monkey (@LeveredMonkey)Photo by Merger Monkey (@LeveredMonkey)Photo by Merger Monkey (@LeveredMonkey)Photo by Merger Monkey (@LeveredMonkey)Photo by Merger Monkey (@LeveredMonkey)Photo by Merger Monkey (@LeveredMonkey)Photo by Merger Monkey (@LeveredMonkey)Photo by Merger Monkey (@LeveredMonkey)
So what would you do as the Saudi oil minister? Let me share the proper assessment for once by one of the best oil market analysts globally - Lakshmi Sreekumar from Capital One. Enjoy it "We have long maintained that OPEC+ lost the plot in Oct 2022. They started on a warpath against Central Banks who were trying to soften demand to bring inflation under control, which resulted in two poor, but natural outcomes that we predicted in late 2022, and it took zero effort to predict it: (1) Higher global supply and (2) Lower global demand. Saudi Arabia giving up market share in July 2023 was our first warning that they were painting themselves into a difficult corner, one, where they only end up having "fair weather friends". You could have learned better from Escobar, that giving up market share is ALWAYS, ALWAYS a bad option, because you don't control the demand prong of balance. These policy error-hens have now come home to roost. I never thought I would say this, but I do feel bad for Saudi Arabia. If they increase supply as planned into Q4 2024, they would still produce 214 KBPD LESS crude than they produced in 2020, a Covid year. They did all the right things on paper for the industry at large. Their own OPEC+ compadres, Non-OPEC+, everyone took advantage of their restraint. If you look around and see supply growth globally, you should at least take a moment to thank Saudi Arabia for sacrificing their own economy, with 4 consecutive Qs of negative growth, running massive deficits (for their economy size) and scaling back on key development projects like Neom that would change the future direction of the country. The time has now come for Saudi Arabia to take back market share. And taking back market share does not transpire easily without lower prices. If they want to resolve the market share issue, Saudi Arabia is confronted with two choices: Pick fights with cheaters or threaten unilateral production hikes and pave the way for an Angola-like exit of countries like UAE and Iraq. I would remind everyone that at the June 2023 OPEC meeting is when the WAF oil ministers held ABS's hands and walked along the corridor in a daisy chain-like uncomfortable formation to "show the world what OPEC solidarity looks like", not even 5 months later, Angola said Adios. OR Keep the face of OPEC+ untainted and pretend that they are raising supply "as planned" and "OPEC+ remains as solid as ever", and force Non-OPEC supply down via price, this also forces higher compliance in the group. If Saudi Arabia is interested in taking back market share, which they should at the point or there are much bigger issues down the road waiting for them, then, I would argue that now is the PERFECT time for consortium to raise supply, as we step into seasonal slowdown, economic slowdown, taking the pain for 1 or 2 quarters to (a) Regain market share and (b) Be able to regain the driver's seat of the supply prong of the balance and of price. This is what they should have done in April 2023, and they would have synced up with Central Bank policy as well as the macro environment, and this issue would be largely solved into 2025 and the Fed starts cutting rates. As I have said before, balances do not support this increase so I am not speaking from my own perspective here, I am speaking from OPEC's perspective but sometimes the strategy is less about balances and more about long term goals. But why did this happen in the first place, surely they didn't just give up market share out of the goodness of their heart alone? Not really. I think it was an "informed" decision, just informed by garbage analysis. In late 2022 and early 2023 there were dishonest factions of the oil analyst community that knowingly or unknowingly fed, and have continued to feed the Saudis and other OPEC members bad information. The reality is that artificially holding prices up against the fundamental balancing agents of supply and demand, into a restrictive monetary policy environment has ramification and into an election year not just in the US, but globally means you get a plethora of agents to conspire against you as well on multiple fronts. Some of the tropes that were floated to the OPEC+ consortium (and our clients in the US, who were entirely too smart to believe any of it...this is why our E&Ps are top in class, they rely on data not conjecture, they remain well hedged and well managed!) Charts below for each of the points. "The death of the Permian is imminent" and "US supply will peak in 2023" NOPE. US supply put up impressive gains in 2023. US liquids grew 7.6% y/y in 2023. Oil grew 7% y/y. At current pace, liquids will grow 3.4% y/y in 2024 and growth continues into 2025 as well. "Oil demand is completely price inelastic" WRONG Oil demand is (a) NOT price inelastic and (b) responds to lag effects of restrictive monetary policy "Compliance in OPEC+ cuts will be high because countries cannot ramp up" and "We are going to get into supply compliance" - heard from UAE, Iraq, Kazakhstan, Russia etc. since 2023. Not at all. Supply compliance in OPEC+ is inversely correlated to price; "Russia production is going to 0 because of low international investment" NOPE. Russian production has been so stable, that even the Saudis and Emiratis had to privately plead with them to reduce supply. Russian production will have an impact as the war continues, but the real impact will likely not be felt until 2026, assuming the conflict continues. "Iran cannot export more due to secondary sanctions" Yeah, about that. Iran is exporting the most it ever has since 2018. Nearly everyone got Iran wrong, and this is why I keep stressing that your sources on Persian Gulf policy is very important. Even the chihuahua on the street has an opinion on this, but are you going to trade on his views? Absolutely not. "China will recover a second time" Sadly, Chinese demand is negative y/y, and continues down this path UNLESS the CCP unleashes direct stimulus to the consumer "War means we lose all the oil in the world" We haven't seen any effects yet, what we have see is that war has meant we have created more volatility in the market, again propelling higher supply and compelling lower demand; "Oil inventories are what matter" NOPE. Product demand & inventories are what matters. Always, always, always focus on product and focus on cracks. The real case of Penny wise, Pound foolish: Cracks being weak is NOT just a function of demand alone. It has gotten worse, not better in the refining world. If we look at custom compound margins, what refiners actually make, not just a simplistic formula of 3:2:1. Compound margins are ~ $7.00/BBL in the US, Europe is under $4/BBL, Asia is under $5.50/BBL. Comparatively, in Aug 20203, these numbers were $24.00/BBL in the US, $18.00/BBL in Europe and $17.00/BBL in Asia. Weighted average global Compound margins currently a 1/3rd of what it was at the same time last year. And what is driving this? Demand is half the problem, but not the whole problem. There are also supply issues with higher refinery runs coming from generally crack-agnostic producing countries, aka OPEC countries. Now I am not saying they all run on negative cracks, but if it's positive they will run it. I present to you the two-faced-ness of OPEC+. So let's see who is eating whose refining margin lunches (August levels): • Iraq running ~+196 KBPD y/y • Iran running ~+173 KBPD y/y • Kuwait running ~+ 170 KBPD y/y • ME/Persian Gulf overall is up ~+500 KBPD y/y...you would think if OPEC+ wanted to help itself, and it knows where its bread is ultimately buttered, it would protect global refinery margins more than protecting DFLs and CFDs with silly OSP games and oh don't anyone forget the Saudi "clandestine export cuts in June" in a hail mary effort to support prices. Penny wise, severely Pound foolish! • Dangote was running as high as 356 KBPD y/y in June, it tapered off to under ~+ 341 KBPD y/y Meanwhile.... • China is down -1.2 MBPD y/y • OECD Americas are down slightly -50 KBPD y/y • OECD Europe is down slightly -110 KBPD y/y • OECD Asia Pacific is down massively by 400 KBPD y/y I have no idea what OPEC will or won't do for sure. But my view is that this is the time for OPEC+, really Saudi Arabia, to revisit the policy and get off the "demand weakness, cheating and supply growth are all TRANSITORY" wagon and do what is best for them, finally. It is time to STOP BLAMING ALGOS and take control of market share, if they want to set up for medium and longer term success. If they get flustered and lose their vision and continue to keep these cuts in place, it will be a MUCH BIGGER WORLD OF PAIN for them into 2025. So what's next then Lakshmi? What do you think of price and outcomes? This remains a trader's market and not an investor's market. I am just going to repeat exactly what I wrote in my Balances note from Aug 22nd. There has to be a further wash out on prices, and the US is still expanding albeit at a much slower rate, so the real pain trade still hasn't hit us yet. While I would normally say we are heading to the bottom end of the intervention collar here and this looks oversold and could be a great play on the bottom range, this is NOT the time, in the part of the cycle where we are to load up on spot commodities, because spot commodities are usually the last to fall into any serious economic correction. Yes you will get your positioning inspired dead cat bounce, but unless there are extenuating circumstances on the supply side, every dead cat bounce is a sell in this regime. Historically risk asset sell offs BEGIN after the first Fed Rate cut following a hiking cycle. While this may not make sense fundamentally, this is how macro regimes work and it is built into the algosphere and every CTA model. We are at the cusp of sentiment driven regime change, it is not the time to get cute and have a thousand expressions of the same trade with a bunch of derivatives on top of it, remember negative gamma cuts both ways. I am not inclined to catch falling knives, and this is an expression of risk management prudence vs fundamental view, in that fundamentals in oil are weak (as balances show), but not terrible. Fundamentally, we think fair value for Brent remains at ~78.50 USD/BBL. There will be a sweet time to load up on spot commodities, and that time comes AFTER the first slew of rate cuts from the Fed, which gives the PBOC and CCP a potential green flag to unleash direct stimulus to consumer (we they have to see if they will actually bite, it is not a sure thing like it is in the US). But we are simply not there yet from a structural supportive trend up and to the right. You can of course continue to play the intervention collar but that requires a lot of baby sitting and extremely cautious risk management. I know this is a charged topic and none of this is written to elicit any kind of emotion from any of you, because data doesn't have emotions. Some of you will be tempted to counter a lot of what I have said with "But Saudis will win in the end", "US production is going to zero", "But Matt Simmons said...". I do agree with some of you that the Saudis can win in the end, IF AND ONLY IF they make the correct policy adjustments at this most opportune time. However, I am not going to engage in the hyperbole of the Ghawar field imploding or the imminent death of the Permian using EIA charts of completions, declines and DUC counts. Oil is a global market. Wake up from those old tropes and consider maybe the problem is not the data, the problem is self-censorship of data that suit your own biases and the interpretation of it, woven by people who want you to conform to their thinking so you can stay on their hook and continue to send them a monthly check for absolute garbage of analysis. I think this is what has happened to our industry, there is 0.001% of original thought and the rest is about who can outcompete the rest of the herd in calling for $200, $300, $500 oil or $30, $20, $10 oil. Broad swathes of analytics in our field, particularly oil, has become the secondary derivative of a meme and I am very sad about it.
13
117
39
630
114,762
Bill promising appreciation? He’s gone full SBF
If you like watches, check out @Bremont. They are handsome, rugged, engineering marvels that will appreciate in value over generations. About 30% of sales to military and special forces teams around the world. A best kept secret in the watch world, but not for long.
1
685
Merger Monkey retweeted
Replying to @TashaARK
So your $TSLA ā€œBear Caseā€ remains 10M vehicle units sold in 2026? That is almost a 70% CAGR in units from 2022’s 1.3M figure. And over 2x the 4Q Y/Y growth rate of 31%. Does that really seem reasonable as a ā€œBear Caseā€ to you, at this point? @CathieDWood
17
13
3
322
30,833
Elon really wants Trump back on Twitter
1
Replying to @HedgeyeComm
I think he has a pretty impossible task coming in towards the end of Avengers and having to build Disney+ along with figuring out how to monetize Espn better. On top of having a shareholder base that’s switching out.. watch Iger come in after the groundwork’s set up and take over
4
1
7
I'm creating a document of everything $GEOFF has ever written on investing in one document so people can Ctrl-F whatever topic they want. I'm only 6 years in and the document is already 560 pages with 244,986 words... šŸ˜… 11 more years to go.
19
20
2
245
Merger Monkey retweeted
pretty rich coming from a VC
Does anyone still work?
3
4
95
Merger Monkey retweeted
A ā€œrazorā€ is a rule of thumb that simplifies decision making. The most powerful razors I’ve found:
1,216
17,186
2,106
83,113
Merger Monkey retweeted
"Oil in the ground that you're not producing is a national treasure... Imported oil is not your enemy, it’s your friend." Charlie Munger.
1
10
9
The most entertaining outcome is @elonmusk being forced to acquire $TWTR
Replying to @BillyM2k
The most entertaining outcome is the most likely
ā€œOur peers are trading shares at the short end of the equity yield curve where the competition is the greatest, and we are investing at the long end where competition is the least. We respond to completely different stimuli.ā€
ā€œThe underlying fundamentalsā€
Ok, bitcoin under 20k feels like an over-rotation. The underlying fundamentals, adoption, and infrastructure have never been stronger. We saw the irrational top. This feels irrational in the other direction.
2
30-year yield took out the 2018 closing high today only to powerfully reverse by 25 bp. This action is called a ā€œthrow overā€ and often marks an important trend reversal.
136
297
58
2,213
Merger Monkey retweeted
China said its giant Sky Eye telescope may have picked up signs of alien civilizations, according to a report by the state-backed Science and Technology Daily, which then appeared to have deleted the report and posts about the discovery trib.al/Whritw4
51
156
104
407
He never misses
notice rates going down.. bond people know this is deflationary
ā€œThis piece allows anyone to absorb all of Gurley’s knowledge bombs in the fraction of the time it took me to do it. I hope this piece brings you as much value as it did to me.ā€ @marketplunger1 on Bill Gurley macro-ops.com/the-bill-gurle…
3
13
When your Chief Legal Officers uses the term FUD … 🚩
Replying to @iampaulgrewal
But you may have heard about a certain disclosure in our recent 10Q and FUD around this led to some genuine concern for our customers. So fashion faux pas be damned; we’ve added belts to our suspenders. Here’s how: šŸ‘‡
The Story of Zales This is my account of the story at Zale Corporation from the fall of 2007 to the spring of 2011. This is my memory of the events that at least in part define the investor I am today. This is a complete discussion, at least from a financial perspective.
46
149
55
1,353