Tonyukuk retweeted
🇹🇷 T125
⚜️ Anatolian Turkish
▫️ Minorethnicity: Çepni
🔸 Ordu / Ünye / İnkur
🧬 C2a1-Y266167
Tonyukuk retweeted
IOSIF "INCONSISTENT" LAZARIDIS
YOU STATED MA2196 AS "Steppe Nomad derivation" WHICH HAS TWICE AS LESS EA THAN MA2195
reich.hms.harvard.edu/sites/…
Replying to @iosif_lazaridis
Naturally, if one uses a sample from the center of Anatolia, half a millennium after the arrival of Turkic people to Anatolia, as a supposed representative of incoming Turkic tribes, one is going to get higher proportion estimates than in either our study or the literature.
2/2
Tam olarak Oğuzların kökenini N-VL73 belirleyecek dediğim gün böyle bir şey ortaya çıktı.%100 kesinlik olmasa da N-VL73 artık SlabGrave kökenli.3 üst dalı için STR sonuçları pozitif çıkmış.
Oğuzların kökeni artık kuvvetle muhtemel Tiele.
Tonyukuk retweeted
docs.google.com/spreadsheets…
Kars and Mahley have the same issue. Dont play 3 monkeys online lad.
Also, PCA modeling is pseduoscience. Make AT2 if you are brave enough.
If you've tried a qpAdm model, share it with me, Champ. If you haven't, let me teach you. Try modelling Anatolian Turks using Native Anatolian-Central Asian–East Asian (Hunnic) sources, and the amount of DA ancestry contributed by the later Oghuz migration will become apparent..
(Tiele proportion × 90 + Sogdian proportion × 5) ÷ (Total Tiele + Sogdian)
Come on, why don't you conduct a study on this? But I guess that wouldn't suit your agenda, would it? After all, you're neither an academic nor anything other than a Turkophobe.
teapaw.org/iosif_lazaridis/status…
Four different studies with indistinguishable means. How remarkable that "targeted sampling" all converge to the same estimate.
You tried to play the dirty trick, but I know genetics ;-)
teapaw.org/iosif_lazaridis/status…
Anadolu Türklerindeki en yaygın Doğu Asya haplogrubu N olduğu için C+O'yu bir şeyle çarpmak oldukça ilkel ve yanlış bir yöntem.Etnik Anadolu Türkleri üzerindeki 1700+ sayılı örneklemle sadece N haplogrubunu %11 olarak tespit ettik.C2 ve O ise Anadolu Türklerinde yüksek orana sahip doğu asya babasoyları değil.(O %0.5 C2 %3.5)
Ayrıca akedemisyenlerin ADMIXTURE sonucunu nasıl böyle bulduklarını merak ediyorum zira etnik Türk olmayanlar dışlandığında fırat-trabzon batısı bundan çok daha yüksek Central Asian katkısına sahip olduklarını görüyoruz.Sadece Doğu Asya oranı %11.5.Dolayısıyla bu modası geçmiş makaleyi bize verdiği örnekleri yeniden kullanmak dışında bize fayda sağladığı hiçbir şey yok.
Replying to @iosif_lazaridis
"Paternal gene flow based on Y chromosome haplogroups C-RPS4Y and O3-M122, which were previously implicated as Central Asian specific, ranged from 8.5 to 15.6%."
Tonyukuk retweeted
Kökenim'den test yaptıran arkadaşların mtdnasının daha alt dala inmesine yardımcı olabiliriz. Sonuç alanlar telegram chatinden veya buradan bana ulaşabilirler.
t.me/turkicdnachat
To be honest, the main point of the post wasn't to modeling via MA2195. MA2195 is very likely a misdated Oghuz sample that does lacks Anatolian admixture. This sample has a 48% East Asian ancestry proportion,the models run with it fall within the "9–22%" range.
The fundamental critique we have regarding "9–22" is that a low figure like 9 meaning the possibility of Oghuz conquerors having 100% East Asian genetics was evaluated, which everyone knows is impossible. Also, I don't understand why a 100% East Asian proxy was included rather than being dropped down to ~32%. Although I personally don't find 32% logical either, it is clearly much more logical than 100%.
Additionally, samples from Trabzon were overrepresented more than they should have been, causing the average to drop. Trabzon forms an exception among ethnic Turks and contains even less East Asian ancestry than populations in Anatolia like Kurds or Circassians they should have been labeled as "Turkish_o".
Another problem with "9–22" is that many people think it means that the lowest group has 9% and the highest group has 22% Central Asian contribution, rather than Central Asian contribution of Turks lies between 9% and 22% . Still, that is not your responsibility.
Coming to the main subject of the post you quoted: the purpose of that post was to explain that when Anatolian Turks are modeled using MA2195, they require an excess Eastern Iranic heritage. If we exclude Anatolian Turks from MA2195, what we are left with besides groups like Rums, Armenians, and Slavs are also Eastern Iranic groups.
Therefore, the purpose of the post was to argue that the average Oghuz conqueror's East Asian ancestry should be lower than 48%, given that Anatolian populations did not possess an Eastern Iranic-specific admixture. This Eastern Iranic admixture was brought to Anatolia by the Oghuz who carried it. Consequently, if there is an excess Eastern Iranic heritage left over, this indicates that the average East Asian ancestry should be lower than that of MA2195.
This is not the only formula I use to calculate the average East Asian ancestry of the Oghuz conquerors. Furthermore, as can be seen from qpAdm and other tools, when Anatolian Turks are modeled in the format of Hunnic_Eurasia (RISE603, BRE008, BRE014, KRY001) + East Iranic (China_Xinjiang_Abusentaar_IA_oWestEurasian) + Local Anatolian (proxy varies by region), the combined amount of East Iranic + Hunnic weights generally tends to be higher compared to when they are modeled with Karakhanid or MA2195. The formula I use for this is as follows:
[Hunnic weight x East Asian percentage of the proxy (hypothetically let's say 87%) + East Iranic weight x East Asian percentage of the proxy (hypothetically 5%)] % (Hunnic weight + East Iranic weight) (Alternatively, it can also be calculated as 100 % [(Hunnic weight + East Iranic weight ) % East Asian weight(Mongolia_North_N or another proxy for it)]).
To give an example (which I will put visually): Turkish_Aydin.HO is modeled as Hunnic_Core 13.5%, China_Xinjiang_Abusentaar_IA_oWestEurasian 21.3%, Mugla_Stratonikeia_Byzantine 65.2%.
If this formula were to be applied to this sample:
[(13.5 x 87) + (5 x 21.3)] / (13.5 + 21.3)
This would give us a result of 36.81.
This indicates that the amount of Oghuz conqueror East Asian ancestry affecting this Aydin_HO sample is around 37%.
On this matter, a friend of mine (@Ilb3548) ran about 1,800 qpAdm runs(Turkish_Aydin.HO,Turkish_Balikesir.HO,Turkish_Kayseri.HO) with a neutral right set, and the result he found was that models requiring excess Eastern Iranic or having lower East Asian Central Asian samples (such as da89) had a tandency to pass meaning that out of 1,800 runs, we obtained a result showing that an excess Eastern Iranic contribution is quite correlated with a higher tendency to pass. I will send you these 1,800 runs via dm for you to check out.
Tonyukuk retweeted
Genetic Profile of EarlyModern Kazakhs
Most of the Samples are from Central. Without the Outlier (B2_B7) Sample
#Kazakh #kazakhstan #KazakhKhanate #G25 #Genetics
Although pre-Turkic Slavic migrations to Anatolia are documented by historical sources, their autosomal presence ,while not constituting a very high value, can still be observed particularly in the northwestern regions. Furthermore this presence is supported by various branches of I2 and R1a Y-DNA that do not exhibit a founder effect. While Y-DNA alone is not a reliable historical explanation on its own, the existence of non-founder effect Y-DNA lineages is particularly important for providing insight. In fact some individuals carrying Slavic paternal lineages even migrated from Anatolia to Azerbaijan.
Replying to @agaoglulevent
Yes, this is another nonsensical model in which Slavic ancestry penetrates deep into Anatolia.























