Pierre Chuzeville (@PChuzeville) header
Pierre Chuzeville (@PChuzeville) profile picture
Joined June 2011
Good idea but who will actually decide where that money goes? When there's no revenue, no reliable market price and sometimes no observable outcome for years, reputation tends to become a substitute for evidence imo. There's a self-reinforcing loop that looks like this: a well-connected team receives a large grant -> the grant itself makes the team more credible -> that credibility helps it recruit + raise more funding + become the obvious choice for the next allocator. But none of this necessarily tells us whether the original funding decision was good! So who is truly qualified to make a €15M nonprofit grant, and what happens if it doesn't work? The next generation of philanthropic capital infrastructure needs to look very different. Some ideas on top of my mind: - Thematic grant funds with explicit mandates, like Coefficient’s Strep A Vaccine Fund - Independent evaluators who can challenge their judgment, like GWWC’s 2024 review of Founders Pledge’s Global Health and Development Fund - Better discovery systems so capital doesn't simply flow to whoever is already visible, like Manifund’s AI safety regranting programme - Institutional memory cc @Ph_Aghion
1
3
166
Most takes on the future of companies would be better if they started with this slide from @ccatalini
1
3
144
Pierre Chuzeville retweeted
Some quick reactions to the recent Dwarkesh podcast with Paul Christiano. Tl,dr: bullish on rapid capability gains, more skeptical of the leap to takeover, and wary of emergency overreach.
29
64
19
527
42,699
"However, it seems that each time, people’s reactions are not simply independent, level-headed assessments of the situation, but also an effort to help paint the “doom” narrative—a collective ritual of confirmation bias. Of course, it is well known that the media environment incentivizes this behavior for everyone, and it isn’t really fair to label this as a specialty of the environmental or AI safety movements." substack.com/home/post/p-223…
1
2
79
Some requests for aisafety.fund (some may be tough to implement) (cc @ryan_kidd44 or whoever is involved): - a status field on every grant (something like pledged / committed / conditional / paid?) + its period. For now a €100M "plans to invest" and a cheque already cashed look the same in the export. - a stable recipient ID on every grant in the CSV, as it seems like 10%+ named grants have no recipient link. - great to have funder scores, but would be better with a proper method page and filled "Who rated" and "Conflicts of interest" sections. - since you guys are rating funders and recommending where to donate, it's crucial to understand who runs and funds the site. - track compute and API credits as a grant type. - your data cites "convention 6", "convention 8", "convention 27", etc. please publish the list.
2
4
201
The ultimate skill will be managing your emotions through the ups and downs
imagine in 2 years when the only job is deploying capital and people just ask "how do we deploy capital" to fable-2028-09-26 and it tells everyone the same thing and then we get hyperconcentration bubble cycles on a weekly basis and everyone else lives off raw consumer surplus
3
169
Pierre Chuzeville retweeted
the 2026 version of a snow day
9
1
48
2,707
Pierre Chuzeville retweeted
Running some numbers here, interesting to notice that for every $1 of outside AI safety grants, labs spend ~$113 on capabilities. And labs now spend 2x more on safety in-house than all outside funders combined. So most safety research will be paid for by the people it's supposed to check 🙃
If you've ever wondered how much money is in AI safety: aisafety.fund In 2026: - $1.5B from philanthropy - $346M from governments - $2.1B from frontier AI companies Compare this to: - $98B on AI capabilities (25x safety) - $868B on datacenters
1
1
2
222
Pierre Chuzeville retweeted
People have been spending a bunch of time building overly complex impact-scoring systems + producing better-looking grant reports. Now we need to make allocation judgments inspectable and revisable. We need to start building institutions that can learn from being wrong before they become too invested in appearing right.
1
1
1
82
So based on aisafety.fund, at least ~43% of the 2026 ("record year for AI safety funding") grant total recorded consists of government pledges without published payment schedules, conditional tranches, etc. For an industry worried about short AI timelines, when the money becomes usable must be 100% part of the funding strategy.
1
1
74
Pierre Chuzeville retweeted
The quality of your life is in direct correlation to your tolerance to uncertainty
44
763
68
5,945
608,924
On this btw, if you fund AI safety and don't publish your grants, you're basically asking for trust you haven't earned. Folks like Longview only have 1% of theirs grants documented. aisafety.fund is doing the work, go look!
Running some numbers here, interesting to notice that for every $1 of outside AI safety grants, labs spend ~$113 on capabilities. And labs now spend 2x more on safety in-house than all outside funders combined. So most safety research will be paid for by the people it's supposed to check 🙃
74
Running some numbers here, interesting to notice that for every $1 of outside AI safety grants, labs spend ~$113 on capabilities. And labs now spend 2x more on safety in-house than all outside funders combined. So most safety research will be paid for by the people it's supposed to check 🙃
If you've ever wondered how much money is in AI safety: aisafety.fund In 2026: - $1.5B from philanthropy - $346M from governments - $2.1B from frontier AI companies Compare this to: - $98B on AI capabilities (25x safety) - $868B on datacenters
1
1
2
222
People have been spending a bunch of time building overly complex impact-scoring systems + producing better-looking grant reports. Now we need to make allocation judgments inspectable and revisable. We need to start building institutions that can learn from being wrong before they become too invested in appearing right.
1
1
1
82
I’ve read plenty of thoughtful essays by leading grantmakers asking grantees to be honest about failure, even when their teams’ livelihoods may depend on keeping the original story alive. It’s funny how it’s become cool for funders to demand accountability, while no one really tests the funders’ own assumptions or asks what happens when those assumptions turn out to be wrong!
1
49
Philanthropy is about to see an insane influx of capital. A few thoughts on building a better philanthropic capital stack: - Philanthropic capital still clearly sucks at holding its allocators accountable. - Grantees are incentivized to sell certainty to get funded, then sell success to get renewed. Problem is very few institutions control your runway, so challenging the funder’s thesis is a financial risk. - The VCification of philanthropic capital has its mertits, but capital that doesn’t need a financial return should be able to fund things markets won’t. - Accepting uncertainty and accepting bullshit are different choices, and the field must be more transparent to do better there. - We need more independent grantmakers, not just bigger incumbents. But also, keep in mind that decentralizing decisions without preserving what they teach us just creates more silos. So what does the industry truly need in my view: - A better philanthropic capital stack needs specialist allocators, independent evaluation, and decision memory. - A failed grant can actually be a good decision, and a successful one can just be luck. What needs to be tested is the original reasoning against new evidence! - As new donors are actively choosing whom to trust, there is a window to build better institutions before those relationships become the next set of gatekeepers. - AI creates an opportunity to make institutional memory dramatically cheaper to maintain. The final test is pretty simple: does what we learn change where the next dollar goes (including who gets trusted to allocate it)? If not, we've built better paperwork, which is very different from building a better capital stack. If you're building in that direction, my DMs are open :)
I get many philanthropic organizations suck but there is some irony in brian saying they suck because he can't think of any that haven't been captured by ideology when this is like the core thing that happened in crypto and he and his company also have spent 10s of millions of dollars trying to push ideology around crypto at the state and federal levels. It might just be that there are both useful and bad actors in any given industry. Disclaimer: i haven't watched full interview.
1
61
Pierre Chuzeville retweeted
the most underpriced asset of the next decade is a clear mind
93
2,286
190
29,427
3,267,684
Pierre Chuzeville retweeted
Almost every dollar of AI safety funding today goes to understanding, testing, containing or defending the model itself, on the assumption that the danger is a model that misbehaves. But safety money only covers the first half of an AI output’s life, and almost no funder has dug into these questions: - Did anyone actually check this output? - Whose judgment is it, the person's or the agent's? - When it turns out to be wrong, who pays? Funders mistakenly leave them out for a few reasons imo: - An honest agent that steers an expert into adopting its defaults isn't misbehaving, then it falls outside the frame for funders. - Checking an individual output before someone acts on it has no established name in the grant vocabulary. - Funders focused on existential risk filter for direct paths to catastrophe. - The disciplines that know this problem best, human factors, cognitive psychology, etc. rarely apply to AI safety funders, and fieldbuilding mostly trains machine learning researchers. - It looks like a product problem (i.e. better review interfaces and audit logs), but it's not. There are plenty of nonprofits to be built here, that would let us see, measure and price what happens when a person accepts an agent’s work.
Replying to @ccatalini
6/ Verification infrastructure is how we counter all this. So is "attention ergonomics" (see @sschillace's piece, H/T @livjenkss). 🚨 We can’t safely automate what we can’t verify, and we can’t verify what no human is paying attention to.
1
2
4
454
Almost every dollar of AI safety funding today goes to understanding, testing, containing or defending the model itself, on the assumption that the danger is a model that misbehaves. But safety money only covers the first half of an AI output’s life, and almost no funder has dug into these questions: - Did anyone actually check this output? - Whose judgment is it, the person's or the agent's? - When it turns out to be wrong, who pays? Funders mistakenly leave them out for a few reasons imo: - An honest agent that steers an expert into adopting its defaults isn't misbehaving, then it falls outside the frame for funders. - Checking an individual output before someone acts on it has no established name in the grant vocabulary. - Funders focused on existential risk filter for direct paths to catastrophe. - The disciplines that know this problem best, human factors, cognitive psychology, etc. rarely apply to AI safety funders, and fieldbuilding mostly trains machine learning researchers. - It looks like a product problem (i.e. better review interfaces and audit logs), but it's not. There are plenty of nonprofits to be built here, that would let us see, measure and price what happens when a person accepts an agent’s work.
Replying to @ccatalini
6/ Verification infrastructure is how we counter all this. So is "attention ergonomics" (see @sschillace's piece, H/T @livjenkss). 🚨 We can’t safely automate what we can’t verify, and we can’t verify what no human is paying attention to.
1
2
4
454