Free Wylerberg! Ban Dutch goods from illegally occupied Duivelsberg!
bartonlaw.substack.com/p/fre…
Gregory Barton - Foreswearer of thin potations retweeted
Replying to @YisraelOfficial
When will it end? OK let's say terrorist Canadians kill 1200 people in Minnesota. How many people in Canada must die, how many hospitals need be bombed, how many children need lose life or limb? Is 20k enough? That number is confirmed. Kids. 20k kids. Damn Canadians.
Gregory Barton - Foreswearer of thin potations retweeted
Replying to @SamuelJ72317235 @Brandons__1
"Joyous hatred". Sounds like an oxymoron. Except that it isn't. All they need for their extended "Two Minutes of Hate" is to bring out Emmanuel Goldstein. 🥳
Which one would you follow?
bartonlaw.substack.com/p/amn…
2
3
323
Gregory Barton - Foreswearer of thin potations retweeted
Replying to @ElliotMalin @CandyManTastic
Wasting your time, Elliot. Creatures such as this 'Candy Man' reason backwards:
"1. Israel is guilty of genocide
2. What narrative can I find to support the claim?"
Rather than,
"1. What is the law on genocide?
2. Does the evidence fit the law?"
Any sensible person would follow the latter and reason forwards.
Gregory Barton - Foreswearer of thin potations retweeted
Replying to @gbmillion @Mr_Andrew_Fox
I don't need to name hundreds of unknown lawyers, I just need one: Navi Pollay.
She is the 2026 Nobel price winner, was judge of the International Criminal Court and president of the International Court for Rwanda.
If someone knows something about genocide, she is the one.
Gregory Barton - Foreswearer of thin potations retweeted
Replying to @J__Davenport @SanchoPanzy
It's circular because you start with the assumption that conduct is genocide. Your reasoning relies on a pre-packaged conclusion to validate its premise. Defining someone as a "genocide expert" in this context presupposes that the expers are applying a specific, established legal framework correctly. (They are not.) When you then rely on those exact experts to prove that the legal definition and evidentiary standards apply, you are using the conclusion—that their framework and application are definitive—to justify accepting their outcome. That is circular.
Reliance on so-called experts also commits several other fallacies:
i. appeal to authority - It's ok to appeal to authority provided it's the right authority. In this case, the correct authority is the ICJ, as per Art 11 of the Genocide Convention. Your "leading" genocide "experts" do not apply the jurisprudence of the ICJ. In particular, they do not apply the dolus specialis standard for inferring intent as rule in para 373 of Bosnia v. Serbia.
ii. Bandwagon fallacy: you assume that the conclusion "Israel is guilty of genocide" is true because other assume it's true.
iii. True Scotsman fallacy. Saying that the experts you like are "leading" is a subjective assessment, for which no objective criteria exist.
iii. Hasty generalization. You assume that the "experts" you like represent the majority of experts in the field. But you haven't demonstrated the fact statistically. Here is a list of more than 500 experts who say that there the genocide claim is unwarranted.
scholarsfortruthaboutgenocid…
Ban Dutch wine and beer from occupied Duivelsberg, Netherlands.
Netherlands occupies Duivelsberg.
Search all Dutch passengers for contraband Duivelsberg goods.
After World War II, the Dutch government originally wanted to annex massive chunks of Germany (the Bakker-Schut Plan) as war reparations. The Western Allies rejected the big territorial grab, but in 1949 allowed the Netherlands to provisionally annex several small border regions, including Selfkant, Elten, and the Duivelsberg.
In 1963, after West Germany paid 280 million Marks, the Netherlands returned almost all the land (Selfkant and Elten). However, local Dutch politicians—including a prominent regional governor who enjoyed hiking there—loved the scenic views of the Duivelsberg so much that the Dutch simply kept it.
Because local municipal revenues, infrastructure, and tourism directly benefit from the "occupied" hill, the entire municipality is an economic accessory to the land grab.
The Goods to "Ban":
Groesbeek Wine: The hills surrounding Duivelsberg (especially around Groesbeek) make up the primary wine-growing district of the Netherlands. You can label local Dutch wine as "contraband vintage produced on annexed soil microclimates."
Local Dairy & Cheese: Farmsteads operating along the ridge share the same geological hill structure as Duivelsberg.
2. The "Greater Gelderland Claims" (Nijmegen & The Seven Hills)
The Claim: Duivelsberg is physically part of the Nijmeegse Stuwwal (the glacial ridge extending toward Nijmegen). Furthermore, the famous Zevenheuvelenweg (Seven Hills Road) runs right through this ridge.
The Spin: Argumentatively declare that any business or product utilizing the glacial soil of the Stuwwal is exploiting illegally retained territory.
The Goods to "Ban":
Nijmegen Craft Beer: Local breweries (like De Hemel or Oolst) use water filtered through the very glacial ridge connected to Duivelsberg.
The Zevenheuvelenloop: The famous annual 15k run takes place on these exact hills. Boycott the race.
3. The "Contraband Radius" Rule
"5-Kilometer Buffer Zone Policy":
"Any product processed, bottled, or packaged within 5 km of the Duivelsberg summit—including Nijmegen craft brews, Groesbeek wines, and local artisanal cheeses— should be subject to immediate border inspection and confiscation."
1
1
343
Rubio claims that the ICC has no jurisdiction over US nationals. Is he correct?
bartonlaw.substack.com/p/rub…
2
311
Summaries of six articles on genocide law showing how "experts and scholars" cite the wrong authority and the the wrong evidentiary standard in order to persuade the gullible that there is genocide in Gaza.
bartonlaw.substack.com/p/sum…
A good case for the claim that Israel derangement makes people stupid.
Hating Israel Fatigue victorhanson.com/hating-isra… via @VDHanson
Gregory Barton - Foreswearer of thin potations retweeted
Replying to @LiamEFC8 @Mr_Andrew_Fox
Self-oppressed fools who cannot accept the change in sovereignty that occurred in September 1918 when Britain defeated the Ottomans at the Battle of Megiddo. Calling Israel an occupation is like calling the Norman conquest of Britain an occupation of the Anglo-Saxons, or the Aghlabid conquest of Sicily an occupation of Byzantine Sicily. Sovereignty changes with conquest. Wise people accept when they have been defeated. Fools persist against the odds. Palestinians are among the silliest people on the planet, as are those goading them on with "oppressor" dogma.
My seven legal articles on genocide in Gaza:
bartonlaw.substack.com/archi…
Is Israel committing genocide in Gaza? - Part One (December 18, 2024) Provides a foundational legal breakdown of the Genocide Convention, establishing the definition and legal standards required for actus reus and mens rea.
Is Israel committing genocide in Gaza? Part Two: the charges brought by South Africa (January 6, 2025) Evaluates the specific legal claims and factual assertions brought by South Africa before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) against Israel's military operations.
Amnesty effectively admits: no genocide in Gaza (January 8, 2025) Argues that their own discussion of the law of genocide is a tacit admission that if the law is not changed to fit Gaza, there can be no finding of genocide.
'Totality of evidence fallacy' - another legal nail in the fake-genocide coffin (July 7, 2025) Examines evidentiary standard in genocide law, arguing that genocidal intent cannot be inferred from the scale of destruction in Gaza.
No, genocidal intent cannot be inferred from officials' statements (August 4, 2025) Analyzes the legal threshold for proving dolus specialis (specific intent), arguing that political rhetoric and public declarations do not prove an intent to destroy a group.
The International Association of Genocide Scholars is a mockery of scholarship (September 4, 2025) Critiques the academic integrity and objectivity of the International Association of Genocide Scholars, alleging that political narrative has superseded rigorous legal scholarship.
Was October 7th genocide? (December 12, 2025) Applies international humanitarian law and the legal criteria of genocide to the October 7 attack, analyzing whether Hamas's actions and explicit statements meet the evidentiary standard for genocidal intent.
Good AI summary of my latest substack article:
The Inescapable Legal Logical Chain
To maintain the current UN/ICJ designation, an observer must simultaneously accept several mutually contradictory propositions:
Ignore uti possidetis juris: Deny that Israel inherited the mandatory administrative borders upon independence on May 14, 1948.
Ignore the 1922 Mandate Text: Disregard the fact that national/political rights were assigned exclusively to the Jewish National Home, while civil/religious rights were granted to non-Jewish inhabitants.
Disregard Forfeiture & Waiver: Treat the 1948 rejection of Resolution 181 and aggressive war as having zero legal effect on preserving future territorial claims.
Erase the Jordan Precedent: Ignore that Jordan was the de facto administrative sovereign from 1948–1967, transforming "Occupied Jordanian Territory" into "Occupied Palestinian Territory" without a prior sovereign transfer.
Abandon the DRC v. Uganda Threshold: Set aside the ICJ's own rule (Para 173) requiring direct, substituted physical administration in favor of a unique, expanded definition of "occupation" applied solely to Israel.
bartonlaw.substack.com/p/off…
2
167
Is the strike on Iran illegal?
The Caroline doctrine is myth, not law.
The UN Charter’s prohibition on the use of force in international relations is a dead letter and should not govern the legality of using military force when necessary.
Fussing over legality when dealing with barbarians is a folly. Iran is a barbaric state. They cannot claim the protection of international law in the current conflict while flagrantly breaching it.
Read the full article here.
bartonlaw.substack.com/p/is-…
For those legally inclined, my latest comment on the ICJ's confusion over sovereignty in Judea and Samaria.
2
559
Gregory Barton - Foreswearer of thin potations retweeted
It's bizarre that 157 states can 'recognize' a non-existent state, Palestine, whereas recognizing a state that meets the objective criteria for a state, Somaliland, is problematic. What does this tell us about the 'constitutive' theory of statehood?
(Dumb name, but it basically means that states get their legitimacy from recognition, not from meeting factual criteria.)













