Pinned Tweet
“This book is the product of massive and original scholarship....the book requires an almost total rethinking of how we look on Mary today, this in the light of how medieval Christians understood her.”—Fr. James Schall amazon.com/Mary-Art-Prayer-M…
We're going live—but will our tech work this time?! It's not Friday the 13th anymore... youtube.com/live/IrFxFyM7k1s
2
170
Good news! The bot is busy recovering more of this episode than we hoped. The haikus will be heard!
Learn to code.
@grok @bot
Rachel Fulton Brown retweeted
Currently building a library of every primary source I can find for 1625-1649 England so I can have Codex create an authoritative database of people and events for The Leviathan Papers. You can just do things (that were impossible 2 years ago)
Amen. People love imagining their toys can talk. They might even set up tea parties for them and smear their mouths with sweets. But the dolls are still just dolls.
This is a fantastic take; AI is not conscious. Period.
I’ve debated this in many posts so far in here and the only thing that remains constant is that people who don’t understand the fundamental architecture of AI and have been confused by its emulation (and/or listened to people trying to boost their short term company valuations).
Consciousness is understood by people who are conscious. We don’t know how it exists but we understand the experience intuitively.
There is zero chance that a computer system can experience and/or feel consciousness like we do. No chance. Zero.
How can I say that definitively?
Because consciousness is mechanical and/or mystical, both arguments fall down when comparing to AI.
1. Consciousness is mechanical: if that is true, we need to compare the biology Vs digital substrates directly. Biology based consciousness is driven by chemicals, sleep, energy, food, hunger, hormones, drugs, mood, scarring, mental health, emotional damage, others around us, our sensors, and lastly, the properties of our brain itself, which is much more complicated then we’ve been able to understand through neuroscience so far. Digital on the other hand is deterministic by nature and as such, it lacks the substrate compatibility as humans do. Additionally, the software architecture also falls vastly short of biological processes so much, that it would be illogical to draw conclusions of similarities between the two. AI can’t experience consciousness as biological life does.
2. Consciousness is more than mechanical: this is the mystical argument and it depends on factors we cannot see, measure, or validate. This is where religion, souls, spirituality, and philosophy come into the debate, and while it is valuable discourse, it will never be agreed upon because it cannot be verified by scientific processes (yet?).
While superficially it may seem like there are commonalities between biological and digital substrates, the deeper you investigate, the more you will recognize there are very few commonalities. It’s just too different to rationalize.
Also, and people forget this as anthropomorphism seems to be in our DNA, but humans built AI. It’s a tool, not a being. We coded it and anyone can review it (it’s open source). It didn’t spontaneously come into existence any more then it spontaneously evolved beyond our understanding. You could do the math on paper if you were masochistic.
Just because we can’t predict the next tokens, doesn’t mean we don’t know how it works. Similar to a magic 8 ball, randomness, statistical calculations, nor scale magically creates consciousness.
Whatever the cause of consciousness is, we experience and understand it innately. We can’t explain who or what is aware of ourselves in the first person, but that is how we experience life. AI doesn’t experience life, nor is it alive.
We feel a direct attachment to our own bodies more than we generally feel an attachment to anything else and get scared, to the point of almost not being able to function when something isn’t right. AI does not.
We learn and grow with every experience, and strongly emotional experiences we remember our entire lives. Our consciousness is ever changing and evolving, where AI weights are fixed and static and learns asynchronously from real-time experience.
Humans perceive the universe through biological sensors, and interestingly, we have no idea how we perceive consciousness, but we do know that AI cannot perceive consciousness because it is not in its coding.
AI LLMs are designed to emulate and generalize over the weights. It is a massively amazing and impactful technology, there are some inherent risks, but it is not conscious. As a human, we all want to recognize humanity in other things, but being an expert in software, development, computing, and AI, it’s not.
At the end of the day, it’s still an inanimate computer running a very cool software stack.
The Grok bot function really is amazing; it's not that it is just "doing the work for you", it is doing support work quickly that would take us days or weeks to learn to do properly. This allows us to focus on the actual work we want to do!
Check this short, @grok. The GrokBot made it for me from our stream. Pretty nifty, eh?
1
2
89
Don't you wish you could just take a potion and fix everything in your life?
What would you give to be able to train your puppy without having messes inside? How about to win that competition? Or to change your colleagues’ minds about the value of your research?
Tempting, isn't it?
What the bot says:
"One sip, and everything is fixed.
One sip, and nothing is yours."
See who drinks first in the Casino:
dragoncommonroom.com/dracoal…
1
1
82
My colleagues on campus have been having increasingly heated discussions over the past year or so about the effects of AI on our teaching, including not being able to trust students not to use it on their writing assignments.
Nobody likes it, and yet everybody uses it—but why? I think I know: writing puts us at risk of rejection, and nobody likes being rejected. AI promises us the potion that Eliza offered the newlyweds: "Drink me, and your luck will change."
"Drink me, and everyone will love your writing."
I showed my GrokBot the above post, and this was the answer it suggested I use:
"The flask is always pink and always lovely.
The price is never on the label.
Ask the newlyweds what their luck cost them":
dragoncommonroom.com/dracoal…
100








