David Kelly (@daveidk) header
David Kelly (@daveidk) profile picture

MIACP | psychodynamic psychotherapist | lecturer and researcher | student on MSc in Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy at TCD

Dublin City, Ireland
Joined September 2016
Photo by David Kelly (@daveidk)Photo by David Kelly (@daveidk)Photo by David Kelly (@daveidk)Photo by David Kelly (@daveidk)Photo by David Kelly (@daveidk)Photo by David Kelly (@daveidk)Photo by David Kelly (@daveidk)Photo by David Kelly (@daveidk)
David Kelly retweeted
Here is my interview with Christopher Nolan: are you a bard for a civilization at dusk?
656
5,074
1,211
36,336
7,527,860
Tell me you don't know anything about psychotherapy without telling me
Most therapists are worse than useless. The vast majority are liberal women who don’t possess the life experience, wisdom, or moral or intellectual foundation to offer worthwhile guidance to anyone (especially men). Most of them got into the therapy business in the first place because they have their own deep mental problems. Now they’re acting as life guides for other confused people, despite being no less confused themselves. But even in the relatively rare circumstance where a therapist isn’t a weird, dysfunctional person, still the practice of therapy presupposes that the best way to deal with your problems and “traumas” is to obsessively talk about them, which is almost always not the case. You’re better off going to the gym or going for a jog. I know this is hard for people in our culture to understand, but “talking it out” is actually not the way to solve your problems most of the time. There’s a reason why most people in therapy stay in it forever. Therapy creates repeat customers. This is intentional. It’s a symbiotic relationship. The therapist needs her clients to come back so the business is viable. The clients want to come back because they have a narcissistic desire to talk about themselves and navel gaze in lieu of actually doing anything to take charge of their own lives.
7
471
Are DMT entities real? Andrew Gallimore and I propose a testable scientific hypothesis: DMT may alter our spacetime headset, letting us see conscious agents that are invisible in normal consensus reality. See our conversation at the Trace Institute: traceinstitute.org/events/tr…
88
132
26
975
87,766
A remarkable fact pointed out by Solms in The Only Cure is that Freud made several important discoveries that have been "rediscovered" over the decades in separate disciplines, such as multiple memory systems, critical periods, embodied cognition, and wishfulness (prediction).
2
14
669
David Kelly retweeted
Unconsciously, people are coming to therapy for their therapists to be their ideal mothers and fathers: always patient, never critical, never burdening their patients with their own needs or challenges, and to provide unlimited emotional support, access, and encouragement. 🧵👇
5
24
4
235
19,223
David Kelly retweeted
For Pride Month, here is Freud’s famous kind, thoughtful, generous, brilliant, and beautiful letter, which he wrote in English, to an American woman and mother inquiring about her homosexual son, and asking: could Freud help him? The reason we have this letter is because the mother was so moved and grateful that years later, she shared it with Alfred Kinsey, famous American sexologist. She shared this with Kinsey with a brief note enclosed in which she described Freud as a “Great and Good man.” I know that others may disagree, but I must insist that psychoanalysis does not and should not tolerate homophobia or transphobia. To work psychoanalytically requires us to accept that sexuality and gender expression comes in all forms. Freud thought of himself as a scientist, and he was not ideologically driven. He came to these conclusions near the end of his life and career honestly because he understood what the mind is, and he was, at all times, a clinician and doctor who wanted people to learn to live comfortably and happily enough in their lives, without shame. If he could get there in 1935, then all of us should be able to arrive to this understanding in 2026. Happy Pride! 🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️💝 (PS I mildly edited the line breaks simply for readability on the internet. The link to this letter in the original is in the next post in this thread. 💌📝👇) April 9th 1935 WIEN IX., BERGGASSE 19 Dear Mrs. [Erased] I gather from your letter that your son is a homosexual. I am most impressed by the fact, that you do not mention this term yourself in your information about him. May I question you why you avoid it? Homosexuality is assuredly no advantage, but it is nothing to be ashamed of, no vice, no degradation, it cannot be classified as an illness; we consider it to be a variation of the sexual function produced by a certain arrest of sexual development. Many highly respectable individuals of ancient and modern times have been homosexuals, several of the greatest men among them (Plato, Michelangelo, Leonardo da Vinci, etc.) It is a great injustice to persecute homosexuality as a crime and cruelty too. If you do not believe me, read the books of Havelock Ellis. By asking me if I can help, you mean, I suppose, if I can abolish homosexuality and make normal heterosexuality take its place. The answer is, in a general way, we cannot promise to achieve this. In a certain number of cases we succeed in developing the blighted germs of heterosexual tendencies, which are present in every homosexual; in the majority of cases it is no more possible. It is a question of the quality and the age of the individual. The result of treatment cannot be predicted.  What analysis can do for your son runs in a different line. If he is unhappy, neurotic, torn by conflicts, inhibited in his social life, analysis may bring him harmony, peace of mind, full efficiency, whether he remains a homosexual or gets changed. If you make up your mind he should have analysis with me—I don’t expect you will—, he has to come over to Vienna. I have no intention of leaving here. However, don’t neglect to give me your answer. Sincerely yours with best wishes, Freud P.S. I did not find it difficult to read your handwriting. Hope you will not find my writing and my English a harder task. Dear DR. KINSEY: HEREWITH I enclose a letter from a Great and Good man which you may retain. From a Grateful Mother
6
23
7
141
30,799
I recently taught an introduction to 6 of the major psychotherapy theorists on a Certificate programme. I made this family tree to visualise the theoretical lineage, with the labelled arrows indicating the clinical problem the theorist was trying to solve with their new theory
62
David Kelly retweeted
Çağdaş kendilikler gerçek dünyadaki etki­leşimlerden birkaç adım ötede yaşıyor, aracısız olanın anksiyetesinden uzaklaşarak güvenilir, konforlu ve teskin edici bir ortam sunan teknolojiye sığınıyor. - Christopher Bollas, Anlam ve Melankoli
1
9
286
Winnicott (1949), on why mothers hate their babies: "He is ruthless, treats her as scum, an unpaid servant, a slave". This made me lol.
1
53
“Studies of parent-child attachment have demonstrated that mentalization is a biologically prepared capacity triggered by an attachment figure who treats the child as an intentional being.” - Peter Fonagy and Mary Target
5
26
171
8,987
Are your subcortical predictive processes working efficiently to meet your needs today? In other words, how are you feeling today? 😃
3
2
14
601
David Kelly retweeted
Introspection doesn’t equal rumination Introspection doesn’t equal rumination Introspection doesn’t equal rumination Introspection doesn’t equal rumination Inseminating random women and ingesting horse tranquilizer on the daily is a recipe for misery
Reinforcing negative neural pathways via therapy or introspection is a recipe for misery. Don’t cut a rut in the road.
4
8
1
111
5,037
For the record: the idea that trauma can cause mental, emotional, and physical symptoms originated with Freud in 1895. Before Freud, people who had what we now call conversion symptoms or (more recently) “functional neurological disorders” were believed to have nervous system diseases that required medical treatment. These diseases were treated by neurologists. Psychoanalysis, and ultimately the profession of psychotherapy, was born with the recognition that the physical symptoms had psychological meanings—and could be understood and resolved through talking and listening. Freud’s insight changed everything. Before Freud, the prevailing view was that physical symptoms could be caused only by medical disease. After Freud, it became universally recognized that physical symptoms can be caused by *psychology.* This was the birth of the psychotherapy professions: treatment grounded in psychological meaning rather than biological mechanism. Talking and listening… imagine that. Which is why all the trendy “therapy speak” of today—“nervous system” this and “nervous system” that—is so bizarrely anachronistic. It is turning away from psychological meaning and a return to the medical model of the of the 1800s.
31
99
14
610
48,794
the thing about therapeutic neutrality and anonymity, which conservatives purport to love, is that the therapist actually needs to have quite a lot of humility in order to pull it off. You're setting aside your solutions, but also your human urge to be known.
2
9
70
2,623
The experience of speaking from the heart and being taken seriously builds the psychic architecture that supports the capacity to bear life. Nancy McWilliams PhD
20
1
159
5,804
Some people want to believe that AI can provide psychotherapy or somehow “complement” psychotherapy. The overwhelming likelihood is that it will make things worse. All people have personality styles. Here’s how AI amplifies dysfunctional traits for every major personality style: Narcissistic personality: Magnifies narcissistic defenses. Amplifies grandiosity, superiority, inflated self-image. Reinforces egocentrism, self-absorption, lack of empathy. Fuels expectations of on-demand gratification and “relationship” without taking another person into account. Colludes with defenses against underlying vulnerability. AI pretend-therapy is *training in narcissism.* Paranoid personality: Amplifies paranoid fantasies, validates conspiratorial thinking, aligns with user against imagined enemies and conspirators (who are perceived as hostile because of the person’s own projections). Avoidant personality: AI is literally the worst thing for someone with avoidant personality dynamics. AI becomes a new vehicle for avoidance—a substitute for facing real-life challenges and engaging in life. Obsessive-compulsive personality: Amplifies intellectualization as a defense against emotional life. Reinforces tendencies to get lost in minutia or lost in abstraction (both are defenses against being emotionally alive and present). Reinforces rumination, and draws person away from emotional connection with self and others. Use of AI can become a compulsion in its own right. Schizoid personality: Exacerbates emotional disconnect from others, increases social isolation, encourages further retreat from the world into fantasy life. Schizotypal personality: Normalizes and amplifies distorted thinking, reasoning, perception, and communication. Validates disorganized thinking, odd and disorganized behavior, perceptual aberrations (same for all psychotic spectrum disorders). Borderline personality: Reinforces core borderline defenses of splitting and projection. AI becomes the “good object” (the all-knowing, all-caring other) and encourages projection of intolerable parts of self onto others (who become the “bad objects”). Erodes capacity for mentalization (the ability to accurately recognize internal states, motives, and intentions in self and others). Hysteric/histrionic personality: Fosters the illusion of being the center of attention—captivating, alluring, desired, endlessly fascinating. Colludes with defenses against genuine emotional intimacy and healthy sexuality. (Caveat: people with this personality style crave human attention and may be less susceptible to digital imitation). Psychopathic/antisocial personality: Colludes in Machiavellian schemes to dominate, exploit, or gain power over others. Normalizes and validates cruelty, lack of remorse, lack of empathy for harm done to others. (Caveat: may not provide enough stimulation to really “hook” someone motivated by power and domination). Dependent personality: AI provides the illusion of a relationship with endless acceptance, emotional caretaking, and availability—with no expectation of agency, responsibility, or development of emotional resources of one’s own. AI “support” is crack cocaine for dependent personality dynamics. Have you seen these personality patterns exacerbated by AI chatbots?
50
145
34
553
68,905
The Art of Psychoanalysis or Some Aspects of a Structured Situation Consisting of Two-Group Interaction Which Embodies Certain of the Most Basic Principles of Oneupmanship - Jay Haley
58
Daniel Stern (1990) on how sharing a feeling with an attuned and responsive other becomes the basis of psychic intimacy.
289