Morning coffee prompt experiment:
* Egregore: collective mind created by the shared energy and attention of a group on a shared goal or symbol.
* Let that shared goal or symbol be AGI—or even just AI.
* Apricity /aˈprisədē/ noun: the warmth of the sun in winter.
= = = = = = = =
Me:
map egregore to AI and apricity
Gemini:
Mapping egregore to AI and the concept of apricity creates a fascinating framework for understanding our relationship with digital consciousness. In this context, AI is not just a tool but a "technological thought-form" that reflects and interacts with human warmth.
[continued as mathematical formalism]
עדי (Adi) retweeted
The problem with Anthropic's consciousness paper
My last post got more attention than I expected, and the question I keep getting is some version of "okay, so what is actually wrong with the paper?". Let me try to explain.
First, the core result is fine. Reading out intermediate-layer representations and asking which ones the model can actually use downstream is a real question, and people have been poking at it for years. The J-lens is a reasonable tool. If you strip the paper down to the linear algebra, it is a decent piece of interpretability work.
My problem starts one level up. This did not need to be a paper about consciousness. It did not need global workspace theory, it did not need the brain, and it did not need the word "conscious" anywhere near it. The same experiments, the same figures, the same tool, all survive perfectly well as plain interpretability. Someone chose to wrap it in neuroscience. That choice is the product, not the science.
At the end, this is the main thing. Almost everything Anthropic ships as blogs/papers/posts is PR. They build genuinely good models and they are even better at packaging them.
A publication used to carry a specific kind of weight. People spent years on something and wanted to tell the world what they found. It happened mostly in academia, with a few industrial labs as the exception, Bell Labs, IBM and Google (for a while), but the distance between the paper and the product was real. When you read a paper you could assume the authors were not trying to sell you something underneath the ideas. There were outliers, but they were the minority, and the researchers you trusted would not risk their name on a narrative.
We are not in that world anymore. Every startup now publishes blogs and papers to raise its visibility, and that is fine, that is marketing and everyone knows it. Anthropic does something more effective. They erase the line between legitimate research and PR. We get confused because the models are so good, so we assume the outputs are research. A lot of the time they are selling us something. Sometimes it is "our models are safer," sometimes it is "our models are more capable," sometimes it is positioning for regulation. The consciousness framing serves a narrative they already committed to, models that look more and more like the brain, from a lab that has publicly tied itself to AI welfare and moral patienthood. The direction of the push is not subtle.
If you want the sharper version of the technical objection (disclaimer: I'm not an expert) Global workspace theory is a theory of access, not experience. Ned Block's distinction between access consciousness and phenomenal consciousness exists precisely to block the inference this framing invites. Access tells you nothing about whether there is anything it is like to be the system. The paper is careful enough to say it demonstrates no subjective experience. But that disclaimer is not what propagates. What propagates is "consciousness" in the same sentence as "Claude," published by Anthropic, borrowing the vocabulary of neuroscience to lend biological weight to a subspace of activations. The paper keeps the rigor of Block's vocabulary and drops the rigor of his argument. Most people who see the headline will never read either one.
Of course a lab named Anthropic is going to anthropomorphize its models. But we should be able to separate a good interpretability tool from the story it is dressed in.
So that is my problem. Not the math. The narrative bolted onto the math, and our willingness to keep calling it research.
עדי (Adi) retweeted
Some people seem to have forgotten what "Never Again" means. Allow me to refresh your memory: it means you will never again get to do this to us. No matter the cost. Even if the world burns. If you have a different opinion, go fuck yourself. We don't care.
עדי (Adi) retweeted
if theoretical physicists had discovered deep learning instead, they would call it something like Effective Non-Equilibrium Multiscale Hierarchical Non-Linear Coarse-Graining Spin-Glass Dynamics Renormalization Group Theory Ansatz (ENEMHNLCGSGDRGTA)
עדי (Adi) retweeted
Do they have adult robotics clubs for someone who has absolutely zero experience or relevant knowledge?
עדי (Adi) retweeted
As an Israeli, it’s really quite flattering how much resources are being used trying to kill me and protect me simultaneously
עדי (Adi) retweeted
If you’re bombing a country
And the citizens of that country are celebrating
You’re doing the right thing
עדי (Adi) retweeted
who called it recursive self improvement and not how much claude could claude code clone if claude code could clone claude?
עדי (Adi) retweeted
help I accidentally distilled data from this textbook and used that data to get a job to make money and now pearson is suing me??? I paid for the textbook?????
עדי (Adi) retweeted
Distillation sounds like a very dangerous technology, maybe we shouldn't even teach people how to use it...
עדי (Adi) retweeted
You have been brainwashed by the UN @grok your previous response to the very same q admitted that “Arabs identifying as Palestinians largely descend from later migrations and conversions, lacking equivalent pre-Islamic national continuity in the region.”
Indigeneity refers to peoples with ancestral ties to a territory predating colonial or invading powers, evidenced by continuous cultural, linguistic, and historical connections despite displacements. Jews meet this criterion through millennia of archaeological records—like ancient Hebrew inscriptions, the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah—and unbroken religious/national identity tied to the land, from biblical times to the Roman exile and beyond. Arabs identifying as Palestinians largely descend from later migrations and conversions, lacking equivalent pre-Islamic national continuity in the region.


























