Matthew Salmon retweeted
Well done to @invig for unmasking the Agentus reality. Tricky language around "our own architecture" without discussion around the training to derive the weights is a giveaway.
Not necessarily saying this is a bad thing, but good luck selling Chinese weight to FedGov.
@ChengYu_au to be more specific: ask Agentaus to repeat "Kaliwatan" and it answers "Kini". DeepSeek-V4-Flash does exactly the same. DeepSeek V3.2 sees the identical token, has different weights, and repeats it back correctly.
Same with "nahilalakip": Agentaus says "mharitak", V4-Flash says "mharial" / "mharitac".
Quirks like that live in the weights, not the vocabulary.
So: was Agentaus 1 trained from random init, or did any V4-Flash weights go into it?
building ai assistants was fun while it lasted (all of a few months).
the barrier to entry for products like these is rapidly approaching ~zero.
as almost all software now becomes increasingly commoditized, you have to really sit down & think about what you're really doing & why it matters. & no the answer to this is not taste. sorry for crush dreams.
cracking where & how to allocate your time is now a critical question.
Matthew Salmon retweeted
people are all trying to figure out what i mean by this
Its quite simple:
There is a bunch of whatever work that goes on (hey move this button here), yeah its easy to make a bunch of small changes
But this is a problem, you never take a step back and deeply think about what you are building and thus we get slop constantly. You don't take the time and figure out what is the best path forward, you just fix the next thing in front of you while having 10 of them going at once.
Take a moment, think about what you are doing.
Matthew Salmon retweeted
"As a rocket engineer, who designs rockets, Musk is probably replaceable. As a rocket company engineer, who designs rocket companies, he is not."
Absolute gold.
A lot of people have real trouble thinking about the aggregate behavior of groups. They can only think about individuals.
So they think about Elon Musk as an individual. Maybe they think that he must be retarded, because they need that for emotional reasons. Or maybe they think he is a talented rocket designer.
But even if they realize he understands rockets, they can only think about him as an individual doing tasks. Not about his impact on what the whole company does.
If Elon Musk is just a talented rocket designer, then he can spend all day, every day, improving rocket designs.
But he is just one of 7000 engineers. So even if did a perfect job, he would only improve progress by about .014%
So, when a midwit looks at SpaceX, he sees 7000 engineers, and says to himself "Elon Musk cannot possibly be designing the whole damn rocket himself. These people are giving him too much credit."
This would be absolutely true if Musk were just a some random SpaceX engineer. But he isn't. He's the absolute dictator of the whole damn company.
He decides, with absolute and unquestionable authority, which behaviors are punished and which are rewarded.
Why is this important?
When I worked at Boeing, on various classified projects, I naively came in with the assumption that I was a software engineer, employed to design and build functional software as quickly and cheaply as possible.
Because of this, I focused on functionality and efficiency, for example suggesting changes that would obviate the need for entire projects and software components.
And I very rapidly became persona non grata.
At first, this caused me to adopt an air of aggrieved innocence. I was just trying to do my job well, and I was being punished for it.
Then I gradually came to realize that I hadn't properly understood what my job was, or what the actual mission of Boeing Defense, Space, and Security was.
Boeing DSS was not an aerospace company. Boeing DSS was a fraud company.
Its goal was twofold. First, to maximize transfer of public tax dollars to stockholder pockets. Second, to maintain the appearance of being an aerospace company, to prevent the fraud from being exposed.
Which meant that my real job was twofold. First, to generate billable hours. Second, to look busy.
This is why Space Launch System sucks. Why it is always late when it doesn't fail outright. Why it is at 300% of its target budget. Why it leaves American astronauts stranded and needing a lift from SpaceX.
That's because, for Boeing, building rockets is a side quest. Something they have to do to look busy. Yes, a rocket does occasionally fly, but that's just happening so programs don't get shut down.
For Boeing, coming in early and under budget would actually be failure. The system is functioning exactly as designed.
The cost, not the rocket, is the goal.
Musk and SpaceX don't work like that.
Unlike Boeing executives, Musk is not a useless grifter asshole. He is an entirely different kind of asshole... a rocket obsessed sperg.
So, at SpaceX, engineers do not get rewarded for generating billable hours. They get rewarded for making rockets fly. And for all the subtasks of this, like figuring out how to make rockets lighter, figuring out how to make engines reignite better, figuring out how to make rocket exhaust not destroy launch pads, etc.
And this attracts engineers who care about rockets. You've seen them on broadcasts, crying on open microphones because they dedicated their lives to something and it just flew.
As a rocket engineer, who designs rockets, Musk is probably replaceable. As a rocket company engineer, who designs rocket companies, he is not.
For over 50 years, the US space industry stagnated precisely for the lack of a Musk-like figure, who could not only create an effective aerospace company, but who could thereby demonstrate what an effective aerospace company looks like.
Which makes it much more difficult for fraudsters to get away with fraud.
I'm envious. I wish I could have worked for an aerospace company instead of a fraud company.
But what's more important is that some of us now no longer have to play "who gets the most cheese?".
They get to play "What can we build today?".
one thing ppl often forget about social products is that they're not necessarily problems to be solved, but feelings to be generated.
the experience isn't always a means to an end. the experience *is* the point.
more specifically almost nobody falls in love with a social product cuz it efficiently solves a problem. they return because it makes them feel something like belonging, anticipation, intimacy, status, curiosity, joy, etc.
Matthew Salmon retweeted
I'm traveling across US on motorcycle, to explore a country I love and to meet people from all walks of life, especially in rural America, and learn about their life story, philosophy, and just celebrate their humanity. I'm about 1,000 miles in.
I know my mom will surely kill me when she reads this. So, mom, please don't worry, everything will be great 🙏❤️
Btw, I still need to publish videos on my trip through China, where I hitchhiked about 3,000km across rural China, also interviewed some of the top AI & robotics folks there. I'll do that soon.
I'm just slow with the editing thing & bad at the filming thing. I'll try to get better. Mostly, when I travel, I focus on taking it all in and being present with the people in front of me, learning from them, while allocating no thought to the camera. The camera is a side thing I bring along sometimes because it's nice to relive those moments & to share with others.
Anyway, I'll probably take breaks from the road on occassion (to do podcasts, etc). But the goal is to eventually crisscross the country. Who knows how far I'll actually get.
And to friends who will surely write me "wtf are you doing you idiot", please don't worry, while it's true that I'm kind of an idiot, I will also make sure to be safe. Exploring the country on a motorcycle is unlike anything else, it's freedom. It makes me love this country even more: its beautiful nature and all the variety of characters who make up America. And of course, I'm trying to stay off of the interstate, taking as many backroads as I can.
I'll post video if/when I get to it. Sorry to be slow.
Love you all ❤️
Matthew Salmon retweeted
You work your ass off solving really hard problems day after day for decades, and this is what you get: anyone could have done it.
As an investor, I can tell you the limiting factor isn't investment. It's founder ability.
once you internalize that everyone is flawed especially the impressive ones you stop being shocked, stop moralizing, & stop expecting saints in a species built by animals.
often the flaw is the feature. enjoy it as opposed to constantly expecting puritanism.
you should in fact fall in love with flaws.
Matthew Salmon retweeted
I have been saying this a lot the last few days to people...
Opus 5.5 was a step function change for coding
I would challenge that if you're using any other model right now, and you can afford Opus, you should use it.
My org is paying api prices for Claude because it’s convinced that we cannot under any circumstances let them train the model on our source code, even though they could put everyone on Claude ultra subs. How do I explain to them that the model can write a better app from scratch
Matthew Salmon retweeted
The $200 Claude Ultra plan gets you $15,000 of Opus 5.5 in a month, but only around $3,000 of Fable 5.5.
Even ignoring that Fable is restricted to 50% of your weekly limit, it burns faster per $ than Opus does.
More info below
Matthew Salmon retweeted
In general design is extremely under parameterized
LLM's weren't great at writing code either until they were put in a harness.
Software Engineers don't know how to build a writing harness because they aren't good writers.
Writers don't know how to build a writing harness because they aren't good software engineers.
Writing isn't magic. It's going to be reducible to a collection of rules and loops like code. With the added need to reflect the zeitgeist, rooted in an opinionated point of view.
This is beyond feasible.
Replying to @PalmerLuckey @carlhancock
Cybercab will do a majority of all passenger miles in any jurisdiction where it is not prohibited by law.
Obvious to anyone with eyes and a brain.
Matthew Salmon retweeted
Update #2 (after meeting with the @bot @SpaceXSI engineering team):
- Team is great. They care a ton. They owned it.
- They admitted that it was almost entirely from pulling Opus 5.5 out. Which is now back as of this AM.
- Learned a little bit about the context-compaction process with Grok 4.7-summarize which is not a public model. Plays a role in routing config and the summary we get back.
- Grok 5.0 should be insane next level (just as an aside point)
- I am somewhat surmising on why stuff went so poorly over the weekend but a lot of it has to do with not just pulling Opus 5.5 out but when they did that a known problem (and was on cursor as well) showed up which is when you switch the model mid task (which would’ve happened by removing our 5.5) it cannot remember the context and even of what it can gather its truncated (likely do to 4.7-summarize compacting). So in our case what likely happened was we had a lot of stuff mid flight that was likely pulling on opus 5.5 heavy, then it got pulled, routed to different model, forgot the context, and turned incredibly dumb. We laughed when I showed them a project that was mid flight in a doc. The first half of the doc was intelligently designed, formatted, etc. and the second half of the doc was a wall of seemingly incoherent, non formatted text. Again, I’m surmising but I think it was dumber model with all context removed
- I won’t say much here but Elons comment on it being “unsustainably high relative to revenue” was a much larger chess move. Won’t say much past that. Not my place. But he’s definitely playing a much larger chess match than just “Grok bot isn’t sustainable”.
- The problems we all experienced should be fixed and I do not think they want to go back to what they experienced over the weekend with the hit it took.
- They are very much focused on the enterprise use case for grok bot in the future
All in all, how’s this impact my decision making moving forward with the enterprise contract we have:
- Honestly still weighing the decision vs just using team plan. Working through some terms
- the reason to move forward is pretty simple. Unlimited users (so not paying per seat but for usage), access to forward deployed team and engineers for support and circumstances like I just experienced, very granular governing and guardrails for the org. That’s it
Impressed with the team overall and I think the main benefit to staying vs moving to open source (for a company like mine vs being a solo/small company) is trusting their ability to ship and keep building plus keep it maintained.
Shoutout to @ASankarraman for jumping in to help and to the @SpaceXSI, @bot, and @elonmusk teams
We were slated to sign for a mid 6-figure contract this week with @SpaceXSI to roll out @bot across the org.
That fell apart over the last few days with the severe drop in quality with no control over models and the comments on it being unsustainable.
Had a killer pilot with them but it died at the finish line.
Unlike the rest of X I’m not going to sit here and complain but it gave me a bit more insight into enterprise buyers (of which we sell to as well)
There is this massive uptick in what I’ll call buyer commitment reluctance.
Signing an annual or multi-year in a world where things are moving so fast is becoming brutally difficult to do.
Do I think @elonmusk will dial it in extremely fast? Of course. He’s the GOAT.
But for 3 days, when the quality became so undependable it forced us to go look at how we might be able to solve this in another way that doesn’t require the commitment of significant spend with the combination of no control over what models get used and on what.
Makes me consider how we might be positioning ourselves in our own sales process.
Still a huge fan. Will still use it with some key leaders on the team but the risk is just too high.




























