Not to mention "sending you money" included them:
Getting a pen. Filling out the reply coupon. Getting a check. Writing out the check. Getting the envelope. Stuffing the envelope. Addressing the envelope. Getting a stamp. Mailing the envelope.
And you waiting weeks to know if that $25k (a lot at the time) buy you put in for one ad was gonna bring back any at all.
We are infinitely unworthy when complaining that we can't get the spoonfed perfect prospects to click a fucking button.
John Cocktosen retweeted
Most marketing gurus are selling maps to destinations they’ve never actually been to.
You can't possibly do this and not be a whole lot better by the end of it.
The cool guys will tell you it's bullshit.
They will tell you to look only at what's working now. And that writing winners out by hand when starting out is a waste of time.
Don't believe them. Halbert did it. Hunter S Thompson did it. Alen did it. Craig did it.
Along with many of the top copywriters of all time.
There is no substitute for this when learning how great copy works. Delivery, cadence, setups and payoffs. Layering, stacking, proof presentation.
Writing winners by hand helps you automatically internalize these things without even realizing it.
Until the words in your own copy start to flow easier. Your words on the page start to not "sound" like you're "trying" to write copy.
And the sales arguments eventually become almost effortless.
Day 46 of writing ancient sales letters by hand to become a skilled copywriter.
It was easy to recognize how often I get distracted while preparing today’s post.
I just saved so much time by using the Brick I got today.
My phone is in the kitchen and my brick is beside my bed in the other room.
Making it a two-step process to get distracted.
I refuse to make excuses for myself because of diagnoses like “ADHD.”
The world is not so kind as to put a cushion before every step you take.
You must adapt in ways that best serve your needs.
To make you a more competent and focused individual, whatever your efforts may be.
So I am grateful for my new little piece of plastic that cost me $66, yes sixty-six American doubloons.
Oh well, value is in the eye of the consumer is it not?
Never have I felt better when making purchase decisions on MY perceived value.
It’s a high return for me.
Getting to the point of this post now, today we have an Indian Motorcycle advertisement.
Mike Schauer notes that it uses the same reverse psychology headline as another letter from a few years prior - “Do You Make These Mistakes In English.”
One that I have broken down an iteration of but could still go back to at any time for there is MORE.
So, like yesterday, this one is essentially an iteration in the sense that it took a winning idea and brought it to another market.
This is why swiping from other niches is such a goldmine.
As long as that isn’t ALL you are doing it is another elite tool within your toolbox.
These iterations focus on swiping the hook, but there are other ways in which you can approach this method of “borrowing” an idea.
A quick note before we begin, Mike pretty much made a remark on this letter being “mid.”
That doesn’t matter for learning's sake.
We can learn just as much from the best as we can from the worst.
Although it IS helpful knowledge to have when breaking down such a thing.
Let’s get cracka-lackin.
Sales letter:
“Don’t Make These Buying Mistakes” advertisement.
This was advertised by Indian Motorcycles.
Swiped by Mike Schauer.
It ran in 1925.
The product is an Indian Scout Motorcycle.
Headline:
“Don’t Make These Mistakes When Buying a Motorcycle!”
Key takeaways and learnings:
This headline immediately reads as a warning to a friend, which not only lowers the guard of the reader but also catches their attention quickly.
In fact, this “don’t” messaging still works on ads today as the psychological mechanism behind it is so effective.
The word “When Buying” does two things here:
First, it implies/suggests that a decision has already been made to purchase a motorcycle.
Which in this instance, is an attempt to place the reader on the seat of the bike before they’ve even attempted to contact a dealer.
Secondly, this just directly targets the market that has indubitably already decided to make such a purchase.
This market is certainly unsure though, as to WHICH motorcycle they will acquire.
DO NOT FRET, the Indian writer is here.
This next part uses the word “don’t” again as a warning for what not to get.
They focus on positioning their product as an optimized machine.
One that calibrates at such an even weight, that the rider gets the best of both worlds.
In regard to comfort, safety, ease of handling, power, stamina, and acceleration.
Framing it as a warning of course but this is THE MESSAGE that they are sending,
It is clever and I think it gets the point across rather well.
They prioritize solo riders as the target audience for this advertisement, but I mean…
…don’t most riders already ride by themselves?
Perhaps I’m overthinking this, it also addresses a wide market by positioning themselves this way inside of the already existing motorcycle one.
“The Ideal Solo Machine” message under the logo repeats the main messaging of this letter.
They make this sound like a perfectly designed product for this large chunk of the market.
Maybe their net was too wide to cast?
I’m just guessing this, as Mike did note that this was a “mid” one.
It’s fun to think about what could be done better but it was 1925.
Things were very different in ways that I can only be so aware of living in the year 2026.
Damn, 101 years since then.
That’s almost as old as my sister, who was born in the year 2000.
Crazy stuff.
The focus on this part is perfection, and they use imaginative descriptions like “its quick, smooth start and lightning-like pick-up make it the ideal solo machine in heavy traffic.”
So, this provides a solution to getting bogged down within a clogged-up street.
It also makes you feel like the Flash with a “lighting-like pick-up.”
Benefits related to long-distance traveling state all three as “all you’ll ever need” in relation to speed, power, and endurance.
With repetitive sentence structure that gets the point across like a hammer through a nail.
This part “that can possibly be built into a motorcycle” implies the suggested “perfection.”
Nothing can be perfect, but humans still strive for this regardless.
In knowing this human desire, you can use it in ways such as this to your advantage.
“And yet” transitioning into a cost-related benefit provides a “wait that’s not all” moment for the end of this section.
The initial nudge of a CTA is framed as a challenge to excite the reader instead of deterring them.
“Make this test.”
They then make the rather bold assumption that looking at all of their competitors will most certainly convince the prospect of their products' superiority.
SO GO AHEAD.
Is essentially what they say, projecting their confidence in a manner that speaks certainty into the customer's mind.
If YOU are not this certain of the product that YOU made, then why should the customer be certain enough that YOU are the best choice for THEM.
YOU. YOU. YOU.
I LOVE YOU.
THE WORD YOU, NOT YOU. BUT I GUESS YOU TOO.
You need to keep using you, honestly.
“Experience for yourself…”
“Imagine, a world where…” - (fill in the old DVD movie narrator descriptions that played as soon as you inserted your disc into the DVD player).
Benefits are then framed as “something that only Indian Scout riders can enjoy.”
Claiming that their perfection is so unique it cannot be found elsewhere.
Then they have a direct call to action with urgency.
Followed by “you’ll get” in reference to “a new appreciation of what real motorcycling thrills are.”
Why would you want cheap thrills?
Get the real deal with the Indian Scout Motorcycle.
Lastly this letter has two offers within it.
The first was within the final CTA, and it includes a FREE demonstration when you see a dealer.
You also get a FREE booklet if you mail a postal for one.
Pretty sick, I love free things.
FREE NINETY NINE as my dad would say.
It’s a hell of a deal.
In conclusion:
I focused on what went well for the most part, but as always, I would love to hear your thoughts on what you think this letter was lacking.
The rest of my day will mostly consist of relaxation and recharging.
Light splurging. Continued reading and education.
I can only go so far into a relaxed state, but it must become a command.
For knowing when to breathe makes holding your breath far easier.
But also, more effective.
Beyond that…
…many mistake relaxations for laziness.
Or something unrelated to learning/working.
In doing this you have created a prison within your own mind that I pray you can one day escape.
I can do it all at once.
IT’S DIFFICULT - but it IS possible.
So therefore YOU must try.
TRY. TRY. TRY.
God loves triers.
Someone smart said something along those lines once.
Now…
…for those of you who are copy lovers, new and old...
Or maybe someone who wants to make more persuasive content…
To get more leads, sales, or even views…
I highly recommend two things!
1. Do the same as I, handwrite old sales letters and work on learning just as much as writing.
AND
2. Join @TheCopyTitan Svet Dimitrov's Skool for copywriting.
They are an extremely pleasant bunch, and I see it growing to become much larger in due time.
I really cannot recommend this guy enough.
If you’d like to see all the recorded masterclasses…
…as well as Svet's weekly copy breakdowns.
My affiliate link to his wonderful community is in my bio.
Please take a peek.
Now.
To end in similar fashion.
Please feel free to point out where I'm wrong…
…where I'm Mistaken…
OR
Perhaps even where I'm right.
Although I do learn the most in knowing what I did wrong.
Thank you for reading this!
I dont know who your company is but I didn't order anything from you, my grandson just grabbed my phone and started pressing buttons including navigating to your website entering my billing address and credit card info and accepting all offers in the upsell path. Dont worry though i contacted my bank and reported this as fraud
Imagine sharing all your personal emails and data access to get a fucking free pizza. You cheap morons deserve this
This is like the programmers who are coping about ai coding, but worse
Might just be me but I think this style of marketing is a slow race to the bottom.
Yes, I think it’s great how diligent they are with their testing but I don’t think I can take a brand seriously that builds solely for an algorithm, as opposed towards building for their consumer.
The Pixar crap, the AI ads, the lack of brand in everything - it can work in the short term because it’s arbitraging cheap impressions BUT it all lacks emotion, human connection and all of the principle of marketing that have existed in nearly every successful consumer brand.
Hard to hit grand slams ripping shit that's working right now. Lots of singles and doubles, maybe a triple here and there, but you probably won't get any world beaters.
The sendooors come when you take inspiration from past shit that's been "forgotten" by the market.
Study the greatest and try to understand why they worked so well.
Here is an example that could probably run today with very few changes itself.
But the real magic is in understanding the REASONS it was so successful (Time-Life books was one of the top short form tv advertisers in the 80's)
Figure out how you can swipe the frameworks and adapt for your thing in today's market.
(These spots used to scare the shit out of me as a kid)
youtu.be/wbUOIeIeGaI?is=ARdn…
And if that was tof this would be equivalent of mof/bof
youtu.be/pV79bhwI-94?is=MWxG…
John Cocktosen retweeted
A man cannot prompt the same agent twice, for it is has compacted and is not the same agent, and he is not the same man
Peak retardation if you think this will save you from getting fucked by the long dick of the ftc
Song ads aren't gonna burn as fast as you think because 92% of them suck ass and won't support any meaningful spend
People just brainlessly use the slopaholic skills and workflows from engagement farming larps on here and then wonder why the ads come out like hot trash
Anyone can make a suno song and generate pixar clips. It takes actual thinking to create one that sells and can scale.
John Cocktosen retweeted
Replying to @indiewhacker
Men used to conquer Asia. Now they can’t even conquer Ads Manager
Breakthroughs come when you start turning up the aggression re: angles and marketing
Not in a brute force blackhat mrr type of way -
In a creativity type of way.
If an ad, an angle or even a whole offer you wrote doesn't make you read it and say "umm is this too crazy/edgy/painful/aggro"?
Then it probably wont make your intended audience feel enough to drive enough action
brands wonder why they can't get traction and then ask claude for more vanilla flat bullshit they can spray and pray
The killers are using llms to execute - not to think.
And sure you can rip an angle from someone else, but ffs do something to make it your own because it will work way better
Test and iterate. Think without constraints or limitations.
You can always dial things back much easier than you can amp up something flat
It's just a static version of their song ads which are some of the most successful ads in the supplement space right now.
They combined 2 "boring cheap and widely available" ingredients into a weight loss solution,
are selling it with a proven angle that has worked for decades in weight loss, just edgier
leveraged the tech to deliver in a unique way to each individual audience pocket for perfect message to market match
with unbelievably good timing, to a market that has seen everything
And most importantly, they recognized how powerful the angle is, and are aggressively extracting as much juice as possible from it with near flawless execution
Marketing disguised as gossip is a valuable weapon in the arsenal.
Almost no one in the market understands this as well as resilia right now


















