
A place of safety?, podcast on the mental health system in the UK and elsewhere! DM's open, get in touch! Email: [email protected]
Joined February 2019
- Tweets31.4K
- Following804
- Followers1.7K
- Likes26.1K
Pinned Tweet
For those at the back who are unclear about the relation between the Trieste/Basaglia/Democratic Psychiatry (whatever we want to call it) and "diagnosis"... I will try to explain what the idea of putting the diagnosis "in brackets" means in relation to the current debate 🧵
A place of safety? Podcast retweeted
Trainees in the therapy professions once worked to develop their expertise. Now, some seem primarily interested in developing their brands.
“Expertise” becomes a performance for public consumption, disconnected from knowledge and experience.
Training becomes irrelevant when people can no longer distinguish performance from reality. Visibility and popularity are all that count.
I wish I had something positive and optimistic to add to this, but I just don’t. I’m sorry.
To start from the bottom, maybe we need to look at what the story of that patient is and we may find out that there's a pattern of failures starting waaay before that moment. At that point, justifying forced treatment based on that event starts appearing less persuasive.
You know, I'm a fairly harsh critic of modern psychiatric practice. But when I see tweets calling out psychiatry for "having the power to commit you to treatment against your will," I'm wondering what the remedy is here. Because in about forty-five years of psychiatric practice, I've seen hundreds of patients being involuntarily hospitalized, treated, and relieved of their suicidal urges--and ultimately appreciative of our interventions. To say nothing of their family members.
But if you're hell bent on changing the system, you're going to have to change THE LAW that facilitates commitment. If we choose NOT to commit a patient against their will, and they kill themselves, we can be sued for a VERY LARGE AMOUNT OF MONEY, and will eventually lose our license to practice. This isn't a PRIVILEGE of psychiatry, but an OBLIGATION. The libertarian in me can conceive of suicide being considered a personal right--but I have no legal right to indulge such a belief.
So if you want psychiatrists to cease doing so, you simply need to make suicide a LEGAL RIGHT available to anyone--including your patient that happens to be down in the dumps for whatever reason, buys a gun, and blows their brains out. Then when we're confronted by the family members, we can cite confidentiality, and the patient's right to do so. I guess I could live with that, if it's the law.
But what if they're threatening to BLOW SOMEBODY ELSE'S brains out?
2
3
247
Reactive thinking is indeed very useful when applied to immediate concerns but it's a deeply misguided thinking process when used to design systems of care. Psychiatry exists within a wider network of power dynamics and can't be blamed for where we are, yet it also cannot
1
1
34
What I think history might eventually come to think of this moment in time is that the world is experiencing a failure in moving away from what is usually disparagingly identified as "ideology".
This is evident across different levels of politics and also in mental health care.
as proof that we should not be "ideological", rather than proof that sound arguments are important.
Of course, their proposals to fix the issue ("let's all go private") belie their own ideological assumptions, of which they are in denial and about which they don't allow a debate.
It's quite unfortunate but the UK mh system and Trieste's, & to a significant extent the overall Italian mental health system are deeply offensive to each other. The first prides itself on controlling & separating patients from society, the more unwell the more ostracised.
1
1
80
When the second ideology (used in the most noble sense of the term) advocates for compromise in shaping treatment, for not having a pre-determined answer for any patient, the first sees this as lack of scientific rigour and efficiency, or as lack of loyalty towards guidelines.
1
5

