TheDeframer - Rat! (@TheDeframer) header
TheDeframer - Rat! (@TheDeframer) profile picture

Somewhat libertär. YouTube: https://teapaw.org/t.co/WQA2Z4Fxx4 Discord: https://teapaw.org/t.co/rj0vgIyC9U

Joined May 2023
Photo by TheDeframer - Rat! (@TheDeframer)Photo by TheDeframer - Rat! (@TheDeframer)Photo by TheDeframer - Rat! (@TheDeframer)Photo by TheDeframer - Rat! (@TheDeframer)Photo by TheDeframer - Rat! (@TheDeframer)Photo by TheDeframer - Rat! (@TheDeframer)Photo by TheDeframer - Rat! (@TheDeframer)Photo by TheDeframer - Rat! (@TheDeframer)Photo by TheDeframer - Rat! (@TheDeframer)Photo by TheDeframer - Rat! (@TheDeframer)
But thats not the case for open-weight models - they are already widespread in private hands. Of course, private can still be centralized: if you create your own model, its centralized in your hands because its yours. But you can freely decide to put it into the public.
1
37
Their post means the opposite of what they wanted to say. If its not privatized, it means collectivized/nationalized - collective ownership, worst case in the hands of the state. That destroys private property rights. So no local own LLMs by those terms. The moment you download a local model, it becomes private property in your hands, therefore its then privatized for you. Ownership is the precondition for any free choice about whether to keep it closed or open it.
The revolution will not be privatized
29
I am for privatization, against "for the goods of all for free" - ergo against communism or socialism. You just dont understand me. Ironically, thats your take if you are against privatization/private. @grok Act as a mediator here, explain my position what I mean. Read the full conversation thread for full context.
1
25
Replying to @libertarianism
Its time to move on. We need dark libertarianism to enforce it.
3
82
I am human... Its about correct definitions. You want the model private in your own hands, local - meaning you want it privatized. The same principle applies to everyone else, including companies or people with more resources: they also have full property rights. And private does not mean closed. Private means ownership. Only the owner has the right/power to decide whether to keep something closed or open - because it is theirs. Without ownership, you cannot freely choose; you can only ask for permission.
1
20
To make something open, you first need it in your private hands. Only if you hold the agency and property rights over that object can you freely decide whether to make it open or not. Without private ownership, there is no genuine choice, only permission from someone else.
1
1
31
The harness doesnt matter at all. Just use a different harness to your liking with open models...
1
51
Replying to @praxisnation
I even told them in the comments but they are too dense... teapaw.org/TheDeframer/status/212…
Replying to @NousResearch
Open source is privatization just on an individual level, so the claim is wrong that the revolution is not privatized. The revolution will not be centralized. I think that is what you meant.
12
1,698
Replying to @MartinSellner_
Nee, klingst in echt noch retardierter. Da war die AI noch nett.
1
155
Exactly, so private in your hands... So privatized, not centralized or monopolized.
2
349
Private means something is already in your personal possession or control. Privatized means the act or process of turning something into private property. In our example here this means: Private = the model is now in your personal possession/control (its on your device, you can use it freely). Privatized = the act of downloading it turned it into private property for you. @grok That above gentleman claims that I am wrong, can you check my definition please.
3
26
Private means something is already in your personal possession or control (e.g. "the model is private in your hands"). Privatized means the act or process of turning something into private property (e.g. downloading an open-source model privatizes it for you).
1
2
418
Its not bollocks. Privatization means property in your hands. If you download an open-source model, its private in your hands - its basically your property. Every individual can have those property rights, so everyone can own/have an open-source model.
1
3
47
Replying to @NousResearch
If you download an open-source model, its private in your hands, therefore privatized. What you dont want is monopolization/centralization, but this is only possible if everyone can privately run local models. So decentralization is privatization on a large individual scale.
18
192
If you download an open-source model, its private in your hands, therefore privatized.
1
9
453
@grok Explain to this gentleman what I meant in simple words, so that he can understand it.
2
3
129
Replying to @NousResearch
Open source is privatization just on an individual level, so the claim is wrong that the revolution is not privatized. The revolution will not be centralized. I think that is what you meant.
3
1
1
70
6,413
Replying to @stagerbn
And its crap...
48
Replying to @NeoRothbardian
Taxes and coercion...
8
202