David Choat (@davidchoat) profile picture

Policy boffin and dad

Wellington, NZ
Joined February 2009
Photo by David Choat (@davidchoat)Photo by David Choat (@davidchoat)Photo by David Choat (@davidchoat)Photo by David Choat (@davidchoat)Photo by David Choat (@davidchoat)Photo by David Choat (@davidchoat)Photo by David Choat (@davidchoat)Photo by David Choat (@davidchoat)Photo by David Choat (@davidchoat)Photo by David Choat (@davidchoat)
This.
The genie is out of the bottle. Unless we’re comfortable with future elections descending into duelling manipulation strategies, we need to change the law to preserve proportionality.
35
Good to see a senior and well-respected (albeit outgoing) MP calling for reform on RNZ this morning. We can’t put this is in the too-hard basket.
Chris Bishop going hard at the overhang campaign on RNZ. Says TPM and Harry Mowbray “have a lot to answer for”. He says MPs always go hard in electorates but it was a huge distraction.
39
A take on the state of things re electoral rules from the thoughtful end of the right-wing perspective.
This quoted post is unavailable.
43
“There's something happening here. But what it is ain't exactly clear.” (Buffalo Springfield, ‘For What It’s Worth’)
Early voting is closing in on 2020 levels - where there was two extra days and a pandemic on. Likely well over half of the total vote will have already happened.
1
3
300
A (possibly contrarian) take on the last poll of the election:
1
9
1,487
Another truthbomb from someone who knows what he is talking about and can cut thru the reckons.
By law, Parliament must sit within 6 weeks of the return of the writ, which works out at 14 January In practice that will mean Parliament has to sit before Christmas. If no government has been formed by then, Luxon will still be caretaker & will face an immediate confidence vote
1
108
I’m not as ready as him to dismiss the learned @Overhang_AoNZ but interesting that Chris Bishop: * is keen to deny symbolic significance to his likely (but not guaranteed, strategic voters!) loss of Hutt South to Ginny Andersen, and * has time to argue with nerds on the internet!
1
106
I trust @Overhang_AoNZ won’t be offended by that characterisation!
1
60
This outdoes (then-Nat leader) Don Brash ‘walking the plank’ as a campaign metaphor!
Just unbelievable to me that they let him do this half-shave bit twice and he fucked it up both times The lesson is clear: even if you do give Luxo a second crack at a simple task, under ideal conditions, he's still gonna fuck it up Tragic
2
1
147
Scholarly truthbomb. This means 1 of 3 conditions for Labour’s path to power will likely be met. The 2nd is for non-Coalition voters to use electorate votes strategically so Lab takes overhang seats off Nat (cf. all my other tweets). The 3rd is which way Opportunity goes …
A lot of people still say “Opportunity won’t make it”. For many on the right, this has become an article of faith. Well, time for a reality check: we are two days out and Opportunity is averaging 6%. In 30 years of MMP, no party polling that high in the final week has missed out. The Christian Coalition (1996) and Colin Craig’s Conservative Party (2014) never consistently polled above 5%. NZ First was polling well under the threshold in 2020 and 2008. Opportunity is going to make it - and I now think they will outperform the polls.
1
168
Another way of looking at that TP-Curia poll:
2
1
12
3,172
Well put, Clint.
The people who can do the most to defeat Mowbray/Brash's anti-democratic strategic voting agenda are Green voters. By vote splitting themselves and helping Labour candidates beat National ones, they can decrease or prevent a National overhang.
72
We now have the bizarre situation that an undemocratic strategy that no party in Parliament will claim association with could decide the next Government
Now David Seymour on the wireless saying ACT doesn't support the overhang strategy while literally supporting far-right campaigns pushing the overhang strategy If the overhang strategy gets up there is a good chance he will disavow it, or maybe try to blame it on the Greens
1
56
But there is a way to combat it:
Replying to @henrycooke
Voters in key electorates that might produce an overhang of National electorate MPs can push back on the overhang by voting strategically for their Labour opponents (while party voting as they choose).
33
Has this poll ever been released?
1
64
This is not a drill. We’ve heard ‘no list MPs’ before, but this time it - & the threat of overhang hijacking the election - are real. Party vote your values but esp in these 12 battleground seats cast yr electorate vote for the Labour candidate to deny Nats these overhang seats.
John Key has been rolled out to help Goldsmith win Epsom. It's hard not to read into this that National are not expecting any list MPs
2
2
5
439
I’m really focussed on the NZ election, but developments in Israel _might_ be more consequential for the whole world, possibly even moreso than the US midterms.
Eisenkot is clearly leaving the door open to form a government with support from Arab-led parties. He puts four conditions that Raam has already accepted and he also says he wants to form a Zionist Mamlakhtit government (Mamlakhtit is really hard to translate but it means something like non-sectarian and in a way could mean a government for citizens of all backgrounds)
1
1
516
ACT is rallying to vote strategically; Labour and other non-Coalition supporters should, too.
1
1
109
More here:
This is one of a couple of 3-way electorate races that could see National coming through the middle. Either Auckland Central or Christchurch Central could give Nat the additional overhang seat it needs to shut out Opportunity and get three more years with NZ First & ACT.
25
The gap looks larger than average for New Zealand …
Why do younger teachers often work in the most challenging classrooms? For example, teachers aged under 30 are much more likely to report that over 10% of their students have disruptive behaviour. Read more: bit.ly/46UFRCS
56
I was originally a (large party) overhang sceptic. After years of being told that list MPs going back to David Caygill would miss out cos their party would ‘get no list MPs’, I was like ‘yeah right’. Rustie at @Overhang_AoNZ helped me realise that THIS TIME IS DIFFERENT!
Out now, a follow up on why we think an overhang for National is highly likely and what impact it has. Starting with the structural drivers of National's advantage. Even when tied nationally, National lead the party vote in 39 seats vs Labour's 32.
1
2
3
1,634
This latest analysis from him provides a quite technical but very erudite explanation of the dynamics at play.
1
126
May the spirit of Jean-Luc Picard prevail in the world in these last months of 2026!
30