You all really need to watch this. Then watch it again and share it with every braindead imbecile that sings from Mehdi’s lies. Mehdi Hasan sat down with former Israeli intelligence official Avi Melamed and asked the question he treats as settled fact. Was Gaza a genocide? He asked the question after manipulatively attempting to lead the conclusion to his own delusion. Melamed’s answer was simple. NO. He then did something Mehdi’s usual format isn’t built for. He defined the term instead of treating it as some stupid slogan. Three conditions have to be met. Firstly, a formal ideology that calls for the destruction of a group, secondly, a concrete blueprint for carrying it out, and thirdly, the actual execution. He walked through them one by one. Hamas, he said, checks every box. In September 2021 they held a conference in Gaza, sponsored by Yahya Sinwar, that produced a 20-point plan for what would happen after Israel’s “liberation.” Most Jews, the document made clear, would not survive. Certain specialists would be kept alive temporarily for their expertise. That was the blueprint. October 7 was the execution. Israel, he argued, does not meet those conditions. Civilian deaths in a war against an enemy that embeds itself among its own population are tragic. They are not the same thing as a plan to eliminate a people as a people. Hasan’s standard move is to treat the accusation as self-evident and demand that anyone who rejects it defend the indefensible. Melamed refused and it showed the clear difference between someone honest and intelligent and someone who is a pathological liar and dumb as rocks like Mehdi is. He didn’t deny the scale of the destruction. He simply insisted that the legal and historical category of genocide requires specific intent and a plan, and that the evidence of both sits with Hamas, not with the state that responded to an explicit attempt to carry that plan out. That is the difference between an argument and a narrative. And also the reason why Mehdi has never won an actual argument, probably because he doesn’t argue, he just lies and shouts. One can be tested against documents, evidence and definitions. The other only works if no one is allowed to ask what the words actually mean. This was almost as severe a demolition as @HausdorffMedia inflicted on Mehdi.
19
222
17
605
14,532
Accusation of genocide is the most vicious blood libel against Israel, it ends in the destruction of every Jewish person on Earth
14
Anyone accusing Israel of genocide is actually expressing genocidal intent towards Israel and the Jewish people, and will be held accountable
6
Learn about the legal aspect of war and changing the definition of genocide
2
91
Free all the World
10
A Gazan pleads with Egypt to allow them to cross the border (which Egypt keeps sealed against Gazans with massive walls), stating: "We are actually from Egypt, our true roots are in Egypt, we are Egyptian after all—let us return there."
61
400
42
946
21,511
Izzy David retweeted
Mosab Hassan Yousef, the son of one of Hamas's founding members, is warning Israel about Israeli Arabs. He comes from that world. He knows what he's talking about. Are you going to call him a racist?
8
54
11
91
2,310
Today at the United Nations: dozens of diplomats will attend a special screening of UNraveling UNRWA, a film that exposes Hamas’s infiltration of UNRWA. This is a reality that can no longer be ignored.
240
1,679
56
5,725
98,574
"L'islamisme est un problème mondial. C'est une maladie universelle. C'est le SIDA. Il faut se mobiliser partout. L'islamisme est une pathologie, comme le fascisme, le stalinisme, le nazisme". [Boualem Sansal]
203
2,807
129
6,943
92,480
Yishuv Eretz Yisrael
34
36 שעות אחרי, כולם כבר מבינים בדיוק מה קרה כאן ואסור לנו להרפות או לוותר. את הבחירות הללו חייבים לבטל לאלתר!
323
218
26
1,401
55,148