That is correct. If you are a complainer in a sexual assault/rape trial, anonymity is not just for those who do not know you, but perhaps equally important those who do. Why would you want colleagues, friends etc knowing without your consent? That would be partial anonymity.
The Court heard that "a section of the public" could be a single individual who works alongside the complainer.
So the risk that information might identify somebody to one person
outweighs the right to publish information on a government led conspiracy to frame an innocent.
2
3
685
No it's not... the decision has been sent back to the SIC, so it's not over. This has some way to go yet...
Not terribly surprised, unfortunately, but the decision goes back to the SIC (so it is not over). The fact that the SG did not bring the case of @CraigMurrayOrg to the SIC's attention was a clear dereliction of duty and incompetence. That they used that against him in Court
BREAKING: Court of Session finds Scottish Information Commissioner "erred in law" over demand to release Salmond files heraldscotland.com/news/2668…
Fundamentally, though, I did feel uncomfortable during the hearing, that there did appear to be an ambiguity in the SICs decision. For the sake of those complaining about public figures, to me it would not be good for FOISA to be seen to undermine this.
1
7
573
I've submitted an FOI or two over the years... can't say I have ever been offered a meeting with one civil servant nevermind four.
Update to story of the independence activists who were offered a meeting because they submitted a thorny FOI request to Scot Gov. Four civil servants participated in that meeting - quite remarkable.
(Clip shows Jim Osborne, a Tim Rideout sidekick, speaking at SSRG conference.)
1
9
1,064
With the ministerial code back in the news I just got this back from the SG. I had asked for the communications in which the Independent Advisors were told not to respond to @AnasSarwar email for an investigation into Angela Constance. They refused, and only when the case was
Replying to @benjamin_harrop
Mr Anas Sarwar MSP on 16 December 2025. On advice we did not respond to either request ourselves given the way in which a referral or a decision to undertake an independent investigation should be made."
On those advice were the Independent Advisors told this and why? No where
can tell the Independent Advisors who they can/cannot correspond with, and crucially, concerning leaders of political parties who have made allegations, is a weakness of the code as it stands. Whether or not anyone in Scotland should be able to do so is one Q, but the
1
3
530
I have had a chance to fully watch the case again, and here are my thoughts (remember I am not a lawyer!): I think the case is 50/50, and there are two issues at stake. However, a critical problem has arisen in that the SG did not, in their submissions to the SIC, make reference
Tomorrow, from 10:30, at the Court of Session, is quite literally FOI endgame, the FOI that I submitted in April of 2021 is being heard. How strong our FOI Act will be tested, and it will affect us all (it can be livestreamed here: scotcourts.gov.uk/livestream…)
the SIC will have to do its investigation again and issue a new decision. Roddy Dunlop said that even if the SIC knew about Murray he would still be defending the decision (02:53:00), so the judges may take that into consideration, as we might be back in the Court again.
1
3
450









