Footydoc (@footydoc) profile picture

All tweets and views are personal. Re-tweets are NOT endorsements.

Joined February 2014
#ShreeJagannathaMandirLondon coming soon. Divine Daaru Brahmas found, 30 acres land identified. Calling all Shree Jagannatha devotees to support this sacred mission Visit jagannathtemple.org.uk Donate at paypal.com/fundraiser/charit… @BBSRBuzz @sabyaactor @sukant74 @SurjyaOfficial
Shree Jagannatha Society UK’s first newsletter inaugurated by Odisha Legislative Assembly Speaker Shri Surjya Narayan Patro sambad.in/story/making-of-ja…
To all Western Agenda against Bharat.... Bharat has one missile. That's @palkisu She eats narratives raw in breakfast & doesn't even leave crumbs behind.
75
2,119
26
6,917
144,503
Recently I told you there are two kinds of people in this system: cynics and believers. Ursula von der Leyen, I put her with the believers. And that's exactly why you need to understand how the machine works. Because cynics are very rare. Soros, I put him in that category: he knows exactly what he's doing, and he has never hidden it. He read Popper, he has a theory of change, and he understood early on something the right still hasn't figured out: you don't change a society by winning an election. You change it by funding, for thirty years, the people who will write the reports, train the lawyers, and advise whoever wins the elections. $24 billion spent by Open Society since its creation. More than 50,000 grants. In 2015, he wrote in plain text that the EU must accept at least a million asylum seekers a year, and mobilize NGOs, churches and businesses to take them in. All of it is public. That's the most impressive part. Here's how the system got hacked, in three steps. Step one: selection. Nobody recruits idiots. No need. The money does the selecting on its own. A grant never goes to the person who doubts. It goes to the person who already believes. Repeat that over thirty years and tens of thousands of grants, and you get an entire ecosystem where the free thinker was filtered out at the door. He wasn't fired. He just never got funded. What's left: people who are sincere, credentialed, conformist, and whose paycheck depends on the cause. Step two: funding manufactures conviction. Try explaining something to someone whose paycheck depends on not getting it. The NGO produces a report. The report gets cited by an expert. The expert testifies before the Commission. The Commission turns it into a directive. And the NGO guy ends up in a cabinet, then goes back to a foundation. Everyone knows each other, cites each other, funds each other. It's an echo chamber with a budget. Step three: emotion. You never debate results. You debate intentions. One photo beats a thousand statistics. Every objection backed by numbers becomes a moral failing. And when reality contradicts the narrative, the dissonance always gets resolved the same way: "It's a necessary evil." "It's collateral damage." "The real problem is elsewhere." Immigration is never a problem. The problem is your perception. The result: the system doesn't produce corrupt people. It produces NPCs. People reciting a script while convinced they wrote it themselves. Ursula doesn't need to be bought. She has spent her entire career in an environment where every expert, every report, every "civil society" group tells her the same thing. She is convinced she's on the side of good. And that's what makes her immune to facts. And the best part of the story: Soros isn't even the system's biggest funder anymore. You are. Between 2021 and 2023, €7.4 billion in EU funds went to more than 12,000 NGOs. The European Court of Auditors itself says it can't get a reliable picture of who gets what. The hack worked so well that the machine now runs on your taxes. This is not a conspiracy. A conspiracy hides. Here, the amounts are public, the op-eds are public, the recipients are public. It's an incentive system. And you don't fight an incentive system by insulting the believers. You fight it by cutting off the tap and demanding total transparency: who funds whom, to say what. As long as it stays opaque, they'll keep shipping believers at scale.
306
2,847
299
7,447
290,795
Footydoc retweeted
I was a very fortunate kid. My dad's GP surgery sat between the Dell and Hampshire's County Ground, so at weekends I could go to a game and get a lift home afterwards. It left me with a passion for both sports and a belief that sport opens a window onto who we are. When I was growing up, the Tebbit test was a matter of intense debate. Which side did you cheer for at the cricket? For all the criticism it received, it was a test anyone could pass. If you supported England because you saw it as home, you were part of the team regardless of the colour of your skin. Born in Southampton, 10 year old me passed it without even knowing about it. Giving the @MCCOfficial's Cowdrey Lecture on Thursday made me think about cricket's place in our national life and the current arguments about identity. In Britain we've built the world's most successful multi-faith, multi-ethnic democracy. I was a beneficiary of it. Whatever issues people had with me as PM (and there was no shortage) my race and religion weren't among them. I could read a lesson at the King's coronation or light Diwali diyas on Downing Street with my daughters without controversy. Foreign leaders assumed these must be huge symbolic moments. For most Brits, they just weren't that big a deal. But Britain's democratic achievement is now under strain. Some of the challenges are ones I've written about before, like Islamism, and the failure of governments, including the one I led, to adequately control immigration. But something else is going on - a risk that we start equating skin colour with nationality. After I left office, a debate kicked off here on @X about whether I was English at all, because I was a "brown Hindu". During the election campaign I'd been shocked when footage was broadcast of someone calling me a "Paki." It was shocking precisely because it was so unusual. That kind of abuse had simply not been a feature of my political life. But the Englishness argument was stranger still. Call it the reverse Tebbit test. If you're not white, it no longer matters who you support at the cricket, because you can never be English. It's a test no non-white person can ever pass. I have no truck with people who offend our sense of fairness and come here illegally; I spent half my premiership trying to deport them to Rwanda. I think the bar for legal migration should be high. It is entirely possible to want a radical reduction in immigration and a far more robust approach to integration, and still totally reject the attempt to turn Britishness into a DNA test. If you're born and brought up in England and view it as home, what are you other than English? Denying people their Englishness or their Britishness because of the colour of their skin is a recipe for alienation and a two-tier society. How are children who hear this meant to feel? Sport can play a small but significant role here. Cricket is played by nearly every major ethnic group in this country. Ask what my largely white rural constituents in the Dales and the British-Asian kids in Bradford have in common, and the answer is cricket. If cricket can produce England teams in which every kid can see themselves, the impact reaches far beyond the boundary. As I write in @thetimes today, we must all be on the same side, cheering for the same team. We cannot allow race to be reintroduced into our politics. We cannot allow Briton to be set against Briton.
1,788
1,206
451
10,772
3,354,203
Classic Dalrymplism at work here. Neighborhood shrines that merchants were ALLOWED to tuck into mohallas are being used to wash the record at the great tīrthas. Conveniently hoisting the first to cunningly dismiss the second. Let’s break it down. For starters, let’s consider temples in the capital. These are small affairs folded into havelis and galis, typically without even a shikhara. Hard to even read from the street as temples. The article itself says that of the 96 pre-1857 temples in Shahjahanabad, only 12 have dated inscriptions. Of which, 10 are British-era and all post-1739. And what happened in 1739? Nadir Shah’s Sack of Delhi. That is not a some hidden golden age of imperial Hindu architecture. It’s just urban communities rebuilding after sack and living under a rule that preferred their religious artifacts invisible. Catherine Asher made the same observation...that these temples are almost invisible to the casual visitor. That invisibility was literally the policy. Moving out of Delhi, we have the Chaturbhuj at Orchha, Govind Dev at Vrindavan, Harideva at Govardhan. All build during Mughal reigns. But by whom? Hindu amirs (Bir Singh Deo, Man Singh, Kachwahas) who were inside the Mughal system. These are the “thousands” the headline leans on. They are not the regime’s temples. And the same article admits the pattern: Join us and we’ll let you build. Rebel and we hit your temples. Shah Jahan’s own Shah Jahan Nama records the demolition of Bir Singh’s expensive temple beside the Orchha palace when Jujhar Singh rebelled. These are what the popular memory means by “destruction.” They are not courtyard shivalayas. Diana Eck’s point still stands: no major sanctuary in Banaras as it stands predates Aurangzeb. A Gyanvapi or a Keshav Rai with a mosque on the same plinth is a different historical event from a Digambar shrine in Dharampura. The article itself concedes: This was less “syncretism” and more pragmatic: Jain and Khattri bankers underwrote the Mughal economy, whilst Rajputs, Marathas and Jats supplied much of the army. Correct. That is dhimmi fiscal-military logic, not religious equality. A state that needs Khatri credit and Rajput sowars would obviously not level every shrine in the qasba. The same state can still treat Banaras as, in Aurangzeb’s own words, “the great stronghold of infidelity.” Pragmatism and zealotry ran together but NOT on equal footing. “They needed Hindu bankers” does not explain why idols from Mathura were ordered buried under mosque steps “to be continually stepped upon,” or why the city was renamed Islamabad. That language is not “accountancy.” “Aurangzeb also issued farmans protecting Banaras Brahmins in 1659.” True, early in the reign, and consistent with “don’t touch ancient temples.” The 1669 general order and the Vishwanath demolition come later. Both documents exist. Quoting only 1659 is patently dishonest because the circumstances are far from the same! Muhammad too says “for you is your religion, and for me is my religion (109:6),” “For me are my deeds and for you are your deeds (10:41),” and “So whoever wills, let him believe, and whoever wills, let him disbelieve (18:29).” In Mecca. When he’s still seeking purchase. And what happens once he’s fully secure, in Medina? This: “Kill them wherever you find them (2:191).” “O Prophet, strive/fight against the disbelievers and the hypocrites and be harsh with them (9:73).” “After the sacred months, kill the polytheists wherever you find them, seize them, besiege them, lie in wait. If they repent, pray, and pay zakat, let them go (9:5).” “Whoever seeks a religion other than Islam, it will not be accepted from him, and in the hereafter he will be among the losers (3:85).” See the pattern? Aurangzeb was doing no favors what that 1659 firman. He was not a settled emperor with free will then. He was a usurper in the middle of a civil-war. A full coronation was still months away and Shah Jahan was still alive in captivity. Dara Shikoh was still loose until summer 1659. Dara’s public image in the east was the “Hindu-friendly” brother who read Hindu epics and swore by the Gita. Aurangzeb needed the same constituencies...the pandas, the merchants, the Rajput-linked patrons...not to treat the new regime as a purge. Do you think he could afford to go on a jihadi rampage? Temples were destroyed BY Mughals. Temples were built UNDER Mughals. Big difference! Now if you think all’s fair in war, sure. Vanquishing the enemy means destroying everything sacred to the enemy. But Benaras was no enemy when Granvapi came down. Nor were Hindus always the enemy. How many mosques did Shah Jahan tear down when he crushed Ahmadnagar and beheaded Khan Jahan Lodi? When his son took Bijapur and Golconda later, did he destroy the Charminar, Mecca Masjid, and Bijapur’s Jama Masjid? No. So “we only hurt the enemy’s holy places” predicts mosque demolitions that the sources do not give us. What the sources give us is selective. While the enemy is both Hindu and Muslim, the destroyed structure is always a temple. A Muslim rebel loses his head, his jagir, and sometimes his sons. He does not lose the masjid as a class of object. That the Dalrymples overlook this asymmetry is tragic because otherwise, they are such accomplished scholars. @Aabhas24 should be able to shine a lot more light on this subject.
9
214
2
718
16,392
- 1020-1140, Chaulukyas vs. Paramaras: No jauhar - 1100-1200, Paramaras vs. Chauhans: No jauhar - 1150-1180, Chaulukyas vs. Chauhans: No jauhar - 1160-1180, Chauhans vs. Gahadavalas: No jauhar - 1200-1500, Sisodias vs. Rathores: No jauhar - 1300-1400, Sisodias vs. Paramaras: No jauhar - 1300-1500, Sisodia internal succession wars: No jauhar - 1300-1400, Rathores vs. Paramaras: No jauhar - 1350-1500, Rathores vs. Bhatis: No jauhar - 1100-1300, Kachwahas vs. Chauhans: No jauhar - 1000-1200, Internal Chauhan branch feuds: No jauhar - 1100-1300, Bhatis vs. Jadons: No jauhar - 1100-1150, Tomaras vs. Chauhans: No jauhar - 1400-1500, Rathores vs. Kachwahas: No jauhar No fewer than two dozen major wars were fought among the Rajputs with zero Muslim involvement. Not a single episode involved self-immolation of any kind. Not one. Neither Indian, nor foreign accounts record a single instance. Now see this: - 712-712, Dahir of Sind vs. Muhammad bin Qasim: Jauhar committed. 1232-1232, Gwalior (Rajputs) vs. Iltutmish: Jauhar committed - 1301-1301, Ranthambore vs. Alauddin Khalji: Jauhar committed - 1299-1299, Jaisalmer vs. Alauddin Khalji: Jauhar committed - 1303-1303, Chittor vs. Alauddin Khalji: 1st jauhar of Chittor - 1327-1327, Kampili vs. Muhammad bin Tughluq: Jauhar committed - 1326-1326, Jaisalmer vs. Ghiyath al-Din Tughluq: Jauhar committed - 1486-1486, Kuva (Kankavati) vs. Mahmud Begada: Jauhar committed - 1528-1528, Chanderi vs. Babur: Jauhar committed. - 1535-1535, Chittor vs. Bahadur Shah: 2nd jauhar of Chittor - 1543-1543, Raisen vs. Humayun: 3 jauhars committed - 1568-1568, Chittor vs. Akbar: 3rd jauhar of Chittor - 1634-1634, Bundelkhand vs. Aurangzeb: Jauhar committed - 1710-1710, Daddanala vs. Mir Fazlullah: Jauhar committed Similarly, when the British came, we had a series of gruesome engagements starting with Plassey and Buxar, then going on to the Carnatic Wars, the Anglo-Mysore Wars, the Anglo-Maratha Wars, the Anglo-Gurkha War, the Anglo-Sikh Wars, the Anglo-Burmese Wars, the Anglo-Afghan Wars, and many, many more. No jauhar. Now, when someone like that book reviewer condemns “Hindutva” for “glorifying jauhar,” I am fully on their side. I agree it was a morbid ritual that does not belong in a civilized society, thank goodness we no longer do that. But do you see a pattern in the above lists? Why do you think this macabre ritual was practiced EXCLUSIVELY in conflicts involving Muslim forces? Why didn’t women feel the need to self-immolate when their kingdoms fell to any other adversary? You can’t be dumb enough to not draw the only possible conclusion here. Nobody glorifies jauhar, it was not picnic. We “honor” it. No, not the immolation itself but the debilitating sentiment behind it. With the honor we keep our alive in our collective memory. Know why? Because the demons that drove our ancestors to such extremities still live and breathe amongst us to this day. And they haven’t changed one bit. When someone prefers death to your touch, what even are you?
227
4,992
207
9,997
484,815
1/ Subhash Chandra Garg was the Finance Secretary of India. He signed off on Budgets built on national accounts data. And this week he went on NDTV and made a mistake a first-year economics student would lose marks for. 🧵
78
527
80
1,872
231,662
Footydoc retweeted
Dolly Parton shut down Barbara Walters and the video is trending. Still… nobody did it better than Sean Connery. Absolute legend.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​ A Must Watch.
569
1,051
136
12,306
1,014,643
Footydoc retweeted
They walked out just moments before disaster hit A village in the Nepal–Tibet region was struck by flash floods shortly after residents evacuated their homes
14
182
3
1,080
71,845
Footydoc retweeted
A deep analysis of what may have lead to the Nepal glacial collapse and a breakdown of how the flood overtook communities in a matter if minutes. #Nepal #flood #weather
264
3,872
455
20,490
4,134,953
Footydoc retweeted
The IMF was initially not very keen on granting Sri Lanka a bailout package, with directors feeling quite negative about the prospect. ​Listen to Sri Lanka's former Finance Minister Ali Sabry explain how a single intervention by *India and FM* @nsitharaman entirely shifted the tone and environment at the IMF. This crucial support led to Sri Lanka securing the bailout, laying the foundation for its economic recovery. ​Under the leadership of PM Modi, India continues to prove it is a true friend to its neighbours.
44
1,050
35
2,998
116,722
लाखों दर्शकों से कहता हूँ, जाकर कोई फैक्ट-चेक करे। 1896 के कोलकाता कांग्रेस अधिवेशन में पहली बार वंदे मातरम् गाया गया, जिसकी अध्यक्षता मुस्लिम नेता रहमतुल्लाह अहमद सयानी ने की। वहाँ से लेकर 1923 तक कभी कोई आपत्ति नहीं हुई। 1923 के अधिवेशन में तो उस समय मोहम्मद अली जौहर ने उसकी अध्यक्षता की थी उन्होंने आपत्ति की फिर भी पूरा गाया। झूठ बोलते हैं ये लोग। मैं पूछना चाहता हूँ, 1896 से 1937 तक हर बार कांग्रेस पूरा गा रही थी, तो 1937 में क्या हुआ जो काट दिया? मुस्लिम लीग और जिन्ना ने कहा कि आपको यह वंदे मातरम् काटना पड़ेगा, आप एक के बाद एक सरेंडर कर रहे थे। 1905 में बंग-भंग के बाद उस समय सारे हिंदू-मुसलमान एक होकर वंदे मातरम् गाते थे, मगर ये कट्टरपंथियों के आगे झुक गए। 1916 के लखनऊ कांग्रेस अधिवेशन में मुसलमानों के लिए पृथक निर्वाचन क्षेत्र माँग लिया। फिर उनकी हिम्मत और बढ़ी। फिर 1920 में इन्होंने कहा, टर्की का खलीफा हट गया है, तो अब हम टर्की के खलीफा के लिए आंदोलन करेंगे और महात्मा गांधी ने अली का समर्थन किया। उनकी हिम्मत और बढ़ गई। उसके बाद जिन्ना ने कहा, मैं महात्मा गांधी को महात्मा नहीं बोलूँगा। इसलिए हर फिल्म में मिस्टर गांधी बोलता है। फिर उसने कहा, मैं वंदे मातरम् नहीं गाऊँगा और मैं इनको बताना चाहता हूँ, कोई दर्शक जाकर चेक करे। 6 अप्रैल 1938 को नेहरू को जिन्ना ने एक लेटर लिखा और Selected Works of Jawaharlal Nehru, Series One, Volume 22, Page Number 230 से 239 में लिखा है। क्या शर्मनाक लेटर लिखा है। लिखते हैं, हमने वंदे मातरम् हटा दिया है। पॉइंट नंबर नौ पर। फिर उसके बाद लिखते हैं, पॉइंट नंबर 12 पर, अगर आपको तिरंगे से आपत्ति है, तो हम मुस्लिम लीग के भी झंडे को बराबर सम्मान देने को तैयार हैं। और पॉइंट नंबर सात पर लिखते हैं, मुसलमानों को सरेआम गोहत्या करने का अधिकार होगा। क्या गजब का सरेंडर किया नेहरू ने।
826
5,110
195
12,344
410,854
Sudhanshu Ji is Fire🔥
120
1,510
38
5,361
80,700
🚨 Breaking: Israel Prime Minister Netanyahu: “I call on the Spanish government to show restraint and refrain from a disproportionate response. Only a two-state solution can bring a long-lasting peace to Spain and to the Moroccan population living in its occupied territories.” 🤣
917
4,037
365
31,589
1,201,085
Mesopotamia was never the cradle of civilisation. India was. I spent forty years in international shipping, not academia. When I began researching the history of maritime trade, I had no orthodoxy to defend. I followed the evidence, and it kept arriving in the same place: the Indian subcontinent. Nineteenth century archaeologists dug in Mesopotamia because the climate preserved artefacts, the biblical sources pointed them there, and the Ottomans allowed the excavations. That is the entire basis for the myth of Mesopotamia as "the cradle of civilisation." Nobody applied the same rigour to India. Mohenjo-daro was not discovered until 1922. By then the narrative had already hardened. What was actually there was the largest civilisation of the ancient world. Three hundred cities. Fifty thousand people in each, by 2600 BC. Two thirds of them stood on the banks of the Sarasvati, the central and greatest of the seven rivers described in the Rig Veda, flowing down from the Himalayas before the river vanished entirely by 1900 BC. The Vedic kings claimed territory stretching "sea to sea," from Afghanistan to Maharashtra, some 1.5 million square miles, against Egypt's 13,000. A dock at Lothal built to handle thirty ships of sixty tons, unmatched in Europe for four thousand years. When it was first excavated, it was recorded as a bathing pool. When the scale became impossible to dismiss, the theory was not corrected. It was replaced with a story of pale-skinned nomads from the steppe who supposedly arrived around 1500 BC and brought civilisation with them. There is no evidence. The chronology doesn't work. The Vedas describe no invasion. In 2019 a Harvard-led genetic study revived the claim, and the press reported it as confirmation. It was not. The same study found the builders of these cities were indigenous. The Sarasvati river that the Rig Veda described had already dried up before these newcomers arrived. What the study also found is that a small group of men, arriving after the Sarasvati had already dried up, interbred with the existing population and left a genetic signature. That is all. So, where they chose to dig was mostly an accident of climate and access. The Aryan invasion theory was constructed because an Indian civilisation that owed nothing to Caucasians was a fact the late nineteenth century could not accommodate. Link to full Substack essay with sources in the comments below.
204
4,216
159
12,192
553,154
Meet Tahir Hussein’s cheerleaders. Today Court convicted AAP councilor Tahir Hussein and others in the murder of IB staffer Ankit Sharma. Time to call out these paid cheerleaders who tried to whitewash his heinous crime
136
2,542
61
5,011
79,072
Footydoc retweeted
Intonation changes meaning.
109
882
81
8,693
723,524
Footydoc retweeted
It's a shame no major film has been made about Biju Patnaik. He lived a life that sounds almost fictional: In 1938, he flew his entire wedding procession by aircraft to Rawalpindi for his marriage to Gyanwati Sethi (who became the first Indian woman to hold a commercial pilot’s license, and the couple later flew daring missions together.) While serving in the Royal Indian Air Force (including as head of Air Transport Command), he secretly ferried freedom fighters like Jayaprakash Narayan, Ram Manohar Lohia, and Aruna Asaf Ali to their hideouts. He also airdropped 'Quit India' leaflets to Indian troops while evacuating British families. The British once jailed him for transporting nationalist leaders and distributing anti-British literature but also honored him for bravery in evacuating civilians from Japanese-occupied Burma. During WWII, he flew daring missions delivering arms and supplies to Soviet forces in Stalingrad, and over the treacherous 'Hump' route to China in support of Chinese Nationalist forces against the Japanese. In July 1947, he and his wife flew a Dakota into Indonesia, landed on an improvised airstrip while evading Dutch anti-aircraft fire, rescued Prime Minister Sutan Sjahrir, refuelled using abandoned Japanese fuel, and flew him safely to India via Singapore. A couple of months later, during the Pakistani invasion of Kashmir, he airlifted one of the first Indian troops into Srinagar. The same year he founded Kalinga Airlines, one of India's earliest private airlines. As Odisha CM post-1962 India-China war, he secretly visited CIA headquarters at Langley to forge a covert India-US partnership against China, which led to the Aviation Research Centre (ARC) at Charbatia, which supported U-2 recon missions over Tibet. He was also a legendary administrator and statesman, laying much of the foundation of Odisha's industrial empire (mines, ports, heavy industries etc). When he passed away, Indonesia observed 7 days of state mourning. Russia observed 1 day. He remains the only person in Indian history whose body was draped in the national flags of 3 nations - India, Indonesia, and Russia. Few public figures have left such a footprint. His extraordinary life needs to be brought to the big screen.
What event in Indian history/recent current affairs do you want to see a film made on?
205
2,028
124
6,951
383,153
Such a wonderful lady and what a beautiful answer. Rishi Sunak is certainly lucky to have her as his Lady Luck and so well raised and Sanskar by the Murtys’ 👏🏻👏🏻
6
257
11
1,675
63,919
Emergency numbers. Note them down in case of emergency. 👏🏼👏🏼👌🏼🙏🏼🙂
13
343
8
1,205
27,461