Amanda Bowen retweeted
Yesterday Dr Hilary Cass told the BBC that gender-affirming clinicians are “charlatans” and that most gender-questioning children “grew out of it.”
Today I have submitted a formal referral to the GMC raising concerns about her professional conduct in relation to the Cass Review. @gmcuk
helenwebberley.com/p/i-have-…
Amanda Bowen retweeted
Lies, lies and then ....more LIES!
Back in 2022, the UK media lost its mind over the Tavistock clinic’s Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS).
Headlines screamed "scandal": Daily Mail branded it a “Transing Factory,” The Sun called it a “Discredited NHS clinic handing out hormones to kids,” and The Times dropped the bombshell: “Tavistock gender clinic to be sued by 1,000 families”
This story went viral, parroted across outlets, fueling anti-trans panic that led to the clinic’s shutdown.
Thousands of trans and non-binary youth lost access to vital gender-affirming care – not because of clinical failures, but due to a manufactured moral outrage.
Fast forward to the truth, uncovered via a Freedom of Information (FOI) request to Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust for 2012-2022 data on the former GIDS:
Total complaints: Just 142 over 10 years, for a service handling up to 12,000 users at peak.
Complaints about “wrong or inappropriate” gender-affirming care: EIGHT.
Pogust Goodhead lawsuits: ZERO complaints pursued by this law firm, despite their hype about a group negligence claim. Their website still vaguely references “Tavistock failings,” but there are no active cases.
This FOI obliterates the narrative.
No flood of negligence suits.
No “Transing Factory.”
Just 8 gripes amid overwhelming demand for care that was too slow, too cautious. The real negligence? Closing the clinic based on tabloid fiction, leaving trans kids in limbo.
As the Yorkshire Byelines exposé (10 Feb 2026) nails it: “The real scandal was that thousands of children… lost their healthcare not for any clinical reason, but because of institutional and organised transphobia by the UK government, media and a handful of anti-trans activists.”
Neither The Times nor Pogust Goodhead replied to Byelines requests for comment. There Silence speaks volumes.
Ultimately, there were LIES.
Just as the gender-critical and their media are LIARS when it comes to complaints about the use of single sex spaces - as proven by the FOI data from TransLucent.Org.UK
Post-Cass Review, with puberty blockers restricted and services fragmented, trans youth still suffer from politicised “safeguarding” that prioritises fear over facts.
We need evidence-based care, not hysteria.
Read the full Yorkshire Byelines article and share widely!
yorkshirebylines.co.uk/news/…
Amanda Bowen retweeted
Anti-trans activists are intentionally interfering with data collection to skew evidence, shape public knowledge, and influence policy. This is a coordinated anti-science campaign aimed at shaping law and public opinion against trans people through misinformation.
EXCLUSIVE: Anti-trans activists are negatively impacting scientific research by pushing for 'the existence of trans people to be an impossibility' in data gathering, according to a new study thenational.scot/news/257851…
Amanda Bowen retweeted
Fighting trans hysteria in Britain is so frustrating. Nobody listens. It’s like being in an episode of Black Mirror. Our enemies get to dictate what we are called and how we are described on tv and radio. Complaints by our community are simply brushed aside.
I’ve been writing to @bbcnews and @itvnews in recent weeks about how insulting the terms they now use about trans people are. And raising my very real fears that the BBC and ITV are going to push a vulnerable trans person who finds themselves suddenly in the news spotlight to suicide.
Same that happened to Lucy Meadows.
Almost three weeks on from me writing, @itvnews have not replied. I copied in @RachelCorpTweet @ronkephillips and @laurajwilshaw . ITV’s Home Editor @PaulBrandITV - despite being a gay man and attending various LGBT events where he hears heartbreaking trans stories - is as much use as a chocolate ashtray. Silent. “Well, there are two sides.” Very disappointed by this. Community, aye? Especially as ITV/ITN were the first (and still only) British broadcaster to have a national trans newsreader.
Something that would be completely impossible now in the Age Of Hate, now LGBT inclusion and diversity are no longer in vogue. ITV has crumbled. Fair-weather friends. Fickle. I’m alright Jack. Sure, they’ll champion what they see as acceptable minorities - but trans people: Not interested.
The BBC’s Director of News, @rburgessbbc has at least replied. Which is a small tick. In short, he denies @BBCNews is biased, and says the Gender Critical movement must have a say on how we - trans people - are described. Because we are “contested”.
He also denies BBC News (like ITV News) were biased in their coverage of the Sandie Peggie and Darlington Nurses cases.
To me, it’s nothing more than gaslighting, but I’ll let you decide. Emails to follow 👇@GoodLawProject @TransLucent_Org @AttitudeMag
Amanda Bowen retweeted
Last week, the media declared a “partial victory” for Sandie Peggie, who sued the NHS for letting a trans colleague use the women’s changing room. In fact, the case was a flop. The gender-critical movement might be persuading journalists, but it’s failing with judges 🧵
Amanda Bowen retweeted
We have today written a three-page letter to Girlguiding, the first two of which we are making public.
Amanda Bowen retweeted
When I defended my Master’s thesis under the bombing and rubble of Gaza, the very first question I was asked was:
“Why defend it under these circumstances? What benefit will it bring you now?”
I smiled and answered:
“Maybe I will die holding this degree, maybe it will be a symbol of resilience and strength, and maybe I will inspire others not to abandon their dreams — even in danger, even when death is near.”
This is who I am.
I am proud of what I did.
Proud that I defended my Master’s during the war.
Proud to have become a Palestinian researcher ✌️
Amanda Bowen retweeted
Last night, JK Rowling branded our paper “anti-women” over a story I published
Frankly, Ms Rowling, you have no idea who I am or what our paper stands for
Here, @LauraEWebsterr explains why "anti-trans" is indeed suitable language for these activists
thenational.scot/news/252532…
Amanda Bowen retweeted
🏳️⚧️ NEW 🏳️⚧️
We don't think the interim guidance published by the EHRC and pushed by Bridget Phillipson is lawful.
So today we've started legal proceedings against them.
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Sending a letter before action is not "starting legal proceedings". The very point of a Pre-Action Protocol LBA is to "try to settle the dispute *without* [legal] proceedings".
The Good Law Project have previously had to apologise for misleading statements such as this.
contend.legal/courts-and-pro…
Amanda Bowen retweeted
Ethnic cleansing was always the plan — and our government cannot pretend it didn’t know.
A statement from the Independent Alliance.
Amanda Bowen retweeted
I am really saddened by the level of vitriol and hatred being directed toward the trans community.
We are losing our common humanity. How hard is it to treat people with kindness and respect?
Trans people are human beings — and they deserve to live in dignity.
Amanda Bowen retweeted
Ok explain to me like I’m 5 what’s the fucking difference between innocent women & children being killed in Ukraine, to innocent women & children being killed in Gaza? Why’s it not acceptable in Ukraine but it is acceptable in Gaza? Seriously what TF is wrong with you people?
Amanda Bowen retweeted
New guidance tells GPs not to support trans people by providing blood tests. This is under Wes Streeting's political control of the NHS. This isn't healthcare, this is putting people at risk.
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
This is misinformation. The NHS has NOT been told not to provide blood tests to trans children.
x.com/wesstreeting/s…
x.com/DHSCgovuk/stat…
Amanda Bowen retweeted
Going through boxes from my parents’ storage, I stumbled upon a school project I did at the Jewish day school I attended for 9 years. It’s from either 1999 or 2000 & is very disturbing. A 🧵 about Zionist indoctrination of Jewish children outside 🇮🇱. Pics of the project below 👇
Amanda Bowen retweeted
This massacre must be one of the worst atrocities of all. Rescue workers murdered one by one, then buried in a mass grave.
This is clearly a war crime.
All those responsible should be brought to trial.
And we should stop arming Israel.
theguardian.com/world/2025/m…
Amanda Bowen retweeted
Probably about to lose some followers and I don't actually care.
I read comments from someone today - for probably the 10,000th time - telling a trans person "umm you know actually, you know, you can't actually change your sex and you are delusional."
I want to talk to those of you who say such things. Because, I know you think you are right, and I know you think you are being helpful.
You are not.
You do not know thing one about gender dysphoria or about how these people have struggled. You take a thing that is perfectly normal for you - being at peace in your own gendered body - and you weaponize it against people who have never had that peace. And you tell them that they are wrong for wanting what you just naturally have, that they are broken, that they are delusional, that they need therapy, etc. Or worse, you insinuate or say that they are predators and fetishistic sickos.
You lack even a basic understanding.
They know they can't make their DNA the opposite sex. They just want their body to be more in alignment with what they have yearned for and longed for, in almost every case, since early childhood. They have a lifetime of listening to people like you communicate to them about how weird / wrong / stupid / delusional it is for them to feel the way they do... and yet they still do.
The movement against trans people is not reasoned or principled the way you think it is, and that's true no matter how much you insist it nor how deeply felt that belief you have is. You are not helping.
Listen to me - just listen:
These are people. Almost every one of them has felt this basic disconnect since they were children. Many if not most have already struggled with and fought over it for years before they ever get to the point of even daring to speak it, to say nothing of taking hormones and transitioning. They almost all universally have had the therapy that you think will cure them, and it didn't. Almost all of them have spelunked through their own self-doubt / self-loathing / fear / disgust / hopelessness... just to cobble together a fragile truce that lets them breath enough to even acknowledge that what they are feeling is real.
Then along you come.
And you pile on them not only all your biases and misunderstandings and demands over who *they* should be, but all of your pseudo-scientific BS and your overgeneralizations and in some cases just your pure, selfish bigotry and nastiness... because they have finally, after all their torment and torture and doubt... finally gotten up the courage to stop hurting privately and the courage to start trying to heal.
So naturally, your response is what?
To make them suffer publicly.
With all due respect, may I suggest that f you cannot make peace with someone else living life in their bodies in a way that brings them the peace they have searched for since they were just littles.... that you, my friend, are the one with the problem.
It's not them, it's you.
They are not broken. They are not flawed. They are not bent, evil, horrible, etc.
This is a you problem. You deal with YOU. Don't deal with them, when the reality is that it's you who are bringing your baggage to the ball.
That's all I have to say... click that unfollow button now if you wish; just get on with it. I don't have time for games or for pretending.
That is all.
Amanda Bowen retweeted
Vivian is very much alive and well @elonmusk. You’re just a deadbeat father 😑
Amanda Bowen retweeted
Replying to @ApostateProphet
Here's a brief history of Gaza (full disclosure: I'm a historian of Palestine):
1516 - Ottomans rule Gaza
1917 - Britain occupies Palestine, adopting the anti-democratic Balfour Declaration, rejecting the political will of 85% of the population of Palestine who declared their opposition to Zionism to the King-Crane Commission. teapaw.org/_ZachFoster/status/177…
1917 - 1947 - Britain subjugates 90% of the population of Palestine (the Palestinian Arabs), ignoring their democratic wishes, favoring the Jewish minority, making it easier for Jews to buy land via the annulment of Arab communal land tenure, granting Jews but not Arabs communal autonomy, favoring Jews over Palestinians in awarding contracts & industrial concessions (e.g. Palestine Electric Corporation, Palestine Salt Company, Palestine Potash & Sulphur Quarries), imposing a surveillance regime over the Arabs to subvert their political activity, imposing harsher penalties for Arabs than Jews for similar crimes; preventing the establishment of a Palestinian university & limiting Palestinian secondary education to subvert their political activity. palestinenexus.com/courses/p…
1947 - UN proposes giving the Zionist community of Palestine 56% of Palestine, even though they constituted 33% of the population & owned ~5.5% of the land.
1948 - Israel tried (and failed) to conquer Gaza even though the partition plan called for an Arab state there.
1948 - Israel tried to poison Palestinian Arab wells in Gaza, killing many innocent civilians teapaw.org/_ZachFoster/status/157…
1948 - Israel violently expelled ~200,000 Palestinians from their homes, pushing them to the Gaza Strip (in total, some 750,000 Palestinians were expelled from their homes by Israel during the war).
1950 - Israel expel the last remaining 2,600 Palestinians in Majdal. Israeli forces loaded them onto trucks, sending them off to Gaza. Whoever refused to leave was coerced through intimidation and violence. palestinenexus.com/articles/…
1953 - The Israeli military attacked the al-Bureij Camp in Gaza, killing 50 civilians, seeking to dismantle the refugee camp altogether to disperse in residents. Another Egyptian-UNRWA plan, supported by Israel, was to expel some 60,000 Palestinians from Gaza to Sinai, where land & Nile River water for irrigation was apparently going to be provided. But the project failed when Palestinians demonstrated en masse on 1 March 1955. palestinenexus.com/articles/…
1949-1956 - Tens of thousands of Palestinian refugees (many from Gaza) tried to return home. They were overwhelmingly unarmed. The Israeli army adopted a shoot to kill policy, massacring ~2,700-5,000 during this period. teapaw.org/_ZachFoster/status/180…
1956-1957 - Israel invaded Gaza, occupying it for 4 months. On 3 Nov 1956, Israeli forces entered Khan Yunis, rounding up all men 15+, lined them against a wall, & executed them. They did the same thing in Rafah. They massacred hundreds of Gazan Palestinians in cold blood. teapaw.org/_ZachFoster/status/172…
1967 - Israel re-invaded the Gaza Strip in a war of choice (theintercept.com/2017/06/05/…) imposing a belligerent military occupation there that has lasted to the present day.
1967 - On 18–19 June 1967, the Israeli cabinet adopted this decision: "...[the Gaza Strip] would be annexed to Israel once the number of refugees there was significantly reduced by transfer to other locations of countries." teapaw.org/_ZachFoster/status/176…
1967 - Israel pushed out some ~40,000 Palestinians from Gaza, because they were of the incorrect religion/ethnicity. jstor.org/stable/pdf/4185795…
1968-1970 - Israel pushed out tens of thousands of Palestinians from the Gaza Strip, then forcibly expelled another 38,000 Palestinian refugees in Gaza in 1971 and tried to compel the rest to give up their refugee status or leave the refugee camps throughout the 1970s and 1980s. palestinenexus.com/articles/…
1967-1987 - Israel kills 32 Palestinians on average every year for 20 years (in Gaza & the West Bank); Israel denies Palestinians politica rights. Israel imprisons Palestinians like Fathi Ghaben for painting paintings with black, red, green and white. Israel regularly arrests, detains, tortures and deports Palestinians for speech critical of Israel's brutal military occupation. palestinenexus.com/articles/…
1987 - From December 1987 - December 1988, Israeli forces slaughtered 142 Palestinians in Gaza, while Palestinian forces killed 0 Israelis in Gaza. teapaw.org/_ZachFoster/status/173…
1987 - 1993 - Israel killed about 1,200 Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank.
1990 - Israel threatens the livelihoods of 40% of the population of Gaza, who was at the time working in Israel or in Israeli settlements in Gaza, by requiring them to apply for a permit that was previously granted automatically.
1994 - 1996 - Israel imposes suffocating lockdowns on Gaza, leading to 70% unemployment rate in Gaza during periods of total closure. see Gordon, Israel’s Occupation, 73.
2000 - 2005 - Israel slaughtered ~3,000 Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank, imposing suffocating lockdowns on Gaza, leading the World Food Programme (@WFP) to spin up an emergency food operation in Gaza to save hundreds of thousands of Palestinians in Gaza from going hungry.
2006 - 7 - Israel tightens it's illegal & inhumane siege on Gaza, whose goal was to "dispel the claims regarding Israel's responsibility for the Palestinians in the Gaza Strip" & to “freeze the peace process" (words of Dov Weisglass, Advisor to the then Prime Minister Ariel Sharon).
2007 - present. Israel imposes the longest lasting siege in modern history on Gaza, putting 2M Gazans "on diet," controlling their caloric intake, leading to widespread devastation: 40% of Gaza's population live in poverty, most of them in extreme poverty, more than 80% of households dependent on food aid. Dozens if not hundreds but probably thousands die in Gaza every from inability to receive proper medical and Israel's refusal to allow Gazans to seek care outside of Gaza, owing to the punishing siege, including Fatimah al-Masri, who was murdered by Israel in 2022 after Israel refused to allow her to exit Gaza for medical treatment source btselem.org/gaza_strip/20230…
2008-9 - Israel waged a war on Gaza. Israel killed 1,400 Gazans (who killed 3 Israeli civilians). The Goldstone Report found no justifiable military objective was identified in 90% of Israel's deadly attacks on Palestinian civilians & that Israel's goal was “punish, humiliate & terrorize civilians.” teapaw.org/_ZachFoster/status/171…
2012 - Israel killed 171 Gazans (who killed 4 Israeli civilians); 60% of Gazan victims were civilians; the war started when Israel assassinated Ahmed Jabari, who was about to sign a permanent ceasefire with Israel. Israel preferred war to strengthen it’s “deterrence capacity.” teapaw.org/_ZachFoster/status/171…
2014 - Israel killed >1,500 Gazan civilians (who killed 6 Israeli civilians). Israel launched 6,000 airstrikes on Gaza, mostly on residential buildings. In 40% of investigated cases, the @UN found no explanation for bombing civilians, concluding Israel likely committed war crimes teapaw.org/_ZachFoster/status/171…
2018-9 - Israel killed 223 Palestinians & Israeli snipers left 6,106 Palestinians with life-changing wounds (0 Israeli casualties) after 10s of thousands of unarmed overwhelmingly peaceful Gazans marched to the fence, demanding the right of return and protesting against the siege. No Israeli experienced any major harm at all. teapaw.org/_ZachFoster/status/171…
2021: Israel killed 261 Gazans (who killed 14 Israelis); 113,000 Palestinians were internally displaced; Airwars report concluded: in 70% of the deadly airstrikes on civilians, no militants or military targets were found & Israel indiscriminately targeted dense civilian areas. teapaw.org/_ZachFoster/status/171…
2023 - present. Israel has slaughtered hundreds of thousand of Palestinians in Gaza, used starvation, sexual violence and rape as weapons of war, denied 2.2M people access to water, medicine and shelter, froze dozens of babies to death, in what @hrw, @amnesty, @un and @msf call a genocide.
Replying to @_ZachFoster
2021: Israel killed 261 Gazans (who killed 14 Israelis); 113,000 Palestinians were internally displaced; Airwars report concluded: in 70% of the deadly airstrikes on civilians, no militants or military targets were found & Israel indiscriminately targeted dense civilian areas.































