Pinned Tweet
“If a #lion could #speak, we could not understand him.”
-Ludwig #Wittgenstein
#talkinganimals
#animals
Had a philosophy moment today: I forgot where I put the printouts for an author’s arguments.
Anyone else feeling like you forget the sensible world when contemplating eternal or deep truths?
3
102
Stay tuned for an interview tomorrow with David Hume about animals!!
Can they reason? Are their inferences reasoning?
1
7
261
Dominicans say either some of the smartest things or some of the dumbest. There seems to be no middle ground.
Met a younger one recently who denied there are *any* stages of human action & who held the will can change itself without a change in the intellect.
Hopefully the older ones will continue to work on the intellectual development of the younger. 🙏
1
6
475
When a zebra is being torn apart by the lion is its suffering pain bad? No.
Is the flesh being torn bad?
Yes.
But morally bad? No.
Is pain the greatest evil ?
No.
Is inflicting it always morally wrong?
No.
Is pain always identical with evil?
No.
Thought exp: if you cannot feel pain and don’t feel pain when you put your hand on a hot stove - something’s gone wrong. This lack of pain is bad.
Can you rightly inflict pain for good reason?
Yes, as in punishment or if needed for food, etc.
We should try to avoid unnecessarily causing all animal suffering. But this talk that we should ban all factory farm raised animals is overblown.
What’s a factory anyway ?
That they have an automated food dispenser? That the lights go on automatically? The size of the cage? The number of animals ?
It’s too often become more an emotionally loaded term to denigrate what our farmers are doing for us in providing food for America 🇺🇸 by people who have never lived on a farm nor visited one nor had much experience with animals besides dogs & cats & the random ones they see in a city or on social media.
If you can kill them, you don’t need them to live in palaces or be treated to the most posh conditions prior to death. We should not torture animals but that everything done on these large farms needs to be anthropomorphically comfortable in all respects for the animal is overkill.
Look - in the wild many of these animals would die & Mother Nature especially the weather isn’t exactly very accommodating. Other animals will kill them, they’ll get diseases, or die of starvation. The eco-extremist position effectively entails lots of these animals shouldn’t exist or that few should exist at all.
Love animals but there ought to be a due order to our loves.
Humans first. Humans need food, including meat.
I think I have the best handle on the badness of factory farming when I'm sick.
When I'm lying in bed with a fever and a sore throat that makes it hurt to swallow, it's obvious that it's bad. Sure, part of what makes it bad is that it diminishes my productivity, etc. But a big part of what makes it bad is: it hurts.
But at the very same moment, countless animals--far more than the number of humans who have ever lived--are suffering in ways much more intense. They're being cut by knives, mutilated, castrated, locked in cages, etc. Their pain is bad for the same reason mine is.
And the fact that they're not biologically human doesn't make their pain not bad. If you gave me a pill that made me stupid and not biologically human, it would still be bad for me to suffer. Suffering is bad, at least in part, because it hurts. So the source of incomprehensible suffering is a very big deal, morally.
6
190
Easy: organism = living substance.
But you should read @FeserEdward’s Aristotle’s Revenge to understand more.
Replying to @ThomistAnimals
There u go. There is no good answer to what is an organism. Life is already messy. Ants.. can live for a while outside its colony, a two yr old cannot, some of my cells r clearly organisms tho again none can survive outside.. if cared for.. in a lab environment.. yes.
3
2
136
It smells sooooo good here - I think the terminal’s Chick Fil-A finally opened!
A good end to the chicken’s life? Me thinks so….
63
Sed contra 2:
1) All fire has no natural terminus to its increase in size - give it enough tinder or fuel & it will continue increasing into a larger fire ad infinitum.
2) all living things have a natural terminus or practical limit to their growth (even if asymptotic).
Thus, no fire is a living thing.
2
5
147
Question:
Is merely having the ability to take in nourishment a sufficient condition for being alive?
Or must one also be able to grow as well?
Or to be alive the sufficient condition all 3: that one must be capable of taking in nourishment, capable of growth, and capable of reproducing?
1
40
Sed contra: I say fire is not alive nor is it an animal.
She thinks fire moves towards its food. Thus it’s an animal.
If so, where is its organ of touch?
When it cognizes this as to be eaten - where does this take place? It has no brain, nor nervous system - so this would be an odd case of cognition without a corresponding organ.
Further, is needing to take something into its own substance in order to continue to be a sufficient condition for what’s taken to be food or for the receiver to be alive? Uranium to continue to be needs things to keep it so & to be taken into it. Yet it’s not alive.
Further, is fire itself even a substance or a collection of many? Only substances are alive per se. Modern chemistry indicates it is not a substance but a chemical process whereby wood for example turns into ash, carbon dioxide, water, etc. In older terminology it’s a corruption that’s occurring between potency & act - or at least this is a reasonable interpretation.
2
38
Thinking about submitting an abstract to a conference on Avicenna, but it’s Valentine’s Day weekend…
Who puts conferences on that weekend? Seriously !
I’d like to present my future book chapter on Avicenna on animals but….
2
2
190








