Andrew Grant (@amwgrant) header
Andrew Grant (@amwgrant) profile picture

Climate change, nature, natural resources.

Joined September 2011
Photo by Andrew Grant (@amwgrant)Photo by Andrew Grant (@amwgrant)Photo by Andrew Grant (@amwgrant)Photo by Andrew Grant (@amwgrant)Photo by Andrew Grant (@amwgrant)Photo by Andrew Grant (@amwgrant)Photo by Andrew Grant (@amwgrant)Photo by Andrew Grant (@amwgrant)Photo by Andrew Grant (@amwgrant)Photo by Andrew Grant (@amwgrant)
Andrew Grant retweeted
LOVE this cover! But the content—so many issues... Let me just pick a few.
6
74
27
310
Currently seeing a lot more confirmation bias than data-driven analysis on this topic.
Have you noticed all the Takes doing the rounds about how the current spike in fossil fuel prices shows the energy transition won't work? This is, IMO, absolute brain-wormed nonsense. I wrote on this topic today, here's a quick thread to explain: bloomberg.com/opinion/articl…
So at high level, would seem that venting methane or burning it ultimately results in the same number of atmospheric carbon and ultimately CO2 molecules. The GWP calculation gives the illusion that CNX is preventing 25 molecules of CO2 being emitted for each molecule of CH4.
1
Clearly, it is better to not vent CH4. But ultimately, seems hard to call it carbon negative when it’s the same number of carbon molecules being emitted and only a temporary warming benefit.
1
Footnote: CNX views a 1.5 degree/ net zero by 2050 outcome as “bleak”.
Interesting questions around GHG accounting in CNX’s recent report. It claims to be “carbon negative” across scope 1+2 by virtue of capturing methane from a coal mine (that it no longer owns), that it would otherwise have been vented. The methane (fossil gas) is then sold. 🧵
"Is CNX carbon negative? Arguably no. There's a short-term warming benefit to removing methane a more potent contributor to global warming. They've effectively removed somebody else's Scope 1 emissions & moved it to their Scope 3 emissions" said @amwgrant spglobal.com/marketintellige…
2
1
2
More fundamentally, does this mean CNX can be “carbon negative”? CH4 is a potent GHG but short lived, and then degrades into more stable CO2. CH4 has a half-life in the atmosphere of a decade, whereas CO2 lasts 10x that.
1
On a system-wide basis presumably this should mean the coal miner reports equal positive emissions for the CH4 even though it doesn’t enter the atmosphere. If not then the capture would be double counted. I can’t tell, as the Coronado ESG report is restricted in the UK.
1
CH4 is assumed to have a global warming potential (GWP) of 25x CO2 (100 year average). CNX therefore publishes relatively low emissions from scope 1 and 2 only, with a bigger negative number on a CO2-equivalent basis for the captured methane.
1
The emissions would have been methane (CH4) in the miner’s scope 1, but is now CO2 in CNX’s scope 3 when its customers burn it. Scope 3 accounts for the vast majority of lifecycle fossil fuel emissions, and CNX doesn’t report it (it did for 2019, but didn’t fancy it this year).
1
Andrew Grant retweeted
Great chart by Sankey @crudegusher today re: $XOM and their outlandish forward projections
5
9
6
68
Exxon the first company I've seen take a $20bn impairment charge "as a result of the growing strength of its portfolio". $XOM corporate.exxonmobil.com/New…
Great framing from the Canada Energy Regulator. Headline: new pipelines can "accommodate" all future oil growth in low carbon Evolving scenario Their data: new pipelines = completely surplus in low carbon scenario. Our Pipe Dreams report concluded same carbontracker.org/reports/pi…
Diamondback is about the only O&G producer I am aware of that doesn't have either an explicit or implicit volume growth target in its executive remuneration package - yet its production is proving more resilient than peers.
This quoted post is unavailable.
2
5
Definitely real people
1
Shell impairment being driven by changes at the front end of impairment price deck - it had already moved to $60/bbl long term at year end 2019. Equinor keeping with the optimism for oil/failure of energy transition, it assumes a long term price deck of $80 (2019 real $).
President Putin wants the world to stop and think about the impact renewable energy is having on wildlife. Particularly worms bloom.bg/2Jpg1xt
1
8
1
6