Using AI to vibe-code a game or contest layer on top of your loyalty program? If so, you may have recruited thousands of members hunting for cheats and exploit.
What AI-built loyalty games still need: thewisemarketer.com/welcome-…
#Gamification #LoyaltyPrograms
1
24
We paused a gamified campaign for 5 months. Engagement fell 94%. Coupon redemptions fell 70%. Sales didn’t move.
4 years, 6.5M data points, one national loyalty program. Engagement vs sales: p = 0.84.
What explained sales instead (63% of variation): medium.com/design-bootcamp/i…
8
Steve Bocska retweeted
These networks just walked right into Trump’s trap, which is hilarious.
Everyone knows the White House does not decide what the press reports or publishes. Nobody is arguing that.
The ban is because these networks spent years telling you Trump called Nazis ‘fine people’ When nothing like that ever happened, and it got Trump shot in the head. That lie even played a part in Charlie’s murder as it created a foundation for visceral MAGA hate.
All eyes are on these media outlets as they just walked into a lawsuit trap.
I’ve long argued Trump needs to drop the video of his full Charlottesville statement so the world can see he actually condemned the Nazis that day.
But now it seems as if he’s waiting for court…
🍿
Thread: What 1,407 days of loyalty program data taught me about engagement metrics 🧵
1/ The engagement-drives-revenue assumption is so baked into product metrics that nobody tests it. I tested it. p = 0.84. No relationship.
2/ But when I modeled the full ecosystem (coupon habits, loyalty points, participation rates) R² jumped from 0.125 to 0.633. Engagement doesn't drive sales. It builds the infrastructure that does.
3/ The diminishing returns were brutal. 4x engagement = 72% less revenue per action. Game designers call this "grind." The loyalty industry calls it success.
4/ Midway through, campaigns stopped for 5 months. Engagement dropped 94%. Sales barely moved. The ecosystem has inertia (but engagement does not!).
5/ Full writeup on @Bootcamp_UXC:
medium.com/design-bootcamp/i…
12
Four years, 6.5M engagement actions on a retail loyalty program.
Then campaigns went dark for 5 months. Engagement fell 94%. Sales barely moved.
The ecosystem data explained what engagement couldn't.
medium.com/design-bootcamp/i…
2
12
I spent 4 years measuring engagement in a national loyalty program. 6.5M data points.
The correlation between engagement and sales? p = 0.84. Basically zero.
But the ecosystem engagement built explained 63% of sales variation!!
We've been measuring the wrong thing.
medium.com/design-bootcamp/i…
11
PLEASE tell us you have plans to reopen an amazing new expanded, state of the art worldclass 6-screen location somewhere in the metroplex soon?
Please??? 😢
@CoyoteDriveIn
10
Steve Bocska retweeted
🚨STOP SCROLLING: Everyone Should Bear Witness To This Savage TAKEDOWN of Dr. Fauci by Senator Josh Hawley.
Watch as he DECIMATES Fauci and makes him SQUIRM in his seat.
This is how all of our Representatives and Senators in Congress should act.
Total MASTERCLASS
Spend-based tiers are lazy design:
"Spend $5,000 and you're Gold!" doesn't foster a lasting reciprocal relationship.
The strongest tiers reflect identity - who customers are, how they participate, and what they contribute.
#LoyaltyGame #CX
10
Your best customers are not hunting for a 10% coupon.
What they want is recognition, status, and the feeling that their loyalty actually registers somewhere.
Most programs optimize for the bottom of the pyramid and neglect the very top.
1
Customers don't remember transactions. They remember stories!
Without narrative, every brand interaction is an isolated event. With narrative, they become a journey worth continuing.
Game designers (like me) have always known this.
4
My MBA professor Ron Mitchell built a framework with four forces: traction, friction, slippage, and glide.
I spent 24 years applying it to video games. The loyalty industry spent the same 24 years ignoring it.
McDonald's double-charges customers. Kroger requires 20 min/week of coupon clipping. Starbucks made their program so complex that earned stars evaporate.
Domino's and Chick-fil-A figured it out. Full breakdown:
linkedin.com/pulse/your-loya…
#Loyalty #CX #Gamification
15
Entertainment is passive, but engagement is *participatory*. Most loyalty teams can't tell the difference!
Here's the analogy: Watching a brand video is entertainment. Earning your way through a challenge is engagement. One gets attention. The other earns commitment.
4
Discounts erode margin. But engagement? It protects it!
Customers pay more for brands they feel connected to. Meaning reshapes value perception. Always has.
Every game designer understands this: connection creates economic leverage.
3
Most loyalty programs vanish the moment the receipt prints. If the only time you show up is when you want money then all you've got is a transaction dressed up as a relationship.
Game designers build worlds people return to between sessions. Brands should do the same!!
16
Personality creates familiarity. Familiarity creates trust. Trust creates preference. Preference is the foundation of loyalty.
Most loyalty architects have never mapped that progression. Game designers map it instinctively.
🎥 The Loyalty Game
3
Every loyalty platform promises deeper engagement. But customers still feel like they're talking to software. Characters create relationships. Systems process transactions.
Every game designer learns this on day one.
5




