
A daily Pittsburgh Pirates column authored by @GMBCSuperfan. Every morning at 7am-ish. A “Good Morning Bucco Community” production #letsgobucs #WinterofBen
Joined May 2026
- Tweets362
- Following1.1K
- Followers1.1K
- Likes3.2K
Henry Davis: Pirates A-to-Z
Five years ago, the Pirates had the first overall pick in the 2021 draft and selected a power-hitting catcher whose bat was so impressive that they were willing to overlook concerns about his defense.
Fast forward to 2026 and Henry Davis has become one of the best defensive catchers in baseball. The bat? He left it behind as an agreement with the bridge troll who granted his wish to be a defensive whiz kid.
It’s a pretty remarkable and frustrating transformation, one that nobody saw coming. And now… what?
It feels like some big changes are coming for the Pirates at catcher and where Hank ends up in it is anyone’s guess.
Revisiting the Origin Story
Davis grew up in Bedford, NY just north of NYC, which is weird because I don’t picture him as a northerner. Somehow he ended up attending Louisville where he developed into one of the country’s top college hitters. In 2021, he hit .370/.482/.663 with 15 HR in 50 games, earning All-American honors.
The Pirates selected him first overall as an underslot pick that allowed them to grab Bubba Chandler and Lonnie White Jr. as well. There were questions about his receiving, but he possessed a cannon arm and was considered an exceptionally hard worker.
Davis moved quickly through the minors, putting up a .979 OPS across AA and AAA in 2023 before debuting in Pittsburgh that June. His bat was getting him promoted, but continued questions about his receiving skills had him playing 49 games in RF for the Pirates, a position he had never played and where his defense was laughably bad.
If the goal was to get his big bat in the lineup, that effort failed. He put up a .653 OPS in 255 PA with 7 HR, which at the time felt like such a disappointment and yet would be his offensive high point as a Bucco. It was all downhill from there.
Davis batted a paltry .144 in 2024, getting sent back to AAA after 37 games where he continued crushing minor league pitching. The following season, he returned as a full-time catcher and hit .169 with eight HR in 87 games. But something unexpected happened along the way -- Hank became really, really good behind the plate.
Looking Back at 2026
Bridge trolls are tricky that way. They grant you a wish, but you always end up regretting it somehow. The parable is meant to teach you to be happy with what you have. But for Davis, his inability to hit at the major league level meant he needed a signature skill to justify playing time. Hence the glove.
As Paul Skenes’ personal caddy, Davis was guaranteed at least a backup catcher role to start the year. To serve as starter, he’d need to prove he could hit. But instead, he somehow managed to get worse offensively. In 97 games, Davis put up a .585 OPS.
I did a Weird on Paper that I’ll link in the replies that analyzed his bizarre Statcast data. Davis has become a dead pull hitter whose sweet-spot % is among the worst in the game. In 2026 he was making better contact than before, reducing his K-rate and improving his BB-rate, but the contact he was making was putrid.
Meanwhile, the defense was legitimately outstanding. Davis caught 745 innings, accumulating 8 DRS and throwing out 17 of 37 attempted base stealers, a 45.9% success rate that led baseball. Opposing teams learned -- you don't run on Davis, period.
His throws averaged 85.6 mph, the strongest arm among MLB catchers, and his framing and blocking had improved considerably. He’d become a completely different player from the guy whose questionable defense once caused the Pirates to stick him in the OF.
It wasn’t enough to keep him from losing starts to Endy Rodriguez, whose .840 OPS demonstrated what a productive catcher could contribute offensively. But Endy’s season ended with hip surgery, reopening the door for Davis.
By September, Rafael Flores Jr. had also emerged as an offensive option, hitting .264 with 11 HR in just 47 games. Suddenly, the Pirates had three catchers with very different strengths and weaknesses.
On the Horizon – 2027 & Beyond
So what do you do with this conundrum of a player? Well, for starters, you keep him around. Davis is entering his first arbitration year, with a projected salary around $2M. That’s reasonable for a defensive specialist who handles your pitching staff so effectively.
The problem is how the catching position will be configured in 2027. Rodriguez is recovering from hip surgery that will likely keep him out for awhile, and his defense was so iffy, one wonders if he has a future in Pittsburgh. Flores is the best offensive option of the three, but his defense also remains a work in progress.
That suggests Davis could open 2027 splitting time with Flores while continuing to catch Skenes. And if that’s the plan, I’d be okay with it as a temporary solution. We have Easton Carmichael and Axiel Plaz on the come up through the system, and either one (or both) could be ready by 2028.
I’m also wondering if GM Ben Cherington has a major acquisition in the making. There was chatter at the trade deadline about the Pirates exploring the availability of Hunter Goodman, the 40+ HR-hitting catcher from the Rockies. Adding that sort of offensive production would be a shot in the arm.
Except, would it surprise you to know that Pirates catchers hit 29 HR with a .741 OPS combined last season? That was production while playing catcher, not as DH or 1B. Davis contributed 10 HR to that total.
Throwing a monkey wrench into any acquisition plans was the emergence of Flores who added 9 of his 11 HR at backstop. If you see him as providing production approximating Goodman, pairing him with Davis could be a fine bridge to the future. Goodman's defense is only rated as decent.
Either way, Davis will turn 28 next season. His days of being viewed as a developing prospect are behind him. I predict 2027 is the year he becomes cemented as an outstanding defensive backup with occasional power. There are worse things to be.
A Final Word
I wonder whether being the first overall pick has become something of an albatross for Davis. If he’d been drafted in the 6th round, we’d probably be celebrating his emergence as an elite defensive catcher who hits the occasional bomb into the LF stands.
That draft has been under the microscope since it happened, and ultimately may be judged as much on how the cost savings on Davis brought other players into the system. That’s a bummer, especially for people who've been big fans of his along the way.
Which brings me to this: it’s hard to cover Davis for this series and not also comment on his X counterpart, @NotHankDave, who was unceremoniously banned from the platform as part of a recent purge. Despite it being right in his name, that he is NOT Hank Dave, he doesn’t seem to be on the platform anymore as a result of… "impersonating a professional baseball player?" Or something?
And that’s a disappointment. He was one of my favorite knuckleheads and I found his fandom of Davis to be oddly endearing. I hope he comes back.
#LetsGoBucs
8
13
750
What do you get the guy who has everything?
Well, if you're buying for @NotHankDave, the only answer is a personalized message from his namesake.
Our boy is a bit Henry Davis obsessed, and greeted us all season long with a daily forecast: "Sunny with a chance of HANK."
Well, today is his lucky day. If you aren't already following his account, I encourage it. During the season, he posts "things to watch for" ahead of games that are fun and informative.
In the offseason? Pure chaos.
Where would we be without him? I don't want to know.
#letsgobucs #WinterofHankDave
2
49
Hank Davis Joins the Double-Digit Home Run Club
Henry Davis hit his 10th home run yesterday, a towering flyball to the opposite field that sailed deep into the right field stands… who am I kidding? We all know the drill. It was yet another screaming line drive pulled down the left field line, barely staying fair. It’s just what he does.
We’ve previously covered Davis’ truly bizarre approach to hitting that has resulted in a .164/.264/.295 line that is every bit as awful as it looks. And far from a bad season, the line is basically spot on his four-year career average: .176/.263/.295 across 943 plate appearances. It’s just what he does,
But now he joins six other Pirates as hitters with 10 or more HRs, providing just a glimpse of the hitter this former 1.1 draft pick could have been. He remains one of the more confounding players from this era of Pirates baseball, frustrating with the bat even as he impresses with the glove.
It’s. Just. What. He. Does.
Stacking Up League-Wide
With a wRC+ of just 55, Davis is 48th out of 50 major league catchers with at least 200 PA this season. Thank God for Drew Romo and Carlos Narvaez who are saving Davis at least that dubious distinction.
Why do we continue to run this guy out there? Can his defense really be that good?
Actually, yes, it can. By that same standard of 200 PA, Davis is tied for the 5th best DRS in baseball at +7 just behind Dillon Dingler and Luis Torrens at +11. By Fangraphs’ Def statistic, which measures a player's total defensive value relative to a league-average fielder, Davis ranks 12th out of 50 with 10.4. His 47% caught stealing percentage is among the best in MLB.
Offense from the Catcher Position in 2026
One would think the sacrifice of offense for defense with Davis means the Pirates’ offensive output from the position would be poor, but it’s surprisingly not.
The catcher position actually ranks third on the Pirates in total HR for the season with 27, just behind 2B with 29 and RF with 28. While actively serving as catcher, five players have combined to put up a 111 OPS+ with a .224/.316/.416 line along with 80 RBI.
Balancing out Davis’ anemic bat have been primarily Endy Rodriguez (.924 OPS, 7 HR in 133 PA as C) and Rafael Flores Jr. (also a .924 OPS, 7 HR in 97 PA as C), whose near-identical output have largely mitigated Davis’ weak bat. And vice-versa, Davis’ sterling defense makes up for so-so defense from Flores and pretty bad defense from Endy.
Rounding out the position this season was Joey Bart (.688 OPS, 4 HR in 119 PA as catcher). He was sent packing fairly early on, and that really made a big difference, creating an opportunity for the others. And who could forget Shawn Ross, the wee willy winky who added a HR of his own in his lone start.
They all combine to create a pretty formidable 162 game player. I dare say, we should be overjoyed to have a collection of catchers putting up a combined .732 OPS with 27 HR annually. The last time the Pirates achieved that was… never? The 1930s maybe? I don’t even know how to look that up, but the position mustered just a .605 OPS last year with 11 HR.
Looking to the Future
Are we potentially watching Davis’ final games as a Pittsburgh Pirate? I wonder, really.
I’m actually pretty partial to him as I’m quite taken with his glove. A really above average defensive catcher is pretty rare to find, and Davis is a leader on the field. He has roughly half as many base stealing attempts made on him over the average catcher. I have no doubt those 20-30 additional steals would have had a real impact.
All that said, his offensive output is what it is -- he’s performing to career norms. And it’s not sufficient. It just isn’t. I’m torn between the devil and angel on my shoulders.
At the trade deadline, a rumor was let slip that suggested Ben Cherington was inquiring about All-Star Rockies catcher Hunter Goodman, a guy with an .841 OPS and 38 HR on the season. Could you imagine?
Goodman is not as strong defensively with a -1 DRS, but the trade off for offense would be pretty extraordinary. If nothing else, the fact that Cherington is exploring the marketplace suggests some changes might be coming this offseason.
The Bottom Line 📌
Selecting Davis 1.1 meant the Pirates could sign Bubba Chandler and Lonnie White Jr., and so his being drafted can always be thought of in positive terms, even if he never fulfills his promise.
But in a season that has seen injuries plague the team, it’s interesting to see how this collection of catchers combined to provide such prodigious offense AND defense from the catcher position.
We probably shouldn’t bank on the stars aligning in 2027. We probably should think about moving on from Davis and acquiring a better-hitting catcher to pair with Flores, who is definitely having a breakout season offensively.
I mean, probably. Right?
#letsgobucs
20
Replying to @The_EarlyShift @GMBCSuperfan
Henry Davis: Weird on Paper
I have been one of Henry Davis’ strongest defenders for awhile now. I think his defense at catcher is some of the best we’ve seen at backstop since the heady days of Russell Martin and Francisco Cervelli. I think he handles our pitchers well and is a good clubhouse guy.
But his utter inability to hit outweighs the positives, and his time as a starter needs to end. He is a defensive backup only, and that’s a fine outcome for him.
Endy Rodriguez recently rejoined the Pirates and has been a dynamic addition to the lineup. His two hits and a walk in last night’s 7-0 blanking of the Cardinals was the sort of contribution from the bottom of the lineup we have so desperately needed.
The Pirates have slid to barely above .500 of late, and that has everything to do with a failing bullpen. It isn’t a direct result of Davis’ .137 batting average. But if we’re looking holistically for ways to improve, last night shows that even a moderate hitting catcher matters.
That’s my official stance, and I’m sticking to it -- Davis to backup -- no matter what I say the rest of this column.
A Completely Bizarre Statcast Profile
The funny thing about Davis is that if you glance at just the top half of the Statcast page, you assume you’re looking at a hitter who can’t make contact. The outcomes are disastrous -- 13th percentile xwOBA, 8th percentile xBA, and 10th percentile xSLG -- the exact profile you’d expect from a player drowning in strikeouts and chasing everything outside the zone.
Except that’s not what the rest of the page says. Like, at all. Davis owns a 71st percentile Whiff rate, a 69th percentile strikeout rate, and a 60th percentile walk rate. I haven’t looked, but I’d bet these either lead the team or are in the top-3 of regulars.
The next surprise comes when you look at the quality of contact. Davis’ 90.3 mph average exit velocity sits in the 66th percentile, and his 7.9% barrel rate is almost exactly league average. Those aren’t the numbers of a hitter batting .137.
Yet somehow they coexist with a 3rd-percentile Sweet Spot rate, one of the worst marks in baseball. When Davis makes contact, he’s often hitting the ball hard enough, but he’s rarely hitting it at productive launch angles.
Instead of line drives and driven fly balls, the profile suggests a steady diet of topped balls, rolled-over grounders and pop ups. It’s the exact production we’ve seen from him all season long.
I’ve frankly never seen a Statcast page like this. It’s… extraordinarily weird.
And This is the Offensively-Improved Henry Davis
Last year, Davis had one of the worst K % and Whiff % on the team. He was an automatic out of a different variety, rarely making contact. This year, he’s making contact, but it’s awful contact that is just as much of an automatic out.
In some ways, Davis’ Statcast profile for 2026 is the offensive inverse of our most recent Weird on Paper subject, Spencer Horwitz.
Horwitz produces despite underwhelming raw power metrics because his elite swing decisions and contact quality allow him to maximize every plate appearance. He hit one that squeaked out last night, and I’d bet he didn’t even get credit for a barrel. He would be superhuman with Davis’ even average barrel rate.
Davis, on the other hand, looks to the viewer like he’s just unlucky with hard-hit foul balls, but the underlying data suggests a flaw in his swing that directly contributes to his poor outcomes.
He’s not unlucky. This is production by design.
The Bottom Line 📌
Davis appears broken, with off-season tinkering that attempted to “fix” some aspects of his past failings, but with an Achilles heel that ultimately makes success utterly elusive.
His poor launch angles remind one of another defensive darling who couldn’t hit enough to stay a Pirate: Ke’Bryan Hayes. And like Hayes, I have continued making excuses for years believing that, given enough time, reversion to the mean for Davis will happen, must happen.
But that day never comes. And like Hayes, I fear Davis will simply never be an even average hitter. After nearly 800 professional plate appearances, it’s time to face that fact.
Davis would be a fine backup catcher and caddy to Paul Skenes. And heck, maybe he does figure it out someday. He’s a hard worker.
But counting on that to happen in real time is contributing to a dead zone at the bottom of the lineup, and that needs to be no longer acceptable.
1
18
Khristian Curtis: Pirates A-to-Z
When the Pirates selected Paul Skenes with the first overall pick in the 2023 draft, everyone knew he was destined for the major leagues.
The Pirates took another pitcher 346 picks later in the 12th round whose future was far less secure. His college numbers were lousy, he’d already undergone multiple elbow surgeries, and there were legitimate concerns about whether he’d ever throw a baseball again.
That draft pick was Khristian Curtis.
And as it turns out, Curtis became just the second player from that draft class to make his major league debut for the Pirates. Not bad for someone whose baseball career was nearly over before it started.
Let’s get into it.
Revisiting the Origin Story
Curtis grew up in Beaumont, TX east of Houston and attended Texas A&M three hours away. Almost immediately things went sideways in a pretty awful way.
He underwent surgery in January 2021 to address problems with the ulnar nerve in his pitching elbow. Unfortunately, the surgery was botched. A suture was rubbing against the nerve, gradually damaging it every time he threw a baseball.
Curtis returned to pitch in 2022, but something was seriously wrong. His arm was going numb, and eventually the pain became unbearable. When doctors went back in for a second surgery that April, they discovered the nerve was nearly severed. (!!)
The ordeal left Curtis with lingering numbness in two fingers on his pitching hand. He had to relearn how to use that hand, including something as basic as writing his own name. And then Texas A&M revoked his scholarship. Because, you know, this kid's life wasn't already in the toilet.
Fortunately, Arizona State offered him an opportunity to continue playing baseball, and Curtis transferred for the 2023 season.
The results weren’t particularly strong. He put up a 7.03 ERA in 64 IP with 58 K and 35 BB. But given everything he’d been through, simply making it back to the mound was a remarkable accomplishment. The Pirates liked his raw stuff and selected him in the 12th round.
Curtis put up a 3.98 ERA with 116 K in 108.2 IP in 2025, rebounding from an awful April to earn a promotion to AA. He entered 2026 as one of the more intriguing pitchers in the system, with BA ranking him #6 among the organization’s prospects.
Remarkable climb, right? Newfound respect, big time.
Looking Back at 2026
Curtis opened the season at Altoona and put up an ugly 0-7 record with a 4.73 ERA across 12 starts. If you were just scanning his stats, there wasn’t much reason to get excited. But he struck out 67 batters in 53.1 IP, good for an 11.3 K/9, while allowing just 43 hits.
The problem was the 25 BB and 7 HR. There is a parallel to Bubba Chandler in his profile -- dominating stuff that he just isn’t locating effectively. Still, the Pirates liked what they were seeing and promoted him to AAA in June.
That’s when Piratedom sat up and took notice. In his first start with Indy on June 12, Curtis threw 5.2 scoreless innings, allowing just one hit and two walks while striking out 10. He generated 19 whiffs on 90 pitches, with his fastball reaching 98.5 mph and four different offerings missing bats.
The performance earned him International League Pitcher of the Week honors, and a month later, he was on his way to Cleveland for his major league debut.
With Mason Montgomery serving as the opener, Curtis entered in the second inning and threw five scoreless frames, allowing just two hits and two walks while striking out four. It was the longest scoreless relief appearance in a Pirates debut since Steve Blass in 1964.
And because this was the 2026 Pirates, the bullpen promptly blew the 3-0 lead after he left. Cleveland eventually won 5-3 on a walk-off homer by Travis Bazzana. Welcome to Pittsburgh, kid.
Curtis returned to AAA before rejoining the Pirates in late August and had a bit of an up-and-down end to his season. He finished the MLB portion of his season with a 4.71 ERA in 21 IP across six games. His .205 BAA suggested he was difficult to hit when he was actually throwing strikes.
On the Horizon – 2027 & Beyond
So what do the Pirates do with Curtis in 2027?
At 24, he’s still a legitimate prospect with plenty of runway. The Pirates control him through 2032, and I suspect he is being considered a part of the wave of starters competing for a spot in 2028 when Skenes is likely no longer a Pirate.
The Pirates already have Skenes, Braxton Ashcraft, Jared Jones and Chandler penciled into the rotation for the foreseeable future. Mitch Keller remains under contract, though with what Dustin May just received in free agency, there’s a reasonable chance the team succeeds in moving him.
That leaves Curtis competing with Hunter Barco, Wilber Dotel and Antwone Kelly for opportunities. And unlike some of those pitchers, Curtis has already demonstrated he can get major league hitters out in multi-inning relief appearances.
The problem is that he has to find the strike zone. His 2026 numbers included 48 BB in 86.1 minor league innings, followed by another 12 in 21 IP with Pittsburgh. That’s 60 free passes in 107.1 innings. No bueno.
I think there is certainly a path to starter status for Curtis, but I wonder if that is the best use of his talents. His command issues have followed him throughout his career, and a move to the bullpen might allow his fastball and cutter to play up in shorter appearances. He could be an exceptional right-handed leverage reliever.
But for now, I’d send Curtis back to Indy to open 2027 and give him every opportunity to continue developing as a starter. There’s no reason to rush that decision.
A Final Word
I am really loving this series as it reintroduces players who I thought I knew pretty well. I have tended to come out of the research for each with newfound respect, and boy do I feel that way this morning about Curtis.
Imagine being 20 years old and discovering that the surgery intended to save your pitching career had nearly destroyed your ability to use your arm. How low must he have felt the day his scholarship was revoked?
Imagine being able to talk to that kid at that exact point and share that a little over three years later, he would be pitching five scoreless innings in his major league debut.
Baseball, man. As for his future with the Pirates, I’m cautiously optimistic. There’s a lot of raw talent here, but we’ve seen plenty of pitchers with electric stuff who never figured out how to harness it.
But after everything he’s overcome, I wouldn’t bet against him. I’m just hoping the next time he throws five scoreless innings, the bullpen can manage to preserve the damn lead.
#LetsGoBucs
Oneil Cruz: Pirates A-to-Z
“Oneil Cruz is a Horrible Centerfielder and Should Be Traded”
Yeah, I wrote it. And at the time, I really meant it.
I was dragged something fierce this past season for my opinions about Oneil Cruz. I’m sure it will be a lingering brand for me for some time, and I’m okay with that. I stand behind the analysis I put forward, and have come to understand that saying unpopular things <shocker!> leads to negative perception.
I’m just someone who lends more credence to past performance over physical makeup. So while others pointed to blood-red Statcast data with a belief that Cruz is an anomaly-waiting-to-happen, I saw too little of that translating into performance on the field.
But I’m going to try and not re-litigate my criticisms to justify why I’ve been so sour on Cruz in the past. And that’s because I believe his final 101 plate appearances of 2026 suggest a big breakthrough. And I’m someone who is always willing to change my stance on a player as more data is brought forward.
I’m reversing course to mildly optimistic on Cruz. Let’s explore why.
Revisiting the Origin Story
It’s fair to say that Cruz was born to play baseball. When his father Rafael brought him home from the hospital in Nizao, Dominican Republic, he put an old leather glove beside his crib. Rafael had played three seasons in the Rangers’ minor league system, and he’d already decided his son would follow in his footsteps.
Rafael had been a switch hitter, but his favorite player was Paul O’Neill. He liked the way O’Neill played so much that he named his son after him, then taught him to swing from the same side of the plate. Oneil wound up throwing right-handed, just like his dad.
The Dodgers signed Cruz as a 16-year old for $950k in 2015. Two years later, they traded him to Pittsburgh in the deal that sent reliever Tony Watson to LA. As one contemplates the late-tenure work of GM Neal Huntington, this trade is often pointed to as a high-water mark amongst truly questionable transactions.
Early Performance
By the time Cruz was 20, he was one of the Pirates’ best prospects and one of the more unusual players in professional baseball. He stood 6’6, had tremendous raw power and was still playing shortstop. At the time, nobody that tall had ever started a major league game at the position.
Cruz hit .298 with an .832 OPS across three levels in 2019, reaching Altoona at age 20. But his biggest year was still to come in 2021, when he hit .310/.375/.594 with 17 HR and 19 SB in just 69 games between AA and AAA. It suggested this kid was ready for his shot.
Cruz debuted late in 2021 and then hit 17 HR in 87 games as a rookie in 2022. A fractured ankle ended his 2023 season after just nine games, but he came back in 2024 to hit .259 with 21 HR and 22 SB, moving from SS to CF late that summer.
He followed that up with 20 HR and 38 SB in 2025, but his average fell to .200, including an abysmal .100 AVG against left-handed pitching. Heading into 2026, the question was whether Cruz would ever harness his prodigious skills while wearing a Pirates uniform.
Looking Back at 2026
It didn't take long to figure out. Cruz got off to a blistering start in 2026 with a 2 HR-game against the Reds on March 31 contributing to a 1.070 OPS after his first 16 games. He seemed poised for a big breakout, but then things slowed down considerably.
From April 14 through his final game on June 7 before going out with injury, Cruz put up a .234/.324/.415 line -- a .739 OPS that included 78 K in 213 PA, a 36.6% rate. And he was doing most of it from the leadoff spot in the lineup, which was wasting Brandon Lowe's production following him. His defense in CF was also once again well below average.
When I declared Cruz a failed player deserving of being traded, it was this downward trajectory that inspired it. It was a similar trend line as the previous year when Cruz got off to a hot start only to fade all season long. I'd seen enough.
But there were also signs that something had changed. Cruz had done a complete reversal on his ability to hit LHP, going from a .400 OPS in 125 PA against them in 2025 (seriously) to an .847 OPS in 139 PA by the end of 2026. He had invested in hitting BP against lefties in the offseason, and that really paid off.
If the criticism of Cruz had traditionally been about lackadaisical play and a seeming indifference to how his skills translated into game time performance, this improvement against lefties suggested a maturing approach to his craft.
And it was a sign that ended up being reinforced. Returning from injury on Aug 18, Cruz seemed like a very different player. There was a confidence to him that was night-and-day over the indifference he exhibited two months earlier. And it showed in his production, with a .314/.404/.517 line over his final 136 PA.
On the Horizon -- 2027 & Beyond
What does it all mean going forward? Well, clearly, I may not be the best guy to ask. I continue to have concerns for his K-rate, which was still north of 30% in his final 33 games of the season. And while his defense was somewhat improved in that final run, he is still a below-average centerfielder.
All that said, I am willing to believe that a breakthrough occurred last season -- that the guy who came back from injury was somehow transformed by the experience and is ready to ascend to the superstar status his incredible tools suggest has always been just under the surface.
Fans have perennially predicted a 40-HR season is right around the corner for him, and I can buy that at least a 30-HR year may be likely in 2027 ITIAS. And if he applies himself to his defense in CF as he did to hitting lefties last offseason, we could see a far more complete player moving forward.
The bigger concern is how much more time we might have with him. He is entering his second year of arbitration in 2027, and will be a free agent after the 2028 season. If they don’t sign him to an extension, they’d need to consider flipping him ahead of his final season or at that trade deadline at a time when we should be competing for the playoffs.
Extending Cruz now before he goes nuclear might be the right move. Still so hard to say.
A Final Word
If it seems like I’m still a bit torn, it’s because I am. I’ve come around significantly but still see a lot of risk in his game. If he was league-average in CF, I’d be a lot more optimistic. The poor defense across the diamond was a big contributor to poor run prevention by the pitching staff, and we have to focus on improving that.
There are those who blindly champion him, and I can’t get there just yet. But whereas I felt before that his flaws defined him, I now see the potential shining through all the uncertainty. It's sure taken long enough, but late is better than never.
What is as true now as it was in July when I was championing his ouster is that I am a similarly flawed. I think anyone following this team and writing about them everyday is bound to miss the mark from time to time, and I'm no exception.
Still, I'd stand my work up this season alongside anyone else's content. I own the bias I have for performance-over-potential and allow it to color my analysis. It's my point of view, take it or leave it.
At the same time, I'm still learning this craft and will try my best to have a more open perspective moving forward. It's a damn difficult game, and everyone involved deserves a degree of grace. I can only hope that extends to a hobbyist journalists like myself.
#letsgobucs
Oneil Cruz is a Horrible Centerfielder and Should Be Traded
Here’s some data:
▫️ From April 14th, the 17th game of the season, through June 10 when Cruz went out, he put up a .739 OPS in 48 games: .234 AVG, .324 OBP, and .415 SLG. He also struck out 78 times in 213 PA, a rate of 36.6%. He did hit 9 home runs.
▫️The worst centerfielder in baseball by a country mile is Oneil Cruz. He has a -10 DRS in just over 500 innings this season, which is good for 29th out of 30 CF with at least 300 innings there. The Marlins’ Jakob Marsee is 30th with a -11 DRS, but he’s done that in 770 innings, 270 more than Cruz.
Oneil Cruz had a helluva first couple weeks of the season, and then fell off and went out injured. In the interim, from June 10 through yesterday, Jake Mangum had an OPS of .847 and has a +2 DRS in the outfield this season in the same number of innings (roughly 500).
Perhaps not surprisingly given the data above, the Pirates have actually been scoring more runs per game with Cruz out. In fact, a full run more.
I would argue that is actually because Cruz is not in the lineup. He was replaced by a better player in Mangum, who plays better defense in centerfield and is more consistent. Unlike Sir Whiffs-a-lot, Mangum has a 16.6% K rate, more than half of Cruz.
By just about every measure, Jake Mangum has outperformed Oneil Cruz in 2026. Except for the first 16 games of the season.
I think Ben Cherington could easily trade Cruz and the team would be improved going forward.
1
71
How Do You Solve a Problem Like Oneil?
Well, that happened. Not such a happy opening day.
Oneil Cruz misplayed two balls in the first inning on Opening Day, extending the inning and contributing to the reigning NL Cy Young Award winner exiting after 2/3rds of an inning and 37 pitches.
Having scored two runs in the top of the first on a HR by new 2B Brandon Lowe, Cruz is the primary contributor to the Pirates giving those runs back and then some, going down 5-2.
While that should have been the game, the Pirates gave it a run with another HR from Lowe, a solo shot by Ryan O’Hearn and timely hitting from Henry Davis. But it wasn't enough as the bullpen struggled and the Pirates lost 11-7.
It didn’t have to be that ugly.
Or maybe it did. Cruz is a known quantity in CF having posted poor defense there in 2025, statistically placing him near the bottom among regulars across the league.
The same issues keep showing up -- late reads, inefficient routes, and that deer-in-the-headlights look as he’s deciding whether to come in or go back while the ball keeps traveling. It was a similar story of poor decision-making at shortstop, and now it’s continuing to play out in center.
He’s also 27 years old with more than 1,500 plate appearances. At some point, you stop projecting and start accepting. The Pirates have invested time and coaching, including Kevin Kiermaier this offseason and Tony Beasley during the season, and you can see flashes where it looks cleaner. Then a game like this shows up and we're back to square one.
And yet, he’s going right back out there tomorrow. Because the bat still matters more than anything else.
That certainly didn't stop the casual fans from voicing their displeasure yesterday, advocating for benching Cruz, moving him to DH, or just outright trading or releasing him. After one day of baseball.
First, folks need to calm down -- it's a long season. Further, getting overly worked up about poor defense is probably the wrong place to be looking. I covered a lot of this in February with my (somewhat ignored) series analyzing projected Runs Scored (RS) and Runs Allowed (RA), which dug deeply into concerns for the Pirates' defense:
Offense
teapaw.org/GMBCSuperfan/status/20…
Run Prevention - Starting Pitching
teapaw.org/GMBCSuperfan/status/20…
Run Prevention - Bullpen
teapaw.org/GMBCSuperfan/status/20…
Defense
teapaw.org/GMBCSuperfan/status/20…
Summary
teapaw.org/GMBCSuperfan/status/20…
While that analysis factored in Konnor Griffin as the assumed shortstop (how quaint), I'll still draw on it as a reminder for where we are today.
Defensive Performance Remains a Liability
Cruz’s -14 DRS in 2025 reflects a full season of below-average defense at a high-impact position. Center field requires strong instincts, as much feel as raw physical talent. It would be an exceedingly difficult position for a corner outfielder to learn, much less an infielder who never played the outfield before.
Over the course of the year, Cruz will give up 14 more runs defensively than an average center fielder, and one could argue he got his first handful on the season yesterday. But 14 runs aggregated over a full season works out on average to one run every 11 games or so. If he can make up for it with his bat, it is a tradeoff the Pirates have demonstrated being willing to make. Most teams would.
Offensive Output Drives Playing Time
But that would mean stepping it up offensively. Cruz finished 2025 with a .700 OPS, which is essentially league-average production. The difference has always been in his potential. The exit velocity, the bat speed, the power -- it all suggests there’s more in there if the contact quality starts turning into consistent results.
That’s the bet the Pirates are making. If Cruz turns into a 30-home run bat with an OPS north of .800, the defensive cost becomes easier to carry. A -15 DRS player can still be a net positive if the offensive production is significant enough. That’s why he plays.
It's also why fans need to think of runs scored and runs allowed like calories when you're on a diet. It's not about eating fewer carbs or eliminating fat. It all comes down to calories in and calories out. If you burn more calories than you take in, you lose weight. The same is true in baseball -- if you score more runs than you give up, you win more ballgames.
I mean, duh. I know. But it bears repeating.
Comparable Options Increase Pressure
Jake Mangum complicates this a bit. He posted a .696 OPS last season, which is basically in line with Cruz, and brings a defensive profile that trends significantly positive in center field -- he's the outfield version of Jared Triolo. He's a different player with a different skill set, but the overall offensive value isn’t that far apart at current production levels.
That creates a real decision point over time. If Cruz stays in that .700 OPS range and sulks rather than rebounds, the gap closes, and defense starts to matter more. But if the bat jumps, that conversation ends. It’s that simple, even if it doesn’t feel that simple this morning in the wake of an embarrassing loss.
Bottom Line 📌
Cruz can't be moved to full-time DH because the Pirates signed Marcell Ozuna for 2026. Even looking to next season, Ryan O'Hearn's two-year deal means he would be a potential DH candidate once Garcia Valdez push for roles in the Pirates' outfield.
There are a lot of ways 2027 can be designed, and there will be plenty of time to figure that out. I may in fact be in favor of moving on from Cruz at some point this season.
But it isn't going to be after one game.
Let's get 'em tomorrow.
Oneil Cruz: Weird on Paper
Today is the final edition of The Early Shift published on this account before it moves over to its own channel on Monday. And so I’m going out with a flourish with perhaps the weirdest Weird on Paper of them all: Oneil Cruz.
Our center fielder is having what can only be described as an unprecedented season to-date. If it continues the rest of the year, and there’s no reason to think it won’t, it will end up being the answer to trivia questions and studied by statisticians.
How is Cruz turning one of the worst contact profiles in baseball into one of the most productive offensive seasons in baseball?
A Statistical Anomaly
Most hitters let the law of averages work in their favor by making frequent contact. Cruz instead survives by making infrequent but overwhelmingly violent contact.
Among qualified hitters, Cruz ranks in the 100th percentile in average exit velocity, 100th percentile in hard-hit rate, 99th percentile in bat speed, and 95th percentile in barrel rate. Every time he squares up a baseball, it has a chance to become a highlight reel.
Two days ago, it was a massive home run that went into the Allegheny River on the fly -- only the 7th time that has ever happened. The last time? In 2024 when Cruz did it for the first time.
He has had this ability the entire time he’s been a Pirate. The problem, of course, is that he so rarely squares it up. Cruz ranks in the 1st percentile in strikeout rate and the 2nd percentile in whiff rate. He leads all of baseball with 90 Ks.
Somehow, a hitter who misses this often still owns a .795 OPS and a 121 OPS+, making him 21% better than the average major league hitter.
Cruz is an Extreme Outcome Machine
Cruz’s offensive profile has produced miserable batting averages in the past. He had a .200 BA in 2025 punctuated by a .100 BA (not a misprint) in 108 PA against LHP.
His .258 BA this season ranks only slightly above league average, yet his expected slugging percentage sits in the 81st percentile. His 13 HR have come in only 57 games, putting him on pace for one of the most productive power seasons by a Pirates outfielder in years.
Perhaps most impressive has been his completely turnaround on LHP. He had a .400 OPS against the last year (again, not a misprint) and has more than doubled it this season -- an .880 OPS comprised of a .315 BA, .359 OPS and .521 SLG.
With 90 strikeouts and 60 hits in 233 PA, Cruz has had only 83 plate appearances all season end in something other than a hit or a strikeout. That is a preposterously narrow offensive existence. The ball is either not being put in play at all, or it is being put in play with enough authority to offset the misses.
Finally Dropped in the Lineup
For all of April and the better part of May, Manager Don Kelly continued to pencil in Cruz to the leadoff spot in the lineup -- a strategy that increasingly stopped making sense.
While he had the speed one desires from the position, just about nothing else about him suggests it. In 175 PA leading off this season, he had a .234 BA, .295 OBP and .406 SLG, good for a .701 OPS that is about even with his overall numbers last year.
Since moving down to 5th, he has exploded for a 1.118 OPS in 37 AB. He is still striking out a ton, but now all that punch is happening with guys on base. He has 11 RBI in ten game there, making the best use of his all-or-nothing profile.
The Bottom Line 📌
Cruz is a true enigma. Consider his:
🔳100th average percentile exit velocity
🔳95th percentile barrel rate
🔳81st xSLG
🔳74th percentile sprint speed.
He isn’t slow, he isn’t weak, he isn’t incapable of lifting a baseball, and he isn’t producing weak contact. He is a Superman of the baseball world, but with a kryptonite that is hard to ignore: the game’s worst strikeout rate and whiff rate.
As good as this season has been, just imagine how truly great he could be if some portion of those Ks were walks instead.
But then he wouldn’t be weird on paper.
See you on Monday at the new digs: @The_EarlyShift
#letsgobucs
2
63
Billy Cook: Pirates A-to-Z
This is a fun series to write in large part because of players like Billy Cook getting a whole damn column.
I spent the past year writing about the team and Cook only got one tongue-in-cheek entry back in March. Even when he went 3-for-4 on July 19, sparking the offense in a 7-1 win coming out of the All-Star break, he didn’t get his own write-up. The forgotten man.
Well, not anymore. This morning, Mr. Cook gets an Early Shift special all to himself. Because this is Pirates A-to-Z dammit, and we’re in the Cs, and that means Billy gets his time in the sun.
Soak it in, sir. You’ve earned this.
Revisiting the Origin Story
Cook wasn’t always a 26th man answer to obscure Pirates trivia. Drafted by the Orioles in the 10th round of the 2021 draft out of Pepperdine, Cook put up a .444 SLG across 2,000+ minor league plate appearances. He hit 24 HR for AA Bowie in the Eastern League in 2023.
You weren’t expecting that, were you?
The next year, Cook generated a .275/.375/.474 line in 493 PA across AA/AAA with 17 HR, which caused the Pirates to target him in a 2024 deadline deal that summer in exchange for minor league pitcher Patrick Reilly.
Quick aside: The Pirates may regret parting with Reilly, who had a minor breakout in the Arizona Fall League this year. But he still has a long road ahead, and besides, to make a delicious omelet, sometimes you have to break a couple eggs.
For his part, Baseball America called Cook a fringe hitter but with extraordinary supplemental tools. His speed on the basepaths was always a standout, allowing him to steal 109 bases in the minors. He also had one of the strongest outfield arms in all of AAA baseball, having played six defensive positions including all three outfield spots and a more than serviceable 1B.
Cook was 12th in BA’s Top-30 system rankings for the Pirates ahead of the 2025 season, but wouldn’t appear on the list again as he had a disappointing offensive season at Indy that year, putting up just a .706 OPS with 8 HR. His season ended ignominiously in August with a broken wrist.
Looking Back at 2026
A 26-year-old putting up those sorts of numbers in AAA probably isn’t destined for greatness, much less a spot on a major league team. But there was Cook on the Pirates’ Opening Day roster.
What followed was the calling card of a defensive replacement specialist. Cook appeared in 87 games but logged just 58 plate appearances. For a team with defensive liabilities across the diamond and especially throughout the outfield, having a guy like Cook to cover the late innings was a necessity.
And since that job left him with some time on his hands, Cook naturally took up the role of cone hoister. Because… well, somebody had to do it.
This is probably as good a time as any in this series to acknowledge the important role of the traffic cone in the 2026 Pirates’ season. There’s something delightfully bizarre about a big-league dugout deciding that a piece of road equipment was essential to celebrating a home run. It was an Internet meme-turned-real life icon. God bless social media.
As DH -- designated hoister -- Cook was often the dude pumping that orange cone to the heavens. He also held the water jug when someone was going to get doused following a big game. He provided pre-game handshakes for PR opportunities. He was always up for a Hannah Mears segment. He was “that guy,” and he played the role with dignity and grace.
On the Horizon -- 2027 & Beyond
This is probably not the role Cook envisioned for himself on draft day. And I’m sure the once-and-former slugger who hit 24 HR in AA would love a chance to take a few more swings in Pittsburgh.
For now, I can see him making the team again in 2027 for the same reason he made it last year. The outfield looks to be fairly unchanged with Bryan Reynolds, Oneil Cruz and Esmerlyn Valdez returning for starter duty. That is a below-average defensive outfield, and unless there is an acquisition made to displace Cook, he is likely rejoining Jake Mangum as a role player.
When the Pirates are up a run in the 8th and need someone who can cover ground in any of the three outfield spots, Cook is an easy guy to send out there. The question is whether he can hit enough to get into a game before then.
I mentioned his big game in July at the top of this piece. It came out of nowhere in one of his few starts of the season. Could he do more with the role he’s been handed, flip the script and earn a few more starts?
Have you ever seen the movie Rudy?
"Well, you know what my dad always said, 'Having dreams is what makes life tolerable'."
Anything is possible.
A Final Word
Billy, I should’ve written about you more often. You’re the kind of guy I typically champion. If we're delivered a 2027 season, I promise to mention you more often.
And the next time you go 3-for-4, somebody else can hoist the damn cone. It's the least they can do for a true Pirates legend.
#letsgobucs
Bubba Chandler A-to-Z
Writing about the Pirates everyday, I’ve come to appreciate the intense pressure the individual players must feel. I experience stress from my day job too, but I don’t have tens of thousands of people glaring at me when I screw up, or an entire system of media picking apart my every move.
It’s got to be difficult, especially when you’re just 23 years old as Bubba Chandler was for most of the 2026 season. When I was making copies as a fresh-faced office worker newbie, Chandler was staring down major league lineups, with the hopes and dreams of a fanbase hanging in the balance.
Bubba had himself a rookie season, and though it may not have been the award-winning masterpiece some of us predicted it might be, it was an important stepping stone toward what he is maturing in to. I’ll take it.
Revisiting the Origin Story
Apparently, if you want to pitch for the Pirates, it helps to have played football. We’ve already covered a wide receiver in Braxton Ashcraft and a kicker in Lake Bachar. Here’s our quarterback.
Chandler played QB at North Oconee High School in Georgia, where he also played SS and struck out 96 batters in 44.2 innings as a senior. Clemson recruited him to play both sports. There’s photos from this time of Chandler with bleached blonde hair in full Clemson regalia that suggest the kid would have done some spectacular keg stands.
But instead, the Pirates took him 72nd overall in the 3rd round of the 2021 draft and paid him $3 million to skip Clemson. Some of that money came from the savings on taking Hank Davis first overall. It’s worth remembering Chandler whenever we relitigate that draft, which, being Pirates fans, is frequently.
The fastball made him easy to dream on as he climbed the system, but his propensity to issue walks has been with him from the jump. He handed out 51 BB in 111 IP in 2023, 41 in 119.2 IP in 2024, and another 53 in 100 IP in AAA in 2025.
Along the way he showed an incredible ability to overwhelm hitters, with 11+ K/9. His 1.83 ERA in his final 7 starts at AAA in 2024 suggested we might have another ace to join Paul Skenes soon enough. He made his Pirates debut at the end of 2025 and issued just 4 walks in 31.1 IP. Maybe the concerns for his wildness were unfounded.
Looking Back at 2026
Guess again.
Chandler opened the season in Cincy and somehow walked six guys without giving up a hit. A month later, he issued another 6 BB in a 9-0 shellacking by the Diamondbacks. By the end of May, Chandler had walked 36 batters in 52 innings. That’s 6.2 walks per nine. No bueno.
Having started the season on a lot of ROY watch lists, that faded fairly quickly as each start felt like an experiment to try and dial-in his repertoire. His fastball was at times dialed way back in favor of trying to better place his pitches. But it wasn’t working.
In Toronto on May 22, Chandler cut loose and threw 41 pitches over 99 mph, 11 of them over 100, and struck out 11 in five innings without allowing an earned run. The next start? Back to a mid-90s fastball that was getting knocked around.
He finally returned to his top-end velocity for good by the end of June, hitting triple digits 21 times across the Colorado and Seattle starts after doing it just 19 times in his previous seven outings combined. I remain convinced that Bubba was a part of Bill Murphy’s Electric Kool-Aid Fastball Tests and that it didn’t serve him well.
He pitched better in the second half. Across seven starts from July 22 through the end of August, Chandler put up a 2.95 ERA with just 13 BB in 36.2 IP along with 32 K that was his best stretch of the season. He was going deeper into games and limiting baserunners. He collapsed a bit in September, but with 154 IP for the season, it was by far the most innings he’d ever been asked to pitch.
On the Horizon — 2027 & Beyond
Chandler is easily a rotation staple at this point, but is also more of a #4/5 guy than the #1/2 pitcher he was billed as being. And that’s okay. With Skenes, Ashcraft and Jared Jones in the picture, there's plenty of upside in this rotation. Chandler can play the dark horse.
His biggest challenge remains free passes. He needs to attack the strike zone and let his premium stuff do the talking. If he can throw more first-pitch strikes, he can set himself up in the inning to use his slider to shut down offenses.
Fewer BBs will allow him to go deeper into games as well. He only reached the 6th inning six times in 2026 and he never took a game into the 7th. This despite routinely racking up 90+ pitcher per game. That has to change in 2027.
Chandler mostly pitched like the 4.50 ERA pitcher he ended the season as, but he could take a big step forward in 2027. When he’s on, like he was in July and August, he can be a low-3.00 ERA pitcher who you end of facing ahead of a return to the top of the Pirates rotation. It can be unrelenting.
A Final Word
Ashcraft and Chandler represent the future. Bubba won’t be arbitration eligible until 2029 and isn’t a free agent until 2032. We are at just the very beginning of his career.
It’s worth remembering how young he still is (only just turned 24) and how far he’s come since his high school days riding jet skis on lakes in Georgia.
And if/when he realizes his full potential -- watch out. He's a bit of the bellwether for the team in that way. He has as good or better stuff as anyone in the rotation. There's a sub-3.00 ERA starter waiting to get out. I'm looking forward to watching that pitcher emerge.
#LetsGoBucs
The Maturation of Bubba Chandler
So, I hear last night’s game sucked.
I caught part of it, but was asleep soon after getting in from watching the Grasshoppers’ game at Truist Stadium in Winston-Salem. Seems like I missed another frustrating, bullpen-induced loss.
As a guy who gets up super early everyday, I usually can’t hang for these west coast trips. So I find myself pouring through posts from all of you and the box score to try and understand what went down.
These days, I feel like I have a choice as a columnist following losses -- lean in to the negativity or find a kernel of success to illuminate. Today I’m doing the latter.
Taking stock of last night, what jumps out isn’t the typical bullpen collapse. It’s Bubba Chandler.
The overall line was solid: 6 IP, two runs, 6 hits, 2 walks, and a strikeout. He threw 74 pitches, got ahead with first-pitch strikes to 18 of the 26 hitters he faced (huge!), and left with the Pirates in position to win.
It was just his second quality start of the year, but directionally another step toward becoming the pitcher we all know he can be.
The Walks Are Declining
For much of the season, Chandler’s biggest issue wasn’t his stuff, which is off the charts, but his efficiency. He was falling behind hitters, issuing too many walks, and nibbling when he should have been challenging. In his first 6 starts through the end of April, he walked 20 batters in 29.0 innings.
Since the start of May, that trend has started to change. After a 5.84 ERA in April, he’s put up a 4.70 ERA in May and 4.09 ERA in June thus far. He’s allowed two or fewer walks in each of his last three starts, and the improvement has shown up in the length of his outings. Fewer walks means deeper starts.
Trusting His Entire Arsenal
Earlier in the year, Chandler looked like a one-trick pony, trying to solve everything with velocity. He’s capable of triple digit heat, but needed some secondary stuff to actually land in the strike zone.
Against the Marlins last week, his slider generated eight whiffs on 13 swings. Against the Rockies, he recorded only one strikeout, yet still worked six innings.
I’ve been critical of pitching coach Bill Murphy’s pitch-to-contact approach that has de-emphasized velocity, but Chandler is the sort of pitcher benefitting from building up his spin offerings. When played off his 98.3 mph average fastball, and importantly, when landed in the zone, Chandler is a very different pitcher.
Handling Adversity Better
One thing that stood out from Chandler’s postgame comments was his willingness to acknowledge that he didn’t have his best stuff. And yet, it appears that didn’t rattle him as it may have done earlier in the year.
Don Kelly called it the best outing of Chandler’s season, and I can see the argument. The Rockies put runners on base and Chandler had to work through that. And yet, he continued attacking the strike zone, kept the ball on the ground, and gave his team six innings. Sometimes real success doesn’t look like 7 shutout innings with 11 strikeouts.
The Bottom Line 📌
Chandler’s overall season numbers don’t look great, and it will likely take him all season pitching this way to get back to respectability stats-wise.
But that isn’t what this season is about for him. Over the last several weeks, he’s started to blossom at a time when the Pirates desperately need it. His walk rate, arsenal effectiveness and composure have all markedly improved. Above all, he appears to look comfortable on the mound. There’s no stat for that, but it may be the most important thing.
In relatively short order, he’s become a guy I actually trust and look forward to taking the mound.
I’m as shocked as you are. #letsgobucs
1
52
The Resurrection of Bubba Chandler’s Fastball
This season has been a real conundrum. How can a team that is now 3rd in all of baseball in runs scored be at just .500 on the year? A team that is 2nd in OPS? How is this possible?
The answer is in the pitching, of course. Whereas the Pirates had a 3.76 team ERA in 2025 that was good for 7th in baseball, they’ve slipped to 15th in 2026 with an ERA at 4.14.
I’ve been trying to get to the bottom of what the hell is going on. Why has the Pirates’ pitching eroded so much when it was the strategic strength of the 2025 squad?
And I think I’ve found our test case for the theory I’ve been advancing about fluctuations in velocity: Bubba Chandler. And I’ve uncovered some recent data that suggests perhaps an end to the suffering is upon us.
The Pirates 2026 Pitching Experiment
On the most recent episode of The Pirates Insider podcast, Jason Mackey addressed the declining velocity on Skenes’ fastball:
“Skenes has talked about this. It's a matter of self-preservation. It's a matter of making sure that he's available for the entire season, for the playoffs, that he's effective.”
So, it’s verified as an elective decision on his part to dial back the fastball as a part of “self-preservation.” Not an injury, or exhaustion from pitching in the WBC. It’s a choice. Whether that is focused on the Pirates’ playoff aspirations or his own future payday, I’ll leave that up to you to decide.
In this column, I’ve made the argument that Skenes’ interest in self-preservation is something he sought to influence across the entire pitching staff. I believe Oscar Marin was jettisoned in favor of slow-walking Bill Murphy, who was handed the directive of helping Pirates’ pitchers move off a reliance on high-velocity fastballs.
No pitcher better embodies this staff-wide experiment than Chandler.
A Game-by-Game Breakdown
You can track Chandler’s ineffectiveness to how he was being coached to pitch.
I pulled his Statcast pitch data from every game this season to analyze his game-by-game performance and found a bit of a smoking gun: in games when he was least effective, his fastball had dramatically diminished velocity. It is as if every game was an experiment to help him evolve into a different type of pitcher.
In his first two games of the season, March 31 and April 6, he threw 99+ mph 39 times and 33 times respectively. These were also games where his walks were inflated.
Starting with the third game, his velocity dropped off dramatically. In his April 12 game, he threw 99+ mph 19 times, on April 17 that dropped to 10 times, and then just 6 times on April 23 and only 2 times on April 29.
Not coincidentally, these were also games where he was getting knocked around. In those four games, his ERA was 5.75 with just 17 K in 20.1 IP. His walks diminished, but at the expense of his overall effectiveness.
It continued like that over the next several starts, throwing just 8 pitches over 99 mph on May 10 and just 3 on May 16. More poor results.
The man had had enough. On May 22 in the game against Toronto, Chandler threw 41 pitches over 99 mph, including 11 over 100 mph, and it was his best start to-date. He recorded 11 K with just 3 BB and no earned runs.
Surely, the experiment would end, no?
It did not. Over the next two starts, he was back to diminished velocity with poor outcomes.
Bubba Ascending
And then something changed. Starting in Atlanta on June 7, Chandler’s velocity has increased in every successive game. He’s back throwing over 99 mph with regularity, including 23 pitches on June 19 and 28 on June 25. He’s thrown over 100 mph 21 times across these two games. He only had 19 pitches over 100 mph in the seven starts that preceded them.
Over his last four outings, Chandler has a 2.82 ERA. He’s worked efficiently. And he’s done so without sacrificing his God-given ability to throw his fastball faster than the vast majority of the league.
The Bottom Line 📌
Whatever experiment Murphy was running with Chandler appears to have mercifully ended. Encouraging him to slow down his fastball to help him locate his pitches better was a miserable strategy. And it played out against the backdrop of the Pirates’ trying to make the playoffs for the first time in a decade. These are experiments best kept to the confines of spring training, not as a petrie dish of regular season games.
Across the pitching corps, we have multiple examples of pitchers being encouraged to lessen the velocity on their fastballs, and it has been devastating in both the specific and the aggregate. Chandler offers the clearest example of how this pitching philosophy has not served the Pirates' interests of competing for the playoffs.
The Pirates have a set of flame-throwing starters that are the envy of baseball. Paul Skenes and Bill Murphy aimed to change all that. But now, with Chandler back to pitching the way he was born to pitch, perhaps their reign of terror is over.
One can only hope. #letsgobucs
11
Why Isn’t Bubba Chandler More Successful?
Bubba Chandler lost last night to the Rangers, and it followed a now-familiar script. Texas jumped on him early, tagging him for six runs in four IP, highlighted by a three-run shot from Corey Seager and an inside-the-park homer from Evan Carter.
It continues an uneven start to Chandler’s big-league career. Across nine starts dating back to last season, a familiar pattern is emerging -- dominant outings followed by blowups where things unravel quickly.
It reminds me of one of the smartest people I have ever known, a high school friend, who nearly missed a perfect 1600 on his SAT (back when that was the standard). Hugely smart kid, but without emotional intelligence, who went off to college and flunked out his freshman year. Worked at a Circuit City while we were all graduating into careers. The wasted talent was an early meme between those of us who knew him.
I see the same sort of unevenness with Chandler. The contrast is especially stark when placed next to Braxton Ashcraft, profiled in this column yesterday, who has opened his career with 13 straight starts of steady, controlled execution.
Former big-leaguer Curt Schilling weighed in on Chandler during spring training in late February after a blow-up game, calling him a “max effort” pitcher -- the kind of arm that can look unhittable one outing and completely bomb out the next.
Of the Pirates’ emerging trio alongside Paul Skenes and Ashcraft, Chandler grabs headlines with his 100+ mph fastball. But velocity alone doesn’t separate a pitcher the way it once did. It’s not enough to go out there and throw darts and expect to shut down major league offenses.
Chandler's struggles point to something more foundational that needs to be addressed before he can take the next big leap forward.
It Starts With a Spike in Walks
Through his first five starts of 2026, Chandler has issued 10 walks in 19.2 innings. In his late-season sample last year, he issued zero across his final three outings.
But this isn’t coming out of nowhere. The underlying command profile has always been iffy. In 2023, he walked 51 in 111 IP across A+ and AA. In 2025 at Indy, that number climbed again to 53 BB in 100 IP.
Across 372 IP in the minors, Chandler had 4.2 BB/9, more than a full walk above the 2025 major league-wide average of 3.1 BB/9. That means, instead of working ahead and dictating at-bats, Chandler is pitching from behind, inflating pitch counts and forcing himself into the zone.
And that’s where he gets himself in trouble.
The Fastball Gets Punished
Chandler’s fastball still lights up the radar gun (98th percentile velocity), but the results tell a different story.
His fastball run value sits in the 26th percentile, and when he’s forced into the zone, hitters are knocking him around. Four HR allowed in under 20 IP is a consequence of predictable sequencing matched by poor command.
Opposing hitters are sitting on the fastball, and unlike in the minors where they couldn’t catch up, major league hitters are unloading.
No Put-Away Pitch When It Matters
Chandler’s chase rate is strong (72nd percentile), which suggests hitters are expanding the zone, but that isn’t translating into strikeouts. His K rate sits in the 33rd percentile, with only average whiff rates.
He’s getting to two strikes but not finishing hitters, which leads to longer at-bats, more balls in play, and more opportunities for runs to score as the bases fill.
I see Chandler as a guy who badly needs a new pitch, the way the sweeper has worked so well for Keller this season. Something that can shut the dang door or induce a weak grounder.
Bottom Line 📌
Chandler is only nine starts into his major league career, so I will cut him some slack. His arm talent is unreal, the ceiling remains high, and there is time for this to stabilize.
But the early returns point to a clear developmental gap. What got him here isn’t going to be what makes him a success here. He looks up to Skenes, who is a blueprint for how a pitcher with incredible stuff has to make pitch sequencing and precision his calling card, not 100+ mph heat.
Chandler is behind Skenes and Ashcraft on this point, but he’s also a tremendously hard worker. He is his own worst critic. I imagine he is up early this morning, reviewing video and beating himself up.
I believe in him. He just needs to believe in himself.
17
Tyler Callihan: Pirates A-to-Z
Tommy Boy is one of my all-time favorite movies -- one of just a handful of DVDs I actually owned and something we’d put on when we came back from the pub. I’ve seen the film so many times, I can basically quote it by heart.
Tommy: But the Callahan factory has been in my family for seventy years. You can't just shut it down.
Ray Zalinsky: Son, you got to look at it from my point of view. Callahan's a premium name. That's what I'm buying.
It was a quote I thought of first when the Pirates acquired Tyler Callihan before the season started. Hey, it’s a premium name, but would it be a premium bat in the Bucco’s lineup?
Revisiting the Origin Story
The Reds took Callihan in the 3rd round of the 2019 draft and gave him $1.5M to sign out of high school. Scouts loved the left-handed swing with quick hands, line drives to all fields, and enough power to keep pitchers honest. They had a harder time agreeing on where to put him when the other team was up.
He settled mostly at second base and left field, with some time at third in A+ that went poorly enough for me to cross him off my annual list of Guys Who Could Maybe Play Third Base. Of course, that wouldn’t stop the Pirates from playing him there. More on that below.
COVID wiped out the 2020 minor league season and Callihan had Tommy (Boy) John surgery in 2021. He spent the next few years working his way up, then opened 2025 at AAA with a .303/.410/.528 line in 106 PA. That got him to Cincinnati.
Four games into his major league career, he chased a fly ball down the left-field line in Atlanta and crashed into the wall. He broke both bones in his left forearm and damaged his wrist badly enough to need surgery. Don’t google it -- it’s gruesome and sad for him.
Ten months later, and after much physical therapy, the Pirates sent Kyle Nicolas to the Reds for him on March 4 of this year. I’ll admit that I didn’t really get it. It certainly suggested that the Pirates thought they were in good shape with the bullpen (ha!). And I was pretty bullish that Nicolas was due for a breakout season.
Looking Back at 2026
In the end, the trade was pretty much a draw. Nicolas flamed out with the Reds, got moved to the Orioles, and was flipped to the Nationals at the trade deadline. This past Friday, he was released by the Nationals, bringing his merry-go-round 2026 to an end.
For his part, Callihan had an eventful season, if not a super successful one. He opened the year in Indy and got the call on May 28 when Konnor Griffin went down with a forearm injury. By the time the Dodgers came to town, Oneil Cruz was hurt too, the Pirates had been swept in Atlanta, and the bullpen had already blown the opener against LA.
@burghbulletin had an excellent reflection on this game in the recent Defining Moments series, with Callihan hitting his first career homer 427 feet off Shohei Ohtani before winning it with a three-run HR in the 8th. If you’re scripting a guy’s big moment before washing away into obscurity, you could do a lot worse than that.
Callihan was the lesser of several guys who got their big shot as a function of injuries joining Endy Rodríguez, Esmerlyn Valdez, Jake Mangum and Rafael Flores Jr. over the course of the season.
Callihan kept hitting into early July, then went 1-for-26 and got sent down on July 29. His final line was .211/.283/.389 in 107 PA across 37 games, good for an 81 OPS+ and -0.6 bWAR. He also struck out 38 times, a 35.5% rate.
Perhaps more damning, his defense was poor everywhere he played. His -5 DRS included a -3 in 49 innings in LF, a -1 in 64 innings in RF, and yes, a -1 in 36 innings at 3B. His 140 defensive innings contributed to the Pirates’ awful run prevention efforts.
On the Horizon – 2027 & Beyond
All that said, I could see Callihan getting another shot, just probably not with the Pirates. He hit well enough before his one-fer slide to demonstrate value as a LHB. His versatility should be an asset, but his poor defense anywhere other than RF (and only passable there) narrows his overall potential impact for a Pirates team that really needs solid defense on its bench.
But if you consider where he started coming off what could have been a career-ending injury in 2025, his positioning could be a lot worse. It was proof that Callihan has it in him to be competitive at the major league level.
If he stays with the Pirates, he’d start the season in AAA as the first LH bat called up. With the apparent loss of Brandon Lowe to free agency, the Pirates become slightly less left-hand dominant. If any of Oneil Cruz, Ryan O’Hearn or Spencer Horwitz go down, the need for a LH bat would suggest a Callihan call-up.
But at the same time, I could see him -- like several others -- as attractive in trade to another team. Left-handed power is always a premium.
A Final Word
But is Callihan truly a premium name? I think that really remains to be seen. He’ll always have that one incredible game against L.A. should he end up being a flash-in-the-pan. But I’d be willing to wager that there is more on the horizon for him.
Doubt me? Take it from Tommy Boy himself
"Of course, I can get a good look at a T-Bone steak by sticking my head up a bull's ass, but I'd rather take the butcher's word for it."
#letsgobucs
Defining Moment #8
Tyler Callihan’s Big Game on June 10
by @burghbulletin
Back on May 5th, 2025, then Reds infielder/outfielder Tyler Callihan collided into the left field wall at Truist Park in what resulted in one of the scarier injuries that we’ve seen in recent years of MLB play. It was gruesome. Ultimately, he ended up fracturing both bones in his left forearm along with torn cartilage and ligaments in his wrist. This led to separate surgeries for both forearm and wrist area which effectively ended his first season in the bigs after just 4 games. I mean, just brutal.
Fast forward ten months later to March 4th, the Pirates traded for Callihan in exchange for sending reliever Kyle Nicolas over to Cincinnati. After opting not to pursue a 3B in free agency, the Pirates were entering the 2026 campaign with the likelihood of a combination of Jared Triolo and Nick Gonzales manning the left side of the infield. With Triolo undertaking what was looking to be a full-time role in the lineup, the Pirates were missing out on his utility capabilities and effects elsewhere. So in turn, they opted to make a deal for Callihan as a supposed depth piece, with his utility, as Spring Training was getting into full swing.
The trade was a mostly ‘meh’ sort of deal. Eternal Kyle Nicolas. believers were up in arms about it, but the large sentiment was neutral. Callihan was a .736 OPS guy in the minors, but the utility aspect was why he was brought over. After starting the year in AAA, the Pirates eventually called Callihan up to the majors on May 28th, in response to Konnor Griffin’s right forearm ailment (the irony?) that ended up putting him on the shelf for much of June. Shortly, Callihan’s impact would be felt.
(The Moment)
Up until the Dodgers series, Callihan was honestly playing pretty serviceably and was at least a stop gap for when they needed him in the lineup and in the field with Griffin’s absence. However, the Pirates were beginning to skid. The feeling of lost hope was becoming all too familiar after getting swept in Atlanta, Oneil Cruz going down with the hand injury, and another embarrassing bullpen implosion saw the Pirates lose the first game of their series with LA. That was… until Tyler Callihan happened.
In the second game of the set, Callihan slapped his first career home run (427 feet) off none other than Shohei Ohtani in the 4th inning. The Pirates were in a tight 2-1 ballgame up until, of course, the bullpen imploded with Carmen Mlodzinski giving up 4 runs in the Top of the 6th to give the Dodgers a 6-1 lead. It felt insurmountable, and defeat clouded the already morale-sinking ship that was the Pirates en route to their 6th loss in their last 7 games.
Then, the Bucs strung together 3 runs in the bottom of the 7th to cut the lead to 6-4, knocking Ohtani out and at least making things interesting. Mlodzinski and Sisk worked through the 8th to keep the score there, setting up what would be one of the best moments in the modern Pittsburgh Pirates era.
With runners on 1st and 2nd in the bottom of the 8th, Tyler Callihan sends the first pitch he sees from Dodgers reliever Kyle Hurt over the Clemente Wall in right to give the Pirates a 7-6 lead. They would hold on and win, and it was straight euphoria. Callihan has said in interviews that since his traumatic injury, he has an extra sense of appreciation and gratitude for the game and each day he is able to play it. What a special moment for the young man, another unbelievable example of why there is simply no other sport like the game of baseball.
(A Sign of Things To Come)
That night itself was something that will always be worth remembering, but it also started an encouraging trend for the Pirates in 2026, and hopefully moving forward. Callihan churned out a pretty solid rest of June, and early July for the Buccos and he was certainly a contributing factor in what kept the offense operating at such a high level even with the injuries. He was eventually sent down on July 29th where he found himself in a 1 for 26 stretch and simply leaking confidence, but even with his late fall off he provided a .489 SLG and 9 of his 20 hits being XBH’s.
The encouraging trend I alluded to above was that we started seeing the Pirates all throughout the summer be able to plug in these minor league bats and see them make impacts – some for longer periods than others – and keep things afloat even with key players going down due to injury. We just haven’t seen that from the Pirates at all in recent years. Endy Rodriguez, Esmerlyn Valdez, and Rafael Flores Jr. were the biggest difference makers, and you’ll see more about them as this series progresses. Hopefully, this trend will continue through the system in the coming years.
(Final Reflection)
Baseball is a game of moments. This is why I love this series we’re doing so much. The narratives each of these moments create really shape the entire summer and the direction the season ultimately goes towards. And certainly, this one delivered by Callihan won’t be forgotten. Even if he never plays another game in a Pirates uniform, he will always have this night and us fans will forever remember him fondly for it. It’s a mysterious, and truthfully funny sport in the way that some things work themselves out. For a guy that could’ve seen his career end just a year prior, it warmed my heart to see him have his “legacy game” at a time the team, and fanbase, needed him the most.
“How can you not be romantic about baseball?
The Early Shift retweeted
Til the day I die, I'll firmly believe the Pirates make the postseason in 2026 if they finish off the 6-run comeback against the DBacks.
That was THE turning point of the season. They were in limbo for so long and that was the boat rocking moment. After they lost that, the spiral that put them in a huge hole ensued.
Being in the park that night, I can't even describe how that place was about to explode if they won. Would've probably been the greatest night there since the Cardinals series in 2015.
But fitting to the story of the season, they had so many opportunities but just couldn't come through to put it over the top. I think about this game way too often.
Jack Brannigan: Pirates A-to-Z
Two games. One plate appearance. Jack Brannigan, welcome to Pirates A-to-Z.
This alphabetical run-down of players who suited up at least once this past season meets its definition point today with Brannigan.
But hey, it counts. You’re in the series, my boy. Welcome.
Who is Brannigan? You know what, that sounds like a musical number. “B-R-A, Double-N-I, G-A-N spells Brannigan.” I guess he’s a prospect who accumulated nearly 1,500 plate appearances in the Pirates system. But I can’t say I recall a damn thing about him.
This will be a good education for all of us. Or maybe just me. <starts googling 'Jake Branigian'>
Revisiting the Origin Story
Brannigan was the Pirates’ 3rd round pick in the 2022 draft out of Notre Dame where he was a two-way player. Looking at the draft notes on the BA website, I’m not sure I’ve ever seen a write-up quite like this.
He’s credited as having among the strongest arms in the sport, easily hitting 97-100 mph as a pitcher without really trying. As a batter, he hits the ball hard and runs fast, but simply hadn’t put any of it together come draft time -- just a collection of raw tools. The Pirates took a flyer to see if they could harness his 70 arm, 70 run and 55 power tools.
Things got off to a decent start in 2023 where he put up a .915 OPS with 19 HR in A and A+ combined, which included a five game run where he homered in every contest. He returned to Greensboro in 2024 and regressed modestly with the bat, but was largely on track.
In 2025, he moved up to AA and struggled offensively before a torn labrum in June knocked him out for the season. He only had a .687 OPS when he went out, having played mostly shortstop and a bit of third base that season.
Before his untimely injury, Brannigan was experiencing a fairly classic trajectory for a college position player with tools but big holes in his game. Double-A will separate the men from the boys.
Looking Back at 2026
His season got off to a rocky start during his first spring training with the Pirates when he broke his nose in the second game of the Grapefruit League season. He went back to Altoona before getting promoted to Indy where he returned to putting up middling offense.
So it was a surprise in June when he got called up ahead of the series finale against the Mariners at PNC Park on June 25. It was entirely a function of injuries, with Konnor Griffin and Nick Yorke both out, and Spencer Horwitz having just gone on the IL. The Pirates just needed someone for the bench before activating Griffin who was ready to return.
Whatever, whatever, IT COUNTS! Brannigan got to suit up and spend the day being a real major leaguer, even hearing his name called as he went up to pinch hit (a strike out).
He’d return to AAA where he closed out the season with a .680 OPS. He was called up again in August when there was another need for a warm body and defensive replacement, but that was the extent of his season.
On the Horizon -- 2027 & Beyond
Brannigan plays 3B, SS and 2B, and for that reason alone, he is a guy worth keeping around. As Jared Triolo moves into his arbitration years, his cost will start to be inversely related to his value, and another glove guy with an occasional bat will be needed. Brannigan's defense is sound, with his notably strong arm a hallmark of his prowess.
I'm a little surprised by his relatively low stolen base numbers given how high scouts were on his speed. He has 56 in 342 minor league games. As a reminder, Griffin put up 68 in 131 games. If he was a little more accomplished on the basepaths, he might have a role as a pinch runner as well.
He’ll begin the AAA season next year as a 26-year-old, which tends to be the dividing line between true prospects and minor league filler. If he can adapt to hitting at higher levels, there could be a bench spot or maybe more for the Pirates should an injury require someone to fill in.
Or he could be trade fodder as the team contemplates ways to improve against the ceiling of their payroll. As he sits, he is likely capable of serving as an infield specialist for a team in need of a utility guy. He has occasional power and, oh yeah, did I mention his grade 70 arm?
It’s surprising they didn’t try him out in the bullpen during the early-season troubles last year.
A Final Word
So there he is, folks. The only one-at-bat-guy in this series. Even Davis Wendzel, who will come much later in this series, got multiple plate appearances.
In truth, I’ll probably forget Brannigan’s in the system again by the time we’re playing meaningful baseball. But now I at least have a catchy show tune to remind me of his name.
B-R-A, Double-N-I…




















