Mark Gibb (@MarkDGibb) header
Mark Gibb (@MarkDGibb) profile picture

Libertarian. Lover of pearl-clutching. Equal opportunity president hater. Aerospace Engineer in the real world. Iowa State University. Catholic.

Joined October 2013
Photo by Mark Gibb (@MarkDGibb)Photo by Mark Gibb (@MarkDGibb)Photo by Mark Gibb (@MarkDGibb)Photo by Mark Gibb (@MarkDGibb)Photo by Mark Gibb (@MarkDGibb)Photo by Mark Gibb (@MarkDGibb)Photo by Mark Gibb (@MarkDGibb)Photo by Mark Gibb (@MarkDGibb)Photo by Mark Gibb (@MarkDGibb)Photo by Mark Gibb (@MarkDGibb)
Replying to @ChrisMartzWX
People on the left often invoke Jesus when talking about the goodness of the welfare state. But Jesus's commands were to individuals, not States. Compelling someone by force to perform charity removes all agency and morality from the act. A person who chooses to be like Jesus and help the poor has done a morally positive act. There is no moral act with government aid. It also removes the moral response from someone who receives the help. Money raining down from the magic government in the sky does nothing to improve the moral state of the recipient. It causes no sense of gratitude, no sense that self improvement is good, no knowledge of those who are helping. It creates entitlement and enervation. Btw, I might as well add this pic. The AP accidentally showed that a welfare state is not required:
2
1
16
2,691
Mark Gibb retweeted
The true danger to our country, the most imminent danger, is from within. It isn’t from without. It’s not the Canadians invading. It’s not the Mexicans invading. It’s not Russia invading. It’s the deficit overwhelming us and truly dragging us down.
1,174
363
66
4,252
153,351
Mark Gibb retweeted
I have yet to encounter a Protestant objection to the Catholic Church that actually addresses what the Catholic Church teaches. This will be a long post,🧵 but my hope is that this will provide education to those who are sincerely seeking truth, and edification for those who are already Catholic. Nearly every objection I have ever encountered, both as a Protestant before converting and after becoming Catholic, is built upon a misrepresentation, an ignorant misconception, or a deliberate redefinition of Catholic terminology that no informed Catholic would recognize. Here are some of the most common Protestant objections to Catholicism, followed by what the Catholic Church actually teaches: 1. Confession Protestant objection: "Only God can forgive sins! No man has that power!" What Catholics actually believe: God alone forgives sins. Priests exercise the authority Christ gave His apostles to forgive sins in His name, as we see in John 20:21-23. The priest is an instrument of Christ's forgiveness and NOT an independent source of it. 2. Faith and Works Protestant objection: "You cannot earn your salvation through good works!" What Catholics actually believe: Salvation is entirely dependent upon God's grace. No one can earn initial justification. However, the grace we receive TRANSFORMS us and ENABLES (Two important key words here) us to cooperate with God through, as Galatians 5:6 puts it, faith working in love. Good works done in grace are essential for salvation, but they do not purchase or earn it. 3. Praying to the Saints Protestant objection: "Prayer is worship! You're worshiping dead people!" What Catholics actually believe: Prayer is not necessarily worship. Even holding to Scripture alone, there is no verse that states ALL prayer is worship. To pray means to ask or petition. Asking the saints to intercede for us is not offering them the worship owed to God alone. Many verses, such as Luke 20:38, demonstrate that the saints are alive in Christ, not spiritually dead. 4. Christ as the One Mediator Protestant objection: "Praying to others makes them mediators when Jesus is the ONLY mediator between God and man!" What Catholics actually believe: Catholics believe what 1 Timothy 2:5 says, that Jesus Christ is the one mediator of salvation. The intercession of the saints participates in Christ's unique mediation and does not compete with or replace it. 1 Timothy 2:1-4 commands Christians to intercede for one another, and nowhere does Scripture state that command is only for those on earth, and that those in heaven do not pray for us. 5. Mary Protestant objection: "Mary is not God! Stop worshiping her!" What Catholics actually believe: As Catholics, we believe Mary is not God. She is a creature, redeemed by Christ, who receives special honor because of her unique role as the Mother of God, Jesus Christ. Adoration belongs to the Holy Trinity alone and not to any creature. Catholic doctrine explicitly forbids worshiping Mary, or anything else other than God. 6. Statues and Images Protestant objection: "God forbids idols! Bowing before a statue is idolatry!" What Catholics actually believe: Statues and sacred images are not gods. Honor shown to a sacred image is directed toward the person represented, not the material object itself. Even in many Protestant churches, Protestants will bow and show reverence before an empty cross, but no one thinks they are worshiping that wooden object. In Exodus 25:18-20, Scripture even records God commanding sacred images to be made. Bowing to show honor for those in the Body of Christ is not deifying them in any way. 7. Papal Infallibility Protestant objection: "Popes sin and make mistakes! No man is infallible!" What Catholics actually believe: Popes are sinners who can make mistakes, and often do. Papal infallibility is a narrowly defined protection by the Holy Spirit from error when the Pope definitively teaches a doctrine of faith or morals to be held by the whole Church. It is not personal perfection or universal immunity from error. 8. Purgatory Protestant objection: "Jesus paid for all our sins! Purgatory means His sacrifice wasn't enough!" What Catholics actually believe: Christ's sacrifice is entirely sufficient for salvation. Purgatory is the final purification of those who die in God's grace but still require purification before entering Heaven. Purification from what? From any and all attachment to sin. Everyone in purgatory is already saved. It is not a second chance at salvation. Nothing unclean can enter heaven, and Purgatory is that purification that makes one experientially and ontologically holy and pure before entering heaven. 9. Sacred Tradition Protestant objection: "The traditions of men cannot override the Word of God!" What Catholics actually believe: Sacred Tradition is not a collection of man-made customs. It is the apostolic teaching handed down within the Church. Scripture itself commands in 2 Thessalonians 2:15 Christians to hold to apostolic traditions transmitted both orally and in writing. The Canon of Scripture itself comes directly from the apostolic deposit of faith, IE, Sacred Tradition. 10. The Eucharist and the Mass Protestant objection: "Jesus died ONCE for all! Catholics sacrifice Him over and over again!" What Catholics actually believe: Christ's sacrifice occurred ONCE for all and is NEVER repeated. The Mass makes that one sacrifice sacramentally present in an unbloody manner. Every Mass is a participation in that one sacrifice. For example, the Jews would participate in the passover each and every time they would have the passover feast. It was not a repeat passover, but a participation in that one event. Likewise, Catholics participate in Christ's sacrifice in the same way. Catholics do not believe Jesus is crucified again at every Mass. 11. Indulgences Protestant objection: "You cannot buy forgiveness or purchase your way into Heaven!" What Catholics actually believe: Forgiveness and salvation cannot be purchased. An indulgence is the remission of temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven. What is temporal punishment, you may ask? For example, think of sin as hammering a nail into a wooden fence. God's forgiveness pulls the nail out, removing the eternal punishment. Temporal punishment is simply the temporary process of filling and healing the hole left behind. An indulgence is like God giving you the wood filler and sandpaper, and helping you smooth over the hole so the fence is fully restored faster. The Church explicitly condemns the buying and selling of spiritual things. 12. The Priesthood Protestant objection: "We don't need priests! Jesus is our High Priest!" What Catholics actually believe: Jesus is our one eternal High Priest. Catholic priests in no way replace Christ in the same way the Apostles and their ministry never replaced Christ. The ministerial priesthood participates in the priesthood of Christ and exists to serve His Church through the sacraments. 13. The Authority of the Church Protestant objection: "Only God has authority over Christians! The Church cannot command us!" What Catholics actually believe: All legitimate authority in the Church comes from Christ, and Christ alone. He explicitly entrusted authority to His apostles, including the authority to bind and loose, as we find in Matthew 16:18-19 and 18:18. The apostles used that power to give authority to other men such as Titus, Timothy, Clement, Ignatius, etc to do as they did and preserve the apostolic deposit of faith authoritatively. The Church does not claim authority independent of God. 14. Baptismal Regeneration Protestant objection: "Water cannot save anyone! Salvation is by grace!" What Catholics actually believe: Ordinary water does not save anyone by its own power. God saves through His grace, and as we see from John 3:5, Acts 2:38, and 1 Peter 3:21, baptism is an instrument through which He ordinarily grants regeneration and the forgiveness of sins. And no, Catholics do not believe baptism is efficacious without God granting an individual faith. And the list goes on. But these are just a few common ones. In short... If your argument against the Catholic Church requires you to misrepresent what the Catholic Church teaches, then you are simply exposing a deep ignorance of what the Church teaches, or revealing that you are inherently dishonest and shouldn't be taken seriously. Before you attempt to refute Catholicism, you should at least understand what Catholicism teaches. Hopefully this post serves to aid with that.
26
60
5
310
6,038
Responding in my personal capacity, but wanted to share my perspective.. We are in a great-power competition with so much at stake in the years ahead. There is no one in America who has lived during a time when the United States wasn't the preeminent superpower and, despite our imperfections, a force for good in the world. A nation that fought and helped end wars on behalf of those who couldn't, pioneered powered flight, put humanity on the Moon, led revolutions in medicine and technology that improved billions of lives and distributed hundreds of billions in aid around the world. I don't know how handicapping this nation by going after one of its largest employers, a company that has created wealth for millions, ushered in electric cars, rockets that don't need to be thrown away, satellites that connect the disconnected and have unquestionably saved lives, not to mention access to information that is pretty foundational to solving many of the world's problems, biotech to restore function to those with disabilities, and so much more, serves America's interests. Without the contributions of these companies, there is little question America would be behind in a competition where the outcome is far from certain and the consequence so great. Now, maybe I am just a bit new to this, but from the billboards, TV and digital ads, spam texts, and fundraising calls, it would seem both parties have no issue raising money, including from billionaires, with the aim of influencing and buying votes. And if that means campaign reform, maybe include dialing back the spam calls and texts..But with all that is going on in the world, and so much at stake for our country, I question the priorities reflected in the post below.
We’re going to do everything we can to make Elon’s worst nightmare come true next Congress: a democracy where the ultra-wealthy can’t buy elections.
1,307
4,841
392
32,897
1,005,279
Mark Gibb retweeted
I am the only Republican senator in opposition to voting for another $450 billion for the Iran War right now. At this point, the entire fiscal conservative movement in the Senate is only me. I don't say that to brag. I say that in disappointment. @petermlaffin @dcexaminer
1,200
968
111
6,566
191,521
Mark Gibb retweeted
Big Tech working in cahoots with the Biden admin to stifle covid dissent was a massive abuse of governmental and corporate power. The notion that if AI gets in every crevice in society that these same companies will not abuse power again is only credible if you completely discount the wisdom of the Founding Fathers re: human nature and the dangers of concentrated power.
211
1,457
38
8,700
105,978
Mark Gibb retweeted
Replying to @vlatdd
The biggest lie is that governments primarily serve the public interest. In reality they expand their own power, shield elites and connected interests, and treat citizens as resources to tax, regulate, and manage. The costs fall on ordinary people through debt, inflation, and eroded freedoms. This pattern holds across most regimes and centuries.
602
7,948
861
26,178
456,068
Mark Gibb retweeted
Democrats must be gaining power because Republicans have once again remembered that there is a deficit.
Nobody wants to hear this, and it’s not going to improve your mood, but you deserve the truth about how our $40.5 trillion debt is about to hit your family. Last month alone, they spent $773 billion while only taking in $369 billion. Almost 30 cents of every tax dollar you send them now goes purely to interest. Not roads, not troops, not Social Security. Just interest. And the more reckless our government gets with its borrowing, the higher interest rates climb for everyone else. That is why mortgage rates keep going up and one reason why your kids can’t buy a home. Both parties just point fingers at each other while they keep spending trillions more. Nobody has a real plan to stop it, and nobody is coming to save you. So save yourself. Pay off credit cards and any debt where the interest rate isn’t locked in. Start building a cash savings. Plan for Social Security cuts, and encourage your kids to learn high-demand trades like welding and electrical engineering so they stand a chance to make enough money in something that won’t go away. Get ready now, because our nation has been living on borrowed time and borrowed money for decades. And the bill is coming.
23
428
6
4,571
42,336
Maccabees is Scripture. All RB's arguments fail. 1. "It was not included in the Jewish Hebrew canon." This is irrelevant, as the Jewish Hebrew canon was established after they rejected Jesus & separated from the Church. The Fathers of the Church are the sources for authority, & the vast majority say the Greek Septuagint is canon, not the Jewish Hebrew Canon. At the time of Jesus, the debate of the canon was still open. 2. "It was not written by a prophet." This is irrelevant, as many Old and New Testament works were not written by a prophet. 3. "Neither Christ nor His apostles identify it as Scripture." None of these directly tell us which possible OT books are Scripture or not. The apostles indirectly tell us that it is Scripture by quoting the Greek Septuagint version of the Old Testament over the Hebrew (for example, "A virgin shall be with child"). If the Septuagint is the proper version, then Maccabees is Scripture as it is part of the Septuagint. 4. "Historical literature does not become the inspired Word of God simply because Rome declares it canonical." Rome only declares something canon, because it is, not vice versa. This works the opposite way, much stronger. We already established that the early Church almost universally accepted the Septuagint as the Old Testament. The truer version: "Historical literature does not cease being the inspired Word of God simply because Protestants declare it uncanonical."
Maccabees is NOT inspired Scripture. It was not included in the Jewish Hebrew canon. It was not written by a prophet, and neither Christ nor His apostles identify it as Scripture. Historical literature does not become the inspired Word of God simply because Rome declares it canonical. You cannot establish a biblical doctrine using a book that is not Scripture.
120
166
15
1,396
47,148
Mark Gibb retweeted
Most people, to be honest, are not excited about this. They don’t understand the implications, nor what happens when flights accelerate. Much media is quite hostile to SpaceX. Explosions get emphasised and achievements downplayed. So people are going to be taken off guard when the flight rate starts to pick up. When it’s not long possible to dismiss Starship, the debate will move on to “how can one company and one man have this power? Surely it should be shared with us, the people who didn’t contribute to it and who criticised it endlessly when it was being developed?”
500
1,320
123
10,919
314,245
Replying to @ZacksJerryRig
What’s up Jerry, how is this for you: - $185 million stopped in Minnesota from going to daycares - $1.2 BILLION in California Medicaid deferred - The head “Learer” pleaded guilty to daycare fraud in Minnesota - Largest autism fraud bust in US history following my video - 450+ daycares in Minnesota shut down - 500+ hospices in LA shut down - Multiple NYC adult daycares raided and recently a $100m fraud bust in NYC - Over $250 BILLION in fraud exposed since my Minnesota fraud video Are you angry I’ve stopped money going to learers and put it back into the hands of the poor and needy who actually depend on these government programs? Please continue to defend people who rob, steal and cheat from the most vulnerable in the United States. I’ll continue to help America while you keep complaining on 𝕏.
1,167
3,766
163
47,580
580,129
Is your girlfriend a Chinese spy? Know the signs!
227
1,575
132
9,635
300,583
Mark Gibb retweeted
Our Founding Fathers built checks and balances into our Constitutional Republic for a reason. Justice Scalia called those checks the single most important thing about the Constitution. The Electoral College is one of those checks, and one of the most brilliant compromises of the post-Revolutionary era. Now the socialist left is trying to dismantle the Electoral College. It’s up to us to defend it.
629
1,218
70
8,725
187,581
Republicans are leftists when it comes to the constitution. Especially on war powers. rather than looking to what the founders said during the ratification debates and DID to implement those powers - they look to precedent that has been set since then, mostly modern precedent. And governing by precedent is - as Thomas Paine told us - VILE. They also actively LIE about what the founders said and did.
8
46
2
168
1,563
IMPEACHMENT, Article III The law requires our military to withdraw from hostilities within 60 days if Congress does not authorize the activity. Operation Epic Fury has been underway for 256 days. Congress has not authorized it. Hegseth is breaking the law. Not even debatable.
5,883
14,138
593
97,084
1,780,169
Friends, Catholic social teaching holds two things together: a nation has the right, and the duty, to regulate its borders, and every migrant is a person of incomparable dignity who deserves generosity. In January, amid the tensions in Minnesota, I proposed that enforcement focus on those who have committed serious crimes. Last year, together with my brother bishops of Minnesota, I called on Congress to pass comprehensive immigration reform. What the President described Sunday in his 60 Minutes interview about immigration is very much in that spirit. The President now proposes working with Democrats toward a solution that involves a properly regulated border, the deportation of people who have committed serious crimes, and a generous approach toward those who have been non-violent and have contributed to the economy. He even admitted that the enforcement of his immigration policy has been too tough. That is the balance the Church’s teaching points toward. We have waited years for a solution to this thorny problem. I would strongly encourage leaders in both parties to take advantage of this extraordinary opportunity.
1,447
402
195
3,794
431,900
The anti Musk stupidity is max stupid!!
10
Mark Gibb retweeted
AI is going way too far The wall 😭😭😭
127
622
42
4,101
174,050
This is why the 17th Amendment (direct election of Senators) should be repealed. Before the 17th Senators were appointed for 6 year terms by the State Legislature to represent the interests of the State. Legislatures also wanted their own turns as a U.S. Senator and would NEVER send brain dead fossils to DC for decades. Repeal the 17th!
The lights are on, but nobody's home...
97
174
15
1,763
63,794
After years of screaming about the "Handmaid's Tale", now liberal women have voted in a man whose wife is forced to dress like this. Astonishing. w.
266
1,017
62
4,462
42,778
Mark Gibb retweeted
This is pretty much our neighborhood. We rarely talk politics, but we look out for each other, share what we have, and respect our differences. Community doesn't require agreement. Just good neighbors. ❤
16
17
157
1,788