
Writer: New Statesman, The Financial Times, The Times, The London Magazine, The Spectator and Engelsberg Ideas. [email protected]
Somerset
Joined July 2021
- Tweets376
- Following1.5K
- Followers1K
- Likes2.1K
Pinned Tweet
‘How is a biographer to capture a subject like this, one as inscrutable as a stone, as ethereal as the west wind? This is the dilemma facing anyone who undertakes to write the life of Emily Brontë.’
My review of Deborah Lutz’s This Dark Night:
My review of Tessa Hadley’s first essay collection, Alone with a Book, for @spectator:
1
4
350
Charlotte Stroud retweeted
Really interesting piece by @questingvole on how you can devoutly read to your children and yet still find they may not grow into voracious readers later in life spectator.com/article/the-re…
‘Poetry makes nothing happen,’ W. H. Auden wrote, ‘it survives’; and because it does, so can we.
My review of Marlon James’s The Disappearers for @spectator
1
2
219
Annie Dillard’s Pilgrim at Tinker Creek is the closest thing I have to a sacred text. A paean to the mystery and extravagance of creation, it’s a book that can sustain a lifetime of rereading. RIP, Annie
2
183
Charlotte Stroud retweeted
I rewatched Paul Thomas Anderson's 2017 movie 'Phantom Thread', which I hadn't seen in many years. I think it is especially important to see now amid the Nolan debates (he loves this movie), as contrast.
My thoughts upon rewatching:
🪡 It is very very hard for a filmmaker to be truly wise. Wisdom -- sapientia --, the knowledge of people and the world is independent of talent, life experience, often even age. True, some artists are more sensitive, more attuned. But many end up as less wise because they are also so attuned to themselves, and focus on the inside too much.
But PTA has now been wise several times, and shown he understands people and the world very deeply: Boogie Nights, Magnolia, Punch-Drunk Love are works of wisdom. I was worried when he hadn't shown his knowledge again until Phantom Thread came out. Phantom Thread is a work of great wisdom, like the novels of Proust or Tolstoy, like the movies of Bergman or Sally Potter. Again, this is very very hard to do, and PTA has done it 4 (!) times.
(By contrast Chris Nolan never made a wise movie until glimpses of sapientia showed up in The Odyssey, a story he finally did not write himself.)
🪡 It is very hard to portray being in love on the screen. You think, oh every filmmaker tries it. True. And they mostly fail. As do writers. Especially in our polite, rational, behavioral studies ridden, post-woke era, people expect love and desire to be clean, polite, ultimately risk-free, every emotion and urge keeping nicely to their little boxes, and even if you want it differently, there is a name for it, now you have a "kink", and even that will be data-captured, and categorized for you.
This attitude, needless to say, is the opposite of wisdom. Knowing people is knowing that love is always a revolution, as is art. Nothing is birthed in a polite way. Nothing new can be created predictably. When you say I want to make something new -- a new private world with somebody, a new piece of art, a new social entity -- you unleash a chaos you know you won't be able to fully control. (Our contracts, norms, weddings are but ways to mitigate the thus unleashed human tsunamis.) Men and women come from two different systems, and our encounters, be they personal, intellectual, or professional, always necessarily break rank. We rebel for each other, and break things. That is the whole point: to break the stasis, the sterility!
PTA chose to show the visceral, vicious disrespect encoded into LOVE by contrasting the pristine Christian white fabrics and the boiling primordial witchcraft of the kitchen, familiar to every parent of a toddler, anyone with a household, every date, every first communion. It is ME in the white satin. It is also me scarfing down juicy, saucy food, and licking my fingers. Do you like me? Or do you like only the well-washed version of me? You see how that is impossible.
And so from the outside, every couple must look totally insane -- if the relationship works, their inner logic will cohere and will look bizarre to everybody else outside. The participants will look unjust, their behavior puzzling, their love unmet. And yet...
(Contrast with how unconvincing the self-built couple worlds of Inception or Oppenheimer felt, intellectually over-constructed for the actors but never inhabited because those relationships did not internally make sense. But love always does make sense to the participants, and in terms of its endurance which is its proof.)
🪡 It takes wisdom to show that the most serious aspects of life are still just a game. Art, legacy, money -- sex, family, loyalty. Nations. Betrayals. The great war of the sexes. The great heartbreaks with lasting trauma. Grief. Hope. Addiction. When you find your willing playmate, the game comes to life and becomes an intellectual pleasure.
There is no sex in Phantom Thread -- a movie about a love -- because there doesn't have to be: it is seething with desire in every corner of that old house, with every creaking of the stairs, every stitch of the needle and stir of the spoon. Everything these two people do conveys lusting and plenitude, hunger and greed and fealty. When they fight and think it's over is when you know their relationship begins. Words matter little, the people stay.
I often despair over how hard it is for filmmakers to show real desire, the terrifying, embarrassing, impolite, identity-threatening, values-subverting experience that humans experience through their sexuality and both want it and does not want it, flee from it, reject it. And it still happens. Men and women, we break rank even with ourselves to reach the other. You don't need scenes of naked people fucking to make the audience *feel* that terror and that beauty. You can just drape a piece of clean fabric on a woman who does not and will not stay clean, but will somehow cleanse this man who wants to.
A very very wise filmmaker. An impossible feat achieved. A great movie. Paul Thomas Anderson didn't even have a cinematographer, he wanted to be the eyes of this movie. I see why.
Go (re)watch it.
Charlotte Stroud retweeted
New Substack post: Style is Morality richardstrachan.substack.com…
Charlotte Stroud retweeted
For the July issue of @commonwealmag, I wrote about Gabrielle Tergit’s novel Effingers, brilliantly translated by Sophie Duvernoy and published by @nyrbclassics
commonwealmagazine.org/jense…
Charlotte Stroud retweeted
At some point academics will surely have to take the fight to the Admin Class. Say straightforwardly to VCs that if cuts have to be made, then it’s time to liquidate the lanyards.
Worrying from Exeter - the University it seems planning to slash humanities teaching while telling colleagues it is “in line with the government’s industrial strategy”. bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cx2d…
Really enjoyed this intelligent dissection of Starmer’s resignation speech.
As Martin Amis used to say, ‘style is morality’. Starmer’s reliance on off-the-peg phrases tells us all we need to know.
Charlotte Stroud retweeted
That we are forced to endure people blasting music over such moments of national significance is indicative of our wider problem. It is - quite obviously - preposterously antisocial and rude, but we just allow it to continue with a shrug as if there is nothing we can do about it.
Charlotte Stroud retweeted
The Ruffian has LANDED. This week: why I am, uh, somewhat sceptical that Burnham will be an effective PM
Charlotte Stroud retweeted
The folks at Lit Hub were kind enough to publish an extract from LIKE A CAT LOVES A BIRD: THE NINE LIVES OF MURIEL SPARK, all about Spark's idea of the 'intellectual monster' (a woman who, horror of horrors, isn't all that fussed about men and marriage)
lithub.com/an-intellectual-m…
My summer reads, for @EngelsbergIdeas
More excellent recommendations here: engelsbergideas.com/essays/a…
Charlotte Stroud retweeted
Adam Kirsch reviewed The Master of Contradictions for @nybooks:
“The combination makes The Master of Contradictions the rare work of literary criticism with real appeal for the common reader.”
nybooks.com/articles/2026/06…
Charlotte Stroud retweeted
‘How is a biographer to capture a subject like this, one as inscrutable as a stone, as ethereal as the west wind? This is the dilemma facing anyone who undertakes to write the life of Emily Brontë.’
My review of Deborah Lutz’s This Dark Night:
Charlotte Stroud retweeted
The art of biography has its limits, especially when it is aimed at a life lived through literature.
There was no ‘I’ in Emily Brontë | @char_stroud
engelsbergideas.com/reviews/…



















