Siôn Pryce (@PryceSion) header
Siôn Pryce (@PryceSion) profile picture

🇺🇸🇱🇺🇩🇪

Colorado, USA
Joined April 2024
Photo by Siôn Pryce (@PryceSion)Photo by Siôn Pryce (@PryceSion)Photo by Siôn Pryce (@PryceSion)Photo by Siôn Pryce (@PryceSion)Photo by Siôn Pryce (@PryceSion)Photo by Siôn Pryce (@PryceSion)Photo by Siôn Pryce (@PryceSion)Photo by Siôn Pryce (@PryceSion)Photo by Siôn Pryce (@PryceSion)Photo by Siôn Pryce (@PryceSion)
Another one bites the dust! @BaptistBen316
1
1
189
This is a selective history of Christianity. Filioque: Yes, the phrase was added later to the Latin Creed. Catholics freely acknowledge that. But the theology was not invented then. Long before the schism, the Latin and Alexandrian traditions spoke of the Spirit’s relation to the Father through or with the Son. Even Catholic teaching recognizes the Eastern formula “from the Father through the Son” as legitimate. Papacy: First-millennium Christians did not treat Rome as merely one interchangeable bishopric. At Chalcedon, Leo’s Tome was acclaimed with “Peter has spoken through Leo,” and the council subsequently sought Leo’s ratification of its disciplinary acts. Exactly how Roman primacy functioned is debated between Catholics and Orthodox, but pretending the first millennium knew only a ceremonial “primacy of honor” is much too simple. Purgatory: The later terminology developed. The underlying belief did not appear from nowhere. Christians prayed and offered the Eucharist for the dead from antiquity because they believed those prayers could benefit them. Catholics call the postmortem purification of the saved “purgatory.” Baptism and Chrismation: This one is particularly weak. Catholicism itself contains Eastern Churches that baptize, chrismate, and communicate infants together. Rome acknowledges that the West separated Confirmation from Baptism as a disciplinary development, principally to preserve the bishop’s role. That is a difference in sacramental discipline, not a different faith. The chalice: Again, discipline, not doctrine. Catholics believe Christ is wholly present under either species, and the Latin Church today permits the laity to receive under both kinds. Clerical celibacy: This is not even Catholic dogma. It is Latin discipline. Catholic Eastern Churches ordain married men to the priesthood today. So half your list consists of disciplinary differences that Catholicism itself never claimed were immutable apostolic dogmas, while the rest involves genuine theological disputes whose roots extend deep into the first millennium. And there is a bigger problem with the “Orthodoxy never changed” argument: development itself cannot prove apostasy. Eastern Christianity also developed its terminology, canon law, liturgical practices, and theological formulations over centuries. The actual question is whether later developments contradict the apostolic deposit or legitimately articulate it more precisely. Simply labeling every Western development an “innovation” while treating Eastern development as “preservation” assumes the very conclusion you need to prove.
The Roman Catholic Church strayed from the faith of the undivided Church. It altered the Nicene Creed by adding the Filioque — “and the Son” — without an Ecumenical Council. It transformed the Pope’s ancient primacy of honour into universal jurisdiction over the whole Church, then formally declared papal infallibility at the First Vatican Council in 1870. Rome also introduced doctrines unknown to the ancient Church, including purgatory, indulgences and the Immaculate Conception. It separated baptism from chrismation, withheld the chalice from the laity and imposed compulsory clerical celibacy in the Latin Church. These were not the beliefs and practices of the undivided Church of the first millennium. They were later Roman innovations. The Eastern Orthodox Church has preserved the faith of the Apostles, the teachings of the Fathers, the ancient liturgy and the authority of the Seven Ecumenical Councils. It has retained the original Creed and rejected the idea that one bishop can rule the entire Church or define doctrine apart from the councils. Orthodoxy is not a new denomination that appeared after Rome. It is the continuation of the ancient Catholic Church founded by Christ and His Apostles. Rome departed from the ancient Church. Orthodoxy remained faithful to it. Sources: Orthodox Church in America: oca.org/questions/history/th… oca.org/questions/otherconfe… Greek Orthodox Archdiocese: goarch.org/introduction-arti… goarch.org/-/the-fundamental… Orthodox Patriarchal Encyclical of 1895: sangiulio.org/holy-canons/th… Orthodox theological response: theorthodoxchurch.org/resour…
2
1
2
340
Correct. And if you think you cannot lose salvation, you have to explain the warnings Scripture gives Christians. “Let anyone who thinks that he stands take heed lest he fall.” 1 Cor. 10:12 “The one who endures to the end will be saved.” Matt. 24:13 “If we deny him, he also will deny us.” 2 Tim. 2:12 Hebrews even warns those who have “shared in the Holy Spirit” about falling away. Heb. 6:4–6 So yes, eternal security may be Reformed theology. That does not make it biblical.
If you think you can lose your salvation, you are not Reformed.
1
4
165
Another one bites the dust.
98
Another one bites the dust.
2
191
Alaska is another planet
1
102
I had no idea there were so many middle aged women out there just learning to drive.
1
1
119
Replying to @MichelleDLesley
@MichelleDLesley Here’s my reply since you’ve revoked my ability to reply. Quoting Scripture doesn’t make your personal interpretation God’s judgment. The devil quoted Scripture too (Matt 4:6).
2
30
USAID tells staff only a few hundred will be retained. This is a good start! Looking forward to hearing about the DOJ, FBI, USSS, IRS and DOE, etc. ft.com/content/92c8514d-1075…
27