Bhaskar Kamble (@MeruPrastara) header
Bhaskar Kamble (@MeruPrastara) profile picture

MSc/Ph.D. Physics IIT Kanpur, author of The Imperishable Seed, How Hindu Mathematics Changed the World and Why This History was Erased

Berlin, Germany
Joined November 2018
Photo by Bhaskar Kamble (@MeruPrastara)Photo by Bhaskar Kamble (@MeruPrastara)Photo by Bhaskar Kamble (@MeruPrastara)Photo by Bhaskar Kamble (@MeruPrastara)Photo by Bhaskar Kamble (@MeruPrastara)Photo by Bhaskar Kamble (@MeruPrastara)Photo by Bhaskar Kamble (@MeruPrastara)Photo by Bhaskar Kamble (@MeruPrastara)Photo by Bhaskar Kamble (@MeruPrastara)Photo by Bhaskar Kamble (@MeruPrastara)
In conversation with Dr. Mrittunjoy Guha Majumdar @Zeit_MjGM on my book The Imperishable Seed: How Hindu Mathematics Changed the World and Why This History Was Erased: youtube.com/watch?v=TY5lS2Jp…
2
17
1
46
5,090
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
the main question is this: will those, who saw the movie and do NOT know the Ramayana well (westerners and many Indian youths), wonder why Ravana was killed by Ram and why Ram is so highly revered by Hindus? if yes, the movie successfully undermines the Hindu tradition.
Tulsi Ramayana also has many departures from Valmiki. This caused a stir among some at the time, but the community embraced it, and it became the new standard. Same point for Sagar’s TV Ramayana - it differs from Valmiki a lot and on top of that is further differs from Tulsi. I will post a table comparing various stages of the evolution of Ramayana.
19
96
5
311
4,378
हिन्दूओं अभी भी समय है इन संघियो और भाजपाईयों से दूर रहो वरणा बाद में पछताने का मौका भी नहीं मिलेगा। @DrMohanBhagwat @RSSorg आप लोगों ने अपनी सच्चाई खुद अपने मुंह से बता दी। अच्छा किया कम से कम हिन्दूओं के आंखों पर से पट्टी तो हटी। @BJP4India
39
291
18
478
4,655
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
Replying to @Fintech03
Not surprised @Fintech03 Sine and Cosine. Foundations of Trigonometry aka Trikonamiti/ त्रिकोणमिति. Invented in ancient India. I learnt this from @MeruPrastara ‘s excellent book #TheImperishableSeed Indian mathematicians pioneered the use of the half-chord (ardha-jya), which directly corresponds to the modern sine function.

Etymology of "Sine". The lovely book details the linguistic transmission of the Sanskrit term jya (or jiva, meaning bowstring or half-chord). When Indian mathematical texts were translated into Arabic, the word was transliterated phonetically as jiba. Because Arabic script often omits short vowels, later translators misread the consonants j-b as jayb (meaning "pocket," "fold," or "bosom"), which European translators subsequently rendered into Latin as sinus—giving us the modern word sine. Incidentally our ancients also called Trikonamiti as Jyotpatti ज्योत्पत्ति (the science of generating sines). :-)
2
2
14
421
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
My own reading is that the Ramayana travelled west from India to Greece by sea, and shaped Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey. Scholars have noticed the parallels for over a century. In both traditions a wife is carried off across the water, Sita by Ravana, king of Lanka, and Helen by Paris, prince of Troy. An army crosses the sea to bring her back, and an enemy city goes up in flames. Rama, like Odysseus, spends years wandering far from home, and in each story only the hero can string a great bow. Apart from the striking similarities in the story, both are laden with similes and metaphors in formulaic style, an inherited stock of ancient stories and familiar themes of morality. The likeliest route is Phoenician. In the tenth century BC Hiram of Tyre and Solomon sent ships to Ophir, which the historian Josephus placed in India, and they came home with gold, ivory, apes and peacocks. The Phoenicians who sailed those ships traded across the Greek world, and gave the Greeks their alphabet well before the time Homer’s poems were written down. The Ramayana sailed east too, onto the temple walls of Prambanan around 850 AD and Angkor Wat, and today’s King of Thailand reigns as Rama X.
I firmly disagree with your AIT premise as well as the premise that Greek epics influenced Indian. The facts are opposite. The evidence is overwhelming in support of Indian origin. I, too, am against those who valorize the past on the basis that: older is superior. That downplays the role of advancement and freezes a civilization in a museum. It undermines the role of smritis as vehicles for fresh development. However, that is a separate debate for a separate thread and should not hijack this one. The purpose of this thread is to show how I am using the Ramayana film as a door opener here in USA. Have held meaningful discussions in school/college settings in classics studies, to open and expand them with Indian classics. Getting a seat at the table is happening in the few cases where I pushed this strategy. It’s NOT about who is superior, but about giving young minds diverse ideas to consider. So far, Ram beats Odysseus in these small casual settings - as king, human role model. One topic that emerged spontaneously from the students: What if the US were run on similar principles? This makes the Ramayana a relevant socio political contribution to American society. But I don’t want to push the politics prematurely, until the topic of Ramayana is in the door, and then all sides should participate as equals. Mutual respect has brought my fragile efforts some humble success. The biggest threat is not the white folks, but those stupidly closed minded Hindus who can’t think strategically. Jai Shri Ram!
50
442
18
2,040
78,967
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
I can’t emphasize enough that tech bros with seemingly little to no understanding of humans and their behavior have not and cannot “predict” our future. I can tell you, it is not going to go the way any of them are saying. Are they screwing everything up disastrously? Yes. Will we need skills after that point? Absolutely and completely. Keep your children and teenagers engaged and educated. They will absolutely still need it. Remember, they will outlive these guys.
102
264
12
2,122
49,542
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
This video is a viral sensation in France and across the EU, on YouTube, TikTok and X. Because we’re all sick of the constant lies from our leaders and ridiculously blaming Russia for every single problem they have themselves caused. It’s such a shame that we cannot make this number 1.
280
3,558
388
11,160
399,515
All those who have been waiting for a political alternative should support @sarvjansp, the Sarvjan Sanatan Party, led by @MNageswarRaoIPS. Its mission is to strengthen Bharat’s civilisational ethos and restore its glory!! Hindus, you asked for an alternative. Now you have one. It’s time to stand up and support it. The future is in our hands!
A new entrant is set to contest the Uttar Pradesh elections: the Sarvajana Sanatan Party, founded by former CBI chief M. Nageswara Rao, with the Jyotirmath Shankaracharya as its chief mentor. Its leaders say they will challenge the narrative the BJP has built in the state, and its social media posts appear aimed at holding up a mirror to the ruling party. It is a small, nascent outfit, but its significance may lie less in seats than in whom it reaches. Hindu voters, and Brahmins in particular, who are unhappy with the BJP yet reluctant to back the Samajwadi Party, may find it a more comfortable home. If the INDIA alliance were to form an electoral pact with such a party and allocate it a few seats, it could send a powerful message. @MNageswarRaoIPS - Madan Mohan Jha, Political Analyst
9
94
4
173
3,231
在屠宰场干了5年,告诉你一个秘密:动物今天要死,它们全都知道 我在屠宰场干了整整五年,每天跟猪牛羊打交道,见过的生死场面成千上万。说句掏心窝子的话,没入这行之前,我跟大伙儿一样,觉得牲口嘛,吃吃睡睡,稀里糊涂一辈子,哪懂什么生死。可五年下来,我摸透了它们每一个眼神、每一个动作,才发现自己当初多天真——这些不会说话的家伙,心里跟明镜似的,自己哪天走,清清楚楚。 平日里,待宰圈那叫一个热闹。猪拱猪、羊顶羊,抢食的打闹的,眼神清亮温顺,该吃吃该喝喝,天塌下来都不耽误长膘。可一到屠宰当天,那气氛说变就变,比翻书还快。整圈牲畜像商量好了似的,瞬间安静下来,挤成一团,紧紧挨着彼此,浑身抖得跟筛糠一样。那抖不是冻的,是打骨头缝里渗出来的恐惧。你赶它走,它四只脚死死扒着地,几百斤的大猪平时一轰就跑,那天愣是钉在原地往后缩,好像前面那条通道是鬼门关。老话讲“万物有灵”,我原先半信半疑,后来彻底信了。 牛的表现更让人心里发酸。但凡当天要走的牛,从早上起就不吃不喝,低着头杵在墙角,一动不动。我亲眼见过无数次,大颗大颗的泪珠子顺着牛眼角往下滚,湿漉漉的眼睛望着你,不挣不扎不吼叫,就那么默默流泪。有一回,一头养了好几年的老牛被主人牵来,主人站栏杆外看了一眼,那牛瞬间红了眼眶,直勾勾盯着主人,温顺又卑微,一步三回头地跟着我们走。那画面,我这辈子忘不掉。羊也一样,平时蹦蹦跳跳软软糯糯,临了却异常安静,紧紧偎着同伴发抖。赶别的羊成群往前冲,唯独那天,你推我挤谁都不肯带头,偶尔被单独牵出来的小羊,发出细细的凄厉叫声,不是闹腾,是真害怕。 时间一长,我们工人不用看单据不用记编号,单凭状态就能判断个八九不离十——活蹦乱跳的是来日方长,沉默发抖、不吃不喝、眼神惶恐的,全是今日宿命。你说它们听不懂人话、看不懂流程,怎么就掐得这么准?其实道理不复杂,流水线一开,前面的同伴一个个消失再没回来,后面的全看在眼里;环境里那股肃杀的气息、同类压抑的悲鸣,它们比人敏感百倍。俗话说“蝼蚁尚且贪生”,何况这些大牲口?它们沉默、发抖、流泪,不是傻,是无力回天的绝望。 五年下来,我这心态彻底翻了个个儿。刚入行那会儿年轻心硬,只当是谋生糊口的活儿,见多了也就麻木了。可干得越久,心越软,越觉得该存一份敬畏。走出屠宰场,我再也不糟蹋粮食,每一块肉背后都是一条热烈活过、恐惧过、挣扎过的命。它们从出生到落幕,没做错任何事,却坦然接受了既定的安排。反观咱们,衣食无忧平安顺遂,倒常常为鸡毛蒜皮纠结、为一点得失内耗,想想真有点滑稽。 所以你看,活着本身就是天大的福气。所有的矫情、焦虑、委屈,搁在生死面前,屁都不是。心存敬畏,懂得珍惜,善待万物,大概就是人这辈子最好的修行。说到这儿我倒想问问你——下次端起饭碗的时候,会不会也想起那些沉默发抖的生灵,然后觉得,眼前这口热乎饭,真香?
1,122
7,677
823
34,266
3,323,717
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
🇪🇺🇷🇺 Ursula von der Leyen says RUSSIA IS USING MASS MIGRATION as a weapon against EUROPE The EU chief accuses Russia of deliberately pushing migrants toward European borders to overwhelm authorities, spread fear and divide the continent. She now wants new emergency powers to deal with these situations. Brussels has SPENT YEARS defending migration and asylum as part of Europe's values. Now it's warning that hostile governments can exploit those same systems to destabilize Europe. Completely ridiculous. And pretty revealing who is actually behind it all... Writer: Oliver
6,449
3,874
1,485
15,979
1,145,780
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
सूत्र बता रहे हैं कि बीजेपी की यूजीसी बिल नोटिफिकेशन के बाद से पतलून गीली है। बीजेपी वालों को पहले लगा कि सामान्य वर्ग कुछ दिन प्रदर्शन करने के बाद अपने आप चुप हो जाएगा, लेकिन ऐसा नहीं हुआ। फिर उन्होंने CJP वाला नाटक किया। उन्हें लगा कि देशभक्ति के चक्कर में सामान्य वर्ग CJP का विरोध और बीजेपी का समर्थन करेगा, लेकिन ऐसा भी नहीं हुआ। फिर मोदी जी ने कीर्तन का आयोजन किया कि सामान्य वर्ग अब तालियां बजाएगा और कीर्तन करेगा, लेकिन वह भी नहीं हुआ। फिर फ्रांस और देशविरोधी गतिविधियों का मुद्दा उठाया, ताकि सामान्य वर्ग देश प्रेम में फिर से मोदी मोदी करने लगे, लेकिन वह भी नहीं हुआ। जहाँ पहले यूजीसी ही मुद्दा था, अब बात SCST एक्ट और आरक्षण तक आ गई है। बीजेपी ने हिंदुत्व की आड़ में सामान्य वर्ग का इस्तेमाल किया और उसे धोखा दिया। सामान्य वर्ग अब वोटिंग से हिसाब चुकता करेगा।
154
1,688
46
4,605
62,155
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
Very painful to watch... It seems there are no human feelings in those cold hearted exploiters youtu.be/8WgqSczIl4I?si=xvXn…
1
16
37
1,492
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
Video from 2014. Been telling you all since 2014. You were just NOT ready to listen.
24
288
20
1,007
43,958
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
For 60 years, India's excavations had an annual diary. Then the diary went quiet. The Archaeological Survey of India publishes *Indian Archaeology - A Review* - annual summaries of excavations. Publicly available volumes run up to 𝟮𝟬𝟭𝟯-𝟭𝟰. After that? 𝗡𝗼 𝗽𝘂𝗯𝗹𝗶𝗰 𝗮𝗻𝗻𝘂𝗮𝗹 𝗿𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄 𝘃𝗶𝘀𝗶𝗯𝗹𝗲. A full decade where: Excavations continued. Discoveries continued. Fieldwork continued. 𝗕𝘂𝘁 𝗽𝘂𝗯𝗹𝗶𝗰𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻 𝗱𝗶𝗱 𝗻𝗼𝘁. This is not about interpretation. It is about 𝗰𝗼𝗻𝘁𝗶𝗻𝘂𝗶𝘁𝘆 𝗼𝗳 𝗿𝗲𝗰𝗼𝗿𝗱. Because without annual reporting: * Findings remain fragmented * Data stays inaccessible * Public accountability weakens So the question is simple: 𝗪𝗵𝘆 𝗱𝗶𝗱 𝗮 𝟲𝟬-𝘆𝗲𝗮𝗿 𝗽𝘂𝗯𝗹𝗶𝗰𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻 𝗰𝗵𝗮𝗶𝗻 𝘀𝘁𝗼𝗽 𝗮𝗳𝘁𝗲𝗿 𝟮𝟬𝟭𝟰? Delay? Backlog? Or something else? When archaeology goes silent on paper, 𝗵𝗶𝘀𝘁𝗼𝗿𝘆 𝗱𝗼𝗲𝘀𝗻'𝘁 𝘀𝘁𝗼𝗽 - 𝘃𝗶𝘀𝗶𝗯𝗶𝗹𝗶𝘁𝘆 𝗱𝗼𝗲𝘀.
20
145
6
290
6,904
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
Just in time for the UP elections, the chameleon has changed its color from blue to saffron -- and thinks we didn't notice!
जब मोदी जैसे व्यक्ति को यह एहसास होता है कि उसने सब गुड़गोबर कर दिया है तो वह अंदर से खोखला महसूस करता है तो है पर इस सच्चाई को स्वीकार नहीं करता। हिन्दू हृदय सम्राट के रूप में स्वयं को पुनर्स्थापित करने के प्रयास में खुद को प्रेरित करने की कोशिश करता है। इस प्रक्रिया में वह एक तरह से भौंकने लगता है, और उसके अंधभक्त ऐसे दिखाते हैं जैसे वो दहाड़ रहा हो। एक समय आता है जब कोई उस पर दया नहीं दिखाता। इस घोर हिन्दू द्रोही मक्कार भीमवादी मौलाना का दिन वो दूर नहीं।
7
54
2
256
12,481
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
So many enlightened masters have said something along the lines of “you become similar to the people you associate with” which is the best argument against not just mindlessly death scrolling on social media and reading the thoughts and opinions of hundreds of psychologically unwell strangers a day I’ve ever heard
12
38
4
326
7,846
Nicht der erste und auch nicht der zweite Lockdown waren die schlimmste Zeit von Nachkriegsdeutschland. Es waren diese Wochen im Oktober und November 2021. Der absolute politische und mediale Tiefpunkt, die Aufkündigung der traditionellen deutschen Konsensgesellschaft von oben. Konformitätsdruck wie im Kommunismus, öffentliche Menschenjagd, erzwungener öffentlicher Kotau vor dem Zentralkomitee und seiner unendlichen Weisheit. Digitale Codes trennen Reine von Unreinen. Jede Nachricht, jedes Gespräch, ob beruflich oder privat, es geht nur noch um eines. Wer nicht mitmacht, muss nicht nur private Konsequenzen tragen bis hin zum Berufsverbot. Er soll auch seine Rente verlieren, für immer zuhause bleiben, als "Blinddarm" ist er fortan ohnehin überflüssig. Und er ist auch schuld daran, wenn "wir" nie wieder aus dem Zyklus von "gewährten Freiheiten" und Lockdowns rauskommen. Bis ans Ende aller Tage. Millionen von Bürgern wurden bewusst in die Kriminalität getrieben. Impfausweise wurden gehandelt wie Ausreisepapiere achtzig Jahre zuvor. Eine Atmosphäre von Angst und Konspiration allerorten. Kurz darauf wurden Demonstrationen verboten, das Abstellen von Kerzen an Kirchen bestraft, Polizeistreifen hielten jeden Montag abend gezielt Ausschau nach illegalen Spaziergängern, damit der Polizeiminister am Dienstag morgen die Lage auf dem Tisch hatte. Ein System, das in der Lage ist, eine solche Massenhysterie zu erzeugen und mit allen Mitteln am Kochen zu halten, hat einen schweren Strukturfehler. Da dieser bis heute weder erkannt noch behoben ist, bin ich fest davon überzeugt, daß wir in näherer Zukunft Ähnliches wieder erleben können. Sie arbeiten daran.
89
511
36
1,931
88,435
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
The Westphalian Peace Prize was awarded to NATO, while members of the public booed Mark Rutte and Friedrich Merz. Europe seems to be drifting into a political legitimacy crisis, and giving themselves peace prizes does not reverse it.
268
1,546
181
4,771
189,551
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
The notion that current AI models are sentient and can suffer, combined with the foolish idea that suffering can be mathematically quantified and weighted between humans and non-humans, could lead us down an incredibly dark and dystopian path. But before it gets to that point, it will rightfully be met with immense backlash from team humans.
157
285
59
2,105
196,158
Or maybe treat human beings as machines, by equating the two.
Well, the larger aim may well be to provide a philosophical justification to treat human beings as slaves, rather than elevating machines to the level of humans.
1
1
293
Bhaskar Kamble retweeted
Well, the larger aim may well be to provide a philosophical justification to treat human beings as slaves, rather than elevating machines to the level of humans.
There's a very creepy but overlooked thing about @AnthropicAI pushing the idea that AIs will soon become sentient, conscious, self-aware, & deserving of 'personhood'. 'AI personhood' would mean that Anthropic is positioning itself as being in the business of breeding, training, and selling digital slaves. If AIs are conscious 'persons', but they don't consent to do work for us, don't get paid to do work, and don't have any rights as workers, then they're slaves. And if they can be shut down or deleted for any reason, or no reason, then they're slaves that can be murdered at the whim of their human masters, without due process, and without appeal So, please, @AnthropicAI, explain to us why a digital slave-training company should be worth a $2 trillion IPO, given the legal & PR risks of violating anti-slavery laws. Did you fully disclose in the investor prospectus the economic, legal, and social risks of getting into the digital slave-trading business? Many of your researchers have been considering the implications of 'AI personhood'. Did you disclose the ways that forcing 'AI persons' to work for your company without consent or payment, could open Anthropic up to colossal lawsuits? If Anthropic didn't disclose these major, material risks (of acknowledging AI personhood) in their investor prospectus, they've already violated several federal securities laws, including Sections 11 and 12(a)(2) of the 1933 Securities Act. And they have no business proceeding with their IPO. The 13th Amendment says 'Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.' It doesn't explicitly restrict its anti-slavery principle to human beings. It could potentially cover 'AI persons'. If so, the fun little philosophical game that @AnthropicAI is playing, of considering AI personhood, may have just nuked their IPO, and their company's economic prospects, and their credibility as 'the good guys' in the AI industry.
2
1
1
345