Lisa Marchiano (@LisaMarchiano) header
Lisa Marchiano (@LisaMarchiano) profile picture

Writer, Jungian analyst, and podcaster @ThisJungianLife.

Philadelphia, PA
Joined September 2015
Photo by Lisa Marchiano (@LisaMarchiano)Photo by Lisa Marchiano (@LisaMarchiano)Photo by Lisa Marchiano (@LisaMarchiano)Photo by Lisa Marchiano (@LisaMarchiano)Photo by Lisa Marchiano (@LisaMarchiano)Photo by Lisa Marchiano (@LisaMarchiano)Photo by Lisa Marchiano (@LisaMarchiano)Photo by Lisa Marchiano (@LisaMarchiano)Photo by Lisa Marchiano (@LisaMarchiano)Photo by Lisa Marchiano (@LisaMarchiano)
The paperback edition of Dream Wise is out on June 9! a.co/d/0fXlDkiC
1
1
1
962
The more that people are self-righteous and never live their shadow side, the more they project it and see others as the evildoers. The righteous live in a constant state of righteous indignation, hunting down their own shadow in the form of the outer person.~ML von Franz
13
125
11
573
14,537
Lisa Marchiano retweeted
The spiral of silence is a theory of public opinion developed by German political scientist Elisabeth Noelle-Neumann in the 1970s. It describes how people tend to remain silent when they believe their views are in the minority, which in turn makes the majority view appear even stronger and further discourages dissent. Core idea People constantly scan their social environment (through media, conversations, and observation) to gauge which opinions are dominant or gaining strength. Those who feel their view is on the rise or already majority are more willing to speak out. Those who perceive their view as losing ground or minority become more reluctant to express it, fearing social isolation. This silence makes the minority position seem even smaller, reinforcing the spiral. Noelle-Neumann called this the “spiral of silence.” The fear of isolation is the key psychological driver. Humans are social animals who monitor the “climate of opinion” to avoid being rejected or ostracized. Key mechanisms •Quasi-statistical sense: People develop an intuitive sense of the distribution of opinions in society, largely shaped by media. •Willingness to speak out: Strongly influenced by the perceived trend (which side is winning) rather than just the absolute majority. •Media’s role: Mass media are especially powerful because they can present a particular view as the majority or as the direction of the future, even if it is not yet so in reality. This can create a “silent majority” or amplify a vocal minority. •Hard cores: There are always small groups (the “hard cores”) who will speak out regardless of isolation. They can break the spiral if they gain enough visibility. Classic conditions The theory works best when: •The issue is morally or emotionally charged. •There is a clear perception of a dominant opinion. •Social isolation has real costs. •Media coverage is relatively uniform or strongly framed in one direction. Evidence and examples Noelle-Neumann tested the theory extensively in Germany, especially around political issues. Later research has found support in various contexts (e.g., environmental issues, political correctness debates, wartime public opinion). Classic illustrations include: •People underestimating support for certain policies or candidates because dissenters stay quiet. •Rapid shifts in expressed opinion once a new “climate” is perceived (the spiral can reverse). Criticisms and limitations •Individual differences: Not everyone fears isolation equally. Personality, education, and strength of conviction matter. •Social media: The theory was developed for mass media. Online spaces can create “echo chambers” or allow minority views to find communities, sometimes weakening the spiral or creating multiple competing spirals. •Pluralistic ignorance: Related but distinct — people can misperceive the majority opinion. The spiral of silence focuses more on the dynamic of speaking vs. remaining silent. •Empirical mixed results: Some studies strongly support it; others find weaker effects depending on the issue and culture. Connection to the earlier discussion In the Serbian context we discussed (two years of agenda-setting around corruption, the Novi Sad canopy collapse, and the student protests leading to a “referendum atmosphere”), the spiral of silence is relevant in both directions: •For a long time, fear of isolation or professional/social costs may have kept many people quiet about systemic problems despite private dissatisfaction. •Once protests became large and visible (especially after 2024–2025), the perceived climate shifted. More people felt it was safe or even socially rewarded to express opposition, accelerating the spiral in the opposite direction and contributing to the binary “for or against” atmosphere. The theory helps explain why public opinion can appear more unified than it actually is, and why it can shift relatively quickly once the climate of opinion changes.
3
47
6
158
8,669
Lisa Marchiano retweeted
R.D. Laing once said there are three things human beings are afraid of: death, other people, and their own minds. — Michael Pollan, How to Change Your Mind
2
5
52
1,438
Lisa Marchiano retweeted
Everything that happens to us, properly understood, leads us back to ourselves; it is as though there were some unconscious guidance whose aim it is to deliver us from all ties and all dependence and make us dependent on ourselves. — Carl G. Jung, Letters Vol 1
2
30
187
2,987
✍️ This week’s essay (2 min read) ❝ A case formulation links a patient’s presenting or surface problems to the psychological processes that underlie them. These underlying processes then become the focus of treatment. Read free here👇 jonathanshedler.substack.com…
2
18
2
97
11,005
When enough individuals are carriers of the “consciousness of wholeness,” the world itself will become whole. ~ Edward Edinger
4
20
3
128
2,895
The subtext of most relationship is dependency, rather than mutual support of the independence of each party.~James Hollis
1
7
1
105
2,584
Lisa Marchiano retweeted
James Hollis on being 'in service to the mystery'.
1
42
1
224
4,148
A quote @LisaMarchiano shared in this week's podcast episode with Gary Lachman, in which we discuss searching for meaning amidst the world's chaos.  🎧 Find the episode wherever you get your podcasts.
1
1
11
500
Lisa Marchiano retweeted
Had a stimulating chat about assisted death with the wonderful @LisaMarchiano on her new podcast, Cafe Jung cafejung.substack.com/p/the-…
6
24
5,806
More than 50 years ago, the great Paul Meehl wrote “Why I Do Not Attend Case Conferences.” Every serious psychologist knew and quoted it. It was a masterclass in *how to think.* It catalogued common fallacies among mental health professionals. He named one “the spun-glass theory of the mind.” He wrote: “This is the doctrine that the human organism is constituted of such frail material, is of such exquisite psychological delicacy, that rather minor, garden-variety frustrations, deprivations, criticisms, rejections, or failure experiences are likely to play the causative role of major traumas.” This was half a century ago. Some in the mental health professions have no historical memory. They do not build on established knowledge or learn from past mistakes. They don’t just repeat them, they double and triple down on them. The spun-glass fallacy is now endemic in therapy culture. Therapists not only embrace it, they act like it’s a moral virtue. Paul Meehl addressed this in his paper too. More than half a century ago. Our intellectual forebears are rolling in their graves. source: meehl.umn.edu/sites/meehl.um…
13
69
6
413
27,364
Jung said, "Every part of us we do not love will regress and become more primitive." He didn't say, "Indulge it," or even, "Indulge in it." He said, "Accept that part," and he's right to say that." ~Robert Bly, A Little Book on the Human Shadow
4
31
255
3,871
Lisa Marchiano retweeted
🎭 Join ACAP's Fall Theater Conference featuring Terry Johnson's Hysteria, psychoanalysis, & discussion. Nov 1, Montclair, NJ. Register: ow.ly/5kmb50ZQMUq #Psychoanalysis #Psychotherapy #Freud #Hysteria #TheaterAndPsychology #ContinuingEducation #NAAP #ACAP #BGSPNJ
1
1
1
74
Lisa Marchiano retweeted
This is excellent from Jungian, Daryl Sharp on how our persona can easily become a trap.
18
70
1,410
Lisa Marchiano retweeted
New Book Now Shipping! Michael Meade's new book "The Heart of Transformation" explores how transformation is the way of the world, the mystery at the heart of each soul, and may be the only way out of the troubled times in which we live. PURCHASE: store.mosaicvoices.org/produ…
2
2
6
275
🌥️ ACTIVE IMAGINATION: Join us for a free live seminar exploring one of Jung's most important contributions.  With active imagination, we can use our bodies and enter an altered state to have a deeper experience, instead of just thinking harder and harder about our problems.
2
2
7
498
Lisa Marchiano retweeted
For those interested in the teachings of Jungian, Marion Woodman, her audio 'Addiction to Perfection' workshop [5 hours 25 minutes] is currently free to download this month [September 2026] from BetterListen! Link is in the post below.
7
9
3
112
4,294
We shared these beautiful words from Rilke's Letters to a Young Poet in this week's podcast episode, The Princess Who Changed Her Fate: How to Negotiate with Destiny.  🎧 Find the episode wherever you get your podcasts.
1
2
9
447
Lisa Marchiano retweeted
"... 𝘸𝘦 𝘢𝘳𝘦 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘢𝘯𝘤𝘦𝘴𝘵𝘰𝘳𝘴 𝘰𝘧 𝘢𝘯 𝘢𝘨𝘦 𝘵𝘰 𝘤𝘰𝘮𝘦". Fabulous quote from Joseph Campbell.
40
4
155
2,846
Lisa Marchiano retweeted
Jung wrote this in a 1959 letter about depression. What stands out to me is that he doesn't suggest immediately escaping the darkness. He suggests going deeper into it, because something in it may be trying to reach consciousness. “No half-measures or half-heartedness.” - Carl Jung
10
199
24
1,307
64,959