Peter Schurman (@PSchurman) header
Peter Schurman (@PSchurman) profile picture

Former founding E.D. at MoveOn, now building a movement for inclusive global governance. https://teapaw.org/t.co/DHcuUQW7cH

San Francisco, CA
Joined May 2009
🎯 Exactly this.
We get so bogged down in the daily stream of atrocities committed by Israel that it's easy to lose sight of the big picture. At the end of the day the reason why it matters so much, besides it being an affront to our most basic humanity, is because whatever we collectively let happen - or not - will define the fundamental structure of the international order for decades to come. Why, and how? The most important thing to remember about the period we're living in is that we're in a transition between world orders. We're exiting US hegemony - it's over already - and entering an new order. Such transitions happen rarely, once a century or so. The last time was the end of the Cold War when we transitioned from a bipolar world order to US hegemony, or "Pax Americana" as it was known (which wasn't "pax" at all given the millions violently killed in U.S. wars, which is the very reason why it was so short-lived... but that's besides the point). But this transition is extra special, because for the first time in 300+ years, we have non-Western states such as China becoming preeminent powers. As we all know, ever since the Industrial Revolution, it was the West dominating the system. Transitions occurred but between Western states: Portugal to Spain, Spain to the British, the British to the US. So that's the backdrop. Now how does Israel fit in and why does it matter? Orders are based on principles, and founding historical events matter enormously to underwrite these principles. Go back to the past, when the West started colonizing the planet, at first timidly (a few "trading posts" in Africa in the 15th century) and then more and more boldly, all the way to claiming entire continents. Why? Because they could, they were writing the principles (or lack thereof) of a new West-dominated world order. Or if you want a closer example, take NATO's bombing of Yugoslavia in the 1990s, one of the founding acts of the US hegemony era. Completely illegal with regards to international law or even of NATO's own treaty (Serbia didn't attack and wasn't preparing to attack a member state of NATO), so much so that - it's funny to recall today - even Ariel Sharon at the time called an act of "brutal interventionism". Looking back, it premised the entire US hegemonic order: a time of unilateral, hubristic and brutal interventionism with little regard for international law. The message was "we do whatever the hell we want"... And this first act was timid compared with what was to come afterwards and the millions killed in the post 9-11 so-called "war on terror". Now I'm obviously not suggesting that Israel will be a preeminent state in the new world order, it's way too small for this. What I am saying is that the actions we collectively permit today will echo for decades to come and define the larger battles that will shape our future. And everyone can see that the precedents that we're setting are beyond horrifying: some of the principles Israel breaks were established for centuries such as the illegality of bombing embassies, or the killing of medical staff. Even in the Middle-Age we knew better not to do that stuff. People don't realize just how consequential this is: what's at stake is quite simply everything. If we let the future of the international order be based on the murder of Palestinians, and now the Lebanese, we're paving the way for the most unprincipled and nihilistic order we've ever known, where virtually anything goes. I see many people, some of them I believe sincere, defend Israel on the basis that it's a "fight for civilization against barbarism". It's in fact the EXACT CONTRARY. Israel is literally destroying everything civilization is based upon: sovereignty, the rule of law, human rights, freedom, etc. If you care about any of these things and if you truly understood what's happening, you'd be an ardent defender of the Palestinians and Lebanese. Many people cheered Israel on its "daring" actions against Hezbollah, including the killing of Nasrallah, on the basis that these were "terrorists" (remember that one man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter...). What fewer people know is that the reason why Israel did those actions wasn't at all because they were "terrorists", which is always just a propaganda label for the gullible public: according to Israeli officials themselves as quoted by NBC (nbcnews.com/news/world/live-…) they did it because Hezbollah refused a side deal that abandoned the Palestinians and let Israel continue its its land grab and ethnic cleansing unimpeded. In other words the "terrorists" of Hezbollah were the only ones who actually decided to make Israel face accountability on what all UN resolutions and the immense majority of the international community have been calling for ceaselessly. They're the only ones who decided to actually enforce the rules we supposedly have. THAT is why they're getting bombed and killed. All in all, if you genuinely care about the principles that underlie civilization, the Palestinian cause should be THE priority cause for you, because of the precedents that are being set. Another non-trivial group of people defend Israel because they're essentially supremacists, wanting "the West" to crush those "Muslims" (notwithstanding the fact many Palestinians and even more Lebanese are Christian) for daring to rebel against their subjugation. But even if that's your case, if you were to take a step back and use a modicum of common sense, you'd see that in the grand scheme of things this is absolutely not in your interest. Again the key characteristic of the emerging world order is the rise of non-Western powers: by supporting Israel's actions, you're effectively setting the rules of engagement for what may be done to you... Also if you're a supremacist, I imagine that you're not very fond of immigration: in Lebanon alone, one million people have already been displaced from their homes by Israel. As is the case with so many wars (remember Syria, Libya, etc.), Israel's actions are triggering yet another immigration crisis. Or think about this: if you're a supremacist you by definition think that Western values are superior... Doesn't it disturb you in the slightest that objectively speaking what Israel is doing violates just about every single one of these values and thereby destroys the very basis of this supposed superiority? That endlessly, from now on, whenever you'll start your spiel about Western superiority, the immediate answer you'll receive is "yeah but Gaza though..."? So all in all, no matter where you come from on this, once you start thinking through it, the larger implications become impossible to ignore. Every one of us bears responsibility for the world we're creating through the actions we let happen. Do we want a world underwritten by "anything goes" and "might makes right", do we want to step into an unprecedently nihilistic order? Or do we want a world with a vision for a shared future for mankind, underwritten by common principles, a world that makes us somewhat proud to be human? That's what's at stake with Israel today.
4
1,287
Peter Schurman retweeted
Good time to remind everyone that Schumer is actively pushing for Section 1217 (the Senate version of Section 219) that permanently entrenches weapons development and deeper intelligence sharing between the US military and IDF while Chris Van Hollen wants to not do those things.
The director of Mossad was just in DC Friday in case you’re wondering where some of this dirty bomb “intel” is coming from
39
1,375
25
3,736
27,229
Peter Schurman retweeted
I first wrote about the genocide of the Rohingyas in Myanmar over a decade ago. Their suffering has finally been recognized by the ICJ which has legally concluded that they did indeed endure the crime of crimes - genocide. Historic. The Myanmar government should be held to account and the Rohingya refugees should not be abandoned or forgotten.
217
1,833
43
9,012
116,780
Potential 2028 candidates and their allies are anxiously twiddling their thumbs, holding off on deciding their plans until Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez decides whether to run. “We’re just all on pause until AOC decides something,” an analyst tells @zeteo_news.zeteo.com/p/aoc-2028-dem-pri…
27
Peter Schurman retweeted
The fastest way to deliver affordability with the power Democrats actually have would be to defund the war in Iran. It’s a bit mind-boggling that Jeffries won’t commit to that after the clear message sent in the election only a few weeks ago.
25
83
2
450
4,148
Peter Schurman retweeted
MEHDI HASAN: Where does your interest, where does your passion on Israel-Palestine come from? DON LEONARD: I mean, I have a PhD in international politics. The Middle East is not my region of specialty, but we try to keep up as best we can. Truth be told, I think it comes from my inner 14-year-old child. I remember the day that I read a fictionalized account of the Holocaust depicting the way in which Auschwitz was organized. And I remember curling up and weeping. I remember the window that I was staring out of, trying to make sense of a world that no longer made sense to me. And in that moment, I swore to my 14-year-old self that if there was ever a human rights atrocity of that scale in my lifetime, and I was in a position to say or do something about it, that I would do it.
“Israel 1.0 is a failed experiment.” Ohio Rep. @DonforOhio tells @mehdirhasan why he won’t vote to sell bombs to Israel, noting the atrocities of the Gaza genocide and Holocaust are on the same “scale.”
18
398
14
1,987
65,720
Peter Schurman retweeted
Meet Gavin Newsom’s nightmare on a 2028 debate stage “If I was Gavin Newsom, the last person I would want on that debate stage calling out the discrepancies in my record would be Ro Khanna,” said Lorena Gonzalez of the California Labor Fed sfstandard.com/2026/11/17/si…
41
36
22
237
22,069
Peter Schurman retweeted
Israel just bulldozed one of the most prosperous Palestinian farms near the Jordan Valley area This farm feeds 10,000s of people, and is a prominent source of food in the area
4,285
28,446
2,255
46,852
1,548,038
Peter Schurman retweeted
Zřícení části Krymského mostu je pro Rusy jen polovina problému. Ano, je to urážlivé, ponižující a nepříjemné, ale ne smrtelné. Ale zřícení oblouku do plavební dráhy a zablokování Azovského moře je mnohem vážnější. Jak je známo, Krymský most byl úspěšně napaden již potřetí. V letech 2022 a 2023 byl také poškozen, ale byl relativně rychle opraven. Současná situace se však zásadně liší od předchozích útoků. Tehdy byly zničeny konvenční automobilové mosty, které mohly být nahrazeny. Nyní se do vody zřítil centrální kovový oblouk automobilové části – konstrukce dlouhá přes 270 metrů a vážící 5 500–6 000 tun. Není to jen kus vozovky, který lze relativně rychle demontovat a nahradit. Oblouk bude muset být nejprve vyjmut z vody a teprve poté bude možné uvažovat o novém. ❗️ Nejvíce znepokojivým aspektem pro Rusko nejsou ani náklady na přestavbu mostu, ani doba, kterou bude oprava úseku silnice trvat. Trosky skončily přímo v Kerčsko-jenikalském průplavu – jediné hlubokomořské lodní trase Kerčským průlivem. Zbývající úseky průlivu jsou příliš mělké pro plavbu velkých obchodních a vojenských lodí. Obejít blokádu pomocí sousedních rozpětí nebude možné. To fakticky blokuje plnohodnotnou velkotonážní lodní dopravu mezi Azovským a Černým mořem. To je rána nejen pro vojenskou logistiku, ale i pro ruskou ekonomiku. Ačkoli Rusko již fakticky zastavilo lodní dopravu na této trase od 10. července po ukrajinských útocích na lodě, na konci října začaly ruské úřady vydávat první povolení pro průjezd lodí s obilím Kerčským průlivem. Nyní se situace ještě více zkomplikovala: i kdyby se Rusko rozhodlo obnovit plavbu, bude muset nejprve vyčistit kanál od tisíců kovových konstrukcí, které jej tížily. Složitost tohoto úkolu je patrná na příkladu Baltimoru v USA. Po zřícení mostu Francis Scott Key v březnu 2024 trvalo americkým záchranným a inženýrským složkám 77 dní, než kompletně obnovily hlavní plavební kanál. Na tento úkol byly nasazeny stovky specialistů, potápěčů, plovoucích jeřábů a další těžké techniky. A to vše proběhlo v době míru, bez hrozby dalších útoků. Podmínky v Kerčském průlivu budou zcela odlišné: jakékoli plovoucí jeřáby, opravárenské lokality a operace na odstraňování trosek by mohly být potenciálně ohroženy dalšími útoky. Obnova automobilového oblouku je mezitím samostatný, několikaměsíční úkol. I po vyčištění kanálu bude muset Rusko vyrobit novou konstrukci, doručit ji na místo instalace a provést složité instalační práce. Nebude možné most rychle obnovit do původního stavu. Je tu však ještě jeden zásadní bod. Železniční část mostu zůstává neporušená, ačkoli i její oblouk byl poškozen. Železnice je obzvláště důležitá pro vojenské zásobování Krymu a ruských vojsk jižním směrem. Silniční dopravu lze částečně přesměrovat na pozemní koridor přes okupovaná území Ukrajiny, ačkoliv tento koridor sám o sobě je pod neustálou hrozbou ukrajinských útoků. Úplná náhrada železničního přejezdu však neexistuje. Současné zničení silničního oblouku proto neznamená trvalé vyřazení Krymského mostu z provozu. Rusku vytvořilo obrovské problémy s lodní dopravou a exportem, ale dokud zůstane železniční složka neporušená, je zachována i důležitá část její dopravní funkce. Závěr je jednoduchý: zřícení silničního oblouku je velkým úspěchem, ale strategicky největšího efektu bude dosaženo až tehdy, když most zcela ztratí svou železniční funkci.
51
297
9
3,013
212,620
A beautiful, elevating, and inspiring interview:
The work of building power continues long after Election Day. I joined Ta-Nehisi Coates for @vanityfair to talk about the South, coalition-building, and the responsibility that comes with winning. You can read the full conversation at the link in my bio.
12
Peter Schurman retweeted
Jake Sullivan broke US laws to give Israel billions in weapons for genocide in Gaza. Now he's cashing in as a board member of an Israeli venture capital outfit. Sick. He has no place in a future admin. Instead, he should be behind bars for aiding genocide. calcalistech.com/ctechnews/a…
45
813
35
2,769
159,513
2028 Presidential Election (On Point Polling) 🟦AOC 49% (+9) 🟥JD Vance 40% 🟦AOC 47% (+8+ 🟥Ron DeSantis 39% 🟦AOC 46% (+5) 🟥Marco Rubio 41% Link: onpointpolitics.substack.com…
13
And for those with an extraordinarily selective short-term memory, let me remind you that Russia has attacked, is attacking, and will continue to attack absolutely anything in Ukraine that it has the resources, weapons, and means to strike, and that it believes it can get away with politically. Bridges, power plants, heating infrastructure, trains, ports, hospitals, supermarkets, gas stations, warehouses, schools, bomb shelters, residential buildings, cultural monuments, sewage systems, water supplies, and everything else. Russia has been doing this for years, both when Ukraine could not even dream of carrying out the slightest strikes on Russian territory and now, when Ukraine has dramatically expanded its own capabilities and regularly strikes back at Russia. There is no magic formula for Ukraine that goes, "We won't strike Russian X so that Russia won't strike our X." Russia couldn't care less about any "gentlemen's rules." It attacks everything within its constantly expanding ability to strike targets in Ukraine, especially as it develops capabilities such as cheap, mass-produced jet-powered drones and light missiles, or as opportunities arise from Ukraine's crippling shortage of air defenses against Russian ballistic missiles. No, the Russians will not suddenly become nice and well-behaved if we fold our hands and tremble in fear of daring to strike anything on Russian territory. They will exploit their impunity to the fullest and kill and destroy as much as they possibly can.
35
605
13
2,467
43,655
Peter Schurman retweeted
Ukraine hit the Kerch bridge with weapons systems that did not exist in 2022. The Ukrainian army and the Ukrainian military industry are now the most important source of security in Europe.
Grateful to the Security Service of Ukraine, all units of Ukraine’s Defense Forces involved, Ukraine’s Minister of Defense, the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces of Ukraine and the General Staff, and all our weapons manufacturers for an unprecedented operation in response to Russian strikes on our infrastructure. Today, everyone can see the consequences for the main military crossing from Russian territory into our Ukrainian Crimea. This is the result of the seventh stage of an operation carried out over several weeks, developed and coordinated by the Security Service of Ukraine together with the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine. Our warriors gradually destroyed air defense systems, radars, electronic warfare equipment, and other designated targets on the way to the final objective. For this, they used “Dovbush,” “Vendetta,” “Da Vinci,” “Sichen,” “Mich-2000,” “Ruta,” “Palianytsia,” “An-197,” “FP-1,” “FP-5 Flamingo,” and “R-360 Neptune.” Today, at the key stage, the “Palianytsia” drones performed exceptionally well, striking the road section of the bridge, while “Neptune” missiles, “Ruta” drones, and FP-5 drones struck the railway section. Using “Flamingo,” our warriors carried out a precision-guided strike – and the communications uplink worked flawlessly until the very last seconds. We have repeatedly offered Russia steps toward de-escalation – and every proposal has been met with loud rejection. Russia strikes our infrastructure every day, including bridges in Zaporizhzhia, Dnipro, Kyiv, and the Odesa region. We are restoring our infrastructure. But we are also reminding Russia that war will always return to where it began. Ukraine’s defensive capabilities are strong and will remain so, and we will never leave terror against our cities and people unanswered. I thank the true warriors of the Security Service of Ukraine, all our Defense Forces, our intelligence agencies, and EVERY manufacturer of weapons effectively used to defend Ukraine, Ukrainians, and our national interests. Glory to Ukraine!
95
2,225
50
8,032
114,091
Peter Schurman retweeted
... already being delivered and paid for by the citizenry – as in fact is the case with health services – there are no new total dollars or total resources involved. Every dollar that government spends on health relieves us, the public, of dollars that we would have spent on ...
3
26
776
54,262
Peter Schurman retweeted
The Pentagon has been lying to you. @SecWar has been lying to you. It's shocking to me that more media are not picking up this @60Minutes story today.
60 Minutes analysis of satellite imagery and new video shows the scale of destruction the Pentagon has never fully disclosed. Since the start of the war, Iran has hit at least 31 U.S. military and diplomatic sites across eight countries. cbsn.ws/4zP7T04
117
5,129
73
11,881
138,837
Peter Schurman retweeted
BREAKING: 75% of MoveOn members, out of more than 33,000 votes cast, voted to endorse Sen. @ChrisVanHollen for majority leader.
14
233
5
990
13,048
Peter Schurman retweeted
Caolan is doing an amazing job exposing just how deep Russian influence is in the EU and it has to end once and for all.
Every sign at this refinery in Ireland is in russian. The official website is a .RU domain. There’s no reason to hide it because local politicians are openly doing it for them.
80
1,447
14
7,091
105,160